Relative merits of the algorithms under consideration

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
School of Engineering & Technology Computer Architecture Pipeline.
Advertisements

GLAST Science Support CenterAugust 9, 2004 Overview of Analyzing GLAST Data David Band (GLAST SSC—GSFC/UMBC)
Gino Tosti – INFN Perugia1DC2 Closeout Meeting - GSFC May 31 –June 2, 2006 Source Detection with the Perugia Wavelet code (PGWave) Gamma-ray Large Area.
Vector Processing. Vector Processors Combine vector operands (inputs) element by element to produce an output vector. Typical array-oriented operations.
GLAST Science Support CenterAugust 9, 2004 Likelihood Analysis of LAT Data James Chiang (GLAST SSC – SLAC)
Progress Report Ian Evans (CXCDS) On behalf of the Chandra Source Catalog Project Team Chandra Users’ Committee Meeting April 9, 2008.
May 11, 2004CS WPI1 CS 562 Advanced SW Engineering Lecture #5 Tuesday, May 11, 2004.
GLAST LAT ProjectGround Software Workshop, July 15-18, Wrap-up: Science Tools Seth Digel HEPL/Stanford Univ. 18 July 2003 EGRET >300 MeV What we.
GLAST Science Support Center February 12, 2004 DC1 Closeout Detecting Gamma-Ray Bursts in the DC1 Data David Band (GSSC)
GLAST LAT ProjectDC1 Closeout Workshop, Feb , Post-DC1 Work Seth Digel (HEPL/Stanford Univ.) Post-DC1 Work.
The new The new MONARC Simulation Framework Iosif Legrand  California Institute of Technology.
Source detection at Saclay Look for a fast method to find sources over the whole sky Provide list of positions, allowing to run maximum likelihood locally.
Compilation Techniques for Energy Reduction in Horizontally Partitioned Cache Architectures Aviral Shrivastava, Ilya Issenin, Nikil Dutt Center For Embedded.
THB Source Catalog Meeting 12/21/05 1 Healpixels and Wavelets Toby Burnett and Bruce Lesnick University of Washington.
GLAST Science Support Center June 29, 2005Data Challenge II Software Workshop GRB Analysis David Band GSFC/UMBC.
1. Introduction Motion Segmentation The Affine Motion Model Contour Extraction & Shape Estimation Recursive Shape Estimation & Motion Estimation Occlusion.
Bill Reach 2009 May 14 Greater IPAC Technology Symposium.
Software Project Planning Defining the Project Writing the Software Specification Planning the Development Stages Testing the Software.
PRJ566 Project Planning & Management Work Breakdown Structure.
LSST Scheduler construction plan Francisco Delgado Sr. Software Engineer Telescope & Site.
Data Analysis Software Development Hisanori Furusawa ADC, NAOJ For HSC analysis software team 1.
3DFM – Agnostic Tracking of Bead Position CISMM: Computer Integrated Systems for Microscopy and Manipulation Project Investigators: Kalpit Desai, Dr. Gary.
Source catalog generation Aim: Build the LAT source catalog (1, 3, 5 years) Jean Ballet, CEA SaclayGSFC, 29 June 2005 Four main functions: Find unknown.
GLAST LAT Project Catalogs and Diffuse Emissions Working Groups G. Tosti et al.SLAC, May Gino Tosti, Claudia Cecchi INFN Perugia based on Francesca.
A VLSI Architecture for the 2-D Discrete Wavelet Transform Zhiyu Liu Xin Zhou May 2004.
GLAST LAT Project DC2 Closeout Workshop, GSFC, 31 May-2 June Comparisons of Searches for Sources in the DC2 Data S. W. Digel Stanford Linear Accelerator.
External Communications Working Group Molly E Brown, NASA GSFC with WG team.
Tim Pearson US Planck Data Analysis Review 9-10 May 2006 US Planck Data Analysis Review Source Extraction Tim Pearson.
Project Planning Defining the project Software specification Development stages Software testing.
Unit 2 Effort Estimation. Effort estimation represents step 3 of the project planning process.
CSE 351 Caches. Before we start… A lot of people confused lea and mov on the midterm Totally understandable, but it’s important to make the distinction.
EGEE-III INFSO-RI Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE and gLite are registered trademarks Constraints on primordial non-Gaussianity.
All-sky source search Aim: Look for a fast method to find sources over the whole sky Selection criteria Algorithms Iteration Simulations Energy information.
GLAST Science Support Center November 8, 2005 GUC Action Item #15 AI#15: Pre-Launch GI Proposal Tools David Band (GSSC/JCA-UMBC)
Planck working group 2.1 diffuse component separation review Paris november 2005.
Source catalog generation Aim: Build the LAT source catalog (1, 3, 5 years) Jean Ballet, CEA SaclaySLAC, 23 May 2005 Four main functions: Find unknown.
SuperTask / Butler working group
k is the frequency index
Glast Collaboration Data Server and Data Catalog
Photon Event Maps Source Detection Transient Detection Jeff Scargle
for the Offline and Computing groups
School of Computer Science & Engineering
Jean Ballet, CEA Saclay GSFC, 31 May 2006 All-sky source search
Software Engineering (CSI 321)
Soma Mukherjee for LIGO Science Collaboration
sourceIdentify and identification strategies for LAT sources
Outline Texture modeling - continued Filtering-based approaches.
Constructive Cost Model
Proposal for LAT Year 1 Data Release Plan
Source Detection by Count Excess
Questions for Implementers Recommendation
Wavelet Analysis for Sources Detection
Source catalogue generation
Heuristic search INT 404.
All-sky source search issues
Gamma-ray sources detection using Wavelets
Systems analysis and design, 6th edition Dennis, wixom, and roth
Ann Gordon-Ross and Frank Vahid*
Systems analysis and design, 6th edition Dennis, wixom, and roth
Wavelet method for source detection in GLAST photon-counting images
More on Estimation In general, effort estimation is based on several parameters and the model ( E= a + b*S**c ): Personnel Environment Quality Size or.
Gustaaf van Moorsel September 9, 2003
Volume 21, Issue 19, Pages (October 2011)
k is the frequency index
Overview of Workflows: Why Use Them?
Multi-Information Based GCPs Selection Method
Implementation of a De-blocking Filter and Optimization in PLX
Bootstrap Segmentation Analysis and Expectation Maximization
Are you measuring what really counts?
Uncertainty Propagation
Presentation transcript:

Relative merits of the algorithms under consideration Source detection and catalog pipeline architecture Relative merits of the algorithms under consideration Review of selection criteria and time scale for selection '3D' methods (map + energy, map + time) Inclusion of a 'source finder' tool into the Science Analysis Environment ? Pipeline script, interfaces between the successive stages Operational issues (scheduler, database, computational requirements)

Relative merits of the algorithms under consideration Several algorithms have been proposed (likehood, several Wavelet methods, Bayesian blocks, …). We need to have a good understanding on the quality of each of these methods. Some of them are not included in the pipeline and some works need to be done if want to use them. The optimal filter has the advantage to produce a significance map. Such a map could also be derived from the wavelet coefficients but in relatively heuristic way. It is clear that whatever the selected method for source detection, a maximum likehood should be used to estimate the other parameters (photometry, …). It may happen that several algorithms could be useful. For instance, for a quick look analysis, we need a fast method, but not necessary optimal.

Review of selection criteria and time scale for selection For the selection of the detection method, we agreed that it would be useful to first make a set of tests on toy models and make an evaluation of the different algorithm. Then we can decide which algorithms should be included in the pipeline and tested in a more realistic way. Two data sets already exist. A third one is needed, which would allows us to see the resolved power of each method.

'3D' methods (map + energy, map + time) X Y Z We have discussed the need of 3D tools (spatial + time or spatial + energies) and 4D tools (spatial + time + energy). It seems that 4D analysis is not needed. For temporal analysis, we can consider a given energy band and make the temporal analysis for this band only. Several tools/idea have been discussed. The Voronoi methods could be used, but we have to figure out how to use the output of the Voronoi method. Gino has a project of developping a 3D mexican hat. I have reported some ongoing effort to develop a 3D wavelet analysis for GLAST.

z = 0 z = 29

Inclusion of a 'source finder' tool into the Science Analysis Environment ? NO Pipeline script, interfaces between the successive stages. The best is to use the GLAST catalog format. Operational issues (scheduler, database, computational requirements) The likehood method is not fast enough for finding the source positions but Jim has some idea to spead up the algorithm. There is a need to build a tool which create a diffuse emission model of a part of the sky.