DETERMINISM VS. FREE WILL

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Advertisements

FATE v. FREE WILL. Fatalism The idea of fatalism coincides with destiny. This means that everything in our lives is predestined by fate. In other words,

Free will and determinism

DETERMINISM VS. FREE WILL

Libertarianism A Libertarian, such as Taylor:

The Problem of Free Will

Kant Are there absolute moral laws that we have to follow regardless of consequences? First we want to know what Kant has to say about what moral rule.

Foreknowledge and free will God is essentially omniscient. So assuming that there are facts about the future, then God knows them. And it’s impossible.

Kant’s Ethical Theory.

Determinism, Free Will, and Moral Responsibility Traditional threats to free will: Fatalism (every event was meant). Predestination (every event is willed.

Free will Am I ever really free? Determinism: the entire state of the world at any given time fixes, determines, necessitates, all the subsequent states.

THEODICY: WHY GOD ALLOWS EVIL Robby Lashua DSCC Oasis Feb. 23 rd, 2014.

The soft determinist response. the incompatibility argument 1)Determinism is true. 2)If Determinism is true, then none of our actions are free. 3)None.

Hume on Taste Hume's account of judgments of taste parallels his discussion of judgments or moral right and wrong.  Both accounts use the internal/external.

Why Philosophy? Myron A. Penner. Overview I.How + What = Why II.Scholarship: Research Areas III.Scholarship: Teaching.

Having and Making Choices Does causality tie us down?

Freedom and Determinism Libertarianism: Part 2. Libertarianism.

A Meaning for Existence

Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 7 The argument from evil By David Kelsey.

Seeing the “story” of ideas….

Free Will Theories  Agency Theory: we define ourselves as agents through free choices: this we experience (and is what our theory should explain)  Person.

Morality and Religion. Does morality depend on religion?

The Saga of the Rolling Stones. Rolling Stone Rolling Stones.

Influences on Free Will & Determinism Psychology, Social Conditioning, Genetics, Environment.

Free Will FREEDOM VERSUS DETERMINISM. Are human beings free to make moral decisions and to act upon them? Are they determined by forces outside and.

Free Will and Fixed Futures. Fatalism “Gappy” Fatalism: Appointment in Samara Aristotelian Fatalism: The Problem of “Tomorrow’s Sea Fight” in light of.

Kant. Background Immanuel Kant was an influential philosopher of the 17th and 18th centuries. Reason imposes its own abstract, formal laws on our actions.

The Free-Will Problem Appendix to Chapter 9 TOK II.

© Cambridge University Press 2011 Chapter 9 Appendix.

Ted Honderich. The Man Born 30 January, 1933 Canadian-born British philosopher Currently chairman of the Royal Institute of Philosophy. Main work on five.

The importance of free will Human autonomy and dignity Value of deliberation Deserving praise and condemnation Moral responsibility.

David Frost. FREE WILL AND CAUSAL DETERMINISM 1)Are free will and causal determinism incompatible? FREE WILL AND CAUSAL DETERMINISM.

The Moral Philosophy of Immanuel Kant The Ethics of Duty and Reason

PHIL/RS 335 Divine Nature Pt. 2: Divine Omniscience.

Libertarianism. Simple Libertarianism: Someone freely performs an action if and only (i) if she chooses to perform that action and (ii) her choice was.

Freedom and Determinism Libertarianism: Part 1. The Incompatibility Argument 1)Determinism is true. 2)If (1), then the Freedom Principle is false. 3)[So]

© Michael Lacewing Determinism: varieties Michael Lacewing

Responsibility & Free Will

Hume’s emotivism Michael Lacewing

Free Will and Determinism Chapter Three Think pp

Freewill and Determinism Part II. Who Are You? What type of person would people say you are? Jock, hippie, geek, ordinary, etc. Why would people identify.

1. Free Will and Determinism Determinism: given a specified way things are at a time t, the way things go thereafter is fixed as a matter of natural law.

FREEDOM AND NECESSITY A.J AYER. ALFRED JULES AYER  A.J. Ayer (1910–1989) was only 24 when he wrote the book that made his philosophical name, Language,

PHIL 2 Philosophy: Ethics in Contemporary Society Week 2 Topic Outlines.

Modern day science defines itself naturalistically and that it is just atheism masquerading. For example the recent definition states “The universe is.

Amit Zaidenberg. Motivation Motivation is the reason or reasons for engaging in a particular behavior. Motivated - provided with a motive or given incentive.

We can experience the act of making choices. We may feel the burden of having to choose. There is a ‘Moral Self’ that, unlike personality, is not caused.

Freedom and Determinism

The Problem of Personal Identity

Why Be Ethical?/You are what You Do

Quotation of the day… Examiners tip

Business Ethics Concepts & Cases

Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 7 The argument from evil

What is Philosophy?.

Philosophy of Mathematics 1: Geometry

the libertarian response

Business Ethics Concepts & Cases

The implications of predestination and determinism

Free Will and Determinism

4 B Concepts of determinism: Hard determinism: philosophical (John Locke - free will is an illusion, man in bedroom illustration), scientific (biological.

Libertarianism objections.

Existentialism.

Freewill and moral responsibility

Searle, Minds, Brains and Science Chapter 6

Introduction to Epistemology

Free will and determinism

The Problem of Free Will

Presentation transcript:

DETERMINISM VS. FREE WILL An ancient philosophical conundrum

DETERMINISM = The theory that every event, including every human action, is governed by natural laws. Technically, determinism is the belief that a determinate set of conditions can only produce one possible outcome given fixed laws of nature. Many believe this rules out HUMAN FREEDOM.

DETERMINISM IS DIFFERENT FROM FATALISM FATALISTS claim that there is nothing that we can do to affect our lives in any significant way. For example, I cannot in any way affect whether I am going to have a fatal accident tomorrow. DETERMINISTS allow that human actions can make a difference. Fatalism often takes the form of RELIGIOUS PREDESTINATION

If determinism is true it would seem that: We are no more free than robots. There is no reason to praise or blame anyone. It is wrong to punish criminals--because they “can’t help it”.

3 DIFFERENT POSITIONS ON DETERMINISM: Human beings have free will because determinism is FALSE (‘libertarianism’). Human beings do NOT have free will because determinism is TRUE (‘hard determinism’). Even though determinism is TRUE, human beings DO have free will (‘soft determinism’).

Libertarianism Free will requires a gap in universal causality. The self initiates actions but when acting freely is not itself caused to do so. Human decision making thus occupies a special place outside of the natural order. NOTE: This is not the same as ‘libertarianism’ in political philosophy.

Objections to libertarianism The self would have to be non-physical, yet capable of causing events. Does this make sense? Even if it makes sense, what is the evidence for it?

How to be a soft determinist A free act is just a VOLUNTARY act. It issues from what the agent WANTS, unconstrained psychologically or physically. Acts can be ‘free’ in this sense but still determined by natural laws. Determinism is not a problem for those who take this view. Hume

If hard determinism is true… MORAL RESPONSIBILITY is undermined. (‘Ought’ implies ‘can’.) Do praise, blame or punishment make sense without moral responsibility? Is RATIONALITY undermined? Can our acts have reasons as well as causes?

What do you think? Am I writing this essay on my own free will or is it the unavoidable outcome of prior events?