What do these people have in common?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Durkheim and Sociology I: Social Facts
Advertisements

History and Social Theory
Crime and Deviance An Introduction. What’s the difference? Crime is normally seen as behaviour that breaks the formal, written laws of a society This.
What is the most private, psychologically- rooted action that any of us could undertake?
Suicide A sensitive subject which also forms part of the deviance section, here the emphasis is on using it as an example to illustrate methods in action.
STUDYING SOCIETY REVISION
Psychocultural Anthropology:.  Durkheim pioneered the disciplines of sociology and social psychology.  He was an empiricist and positivist, and so grounded.
This Week The three “perspectives” of Sociology Alienation as an example of theory.
The Process for Doing Social Science Research.  Social science research looks for patterns in human behaviour as well as connections among those behaviours.
Sociological Research Methods and Techniques
How do Sociologists Study Problems?
Chapter 7 Deviant Behavior. Positivism Both biological and psychological views of criminal behavior seethe individual at fault in some way, not society.
Durkheim The Sociologist as Scientist With reference to his study of Suicide (Week 3)
A2-Level Sociology Suicide. Defining Suicide Defining suicide is an issue which needs to be considered before we can investigate the reasons behind suicide.
How to study why people commit suicide… using Sociology.
Chapter 6 Deviance and Criminal Justice Defining Deviance Sociological Theories of Deviance Forms of Deviance Crime and Criminal Justice Deviance and Crime.
Emile Durkheim Le suicide Why did Durkheim study suicide? To establish sociology as an academic discipline. To demonstrate that suicide could not.
Chapter 8 Deviance. Chapter Outline Defining Deviance Sociological Theories of Deviance Forms of Deviance Deviance in Global Perspective.
Taking a New Look at a Familiar World
HSP3M Unit 1 What should I study?. What are the Social Sciences? Anthropology – the study or the origin, the behaviour, the physical, social, and cultural.
What does it mean to be “deviant?” What would you consider deviant acts?
How to study why people commit suicide… u sing Sociology.
KANTIANISM AND EUTHANASIA ATTITUDES TO KEY ISSUES.
Religion, Peace and Justice Unit A review of the main topics.
Myths.
Ethics and Values for Professionals Chapter 2: Ethical Relativism
Deviance 8.1.
Sociology.
Life After Death Matters of Life & Death Euthanasia Abortion.
Starter Outline each part of the PERVERT wheel
Crime and Deviance.
Mary: ummm…y? oh…this is hard…no idea
The Science of Social Psychology
Values in Sociology.
Aim #1: Why is Sociological Research Necessary?
Scientific inference starts with a theoretical statement, an element of a theory, which says one class of phenomena will be connected in a certain way.
Sociology and science: positivism
Invisible Female Offenders
Sociology & Science: Sociology is often referred to as a ‘Social Science’ but can it truly be classified as a science? Scientific methodology can be used.
Sociology and science: interpretivism
Write down what you think each of the following symbols represents
Values in Sociology: Positivists argue that society (and therefore individuals) objectively & scientifically. This approach assumes that the researcher.
Functionalist approaches to crime
Year 12 – First year Sociology at a glance
How is Society Like a Human Body?
Sociology & Science: Sociology is often referred to as a ‘Social Science’ but can it truly be classified as a science? Scientific methodology can be used.
Ethnicity Labelling Institutional racism
Sociology.
The Sociological Perspective
Sociological Explanations for Criminal & Deviant Behaviour
Lesson Objectives Thinking Ladder…
Emile Durkheim Le suicide 1897.
A2 Positivism & Objective Quantitative Research
Deviance 8.1.
Deviance Chapter 7.
Key words on Peace and Justice
INTRODUCTION TO RESEARCH
Cwk Action theories What: By the end of the lesson you will know all about action theories. Why: All – know.
Social Cohesion Emile Durkhiem.
Welcome To Sociology 3221 Sociology of Family
Which man might the judge be more likely to convict? Why?
The Suicide debate.
Lesson objectives: To practise learning definitions
Nature of capital punishment Religions and capital punishment
A2-Level Sociology – Unit 4
Exploring Identity and Belonging
Unit 3 Lesson 1: Sociological Theorists & Theory
REVISION SESSION #1 Crime and Deviance.
Answering 4 mark questions
Answering 4 mark questions
Presentation transcript:

What do these people have in common?

What caused their deaths?

Read through the information on each of the deaths – are they as straightforward as the media might have us believe? Start to think about how sociologists might look at this.

Opinion Hoffman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqR4Pnu6d3k Winehouse: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj8JXlarsSQ Monroe (long): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7Xnx0I4GEM

What different reasons might sociologists and psychologists give for these deaths? The economy Social class Gender Religion Region Age Ethnicity Stress Depression Individual psychological circumstances Individual economic problems

The ultimate individual act?

If it is individual, surely there should be no societal patterns? Analyse the items

What have we learnt so far about this cheery topic ‘Suicide’? Emile Durkheim collected stats from official sources We can spot patterns between suicide and region, age, ethnicity, religion etc. If suicide is an individual act surely there shouldn’t be patterns? The process of labelling a suicide is subject to social processes There are societal as well as psychological influences on suicide Suicide is usually a deviant act (not always) and has been/is a criminal act too.

Emile Durkheim Le suicide 1897

Why study suicide?

Why did Durkheim study suicide? To establish sociology as an academic discipline. To demonstrate that suicide could not be explained by psychology alone. Durkheim’s ‘Le Suicide’ (1897) is considered a classic ‘positivist’ study and also represented a groundbreaking approach for Sociology

SOCIAL FACTS https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXUX4CvxP68 “We must inquire whether, among the different varieties of death, some have common qualities objective enough to be recognized by all honest observers, specific enough not to be found elsewhere and also sufficiently kin to those commonly called suicides for us to retain the same term without breaking with common usage.”

Synoptic link with methods Durkheim’s study is an exercise in positivism. He uses the suicide statistics from several European countries Durkheim regarded statistics as ‘social facts’. He would establish correlations & reveal the casual relationships which led to suicide.

Why does suicide need to be studied for crime and deviance?

The ultimate deviant act? Ecclesiastes 7:17 Be not over much wicked, neither be you foolish: why should you die before your time? Jeremiah 29:11 For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, said the LORD, thoughts of peace, and not of evil, to give you an expected end. John 10:28 And I give to them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand. John 12:25 He that loves his life shall lose it; and he that hates his life in this world shall keep it to life eternal.

The ultimate deviant act? Islam: {Nor take life—which God has made sacred—except for just cause.} (Al-Israa' 17:33) {If anyone killed a person not in retaliation for murder (without just cause) or to spread mischief in the land, it would be as if he killed all mankind, and if anyone saved a life, it would be as if he saved all mankind.} (Al-Ma'idah 5:32 {Have you not turned your gaze to one who disputed with Abraham about his Lord because God granted him power? Abraham said, "My Lord is He Who gives life and death."} (Al-Baqarah 2:258

The ultimate deviant act? Hinduism: Killing (euthanasia, murder, suicide) interferes with the killed soul's progress towards liberation. It also brings bad karma to the killer, because of the violation of the principle of non-violence. When the soul is reincarnated in another physical body it will suffer as it did before because the same karma is still present. Death: The doctrine of karma means that a Hindu tries to get their life in a good state before they die, making sure that there is no unfinished business, or unhappinesses.  Prayopavesa, or fasting to death, is an acceptable way for a Hindu to end their life in certain circumstances.

The ultimate deviant act? Judaism: Those who take their own lives are technically not entitled to Jewish burial and mourning rites–but suicide as a freely chosen act (with the above consequences) has been nearly defined out of existence by mental health considerations in the development of Jewish law, and in most cases deaths by suicide are treated like all other deaths. Excerpted with permission  from The Jewish Religion: A Companion,Oxford University Press

UK: Is suicide illegal? The Suicide Act 1961 (9 & 10 Eliz 2 c 60) is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It decriminalized the act of suicide in England and Wales so that those who failed in the attempt to kill themselves would no longer be prosecuted.

Ireland Attempted suicide is not a criminal offence in Ireland and, under Irish law, self-harm is not generally seen as a form of attempted suicide. It was decriminalised in 1993. Assisted suicide and euthanasia are, however, illegal.

DEFIANCE In ancient Rome or medieval Japan, suicide was seen as a defiant act of extreme personal freedom against perceived or actual tyrants.

STARTER True or false? Suicide is always deviant Religions view suicide as a deviant act because only God can choose when to end a life Jewish people will never bury a suicide victim Durkheim found that suicide is a purely individual act Durkheim argued that Sociology can be studied as a science A social fact is a purely individual action

Lesson objective To explore Durkheim’s explanations for suicide.

From your knowledge, what might Durkheim attribute suicide to?

Durkheim’s theory is grounded in two key concepts 1. Social integration The degree to which individuals were integrated into society. Eg: part of a family, at college/work, religious practises etc.

2. Social Regulation Social regulation The degree to which society regulates (controls) an individual’s behaviour Eg: the laws in society, religion, socialisation etc...

He links each possibility to four types of suicide Balance Durkheim believed that if the level of social regulation or integration was too strong OR too weak then suicide is more likely to occur. He links each possibility to four types of suicide

Who commits more suicide? Durkheim’s Findings Who commits more suicide? Married/unmarried Children/childless Protestant/Catholic/Jewish

Durkheim… Used quantitative data from official statistics, analysed suicide rates in a number of European cities. Saw 4 patterns… 1. Suicide rates for each society were more or less constant over time. 4. Rates varied greatly within different groups in society. E.g. single more than married etc.. 2. When rates did change, they coincided with key events. E.g. war… 3. Different societies had different rates. Therefore suicide rates cannot simply be the result of motives of individuals

Egoistic Suicides (more common in industrial societies) Social integration is too weak. Results from the individual not being sufficiently integrated into society. Compared suicide rates amongst Catholics & Protestant’s as evidence.

Homelessness: A silent killer A research briefing on mortality amongst homeless people (Crisis: December 2011) “Homeless people are over 9 times more likely to commit suicide than the general population”

Gang members Around a third (34.2 per cent) had attempted suicide

2. Anomic Suicide (more common in industrial societies) Social regulation is too weak Results from the individual not being sufficiently regulated by society. Where traditional norms & values are disrupted by rapid social change producing ‘uncertainty’ in the minds of individuals. Durkheim pointed out that suicide rates increase in economic booms and busts as evidence.

'My grandfather killed himself in the '29 crash' The Wall St Crash of 1929 is popularly remembered for stories of bankrupt investors throwing themselves to their deaths. The grandfather of criminologist and film-maker Roger Graef was one of them.

3. Altruistic Suicide (more common in pre~industrial societies) Social integration is too strong Where the individual sacrifices their life out of a sense of duty to others. Eg: Hindu wives, Japanese kamikaze pilots, elderly Inuits etc..

KAMIKAZE http://www.history.com/topics/ world-war-ii/world-war-ii- history/videos/kamikaze-pilots

4. Fatalistic Suicide (more common in pre~industrial societies) Social regulation is too strong Common among slaves & now rare in industrial societies. “ the suicide of persons with futures pitilessly blocked & passions violently choked by opressive discipline”. Durkheim said these were of ‘historic interest’.

a) A rural migrant who is bewildered by city life Allocate each of the following cases of suicide to one of the four types identified in Durkheim’s typology of suicide: a) A rural migrant who is bewildered by city life b) A servant who kills himself on the death of his master c) A bravery stunt with a gun that works too well d) A prisoner facing a life sentence in a tough labour camp e) A person’s attempt to make an ex-lover return An educated person who has just lost his wife and children but cannot turn to religion Egoistic – integration too low Anomic – regulation too low Altruistic – integration too high Fatalistic – regulation too high  

What category would these people fit?

Match the suicide to Durkheim’s categories Altruistic; Egotistic ; Anomic; Fatalistic Match the suicide to Durkheim’s categories Suicide of slaves/prisoners Hindu women throwing themselves on graves/suicide bombers Protestants Economic booms/depression

Evaluation What are the strengths and weaknesses of his approach?

Evaluation Weaknesses Relied on official stats too much Strengths Cannot be verified Stats are socially constructed Overestimated role of religion, could be area Strengths Sociological classic Used for over 70 years Links the claim that sociology can be a science

Partial agreement Stack (1983), in a comparative analysis of 25 countries, creatively refined Durkheim's thesis to arrive at the finding that lower suicide rates-for women, but not for men-are associated not with religiously based social integration (as Durkheim and others have argued) but with commitment to a few "life preserving" religious beliefs, values, and practices

Frans van Poppel and Lincoln H. Day The gap between Protestant and Catholic suicide rates in the Netherlands during the years 1905 through 1910 appears to be the result of nothing more mysterious than differences in how deaths to Catholics and deaths to Protestants were recorded: A large proportion of deaths to Catholics, which would have been categorized as suicides had they occurred to Protestants, were categorized as "sudden death" or "death from ill-defined or unspecified cause."

Kruijt (1960) The differences in suicide rates recorded by religious composition in the Netherlands might be explicable largely in terms of nothing more arcane than differences in recording practices: [T]he lowest registration of suicides ... in the south of the Netherlands, and perhaps also in some Orthodox Protestant areas, may correlate with prevailing negative attitudes toward filling in "suicide" as a cause of death on the death certificate. There is a stronger tendency among Roman Catholics to conceal the fact that suicide was the cause of death than among groups that do not judge suicide so harshly or punish suicide with religious sanctions.

Ecological fallacy A fallacy is an error of logic usually based on mistaken assumptions. The ecological fallacy is an error of deduction that involves deriving conclusions about individuals solely on the basis of an analysis of group data. 

Douglas (67) Interactionist approach Stats are based on coroners opinion People commit suicide for four reasons Transforming self Transforming oneself for others Achieving fellow feelings Gaining revenge

Achieving fellow feelings I’m so unhappy Transforming self You ruined my life Transforming oneself Please help me! Achieving fellow feelings I killed myself because you rejected me Gaining revenge

Can we adopt a scientific approach? Individuals place different meanings on suicide Need to look at why not just the stats Therefore using Douglas’s work Durkheim’s work is useless

Atkinson Interactionist approach Stats are socially constructed Based on coroner’s decision Coroner’s inquest is based on Suicide note Mode of death Location and circumstances Life history and mental condition Shows how Durkheim’s work is questionable as stats are based on coroner’s decision

Taylor (90) All have ignored parasuicides What about those people who attempt suicide and fail? When questioned these people are taking more of a gamble than a definite decision Need to incorporate Durkheim and Douglas Successful suicides can be linked into Durkheim’s explanations But we also need to include the meanings behind them