Unexpected nonquenching of the isoscalar spin-M1 transitions

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The role of the isovector monopole state in Coulomb mixing. N.Auerbach TAU and MSU.
Advertisements

Shell model studies along the N~126 line Zsolt Podolyák.
HL-3 May 2006Kernfysica: quarks, nucleonen en kernen1 Outline lecture (HL-3) Structure of nuclei NN potential exchange force Terra incognita in nuclear.
Proton Inelastic Scattering on Island-of-Inversion Nuclei Shin’ichiro Michimasa (CNS, Univ. of Tokyo) Phy. Rev. C 89, (2014)
Systematic study of the many- particle and many-hole states in and around the Island of Inversion - #N=Odd system - M. Kimura(Hokkaido)
Silvia Lenzi – ARIS 2014, Tokyo, June 2-6, 2014 Mirror Symmetry Silvia Lenzi University of Padova and INFN Silvia M. Lenzi Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia“Galileo.
Yoshitaka FUJITA (Osaka Univ.) Hirschegg Workshop /2006, Jan GT (  ) : Important weak response GT transitions of Astrophysics Interest.
GT (  ) : Weak Process: Important roles in the Universe Combined Analysis of Mirror GT Transitions for the study of Proton-Rich Far-Stability Nuclei.
Dept. of Phys., Kyushu Univ. Measurement of 2 H(p,pp)n cross sections at E p = 250 MeV Sho Kuroita 1, K. Sagara 1, Y. Eguchi 1, K. Yashima 1, T. Shishido.
S.N.Nakamura, Tohoku Univ. JLab HallC Meeting 22/Jan/2010, JLab.
1 TCP06 Parksville 8/5/06 Electron capture branching ratios for the nuclear matrix elements in double-beta decay using TITAN ◆ Nuclear matrix elements.
Spectroscopic factors and Asymptotic Normalization Coefficients from the Source Term Approach and from (d,p) reactions N.K. Timofeyuk University of Surrey.
Spin-isospin studies with the SHARAQ Spectrometer Tomohiro Uesaka & Y. Sasamoto, K. Miki, S. Noji University of Tokyo for the SHARAQ collaboration Aizu2010.
XII Nuclear Physics Workshop Maria and Pierre Curie: Nuclear Structure Physics and Low-Energy Reactions, Sept , Kazimierz Dolny, Poland Self-Consistent.
Alex Brown UNEDF Feb Strategies for extracting optimal effective Hamiltonians for CI and Skyrme EDF applications.
Feb defense Study of M1 Quenching in 28 Si by a (p,p') Measurement at zero-degrees 核物理研究センター 松原礼明 (0 度( p,p’ )測定による 28 Si のM1クエンチングに関する研究 )
Measurements of Ay for the pd breakup reaction at 250MeV Yukie Maeda (CNS, Univ. of Tokyo) T. Uesaka, T. Kawabata, K. Suda, S. Sakaguchi, Y. Sasamoto (CNS,
Realistic Calculations of Neutrino-Nucleus Reaction Cross sections T.S. Kosmas Realistic Calculations of Neutrino-Nucleus Reaction Cross sections T.S.
Neutral pion photoproduction and neutron radii Dan Watts, Claire Tarbert University of Edinburgh Crystal Ball and A2 collaboration at MAMI Eurotag Meeting.
Measurements of the cross sections and Ay for D(p,n) inclusive breakup reaction at 170 MeV Y. Maeda Y. Maeda, T. Saito, H. Miyasako (Univ. of Miyazaki)
Cross section enhancement in pd reactions at higher energ y K. Sagara, S. Kuroita, T. Sueta, H. Shimoda, Y. Eguchi, K. Yashima, T. Yabe, M. Dozono, Y.
We construct a relativistic framework which takes into pionic correlations(2p-2h) account seriously from both interests: 1. The role of pions on nuclei.
GT (  ) : Important weak process  decay : absolute B(GT), limited to low-lying state CE reactions : relative B(GT), highly Ex region  decay  isospin.
Low-lying states in 11 B Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo KAWABATA Takahiro RCNP, Osaka UniversityH. Fujimura, M. Fujiwara, K. Hara, K. Hatanaka,
Spin dependent momentum distribution of proton in 3 He studied via proton induced exclusive knock-out reaction CNS, Univ. of Tokyo Y. Shimizu I.Introduction.
Hadron Spectroscopy with high momentum beam line at J-PARC K. Ozawa (KEK) Contents Charmed baryon spectroscopy New experiment at J-PARC.
Institute for Structure and Nuclear Astrophysics Nuclear Science Laboratory E381: Search of potential resonances in the 12 C+ 12 C fusion reaction using.
July 29-30, 2010, Dresden 1 Forbidden Beta Transitions in Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay Kazuo Muto Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology.
1 Isospin symmetry. Beta-decay studies of Tz=-1 nuclei at Rising. B. Rubio for the Valencia-Osaka-Surrey-Leuven-Santiago-GSI Istambul-Lund-Legnaro Collaboration.
Variational approach to isospin symmetry breaking in medium mass nuclei A. PETROVICI Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest, Romania.
Jan. 18, 2008 Hall C Meeting L. Yuan/Hampton U.. Outline HKS experimental goals HKS experimental setup Issues on spectrometer system calibration Calibration.
February 12-15,2003 PROCON 2003, Legnaro-Padova, Italy Jean Charles THOMAS University of Leuven / IKS, Belgium University of Bordeaux I / CENBG, France.
Double β-decay Process mediated by the weak interaction occurring in even-even nuclei where the single  -decay is energetically forbidden The role of.
Search for low spin states at high excitation energies in 20 Ne with the p,t reaction iThemba LABS & Stellenbosch University Energy Postgraduate Conference.
Neutron skin thickness determined from charge exchange reactions on 90 Zr Kentaro Yako (University of Tokyo) INPC, Jun. 6,
Search for direct evidence of tensor interaction in nuclei = high momentum component in nuclei = TERASHIMA Satoru 寺嶋 知 Depart. of Nuclear Science and Technology,
1 Jeff Tostevin, Department of Physics Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences University of Surrey, United Kingdom Sensitivity of two-nucleon knockout.
Young Researchers Session in IFIN-HH 2016
The role of isospin symmetry in medium-mass N ~ Z nuclei
Kazuo Muto Tokyo Institute of Technology (TokyoTech)
L. Acosta1, M. A. G. Álvarez2, M. V. Andrés2, C. Angulo3, M. J. G
Giant Monopole Resonance
Merve DOĞAN İstanbul University
Isovector and isoscalar pairing in low-lying states of N = Z nuclei
Center for Nuclear Study, University of Tokyo
Search for unbound excited states of proton rich nuclei
High-resolution Studies of Charge Exchange on 47,48Ti in comparison with Shell Model Calculations Ela Ganioğlu Istanbul University E. Ganioglu, Stockholm.
Introduction to Charge Symmetry Breaking
Satoshi Adachi Research Center for Nuclear Physics (RCNP),
Isospin Symmetry test on the semimagic 44Cr
Searching for states analogous to the 12C Hoyle state in heavier nuclei using the thick target inverse kinematics technique. Marina Barbui 5/17/2018, Galveston,
Hiroshi MASUI Kitami Institute of Technology
Role of Pions in Nuclei and Experimental Characteristics
Structure of 10Be and 10B hypernuclei studied with four-body cluster model Λ Λ E. Hiyama (RIKEN) Submitted in PRC last August and waiting for referee’s.
Kernfysica: quarks, nucleonen en kernen
High resolution study of TZ= +3 → +2 Gamow-Teller transitions in the
Nuclear excitations in relativistic nuclear models
Study of the resonance states in 27P by using
Study of the resonance states in 27P by using
Physics Interpretation of PREX
Nuclear Decays Unstable nuclei can change N,Z.A to a nuclei at a lower energy (mass) If there is a mass difference such that energy is released, pretty.
Cluster and Density wave --- cluster structures in 28Si and 12C---
Neutrino-Nucleus Reactions and Nucleosynthesis
Kazuo MUTO Tokyo Institute of Technology
Constraining the Nuclear Equation of State via Nuclear Structure observables 曹李刚 中科院近物所 第十四届全国核结构大会,湖州,
Department of Physics, Sichuan University
Magnetic dipole excitation and its sum rule for valence nucleon pair
Probing correlations by use of two-nucleon removal
Presentation transcript:

Unexpected nonquenching of the isoscalar spin-M1 transitions Hiroaki MATSUBARA Tokyo Women’s Medical University matubara@twmu.ac.jp 2015 Nov-16-19 HST15@Osaka

Collaborators

Quenching problem of GT strength (p,n) reaction GT sum rule (model independent) K. Ikeda PL 3, 271 (1963) Only 50% strength has been observed in experiment. Where is missing strength? Measured area Δ-h? ~50% B(GT) 2p2h? 25 50 300   Ex. (MeV) ・Δ-h excitation (excitation of quark) ~300 MeV IV only M. Ichimura, H. Sakai and T. Wakasa; PPNP. 56, 446 (2006). ・2p2h excitation (tensor force effect) ~50MeV IS / IV

Quenching of spin strength 12B (12N) 0+ 1+ T=1 T=0 Quenching factor (sd-shell): Experiment / Theory of transition Ikeda Sum-rule (up to Ex=50 MeV) Shell-Model Calc. (within 0-hw) GT (στ±) 0.9 0.6 IV spin-M1 (στz) -- 0.6—1.0 (*) IS spin-M1 (στ) 0.5—0.7 (*) Uncertain results ・Quench is dominant ・Consistent with       2p2h theories However, ・ Large error bar ・ Nuclear dependence (*) Taken from G.M. Crawley PRC(1989): (p,p’) on sd-shell nuclei

Quenching of spin strength 12B (12N) 0+ 1+ T=1 T=0 Quenching factor (sd-shell): Experiment / Theory of transition Ikeda Sum-rule (up to Ex=50 MeV) Shell-Model Calc. (within 0-hw) GT (στ±) 0.9 0.6 IV spin-M1 (στz) -- 0.6—1.0 (*) IS spin-M1 (σ) 0.5—0.7 (*) Present work (within 0-hw) -- 0.61(6) 1.01(9) Nonquench! (*) Taken from G.M. Crawley PRC(1989): (p,p’) on sd-shell nuclei

Nonquenched IS spin-M1 strength was found by the present work. - Is it consistent with Δ-h excitation? - Is it consistent with 2p2h excitation? No Yes Quenching factor (sd-shell): Experiment / Theory of transition Ikeda Sum-rule (up to Ex=50 MeV) Shell-Model Calc. (within 0-hw) GT (στ±) 0.9 0.6 IV spin-M1 (στz) -- 0.6—1.0 (*) IS spin-M1 (σ) 0.5—0.7 (*) Present work (within 0-hw) -- 0.61(6) 1.01(9) Nonquench! (*) Taken from G.M. Crawley PRC(1989): (p,p’) on sd-shell nuclei

Experiment and analysis

(p,p’) experiment at the RCNP A. Tamii, NIMA605, 326 (2009) Meas. Angle =0—14 deg Proton beam : 295 MeV ΔE (FWHM): 40 keV → 20keV MWDCs Plastic Scinti. Dispersion matching

Targets 12C, 16O, 20Ne, 24Mg, 28Si, 32S, 36Ar, 40Ca Systematic study of all the T=0 (stable, N=Z even-even) nuclei 12C, 16O, 20Ne, 24Mg, 28Si, 32S, 36Ar, 40Ca Five targets will be reported in this talk. 12C, 24Mg, 28Si : Self-supporting metal foil 32S : Cooled self-supporting elemental foil 36Ar : Gas cell target H. Matsubara, NIMA 267 (2009). H. Matsubara, NIMA 678 (2012). Liquid nitrogen temperature Aramid window (6um-thickness)

High energy-resolution spectrum Sn Sp

Energy spectra at 0-degrees 24Mg 36Ar 28Si

Jπ assignment from shape of ang. dist. ・Distorted wave Born approximation by DWBA07 NN interaction. : Franey and Love, PRC31(1985)488. (325 MeV data) Trans. density : USD, USDA, USDB (from shell model calculation) 1+ 1+ 1+ 1+ Forward peaking for L=0 transition. M1 has the maximum at 0 degree. 0+, IS-1+, IV-1+ and others Distributions at 0-5 degree are similar. Difference between IS and IV is due to exchange tensor term.

IS, IV spin-M1 angular dist. (28Si) 0+ 1- 2+

Unit cross section (UCS) ・ Conversion factor from cross-section to squared nuclear matrix element (SNME) ・ Calibration from β andγ-decay measurements (assuming the isospin symmetry) (T= IS or IV) UCS Kinematical factor SNME (To be obtained) ・ Mass dependence established in GT study T.N. Taddeucci, NPA469 (1987).

IS/IV spin-M1 strength dist. Squared Nuclear Matrix Element

Summation of spin-M1 SNME ・ Summation up to 16 MeV (up to 0-hw). ・ Compared with shell-model calculations using USD-int. Squared Nuclear Matrix Elem. (Bare g) (Eff. g) Averaged quenching factors: IS spin-M1 trans. is not quenched. IS spin-M1 IV spin-M1 1.01(9) 0.61(6)

Consistency with the IS Magnetic Moment and the effective g-factor Effective g-factors were determined to reproduce <S>. The factors come from the g-factors in free space. Spin-matrix Data taken from B.A. Brown, NPA (1987). Magnetic moment Spin-matrix <S> Quenching is dominant at the shell-edge.

Consistency with the IS Magnetic Moment and the effective g-factor Effective g-factors were determined to reproduce <S>. The factors come from the g-factors in free space. Spin-matrix Data taken from B.A. Brown, NPA (1987). Magnetic moment Spin-matrix <S> Quenching is dominant at the shell-edge. Quenching is suppressed at the mid-shell.

What does the nonquench suggest? Spin alignment in the ground state Suggesting 2p2h excitation due to tensor force

Spin alignment in the ground state : total spin operator in a nucleus : spin alighment in the g.s. Nonquench suggests

How to deduce <Sp・Sn>? IS : in-phase transition for p and n IV : out-phase transition for p and n Sum of IS : (Closure approx.) Sum of IV : Subtraction of IS-sum minus IV-sum

<Sp・Sn> values USD with eff. g-factors by Arima, Towner, Brown

<Sp・Sn> values Experimental results suggest spin alignment.

<Sp・Sn> values Shell-model : USD interaction Correlated Gaussian Meth.: W. Horiuchi AV8’: 0.135 (stronger tensor) G3RS: 0.109 (weaker tensor) Minnesota: -0.020 (no tensor)

<Sp・Sn> values Shell-model : USD interaction Correlated Gaussian Meth.: W. Horiuchi No-Core Shell-model: P. Navratil

Spin alignment is supported by state-of-the-art calc. with tensor force.

Open questions Experimental results are up to 16 MeV. No experimental data at high Ex. What makes dependence of quench/nonquench at sd-shell ? Large quench for shell-edge nuclei Nonquench for mid-shell nuclei

Summary Non-quenching was observed in the IS spin-M1 transitions. Introducing <Sp・Sn>, the present result suggests that the quenching in spin transitions are due to 2p2h excitations preliminary resulting from tensor interaction. State-of-the-art calculations support the new interpretation of the spin alignment in the g.s. Thanks for the attention.

<Sp・Sn>

Proportionality of UCS (28Si) Detection limit Detection limit Theoretical study (DWBA calc.) suggests 10% uncertainty for IS.

Isospin breaking in 24Mg

Model space dependence USD = sd-shell SDPFM = sdpf-shell 唯一計算できた20Neの例 Free gs-factor モデル空間の拡張でも RIS/IV の絶対値は改善しない

Unit cross section (UCS) For isoscalar part … Mirror states of γ-decay widths of 11B/11C were employed to deduce B(M1)IS. Y.Fujita, PRC 62 (2000) 044314 Decomposition of IS spin and orbital pats T.Kawabata, PRC 70, (2004)

Total-spin-product in g.s. SM calc. Realistic-int. calc. 12C(e,e’): P.von Neumann-C., NPA(2000)

Another approach to GT quenching M1 transition is analogous to GT transition. (p,p’) → spin-M1 (p,n) or (n,p) → GT analogous 1) Δ-N-1 configuration ------ only IV 2) 2p-2h configuration ------ both IS and IV 2p-2h Δ-h M1-IS (στ) possible impossible M1-IV(στz) GT (στ±) SM QIS  > QIV = QGT QIS  = QIV = QGT Difference of quenching degree between M1-IS and IV provides us essential information of GT quenching.

What is spin-quenching? Exp. Calc. Origin GT-quenching GT Sum-rule 2p-2h >> Δ-h Truncation of high-order config. mix. ( e.g. 2p-2h, core-pol.) SM-quenching GT, IS/IV-M1 S.M. BW: B.A. Brown, NPA (1987). TK: I.S. Towner, NPA (1983). Ar: A. Arima, ANP (1987). Spin-quenching at A=17 and 39 Well studied M. Ichimura, PPNP (2006). Understood ?

How are the exp. data of spin-M1? (p,p’) experiment on 28Si 1, Sensitive to spin excitation 2, T=0 target → Separable IS from IV Spin-quenching at A=28 (28Si) 2p-2h ・Large uncertainty ・No systematic study -Only 28Si and 32S ・Incomprehensive trend Why is IS-M1 so quenched? Δ-h : Typical naive example TK, Ar : Assumed mass-dependence Exp. : G.M. Crawley et at. PRC (1989)