Impact evaluation: Examples in the ex post

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Social Innovation 21 May 2012 Henriette van Eijl and Liesbet de Letter.
Advertisements

1 The best of both worlds: combining approaches Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit, DG REGIO.
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION Impact evaluation: some introductory words Daniel Mouqué Evaluation unit, DG REGIO Brussels, November 2008.
Impact analysis and counterfactuals in practise: the case of Structural Funds support for enterprise Gerhard Untiedt GEFRA-Münster,Germany Conference:
1 State of play Evaluations undertaken for DG REGIO.
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION Ex post evaluation of the ERDF Obj. 1+2 Kai Stryczynski Evaluation Unit, DG Regional Policy European Commission.
1 URBAN II – the Urban Community Initiative Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit, DG REGIO Ex post evaluation.
1 First steps in practice Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit DG REGIO.
1 Cohesion Policy Evaluation Network Meeting: Brussels, October 2010 Ex post evaluation of cohesion policy interventions financed.
Regional Policy Revised version Marielle Riché Evaluation Unit DG Regional Policy International Monitoring Conference Budapest 11 th November 2011 Brussels.
Regional Policy Meta-Evaluation Some Reflections Evaluation Conference, Warsaw 12/13 November 2012 Veronica Gaffey Head of Evaluation DG for Regional.
Business Register Outputs in Support of Regional Policy John Perry UK Office for National Statistics.
Regional Policy Common Indicators: Innovation and Productive Investment Definitions and Discussion Brussels, 22 nd November
Regional and local economics Slide 1 Lecture 9b The Renaissance of local economic regeneration in the UK – Main themes and activities Aims  Examine local.
Preparation for the next programming period DG AGRI, November 2005 EU rural development policy.
The Small-Firm Sector. Defining the Small-firm Sector EU definition of SMEs –by number of employees micro enterprises small enterprises medium enterprises.
Research and Innovation Research and Innovation 4.3 Innovation Headline Indicator [RESTRICTED TO ERAC MEMBERS] Clara de la Torre, Pierre Vigier, DG Research.
VERONICA GAFFEY Acting Director – Policy Development DG FOR REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT Przyszłość polityki spójności V Raport Kohezyjny a wnioski z ewaluacji.
Measuring entrepreneurship - the European approach OECD Entrepreneurship Indicators Project Expert Workshop 26-27/10/2005 Peter Bøegh Nielsen, Hartmut.
Beyond surveys: the research frontier moves to the use of administrative data to evaluate R&D grants Oliver Herrmann Ministry of Business, Innovation.
1 Cohesion Policy Adam Abdulwahab Evaluation network meeting Brussels, 21 September 2009 Ex post evaluation of cohesion policy programmes
Innovation Indicators across Innovation Agencies TAFTIE Policy Forum, 25 November 2014.
Can Financial Innovation Promote Energy Efficiency? An Impact Analysis for China November 13, 2009 Hiroyuki Hatashima Independent Evaluation Group-IFC.
Regional Policy Ex post evaluation of ERDF and CF: State of play DG Regional and Urban Policy Brussels, 18 June Cohesion Policy.
What do we know about the health and socio-economic impacts of neighbourhood renewal? Hilary Thomson MRC Social & Public Health Sciences Unit, Glasgow.
1 DG Regio work on counterfactuals Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit DG REGIO.
Maximising Opportunities for London Patricia Muotto Regeneration Manager, Structural Funds 00 Month 2004.
1 Support to enterprise – a counterfactual approach Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit, DG REGIO Ex post evaluation – WP 6c.
Regional Policy Operational Programmes.
1 Counterfactual impact evaluation: What is it, why do it? Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit DG REGIO.
Regional Policy Ex post evaluation of ERDF and CF: State of play DG REGIO – Evaluation and European Semester Brussels, 5 November Cohesion.
1 Cohesion Policy Evaluation Network Meeting: Brussels, October 2010 Ex post evaluation of Cohesion policy programmes co-financed.
1 Counterfactual methods – summer school, future work Daniel Mouqué Evaluation Unit, DG REGIO.
Do European Social Fund labour market interventions work? Counterfactual evidence from the Czech Republic. Vladimir Kváča, Czech Ministry of Labour and.
1 Impact Evaluation in the European Commission Adam Abdulwahab Evaluation Unit, DG Regional Policy Budapest, 6 th May 2010.
The Vienna Institute for International Economic Studies ISMERI EUROPA Ex post evaluation of cohesion policy programmes Work Package 1: Coordination,
Paul Casey Head of Research Monitoring and Evaluation
Ex post evaluation of ERDF and Cohesion Fund
Improving Employment Outcomes for Disadvantaged Groups: The Irish Context Philip J. O’Connell Pobal Conference: Creating an Inclusive Labour Market 9th.
Ex post evaluation of ERDF and CF: State of play
Fourth progress report on cohesion June 2006
Regional Business Demography
Ex post evaluation of ERDF and CF: State of play
Preparations for post-2020 Impact Assessment European Commission Directorate General for Regional and Urban Policy Unit DGA Policy.
7th Progress Report: The regional and urban dimension of Europe 2020
Ex post evaluation of ERDF and CF: State of play
Learning from evaluations
Preparation of Annual Implemention Reports (AIR) 2013
Evaluation activities 2016
European cities confronting the financial and economic crisis
Progress of the ESS.VIP ADMIN Special focus on the ESSnet on quality of multiple sources statistics. DIME/ITDG SG, Fabrice Gras, unit B1.
Counterfactual impact evaluation: Czech experience with control groups
Impact Evaluation Methods
Evaluation Network Meeting: Brussels, October 2010
Anna Nykiel-Mateo Nuria Mariñas Rojo DG COMP
ESF Informal Technical Working Group meeting Brussels,
European needs for urban statistics Mireille Grubert
Counterfactual impact evaluation State of play
Ex-Post Evaluation of Cohesion Policy
On-going Evaluation in Germany
Class 2: Evaluating Social Programs
Class 2: Evaluating Social Programs
Evaluation Network Meeting Brussels, February 2010
How to support innovation in services
Cohesion Policy and Regional data
Preparation of Member States’ Strategic Reports 2009 European Commission seminar for managing and certifying authorities Brussels, 9 June 2009 John.
ESF EVALUATION PARTNERSHIP
DG REGIO B2-European Semester & Evaluation
Core Indicators: Annual Reporting Exercise 2010
How to support innovation in services
Presentation transcript:

Impact evaluation: Examples in the ex post Daniel Mouqué Evaluation unit, DG REGIO Brussels, November 2008

Two case studies in work package 6: Overview Two case studies in work package 6: Thuringia (aid to enterprise) Viborg (enterprise and innovation) The urban community initiative Work in progress, still in preparation

WP6 – enterprise (and innovation) « Betriebspanel » data on 1106 enterprises in Thuringia Some receiving direct SF grants, some not => the controls Data on employment, investment, turnover, etc A range of statistical techniques will be piloted, including DiD, PSM

Enterprise (cont.) Similar study of enterprise (and innovation) assistance in Viborg to follow 563 assisted firms vs matched similar non-assisted firms (location, activity) Results due Summer 2009 (Thuringia), end-2009 (Viborg)

URBAN Community Initiative 70 neighbourhoods in crisis – economic, social and physical regeneration To our knowledge, first time such methods used for urban regeneration Unit: the 70 programme areas « Comparison » not « control » group: similar non-URBAN areas, preferably in same or nearby city

URBAN (cont.) Indicators: unemployment, demography, national deprivation indices (large MSs) Statistical methods: DiD, simple PSM « Heroic » nature (data, controls, sample sizes) – it’s a pilot only! Comparison with other methods (parent city, national trends) to assess validity Results due Autumn 2009