Considerations and Benefits of Using Five Zones for Distance Protection Ricardo Abboud, Jordan Bell, and Brian Smyth Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
MULTISTAGE AMPLIFIERS
Advertisements

FAULT TYPE SELECTION Jeff Roberts April 6 and 9, 2005.
New Energy Horizons Opportunities and Challenges Fault Current Contributions from Wind Plants Dean Miller PacifiCorp July 25,
Power Electronics Dr. Imtiaz Hussain Assistant Professor URL :
Capacitive Charging, Discharging, and Simple Waveshaping Circuits
Fundamentals of Distance Protection
Fundamentals of Electric Circuits Chapter 11
Frequency Characteristics of AC Circuits
Chapter 22 Alternating-Current Circuits and Machines.
1 Industrial Systems A dvanced L ine P rotection S ystem.
Alternating-Current Circuits Chapter 22. Section 22.2 AC Circuit Notation.
Zoran Gajić ABB AB Vasteras, Sweden
PSRC Line Protection Subcommittee Working Group D4
ELE130 Electrical Engineering 1 Week 5 Module 3 AC (Alternating Current) Circuits.
Preferential Subject #3 Protection and Control of Series Compensated Networks Special Reporter: Graeme Topham South Africa Study Committee B5 Colloquium.
Fundamentals of Electric Circuits Chapter 9 Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display.
Slide 1 Line Current Differential Application on Short Lines Presentation to SSCET October 26 th, 2012.
Queensland University of Technology CRICOS No J Protection of distributed generation connected networks with coordination of overcurrent relays.
Introduction To Protective Relays This training is applicable to protective relaying and System Monitoring tasks associated with NERC Standards PRC-001.
Introduction To Protective Relays
Least Squares Estimate Algorithm Bei Zhang
BENATO IT Session 4 – Block 3 – Question 6 Barcelona May 2003 THE ISLANDING PROBLEM PASSIVE PROTECTIONS AS DEMONSTRATE THE POSSIBILITY OF FAILING.
Introduction To Protective Relays This training is applicable to protective relaying and System Monitoring tasks associated with NERC Standards PRC-001.
Introduction To Protective Relays This training is applicable to protective relaying and System Monitoring tasks associated with NERC Standards PRC-001.
Protection of Power Systems
TECHNICAL PAPER ON SIMULTANEOUS AC-DC POWER TRANSMISSION
Chapter 9 CAPACITOR.
Protection of Power Systems
전자파 연구실 1. Fundamentals. 전자파 연구실 1.1 Frequency and time Passive circuit elements is emphasized in high speed digital design : Wires, PCB, IC- package.
TRANSMISION LINE PROTECTION USING GPS PRESENTED BY:- KAJAL MOR M.TECH(PS)
Part Three – Relay Input Sources
Power System Protection 1. Contents Contents Introduction Functions of Equipment Protection Functions of Protective Relays Required Information for Protective.
CIGRE SC-B5 Colloquium 2005 Sept Calgary Canada PS3:Protection & Control of Series Compensated networks Q3:Are there any experiences of other unique.
Static Relays contains electronic circuitry (Diodes, transistors, zener diodes, thyristors,logic gates …etc) ICs are widely being used in place of transistors.
Power System Protection Fundamentals
ELEC 401 MICROWAVE ELECTRONICS Lecture on Matching
Power in AC Circuits Introduction Power in Resistive Components
Announcements Design Project has firm due date of Dec 4
NERC Published Lessons Learned Summary
PS3: Protection & Control of Series Compensated Networks
Effects of GIC Neutral Blocking Devices (NBDs) on Transmission Lines Protection Performance and Potential for Resonance.
Protection of Power Systems
Quality and Security Assessment of Protection Systems
Electric Circuits Fall, 2014
Fundamentals of Electric Circuits Chapter 7
STEADY-STATE POWER ANALYSIS
EI205 Lecture 15 Dianguang Ma Fall 2008.
SWITCH GEAR AND PROTECTION. ACTIVE LEARNING ASSIGNMENT : DISTANCE PROTECTION OF TRANSMISSION LINES. PREPARED BY : JOBIN ABRAHAM.
Passive Shunt Compensation
Series Capacitor Compensation
Power in AC Circuits Introduction Power in Resistive Components
POWER SYSTEM ANALYSIS INTRODUCTION.
Chapter 7 System Protection
Electromechanical Systems
MULTISTAGE AMPLIFIERS
IEEE Guide for Protective Relay Applications to Transmission Lines
Protection Philosophy
Protective Relaying Conference
A Tutorial on the Application and Setting of Collector Feeder Overcurrent Relays at Wind Electric Power Plants By: Stephanie Mercer.
Specifications Updates and Approval
A Unified Approach to Controlled Switching of Power Equipment
Yujie Irene Lu & Song Ji May 2nd, 2018
Directional Elements – How Fast Can They Be?
Distance Protection: Why Have We Started With a Circle, Does It Matter, and What Else Is Out There? Edmund O. Schweitzer, III and Bogdan Kasztenny Schweitzer.
Power System Protective Relaying-Part One
MANUFACTURING SYSTEMS
Fundamentals of Electric Circuits Chapter 7
Reseeding-based Test Set Embedding with Reduced Test Sequences
Fields and Waves Lesson 1.5 TRANSMISSION LINES - LOAD MATCHING.
Exercise 9 Power systems.
Presentation transcript:

Considerations and Benefits of Using Five Zones for Distance Protection Ricardo Abboud, Jordan Bell, and Brian Smyth Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.

Overview Review of pilot schemes Effects of CT saturation Mutually coupled lines Series compensation CCVT transients Guidelines for applying multiple zones

Introduction Distance element protection is widely used for transmission systems Overreaching zones set with long reaches can conflict with line loadability requirements

Zones of Protection Electromechanical relays had limited number of protection zones More zones improves overall dependability and security

Review of Pilot Schemes Permissive overreaching transfer trip (POTT) Directional comparison unblocking (DCUB)

Review of Pilot Schemes Directional Comparison Blocking (DCB)

Guidelines for Applying DCB Scheme With Extended Reverse Zone Reach Remote overreaching zone must not reach beyond reverse zone of local relay To minimize CTD, reverse zone must be set to longer reach to ensure block asserts as quickly as possible Setting of 1.5 • (overreaching DCB zone) – Z1L is recommended

Effects of CT Saturation on Distance Element Performance

Effects of CT Saturation on Distance Element Performance CT saturation can cause calculated impedance to momentarily fall outside the reach One solution to this is to extend the reach

Mutually Coupled Lines Nearby lines can have zero-sequence mutual coupling Coupling can affect impedance measurement

Mutually Coupled Lines To ensure pilot protection has sufficient coverage, typical settings need to be much greater than 125% Using the same zone for pilot and step-distance schemes can cause coordination problems Separate zones for pilot and step-distance protection are required to achieve maximum selectivity and speed

Lines of Different Lengths In past, Relay 1 overreaching zone reached no farther than Relay 2 instantaneous zone In pilot protection, it may extend to 200% to ensure reliable speed

Lines of Different Lengths A zone can be set to extend the reach of pilot protection for speed (e.g., 200%) A separate step-distance zone can be set to not overreach the Relay 2 instantaneous zone If adjacent line is really short, step-distance zone may not be capable of reach coordination, only time coordination

Series-Compensated Lines MOV Resistance Changes, Capacitance Changes

Series-Compensated Lines RC and XCC depend on through current of series capacitor Variation in RC and XCC change impedance measured by the relay

Series-Compensated Lines Reduce underreaching zones Extend overreaching zones Separate zones for step- distance and pilot protection

CCVT Transients CCVT transient response can last up to 1.5 cycles Severity depends on voltage point on wave (inception angle), active or passive FSC, and system SIR

CCVT Transients Transients cause distance calculations to overreach Active FSC CCVTs have more severe transients; therefore, instantaneous zone needs to be limited

CCVT Transients Traditionally, instantaneous zone was reduced to 20% of line impedance Could use marginally delayed zone to cover rest of line

General Guidelines for Applying Multiple Zones Examples Zones 1, 2, and 3 High-speed distance elements Instantaneous zones in step-distance and pilot schemes Zones 4 and 5 Conventional distance elements Time-delayed overreaching zones

General Guidelines for Applying Multiple Zones Zone 2 – 200%+ (forward pilot protection only) Zone 3 – 200%+ (reverse pilot protection only) Zone 4 – 118 to 150% to cover end-of-line step-distance backup Zone 5 – set according to remote backup requirements for forward step-distance backup

General Guidelines for Applying Multiple Zones Zone 2 – 200%+ (forward pilot protection only) Zone 3 – 200%+ (reverse pilot protection only) Zone 4 – 118 to 150% to cover end-of-line step-distance backup Zone 5 – set according to remote backup requirements for reverse step-distance backup

General Guidelines for Applying Multiple Zones Zone 1 – set according to maximum SIR Zone 2 – 200%+ (forward pilot protection only) Zone 3 – 200%+ (reverse pilot protection only)  Zone 4 – 118 to 150% to cover end-of-line step-distance backup Zone 5 – 80% with 1.5-cycle delay CCVT Case Z1 is limited reach Z5 is slightly delayed

Conclusions Requirements for pilot and step-distance schemes can contradict System components can affect requirements Using multiple zones optimizes selectivity, dependability, and speed

Questions?