November 2002 Final 802.15.3 LB Summary 95% approval on LB22 (D14) with no new no votes and no technical changes to the draft. (Yes 70/No 4/Abstain 1) 84% participation (75 of 89 eligible voters) 13 unsatisfied TR comments from 4 voters No unsatisfied TR comments from a new voter Other than power management, all other unsatisfied comments are from a single voter who has not participated in IEEE 802.15 meetings since January 2002. Robert F. Heile, Appairent
LB12 – LB22 - Resolution Comparison November 2002 LB12 – LB22 - Resolution Comparison Robert F. Heile, Appairent
November 2002 LB22 Comment Status Robert F. Heile, Appairent
Unsatisfied TRs Mandatory power management (6) (three voters) November 2002 Unsatisfied TRs Mandatory power management (6) (three voters) Single SPS set instead of four. Agree on technical implementation. Disagree on number of supported instances. Miscellaneous comments from a single voter: Optional slotted Aloha for MCTAs (2) Option for efficiency and alternate PHY support Editorial change of GTS to CTA (1) Force even byte alignment of IEs in frames (1) Remove spreading of IEs over multiple beacons (1) Reduces beacon size during transition periods Remove ASIE (1) Make MIFS & SIFS identical (1) Robert F. Heile, Appairent
Motion to the Task Group November 2002 Motion to the Task Group Move to seek approval from the WG to seek approval from the SEC to forward IEEE P802.15.3 Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot. Mover: James Gilb Second: Al Heberling No Objections – Passed by unanimous consent. Robert F. Heile, Appairent
Motion to the Working Group November 2002 Motion to the Working Group Move to seek approval from the SEC to forward IEEE P802.15.3 Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot. Mover: James Gilb Second: John Barr For – 38 Against – 0 Abstain – 4 Motion Passes Robert F. Heile, Appairent
November 2002 Motion to the SEC Move to seek approval to forward IEEE P802.15.3 Draft D15 to Sponsor Ballot. Mover: Bob Heile Second: Stuart Kerry Robert F. Heile, Appairent
Over the Edge to Sponsor Ballot November 2002 Over the Edge to Sponsor Ballot © William M. Shvodian Robert F. Heile, Appairent