Please Mind the Gap: Examining Student and Tutor Perceptions of Assessment Feedback Lesley Fishwick and Linda Allin Division of Sport Sciences.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Close Reading at NQ Is it really that different to what I have done before?

Advertisements

Together we LEAD!. Riverwatch Middle School Our vision statement is Together we LEAD – Learn, Excel, Achieve and Dream.

Enhancing Induction: Principles for Improving the Student Experience Engaging the learner: Why did I get 37%? Professor Brenda Smith Goldsmiths, University.

Self-directed Learners Mary Pryor Academic Learning & Study Unit (ALSU)

Assessment Design Practical examples. Peer marking using model answers (Forbes & Spence, 1991) Scenario: Engineering students had weekly maths problem.

Experience of using formative assessment and students perception of formative assessment Paul Ong Greg Benfield Margaret Price.

Pre-entry qualifications – staff perceptions versus reality Sarah Maguire Derry Corey.

A Masters in Education in eLearning The University of Hull.

Making Feedback a positive learning experience Joint Academy/NUS Special Interest Group Professor Brenda Smith Senior Associate

Contextualising the learning process in Sports and Materials Science C.L Davis, M. Jenkins and E. Wilcock School of Engineering University of Birmingham.

Enhancing student learning through assessment: a school-wide approach Christine OLeary & Kiefer Lee Sheffield Business School.

Creating a dialogue over feedback between staff and students in the classroom and online Heather A. Thornton

Making the most of Feedback Chris Doye Institute for Academic Development University of Edinburgh 2012.

FEEDBACK! WHATS FEEDBACK? Did you know that..... Feedback you receive is not just confined to coursework and formal assessments. It will not always come.

Ian Atkin & Mike Lowe Department of Exercise and Sport Science MMU Cheshire.

CENTRE FOR EXCELLENCE IN TEACHING & LEARNING: ASSESSMENT FOR LEARNING LEARNING AND TEACHING SUPPORT / STUDENTS UNION External Examiners Seminar, 26 th.

Peer assessment and group work event and practical workshop RSC WM Stimulating and supporting innovation in learning.

Intellectually stimulating and engaging teaching..

Assessment bottle necks a reality or a state of mind? Probing the perception gap between students and staff Dr Liz Partington, Dr Linda Allin & Alex Radu.

Marking and Assessment Policy January 2013 St Richard Gwyn Catholic High School.

Writing an effective assignment in A-Level Leisure Studies.

Session Outcomes Explain how assessment contributes to the learning process Use a model of feedback to enhance student learning Identify a range of feedback.

PRESENTATIONS The whys and hows of including student presentations in a portfolio of learning, teaching and assessment techniques.

Developing your Assessment Judy Cohen Curriculum Developer Unit for the Enhancement of Learning and Teaching.

Slides originally developed by NJDOE A New Vision For Professional Development.

Information Literacy and Inquiry-based learning Pamela McKinney Learning Development and Research Associate (Information Literacy) at CILASS CILASS identifies.

DAF Project Dialogic Assessment and Feedback Martina A. Doolan & Paul Morris Introduction DAF is part of a.

E-portfolios for PDP An overview of student and staff perceptions across subject areas Federica Oradini and Gunter Saunders Online Learning Development.

Innovative and Efficient Assessment Dr Helen Barefoot University of Hertfordshire Professor Mark Russell King’s College London.

The role of the undergraduate work placement in developing employment competences Matthew Hall and Nicola Bullivant Presentation to DECOWE conference,

Oral pathology in a PBL course Dr Mary Toner School of Dental Science Trinity College, Dublin.

Effecting Sustainable Change to Assessment Practice and Experience in the Biosciences; The ESCAPE project Dr Helen Barefoot University of Hertfordshire.

SFC Project Re-engineering assessments Weekly multi-choice tests.

Using formative feedback, asynchronous discussion boards and recognition to develop the creative, confident and inspired learner 2. Teaching and Assessment.

Enhancing student learning through assessment: a school-wide approach Christine O'Leary, Centre for Promoting Learner Autonomy Sheffield Business School.

Goals and Self- Assessment Admin Observation Student Course Feedback Peer Observation Community Feedback.

Online assessment: the use of web based self-assessment materials to support self-directed learning Online assessment: the use of web based self-assessment.

Information Literacy and Inquiry-based learning Pamela McKinney Learning Development and Research Associate (Information Literacy) at CILASS

Engaging Students with Feedback CHALLENGE – EVALUATION – CREATIVITY – CLARITY – FOUNDATIONS – COLLABORATION.

Matthew Dean Faculty of Technology (Teaching and Learning)

A review of peer assessment tools. The benefits of peer assessment Peer assessment is a powerful teaching technique that provides benefits to learners,

1 Ideas of Problem-based Learning As a learner-centred process, problem- based learning meets the learners' interests and as such gives room for developing.

Faculty of Computing, Engineering & Technology COIS40894 COIS40894 PROFESSIONAL AND ACADEMIC SKILLS FOR APPLIED IT I (Introduction)

HOW TO SELF AND PEER MARK SUCCESSFULLY Rebecca Rhodes.

Media Studies 2009 External Achievement Standards.

Welcome 3 rd and 4 th year students! Arne Kovac, Director of Undergraduate Studies.

Examination Feedback Maximum Impact, Minimum Cost? Paul L. Latreille Seminar January 24 th 2011.

indispensable conditions for improvement (Sadler 1989)

P.R.I.D.E. School Professional Day :45 am- 3:30 pm.

1. Assessment Mobile phones Be HERE Bags / laptops / office work away from table Have an open mind Ask questions Listen to learn Be honest Confidentiality.

Feedback in University Teaching Prof. Arif Khurshed Division of Accounting and Finance.

Key Stage 4 Assessment and Reporting November 2014 Specialist School in Mathematics and Business St Mary's High School, Newry.

Year 9 Project 1 ‘Objects’ Useful Resources; Pop Art;

Innovation What does it look like in Adult Learning?

E-Assessment: Removing the Boundaries of C.A.A. Phil Davies School of Computing University of Glamorgan South Wales UK.

Hazel Bryan Adeela Shafi Jenny Hatley Sian Templeton Richard Millican Tristan Middleton ASSESSMENT FOR RESILIENCE.

Good teaching for diverse learners

Subject specialist teaching

COIS40894 PROFESSIONAL AND ACADEMIC SKILLS FOR APPLIED IT I

Formative assessment to increase student confidence and attainment

service within the BA Fine Art course at UCA

PReSS – Iterative Assessment Review

Plenary There is some really excellent practice around the institution & the passion for improving A & F is clear to see Developing students assessment.

Group Talk Feedback – A focus on the individual

Second Semester Overview

Kat Hearn and Dawn Reilly

Group Talk Feedback – A focus on the individual

Giving Feedback and Evaluating Academic Writing

WELCOME ART AND DESIGN GCSE.

CLASS REPRESENTATIVES

Presentation transcript:

Please Mind the Gap: Examining Student and Tutor Perceptions of Assessment Feedback Lesley Fishwick and Linda Allin Division of Sport Sciences

Assessment Malaise Maintaining quality in the face of increasing student numbers Unhappy students Innovative approaches to assessment and feedback

Possible Cure – Assessment Dialogues

Enhancing Student Engagement with Assessment Feedback: Case Studies Formative Assessment Feedback Mechanisms Feedback FormatStudent Group Mock Take Home Exam (0%) eLP Discussion Marking Workshop Peer Self – model answers Tutor - negotiated N = 30 Level 6 N = 5 Level 7 Presentation (20%) Feedback sheets Content analysis Workshop Peer Tutor Self N=50 Level 5 (Yr 2)

Dialogues: Mock Exam (L6 and L7) Mock Take Home Exam 1 week submit Non-assessed on Weekly readings eLP Discussion Board Marking workshop Q1 Peer assessment (model answers) Q2 Tutor marked (negotiated) Q3 Peer and Tutor Presentation (random)

Dialogues: Presentation (L5) Presentation of research proposal in groups (tutors and peers write comments) Lecture: content analysis of presentation feedback comments (wk6) –Identify themes/categories –Select which appropriate to own seminar/group –Estimate group grade

Student Evaluation of Assessment Activities Gained clearer idea of academic expectations (general and specific) Excellent opportunity to practice (mock exam) Could see direct relevance to summative assessment Appreciated willingness to discuss assessment issues with peers and tutors

Perception Gaps Some staff suggest that students unwilling to put effort into non-assessed formative tasks Students have a narrow perception of what is feedback (written comments on text) and indicate continued preference for tutor-led individual feedback Varied student self-perception (estimated and actual grades)

Implications for Practice Create spaces for assessment dialogues Enhance student engagement with assessment feedback Design activities to stimulate questions and self-evaluation Narrow perception gaps

Issues to be considered: Impact on confidence of students Emotion involved in assessment Influence on trust in tutor-student relations Immediacy of feedback in dialogues