PRETAB Planning Model: Local Information Infrastructure (LII) as DSS for Local-level Urban Planning Ayon K Tarafdar Associate Professor, Dr. Department.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
National Prevention Strategy
Advertisements

Property Tax Relief and Reform: Plan Overview Joint Select Committee on Property Tax Relief and Reform June 11, 2007.
Jubail Industrial City A $45 Billion Super Project
1 Changing Profile of Household Sector Credit and Deposits in Indian Banking System -Deepak Mathur November 30, 2010.
1 International Workshop on Regional Products and Income Accounts, Beijing, China, March 2010 Country Presentation -India By National Accounts Division.
February 18, Breakthroughs in Healthcare Workforce Development Transforming Public/Private Partnerships.
1 POLICY ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY BY: M.B. WILLIAMS DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY.
Towards Science, Technology and Innovation2/10/2014 Sustainable Development Education, Research and Innovation Vision for Knowledge Economy Professor Maged.
Oversight of Metropolitan Districts Department of Local Affairs
Survey Internal Communication trends in the Italian banking sector Mario Spatafora Simone DellOrto Milan, September 2002.
Promotion of electronic democracy in Šalčininkai District Gžegož Jurgo Senior specialist at Investments and strategic planning division Šalčininkai District.
1 EU Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region as a tool to implement the EU2020 European Commission Directorate General Regional Policy Territorial Cooperation.
The Implementation Structure DG AGRI, October 2005
Version 3 Südtirol – Alto Adige Applied Spatial Management Co-financed by DG Regional Policy, Innovative Actions Unit 1 Clusterdevelopment within CAN Südtirol.
1. 2 Why are Result & Impact Indicators Needed? To better understand the positive/negative results of EC aid. The main questions are: 1.What change is.
Community Strategic Guidelines DG AGRI, July 2005 Rural Development.
Prepared by: Workforce Enterprise Services For: The Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity Bureau of Workforce Development ENTRY OF EMPLOYER.
Tennessee Higher Education Commission Higher Education Recommendations & Finance Overview November 15, 2012.
CALENDAR.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt FactorsFactors.
LEADER Conference, Przemysl October 2007 Romanian National Rural Development Network Proposed structure Professor Michael Dower.
Alexey Miroshnikov InfoStroy Ltd. Locatioin: St.Petersburg, Russia Established: 1990 APL: since 1979 First APL conference: 1990, Copenhagen People: 42+
Company Name PRESENTATION NAME Compilation and Dissemination of Energy Statistics International Workshop on Energy Statistics, Beijing, Sep 2012 International.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Land and Water Division AQUASTAT FAOs global information system on water and agriculture by Karen.
1 GIS for Water Maximizing the Benefits of GIS Susan Ancel - Director Water Distribution and Transmission EPCOR Water Services Inc. Geospatial World Forum.
USE OF TOOLS & TECHNIQUES
Susheel Kumar, I.A.S. Joint Secretary, Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation Government of India 1.
Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission JNNURM PROGRESS REVIEW APRIL 2007 Reforms-Projects-Funds Mobilisation & Grant Utilisation State___________.
2009 Strategic Planning playbook
Effectively applying ISO9001:2000 clauses 6 and 7.
Orange County Board of County Commissioners Water Conserv II Operations Contract Renewal Utilities Department August 23, 2011 Utilities Department August.
The International Trade Centre (UNCTAD/WTO) The International Trade Centre (UNCTAD/WTO)
EU Market Situation for Eggs and Poultry Management Committee 21 June 2012.
Title of session Building Capacity in Liberias WASH Sector Christine Ochieng 30 May 2013.
1 CAPACITY BUILDING ON ELECTRICITY REFORMS IN BANGLADESH, INDIA AND NEPAL RAJESH KUMAR.
Exploring linkages and cooperation between FETWater and Masibambane III Outline FETWATER Programme Overview Masibambane III Programme …a FETwater perspective.
Developing and Implementing a Monitoring & Evaluation Plan
Industrial Statistics in Bangladesh: Current Practice Md. Shamsul Alam,Director,BBS Md. Azadul Islam,Deputy Director,BBS.
1 Lincolnshire Research Observatory Lincolnshire’s Changing Population Components of Change and the Demographic Impact Eleanor.
Promoting Regulatory Excellence Self Assessment & Physiotherapy: the Ontario Model Jan Robinson, Registrar & CEO, College of Physiotherapists of Ontario.
1 Independent Evaluation in IFC Presentation to Staff of Islamic Development Bank May 3, 2009 Marvin Taylor-Dormond.
AN OVERVIEW OF HEALTH RESEARCH ETHICS IN INDONESIA By : SURIADI GUNAWAN.
Strategic Financial Management 9 February 2012
Economic Crisis Response Program. According to the 2011 MNL Census of Municipalities: 11.7% of small municipalities (fewer than 1000 residents) have economic.
© 2013 E 3 Alliance 2013 CENTRAL TEXAS EDUCATION PROFILE Made possible through the investment of the.
City Council Meeting Agenda Items October 28, 2013.
Grant Management Seminar 1 District 5930 Grant Management Seminar.
7/16/08 1 New Mexico’s Indicator-based Information System for Public Health Data (NM-IBIS) Community Health Assessment Training July 16, 2008.
The UK Development Footprint in India – Urban Sector February 24, 2014.
Salford Carers Strategy Glyn Meacher – Integrated Commissioning Manager PRESENTATION TO CLUSTER 2 SCRUTINY SELECT COMMITTEE.
& dding ubtracting ractions.
Local Government Budgets and Expenditure Review, 2011 Strengthening governance to improve service delivery National Treasury, 14 September 2011.
1 The Role of Family Planning in Achieving the National Strategic Vision in Zambia Ministry of Health September 2010.
Technology For Social change Municipal eGovernance Platform – eGovernments Foundation Technology For Social change.
Urban Development and WATSAN services in Low and Middle Income Countries Dinesh Mehta, CEPT University, INDIA.
A Geospatial Approach to Urbanisation in India: The Unexplored Role of National Urban Information System Dr. Mahavir 1 Prabh Bedi 2 1 Professor of Planning,
Lecture(2) Instructor : Dr. Abed Al-Majed Nassar
The Right to the City Vidyadhar K. Phatak Presented at The 21 st Century Indian City: Developing an Agenda for Urbanization in India March 23,
Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission Preamble This stands for Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission. The Government of India has launched.
Indian National Urban Information Systems as Decision-Making Tool for Urban Planning Prabh Bedi 1 Dr. Mahavir 2 1 Research Scholar, Department of Physical.
Training on JNNURM Urban Development Deptt., GoWB Reforms under JNNURM.
Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission JNNURM PROGRESS REVIEW JUNE 2007 Reforms-Projects-Funds Mobilisation & Grant Utilisation State:- Goa City:-
June 4, 2008 Induction training on BSUP for Officials in the Project Implementation Units in West Bengal Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission.
STATUS OF JNNURM IN KMA 21 st February Sri. P.K. Pradhan, IAS Principal Secretary Urban Development & Municipal Affairs Department Govt. of West.
THE JnNURM IN CHENNAI An assessment with focus on the urban poor Transparent Chennai.
REPORT ON URBAN SETTLEMENTS DEVELOPMENT GRANT
Development Policy Planning in Ghana
on Metropolitan Strategic Planning
Director-General: Mr. E Africa
Presentation transcript:

PRETAB Planning Model: Local Information Infrastructure (LII) as DSS for Local-level Urban Planning Ayon K Tarafdar Associate Professor, Dr. Department of Urban Planning School of Planning and Architecture: Vijayawada (MHRD, Govt of India)

Outline Municipal planning in India – the potential and profile of an (unnoticed) sector ULBs and the notion of non-spatial planning – the fallacy and shortcomings Geospatial tools for municipal planning – an issue of sectoral offerings and approach A way forward – The PRETAB planning model (NTNU-Norway-SPAV research assignment)

Urbanization in India Source: Census of India 19 urban% 35% urban 40% urban National Population National Urban Population

ULBs and Metropolitans In 1991 there were 23 metropolitan cities, which increased to 35 in 2001 – 2011, there are estimated 41 metro cities In 1991, there were 2562 urban local bodies (ULBs), which increased to 3255 by 2001 It is estimated that by the year 2011, urban areas would contribute about 65 % of GDP 3255 ULBs in India? Notified Area (319) Town Nagar Panchayat (453) Town Area Committee (620) Municipality (1290) Municipal Council (32) Municipal Committee (233) Municipal Board (253) Municipal Corporations (55)

National Commission on Urbanisation 1985 NCU, Vol. II, Map 4 77 NPCs

252 SPCs National Commission on Urbanisation 1985 NCU, Vol. II, Map 5

49 SPURs National Commission on Urbanisation 1985 NCU, Vol. II, Map 6

Understanding the local mandate 74 th Constitutional Amendment Act (CAA74, 1993) accorded constitutional status to ULBs – mandated ULBs with the role of preparing spatial, economic and social development plans CAA74 - SchdXII: accords 18 key planning functions for ULBs – – Regulation of land use and building construction – Water supply (domestic and commercial) – Roads and bridges – Public health, sanitation and solid waste management – Slum improvement and up-gradation – Parks, playgrounds, water bodies, etc – Planning for trade, commerce and economic development

This means… Each ULB needs to prepare a municipal/town development plan (10-15 year vision) addressing each sector (18), through: – Strategizing, phasing, projectizing, and evolving implementation plans Leading to 5 Year Plans and Annual Plans; and subsequent project plans 1.Do we have enough (3255)Town Development Plans currently? 2.What does this plan- making mean, financially?

Understanding the potential For almost 10 years, there were no municipal spatial plan, which got approved, after CAA74 in 1993 Led to launch of – National Urban Information System (NUIS), 2006 – Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM), 2005 NUIS Preparation of GIS database by NMA in coordination with State Govts. 137 towns and cities crore population Rs crores JNNURM Preparation of City Development Plan (CDPs), and DPRs 65 towns and cities crore population Rs. 50,000 crores

Understanding the potential The status / outcome as on 2010: – 27 CDPs have been completed; rest underway None of the CDPs are statutory plans – About 43 NUIS town database completed; rest underway None of this finds reference in CDPs or Municipal Plans – About 11 Municipal Corporations out of 55 have an approved plan – About 45 municipalities out of 1700 have an approved plan

Other issues with the CDPs and NUIS… CDPs and NUIS data Non-Statutory documents Not necessarily certified by professional planners Not as per UDPFI/ ITPI guidelines No plan-period specified Non-spatial approach to development (lacks land use plan and control, land suitability analysis, and other spatial aspects) NUIS data not streamlined for urban planning Attribute developed as per available data with census and NMAs and not development agencies

Which means… We do not have plans for almost 96% of our constitutionally empowered 3255 ULBs, since CAA74 in 1993 (17 years) Municipal plans are directly linked to municipal budgets and projects, yet plans not ready Every municipal body continues to have annual budgets, projects and functions, without a local vision or development plan Projects are allocated on a top-down fashion, as earlier, based on district and state economic plans Does this show a way?

Understanding the Need/Potential Estimated annual avg. municipal budget is INR 200 crores (for a medium sized municipality) – Roughly 10% is allocated for plan-making - INR 20 crores – JNNURM allocates around INR 50 crores for CDP preparation – A development planning assignment by a public planning body is estimated to be of around 30 crores (including primary survey), that can be sanctioned from State Planning Board Estimated funding available for plan-making = INR 100 crores per municipality Equivalent to a potential market of INR 300,000 crores – (referring to only plan-making for 3000 ULBs)

Understanding the Need/Potential Assuming 20% to be spent on data assimilation and creation of GIS = INR 20 crores per municipality Equivalent to a potential market of INR 6000 crores for geospatial enablement in plan-making What stops us from acting?

Notional Roadblocks Planning without information Planning without planners Geospatial element left out to mapping and creation of thematic maps, and databases only None of the current municipal plans utilize geospatial tools in its analytical frame Geospatial tools continue to address municipal planning and services at the sectoral level.

The sectoral approach Geospatial CanvassSectoral utility Design and Engg.Infrastructure, utilities & services, construction, network planning etc MappingCartography, thematic representation, delineation Terrain and 3DTerrain modelling, defense, urban design While each of these are formidable tools, they remain potent at the application stage of project implementation within sectors. What then, can be more appropriate for planners?

PRETAB Planning Model Need to inculcate the role of geospatial sciences at the plan making level, particularly land use control Need for a simplified platform for that assists in creation of spatial development plans leading to further sectoral projects. Platform need three main tenets: – Proactivity (geospatial expert enabled) – Reflectivity (planner and local stakeholder enabled) – Incrementalism (system enabled)

Proactive Module: – Spatial & temporal information systems handling quantitative data structures – Capacity to simulate, and analyse inter-sectorally – Inculcates role of experts Reflective Module: – Non-spatial information analytics; Livelihood analysis, socio-economic profiling, stakeholder mapping, fishbone mapping, qualitative data structures, etc – Inculcates role of local people Incremental Module: – Ability to add and delete components of analysis and data structure to the system as required by a specific context and user

A PRETAB Planning Process Model Local Information Infrastructure LII Component A) Proactivity Module Component B) Environmental Module Component C) Territorial Module Component D) Action Module User- defined Input Dynamic exercise User-defined Analysis User-defined Output

A PRETAB Planning Process Model Under development by NTNU-Norway & SPAV

Ending thoughts There is dearth of technology and human capacity There is no dearth of funds and resources There is no dearth of need and rationale What we need is – – Appropriate vision, appropriate applications/tools, and appropriate intervention.

Thank you /