Chapter 16 Consensus Methods © Nursing Research: An Introduction by Pam Moule and Margaret Goodman (2009, SAGE)

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Developing a Competence Framework & Evaluation Tool for Primary Care Nursing in South Africa SUSAN STRASSER 1, LESLIE LONDON 1 & ELMA KORTENBOUT 2 1 Department.

Advertisements

Establishing an accessible data corpus based on evidence to the Victoria Climbié inquiry: Merging user needs and research dimensions Rachel Balen, Graham.

Year Two Year Three Year One Research methods teaching in the social sciences: An integrated approach to inquiry- based learning.

Welcome. Aims of the Workshop The overall aim of this workshop is for delegates to develop skills and techniques to enable them to carry out effective.

The Nominal Group Technique Chapter 42 Research Methodologies.

Nominal Group Technique (NGT) With Multivoting Paula Mower WISD Director Assessment and Organizational Development February 2012.

Community Needs Assessment A successful service project Has realistic goals with measurable results Responds to community identified needs Incorporates.

REFLECTIONS FROM THE EXPERT PANEL CHRIS SPANSWICK, CHAIR OCTOBER 27, 2010.

Reaching Consensus.

Participation Requirements for a Guideline Panel Co-Chair.

Experiences of Patient and Public involvement in the Research Process Roma Maguire Senior Research Fellow Cancer Care Research Team School of Nursing and.

The Health Roundtable 3-3b_HRT1215-Session_MILLNER_CARRUCAN_WOOD_ADHB_NZ Orthopaedic Service Excellence – Implementing Management Operating Systems Presenter:

Publishing qualitative studies H Maisonneuve April 2015 Edinburgh, Scotland.

Assessing When Numbers Don’t Count Binghamton University March 23, 2007.

Identifying Needs and Establishing Requirements John Thiesfeld Jeff Morton Josh Edwards.

Decision Making Ch. 7 Management A Practical Introduction

Element 2: Organisational requirements For employers and managers of nurses and midwives Delegation and Supervision for Victorian Nurses and Midwives.

FOCUS GROUPS DISCUSSION “a way of collecting qualitative data, which—essentially—involves engaging a small number of people in an informal group discussion.

Competencies of Nurse Educators in Curriculum Design: A Delphi Study Milena Staykova, Melissa Marszalek, Shanice Vennable, Dustin Whitaker.

Assessing person-centredness: the Person-centred Practice Index by Dr Paul Slater.

Copyright © 2008 Allyn & Bacon Meetings: Forums for Problem Solving 11 CHAPTER Chapter Objectives This Multimedia product and its contents are protected.

Comparative Evaluation of the Impact of e- participation in Local Climate Change Policy Programs The Effectiveness of E-Participation.

Overview 1.Association between financial problems and mental health problems 2.Financial counsellors need some basic knowledge about how to assist with.

Delmar Learning Copyright © 2003 Delmar Learning, a Thomson Learning company Nursing Leadership & Management Patricia Kelly-Heidenthal

Facilitator Training Program. Day One Agenda – Day One Welcome Getting Started Activity Course Objectives Overview of Facilitation Skills Facilitation.

Telephonic Health Coaching: How to do it best Erin MB Ratelis Master of Business Communication Final Project Presentation May 2006.

Territorial Impact Assessment of Governance of Territorial and Urban Policies in ESPON Space ESPON PROJECT 2.3.2: GOVERNANCE OF TERRITORIAL AND URBAN POLICIES.

Partnerships for the Future Implementing a sustainable framework of partnership working with service users and other partners Thursday 2 May 2013 Giving.

Chapter 14 Decision Making – A Book Review

 The model consists of 6 steps: Step 1: Define the problem or opportunity. Step 2: Set objectives & criteria. Step 3: Generate alternatives. Step 4:

The Audit Process Tahera Chaudry March Clinical audit A quality improvement process that seeks to improve patient care and outcomes through systematic.

Note to evaluator… The overall purpose of this presentation is to guide evaluators through the completion of step 7 of the UFE checklist and to “level.

Best Practices: Standing on the Shoulders of Giants? Ronnie Detrich Wing Institute.

Theological Dialogue on Medically Administered Nutrition and Hydration January 18 – 19, 2006 Summary of Discussion.

Nursing Research Capacity Building. Background CON –opened as 9 th College at SQU in 2008 The CON’s next challenge is promoting nursing care based on.

Core Outcome Domains for Eczema – Results of a Delphi Consensus Project Introduction Eczema is a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory skin disorder that affects.

Simon Wills Head of Wessex Drug & Medicines Information Centre Introduction Research is needed to help inform service development and to demonstrate the.

9-1 Decision Making Chapter Value of Group Decision Making Advantages  Process gain  Higher quality decisions  Motivational effects Disadvantages.

Psychological Factors u Attention - Focusing on specific behaviors to observe. u Sensation - Using senses to focus u Perception - Meaning of information.

METHODOLOGIES – PART 3 Focus groups, nominal group process, Delphi technique.

Chapter 12 Team Decision Making Tools. Objectives Decision Making Tools: Brainstorming Nominal group technique (NGT) Voting.

Loughborough London School of Sport & Exercise Sciences Evaluating the Competencies of Sports Managers in Taiwan: A Delphi Approach Ling-Mei Ko Professor.

Effective School Council Meetings School Council Forums 2009.

Research Methodology CCCCourse contents 1. Overview of selected methods used in conducting public health research including Rehabilitation. 2. Insight.

Quality Tools. Decision Tree When to use it Use it when making important or complex decisions, to identify the course of action that will give the best.

Educational Template Chapter 13 Research Applications Kathy Momtahan Chapter 13 – Research Applications.

Copyright © 2009 Elsevier Canada, a division of Reed Elsevier Canada, Ltd. The Role of Research in Nursing Chapter 1.

Evidence Based Medicine. What is Evidence Based Medicine? What qualifies as Evidence Based Medicine? Does Airrosti treat patients by utilizing an Evidence.

Chapter 6 Determining System Requirements. Objectives:  Describe interviewing options and develop interview plan.  Explain advantages and pitfalls of.

Investigating service user ethical priorities in psychological research Rachael Carrick.

THE IOWA MODEL OF EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE TO PROMOTE QUALITY CARE Jill Collins, Jerilyn Rodgers, Sandy Siebert & Julie Unruh **please refer to page 252.

Evaluation of the Community Advisory Committees to Boards of Victorian Public Health Services Health Outcomes International Pty Ltd HEALTH AND COMMUNITY.

Tools for Knowledge Synthesis – Dialogue Gabriele Bammer.

Ashley James & Tom Flammini October 8, 2013

CHAPTER TEN Multiple Parties and Teams McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.

Future Prediction Methodologies using expert groups

Learning the lessons 2012 and 2014 procurements of audit services.

13-1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin ©2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved CHAPTER THIRTEEN Multiple Parties and Teams.

Copyright © 2012 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 11 Specific Types of Quantitative Research.

Enabling Collaborative Leadership Pioneer Programme A very brief introduction.

The RutDel Methodology Presented by: Danielle Lombardi.

Using correspondence analysis: a tool for researching nursing informatics competencies Peter Kokol, Helena Blažun Faculty of Health Sciences, University.

Making Decisions and Solving Problems. Learning Outcomes 1. Terms 2. Describe differences between decision making and problem solving. 3. Identify decision.

DEVELOPING AND TESTING THE STANDARD OF PRACTICE AND EVALUATION OF CRITICAL-CARE-NURSING TOOL (SPECT) FOR GRADUATES OF CRITICAL CARE NURSE EDUCATION PROGRAMS.

Identifying national research priorities for the Radiography profession: an online Delphi consensus study Hills S1, BSc(Hons), MA. Probst H1, PhD, MA,

Figure 1 Key elements of the proposed modified Delphi study

Technology Assessment

Creating a Multidisciplinary Team to Develop and Implement Interprofessional Education (IPE) Simulations Preparing Students for Collaborative Practice.

Levels of involvement Consultation Collaboration User control

Presentation transcript:

Chapter 16 Consensus Methods © Nursing Research: An Introduction by Pam Moule and Margaret Goodman (2009, SAGE)

Learning outcomes Understand Delphi, nominal group and Consensus techniques. Appreciate when these techniques might be employed in data collection.

Consensus techniques Used when: -there is a lack of understanding of a particular health care issue -if the evidence base is lacking and the degree of effectiveness and appropriateness of care delivery is unknown. There are three main techniques : -Delphi technique -Nominal group technique (NGT) -Consensus technique.

Delphi technique (1) A technique to gain consensus opinion from a group of experts. Research team identifying possible expert panel members. May need ethical permission prior to approaching panel members. Data collection via a series of consecutive questionnaires.

Delphi technique (2) The initial questionnaires are more exploratory. Subsequent questionnaires are more focussed based on the analysis of earlier responses. Experts are asked to rank their level of agreement with statements. There may be several rounds of questionnaire completion.

Delphi technique (3) Can be useful in determining research or care priorities. Can be less time-consuming for participants. Can enable engagement of a geographically disparate group.

Nominal group technique (NGT) Uses some of the processes of the Delphi technique and combines these with focus group methods. The participants meet face to face to try to achieve a consensus through a process of ranking and refining responses to key issues. Groups are around five to nine in number.

Consensus technique (1) Works on the same principles of the Nominal group technique, bringing experts together in one face-to-face forum to gain either further understanding or consensus in a particular field. An initial search of the key literature may be provided to panel members ahead of the meeting.

Consensus technique (2) The process is facilitated by either an expert in the field or someone seen as credible in the eyes of the expert panel members. Can be used in the development of clinical guidelines.