IPDET 2011 Lunch Presentation Citizen Report Cards: Community Evaluations and Civic Engagement Dr. Suresh Balakrishnan UNDP, Lao PDR.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Coordinated Veterans Care (CVC) Program Social Assistance and its delivery through the Veterans Home Care Program 1.

Advertisements

1 Entering through the same door - Universal design put simple Soren Ginnerup Danish Building Research Institute Consultant to the COE group on Universal.

Quality Monitoring for Communication Manager

Empowering Residents to Action Using Social Media and Innovation Presented by: Sheryl Johnson Kimberly Adams.

Sydney, 17 July 2007 IBM SOA EXECUTIVE SUMMIT. IBM SOA © 2007 IBM Corporation Dollars & Cents, Justifying Your Business Flexibility Project Matt English.

A Guide to Localizing the Hyogo Framework for Action

1 Outcome of Mutual Accountability & Aid Transparency Survey: Bangladesh Monowar Ahmed Joint Secretary Aid Effectiveness Unit, ERD.

Integrating the NASP Practice Model Into Presentations: Resource Slides Referencing the NASP Practice Model in professional development presentations helps.

ClimDev-Africa Program & African Climate Policy Center (ACPC)

1 CHI CLINICAL GOVERNANCE REVIEWS Half-Day Event for PCTs Paul Bates, Chief Executive, Herefordshire PCT 5 November 2002.

Reducing administrative burden in Bulgaria: Single Entry Point for Reporting Fiscal and Statistical Information Dr.Mariana Kotzeva President of National.

ENGAGING STRATEGICALLY WITH NON-STATE ACTORS IN NEW AID MODALITIES 7th July 2011 DEVCO-Europeaid – D2 civil Society.

Pricing mobile services: Trends and tactics Dr Tim Kelly, International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Workshop on settlement reform and the costing and.

Copyright © 2012 California Department of Education, Child Development Division with WestEd Center for Child & Family Studies, Desired Results T&TA Project.

1 Common Core State Standards What they are! & How they came to be! Implications for New Jersey New Jersey State Board of Education May 4, 2011 Dorothy.

1 NECOBELAC Project WORK PACKAGE 3 Cross-national advocacy infrastructure.

Belgrade December With support from the European Union Progress Programme.

Principles of Assessment and Feedback for Learning CHEP Strategic Work-stream Assessment and Feedback for Learning Dr Alan Masson.

Dr Sita Sekhar, OSF Convention, Johannesburg, July18-20,2011 HOLDING A MIRROR TO THE GOVERNMENT! EXPERIENCES WITH CITIZEN REPORT CARDS 1.

1 Performance Management Challenges and Opportunities Harry P. Hatry The Urban Institute Washington DC.

1 Title I Program Evaluation Title I Technical Assistance & Networking Session May 23, 2011.

2009 Strategic Planning playbook

Integrated Approach to Area Master Planning in Jubail Industrial City

1 WSSD Global Partnership for Capacity Building to Implement the Globally Harmonized System of Chemical Classification and Labelling Objectives, Targets.

Piedmont Regional Voice over IP Pilot Project Law Enforcement Information Management Conference Greensboro, N. C. May 21-24, 2007 Major Dean Hairston,

Results from the MLC Evaluation Ruth Wetta-Hall, RN, PhD, MPH, MSN Kansas Public Health Conference September 20, 2011.

IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre 31 May 2013 Monitoring for Learning and developing Capacities in WASH 1.

“From Shouting to Counting” - Introducing the Concept of Social Accountability Participation and Civic Engagement Group, Social Development Department,

Increasing Accountability to the Poor: Participatory Public Expenditure Management Parmesh Shah Participation Coordinator The World Bank

Addition 1’s to 20.

Management Quality - Achieving Excellence in Allied Health Profession’s Services Management Quality Matrix Dr Robert Jones Head of Therapy Services Directorate.

1 An Investigation into the Development of a Computerised Information System for NHS Physiotherapy Services in England Dr Robert J. Jones East Sussex Hospitals.

Liberating the NHS HealthWatch DH GATEWAY REF

1 United States Department of Labor Mine Safety and Health Administration Robert M. Friend Administrator Metal and Nonmetal Mine Safety and Health.

Bottoms Up Factoring. Start with the X-box 3-9 Product Sum

Collaborative Communities A DOE and GLRS Collaboration 2013 Fall G-CASE Leadership Conference Kimberly Simmons Kathryn Ellis.

A A member of the U.N. Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction An international scientific organization dedicated to the reduction of disaster risk.

Citizen voice in Water and Sanitation Reform Rosemary Rop, Water and Sanitation Consultant July 24 th 2007.

Emerging Trends and Challenges in Business Environment Reform Donor Committee for Enterprise Development Montreux 12 September 2006.

Dr. Gopakumar K Thampi, Public Affairs Foundation, Bangalore CITIZEN REPORT CARDS An Introduction.

CRC, Public Affairs Foundation, Public Health Watch (PHW) Community Monitoring Workshop, March 23-25, 2010 HOLDING A MIRROR TO THE GOVERNMENT! EXPERIENCES.

NATIONAL GPAR PROGRAMME : INITIATION PLAN PRESENTATION TO LOCAL PROJECT APPRAISAL COMMITTEE June 23, 2011.

The Evaluation Plan.

1 The 14 th Meeting of the ASEAN Working Group on Water Resources Management (AWGWRM) Increasing Long Term Awareness Knowledge and Community Participation.

Citizens’ Report Carding – UN Habitat/Maji na Ufanisi Lake Victoria Region and Zanzibar Maji na Ufanisi (Water and Development) Grubs Planning Workshop,

Overview of Building Blocks of Participation at the Macro Level Parmesh Shah Participation Coordinator The World Bank

Citizens’ Feedback on Service Delivery For Acceleration of the Millennium Development Goals Minar Pimple Regional Director, Asia and the Pacific UN Millennium.

Bringing Local News to Local People Khoun Radio Support Project Local Project Appraisal Committee 15 February 2006.

Public Affairs Foundation, Bangalore THIRD CITIZEN REPORT CARD ON CIVIC SERVICES IN BANGALORE, 2003.

Samuel Paul, PAC PUBLIC AFFAIRS CENTRE PUBLIC AFFAIRS CENTRE MISSION STATEMENT “ IDENTIFY AND PROMOTE INITIATIVES THAT FACILITATE A PRO-ACTIVE ROLE BY.

Infrastructure Service Delivery: An Overview. India’s infrastructure deficits Two types of deficits:  “Investment gap”: Gap between existing and required.

Contact Monitoring Regional Network (CMKN). Why procurement It is estimated that an effective public procurement system could save as much as 25% of government.

Kick Off Meeting June WP6: Overview WP Leader: Province of Asti (in close collaboration with iMpronta) Importance of monitoring and evaluation:

Monitoring public satisfaction through user satisfaction surveys Committee for the Coordination of Statistical Activities Helsinki 6-7 May 2010 Steve.

ILO Management of Training Institutions Workshop Flexible Training Delivery Trevor Riordan ILO Senior Training Policy Specialist.

Using the Minimum Standards Attitudes, experiences and application.

Meena Nair, Head – PGRG, Public Affairs Centre, Bangalore For National Consultation on Community Action for Health (CAH) October 28-29, 2014, New Delhi.

Dr Sita Sekhar, OSF Convention, Johannesburg, July18-20,2011 PUBLIC AFFAIRS FOUNDATION CITIZEN REPORT CARDS AND MORE 1.

Introduction to advocacy. Objectives Understand what is meant by the enabling environment Understand the important and purpose of dialogue and advocacy.

Dr. Gopakumar K Thampi, Public Affairs Foundation, Bangalore CITIZEN REPORT CARDS & REFORMS Exploring the Scope.

Esri UC2013. Technical Workshop. Technical Workshop 2013 Esri International User Conference July 8–12, 2013 | San Diego, California ArcGIS for Law Enforcement:

Community Participation and Monitoring in Health Alexandra Gugliuzza| Cornell Global Health| GRAAM.

Regulatorna agencija za komunikacije Регулаторна агенција за комуникације Communications Regulatory Agency Community access to ICT measuring,

Seminar on Public Private Partnerships February PPP Experiences – Challenges and Way Forward Administrative Staff College of India.

1Your reference The Menu of Indicators and the Core Set from the South African Point of View Moses Mnyaka 13/08/2009.

Lusaka, Zambia April The Dilemma of Measuring Corruption How do you measure something which differ across societies in terms of its definition,

AUDITING SOCIAL CHANGE NEW DIRECTIONS? PRESENTATIONBY DR. SAMUEL PAUL AT 6 th GLOBAL FORUM ON REINVENTING GOVERNMENT SEOUL MAY 26, 2005.

Overview Why look at “success”? Bengaluru, India Local government in the Philippines Improving local government in Peru Diagnosing corrupt systems with.

Fecal Sludge Management in South and South East Asia: Needs and Interventions Thammarat Koottatep.

Presentation transcript:

IPDET 2011 Lunch Presentation Citizen Report Cards: Community Evaluations and Civic Engagement Dr. Suresh Balakrishnan UNDP, Lao PDR

2 OVERVIEW OF PRESENTATION Introduce Citizen Report Cards Short film on the concept and applications Closing points and Q&A

3 CITIZEN REPORT CARDS & EVALUATION Citizen Report Cards: simple and useful evaluations Meant to empower citizens in their interface with government Helps communities use surveys to evaluate most tangible activity of governments - public services Initiated in India; thereafter implemented in The Philippines, Vietnam, Pakistan, Uganda, Peru, etc.

4 A SIMPLE REPORT CARD Name: Gopa Class: IX

5 VALUE OF REPORT CARDS Results from a simple evaluation Provides total feedback on performance Structured for simple communication Starting point for reflection & corrective action Not in isolation –allows comparison with peers

6 IMPROVING SERVICE DELIVERY: CITIZEN REPORT CARD BASED APPROACH Same principles applied to public services Citizen based effort to assess and improve services Feedback survey to assess performance of different service providers, and compare them Enables benchmarking and follow up assessments, as well as multi stakeholder dialogue to find solutions

7 Eg. SATISFACTION WITH SERVICES (Survey with 1036 households in Bangalore) AgencyNo. of users% satisfied %dissatisfied Power Company Water Board Telephone Co Driving License Urban Dev. Authority Police653426

8 Eg. RANKING BY USER SATISFACTION (Survey in 1999) Agency Rank Power Company 2 Water Board 3 Telephone Co.1 Driving License5 Urban Authority6 Police4

9 OTHER DIMENSIONS ASSESSED Some examples of other dimensions assessed Factors directly related to service Ease of access to service Frequency of breakdowns Downtime and waiting time for services Related factors Helpfulness of service agency staff Corruption encountered

10 STAGES IN CITIZEN REPORT CARD ASSESSING SITUATION & DEFINING SCOPE OF ACTION PREPARATIONS AND COLLECTING CITIZEN FEEDBACK RATING OF SERVICES DIALOGUE AND RESPONSE OF AGENCIES CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT IN REFORM PERIODIC BENCHMARKING AND PUBLIC REVIEW

11 WHAT CITIZEN REPORT CARDS DO!! Help move from apathy and coping to voicing Enable the shift from shouting to counting Puts the spotlight on hidden costs like corruption Shaming by comparison; pressure on bad performers Platform for advocacy and mobilization

12 VIDEO FILM ON CITIZEN REPORT CARDS

13 THANK YOU

14 CONTACT INFORMATION Dr. Suresh Balakrishnan Chief Technical Advisor (GPAR SBSD) United Nations Development Programme Lane Xang Avenue, Vientiane, Lao PDR Tele :