Criminalizing Georgian Schooling: Crime as a Mode of Governance since the Rose Revolution Gavin Slade University of Oxford

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Getting Tough on Crime, Getting Tough on the Causes of Crime: The Impacts of Penal Populism on the Criminal Justice Practitioner
Advertisements

Nazis in Power essays To write a good essay it is really important you know what the question wants you to do. Sort the past paper questions into theme.
Government of the Republic of Serbia Ministry of Labor and Social Policy GENERAL AND SPECIAL PROTOCOL ON CHILD PROTECTION FROM ABUSE AND NEGLECT.
Maintaining Legal and Social Framework
Planning Step 1: Choosing a Study Theme.
TRUST IN JUSTICE – EURO-JUSTIS & the ESS Professor Mike Hough Birkbeck College Crime Surveys User Meeting 7 December 2010.
AfriMAP’s The Justice Sector and the Rule of Law in Namibia
Ministry of Interior of Montenegro,,The Fight against corruption and organized crime in Montenegro Ministry of Interior of Montenegro,,The Fight against.
ROSE BROAD ESRC PHD STUDENT SCHOOL OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER The UK Criminal Justice System and Researching Human Trafficking.
Impact of Social Institutions on Caribbean Culture and Society Cont’d
Differences in safeguarding children and vulnerable adults
M. Foucault ‘Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison’ Part 4 - Prison.
Crime and justice in revolutionary Venezuela Rogelio Pérez Perdomo Washington, June 30, 2012.
Crime and crime prevention in SA Presentation to the Safety and Security Portfolio Committee Anton du Plessis, Duxita Mistry and Makubetse Sekhonyane Crime.
Copyright © 2006 Pearson Education Canada Inc Chapter 8 Violent Crimes “To all of us crime seems like violence” K. Menninger, ’68:157.
The U. S. Economy: Private and Public Sectors
Department of Criminal Justice California State University - Bakersfield CRJU 330 Race, Ethnicity and Criminal Justice Dr. Abu-Lughod, Reem Ali CONCLUSION.
US Society  classless society  majority believe they are middle-class  system produces many winners  strong work ethic  self-reliance important 
BY TANYA MARIA GOLASH-BOZA Chapter Eleven: Racism and the Criminal Justice System.
Class Name, Instructor Name Date, Semester Criminal Justice 2011 Chapter 2 PUBLIC OPINION, THE NEWS MEDIA, AND THE CRIME PROBLEM.
Mandatory Sentencing Charlotte Baker HSC Legal Studies.
EU Criminal Law Introduction, Lisbon Treaty. EU criminal legislation EU cannot adopt a general EU criminal code EU cannot adopt a general EU criminal.
How to survive in a non-supportive environment: Experience from Russia Ivan Varentsov (Andrey Rylkov Foundation) AIDS 2014, Melbourne.
Criminal Law and Young People
Parliamentary Oversight of Internal Security Forces Basic oversight features in liberal democracies: the role of Parliaments vis-à-vis internal security.
Examine the role of the government in the US economy. The US is a mixed economy with private and public sector. The government has a crucial role in finding.
A teacher passes out an individual assignment to his students. Some students immediately understand the assignment and are able to complete the work while.
Chapter 2 Sentencing and the Correctional Process Corrections: An Introduction, 2/e Seiter ©2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Pearson Prentice Hall Upper Saddle.
Political Ideologies Unit 1: Introduction to Government.
CJ AU Criminology Unit 8 Professor Shane Kelley.
Race Discrimination in the Criminal Justice System.
Unit 9 Seminar Important due dates Unit 9 – Discussion Board – Due 4/27 Unit 9 Quiz – Due 4/27 Final Power Point Project – Due 4/27 me at
In Reference with Chapter Six.  Coolidge’s administration of the 1920’s implemented policies reflecting his laissez-faire stance.  The 20’s USA was.
CHANGE AND CHALLENGE: The justice system reform process in Latin America LAC SURF.
Policing Democracy: Overcoming Obstacles to Citizen Security Reform in Latin America Traditional vs. Problem-Oriented Policing - Reforms: 1. Structural.
Chap 9 What events triggered the ”3 strikes" fad? Ex-con crimes in Wash and Calif -- spread across country -- fueled by media myths of lenient system “soft.
The parties. 5 Functions of Political Parties Campaigning for Candidates – help politicians get elected to office. Informing Citizens – help citizens.
What’s Going On? Society, Politics and Law and Order Understanding Criminology 17 th March 2009.
Difficult Crime and Law Questions. Int Explain, in detail, why some people believe that prisoners should always serve their full sentence and.
Criminal Justice Reform Speaker: Otar Kakhidze Date:
Unit 9 Seminar Important due dates Unit 9 – Discussion Board – Due 4/6 Unit 9 Quiz – Due 4/6 Final Power Point Project – Due 4/6.
Social Studies 9.  Unit 1 focuses on the structure of the Canadian federal government. This includes: ◦ The separation and division of powers within.
Breaking the cycle: effective punishment, rehabilitation and sentencing of offenders Ministry of Justice Green Paper.
Stephen Farrall (CCR, Sheffield Univ).
What is ideology? Ideology is a belief system. A plan how to improve society and how it should work. Ideologies are not supposed to be calm and even rational.
Sentencing A Criminal Justice Issue Area Primer for the National Foundation for Women Legislators.
AC4.1 – Sociological theories
Crime and Deviance.
Criminal Justice & Mass Incarceration
Public Opinion, Crime and Criminal Justice Sofia May 26, 2009
Stephen Farrall (Centre for Criminological Research, Sheffield Univ).
Critical Criminology: It’s a Class Thing
Chapter 1: Crime, Law and Criminal Justice
Unit 7: The American Legal System
CJA 394 Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394 Enthusiastic Study/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394Competitive Success/tutorialrank.com
CJA 394 GUIDE Education Your Life-- cja394guide.com.
CJA 394 GUIDE Lessons in Excellence-- cja394guide.com.
CJA 394 Education for Service-- tutorialrank.com.
CJA 394 Education for Service/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394 GUIDE Education for Service-- cja394guide.com.
AJS 582 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com
CJA 394 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com
Situation Analysis in Tourism
Acquire knowledge of the impact of government on business activities to make informed economic decisions 5.04.
Programme Introduction
The Marketing Environment
Political Ideology.
Political Ideology.
Presentation transcript:

Criminalizing Georgian Schooling: Crime as a Mode of Governance since the Rose Revolution Gavin Slade University of Oxford

Zero Tolerance: Justice for All Mandatory custodial sentencing Three strikes and your out drugs laws Anti-Mafia legislation Plea-bargaining More effective police and prosecutors Dependent judiciary Miniscule acquittal rate

The Great Confinement

And the Winner is…Georgia?

Carceral Economics

Positive Externalities Unemployment kept down Prison building helps poor, rural areas Saves on social spending in unequal society and deregulated labour market Helps control politics and opposition Confidence for investors and the wealthy ….and zero tolerance reduces crime!

Victimization Rates

Perceptions Fear of crime relatively high in the 1990s Feelings of security have increased Yet people believe that crime is still increasing Popular punitivism: 32% believe that punishments need to be harsh Feedback loop: state policy creates perceptions of disorder maintaining demand for policy itself However, most feel that prison population is too high and many protest govt policy

Safe Schools : educating for legality idea imported from the US via Sicily : UNICEF research supports introduction of Safe Schools initiative 2008: Project Harmony implement legal socialization project 2010: legislation passed and mandaturi and CCTV enter schools

Mandaturi

2010: Zero Tolerance in Schools Mandaturi report on all disciplinary issues to the Ministry, including truancy, lateness and teacher behaviour Patrol the perimeter of school, CCTV Policing now competing with teaching as a mode of socialization Reduce discretion in punitive responses

Governing Through Crime Use of criminal justice logics and practices in other spheres Policy-making in other spheres framed in a criminological discourse Heavy concentration on crime and victims of crime in the media and govt rhetoric The logic of zero tolerance expanding outwards

Competing Frameworks Response to fear of school crime? - School killings in Victimization levels? Ministry incentive to control schools? - Fear of crime partly produced - Discourse of us vs. them: dzvelibichoba Or wider mode of governance in de-regulated economy? - preparation for post-industrial discipline - prison-school complex

Explaining Criminalization Incentive to control admin of schooling Genuine concerns in society over school crime Control of media and govt emphasis on crime: political utility in fear Developed networks: promote criminal justice logics; power of Interior Ministry Safe Schools policy ideas already floated

Issues for Research: Impacts US research: powerlessness and distrust At odds with developments in other ministries Not popular with teachers in Georgia? But, popular with parents? What about the children themselves? How to design research into this? Where next for Governing through Crime?