Advanced Corporate Finance Finance 7330 Lecture 2.2 Ronald F. Singer

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Advanced Corporate Finance Capital Budgeting Complications Finance 7330 Lecture 2.1 Ronald F. Singer.
Advertisements

Chapter Outline 6.1 Why Use Net Present Value?
Timothy R. Mayes, Ph.D. FIN 3300: Chapter 9
The Capital Budgeting Decision (Chapter 12)  Capital Budgeting: An Overview  Estimating Incremental Cash Flows  Payback Period  Net Present Value 
Capital Budgeting Processes And Techniques
Capital Budgeting Analysis
Why present value leads to better investment decisions than other criteria Yes, there are two paths you can go by, but in the long run there’s still time.
© Prentice Hall, Chapter 8 Evaluating Investment Projects Shapiro and Balbirer: Modern Corporate Finance: A Multidisciplinary Approach to Value.
Managerial Finance Finance 6335 Lecture 5 Chapter 6 & 7 Alternative Decision Rules Fundamentals of Capital Budgeting Ronald F. Singer.
B280F Introduction to Financial Management
Capital Budgeting. FIN 591: Financial Fundamentals/ValuationSlide 2 Typical Capital Budgeting System.
Capital Budgeting Net Present Value Rule Payback Period Rule
2-1 Copyright © 2006 McGraw Hill Ryerson Limited prepared by: Sujata Madan McGill University Fundamentals of Corporate Finance Third Canadian Edition.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Corporate Finance, 7/e © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 6-0 CHAPTER 6 Some Alternative Investment Rules.
Chapter 10 - Capital Budgeting
1 INVESTMENT DECISION RULES (REVIEW). 2 3 NPV and Stand-Alone Projects Consider a take-it-or-leave-it investment decision involving a single, stand-alone.
Issues in Capital Budgeting II
Last Study Topics What To Discount IM&C Project. Today’s Study Topics Project Analysis Project Interaction – Equivalent Annual Cost – Replacement – Project.
Chapter – 5 & 6: NPV & Other Investment Rules, Cash flows
Ch 6 Project Analysis Under Certainty
Capital Budgeting Evaluation Technique Pertemuan 7-10 Matakuliah: A0774/Information Technology Capital Budgeting Tahun: 2009.
Ch 9 Learning Goals 3. The importance of risk in capital budgeting.
4. Project Investment Decision-Making
COMPLEX INVESTMENT DECISIONS
FIN 40153: Advanced Corporate Finance EVALUATING AN INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY (BASED ON RWJ CHAPTER 5)
Capital Budgeting Investment Rules
Capital Budgeting Chapter 9 © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning.
Capital Budgeting FIN 461: Financial Cases & Modeling
Lecture 1 Managerial Finance FINA 6335 Ronald F. Singer.
BUA321 Chapter 10 Capital Budgeting Techniques. Capital Budgeting Terminology What kinds of projects are analyzed with capital budgeting? What is meant.
Chapter 10 - Cash Flows and Other Topics in Capital Budgeting.
Investment Decisions and Capital Budgeting
1 Practical Problems in Capital Budgeting Lecture 3 Fall 2010 Advanced Corporate Finance FINA 7330 Ronald F. Singer.
Unit 4 – Capital Budgeting Decision Methods
Business Finance (MGT 232)
Chapter 6 Investment Decision Rules
Class 3 Investment Decisions and Capital Budgeting.
1 Capital-BudgetingTechniques Chapter 9. 2 Capital Budgeting Concepts  Capital Budgeting involves evaluation of (and decision about) projects. Which.
Financial management: lecture 6 NPV and other Investment Criteria Capital Budgeting Decisions.
8-1 Lecture 8: Net Present Value and Other Investment Criteria This lecture presents multiple valuation techniques used during the capital budgeting process.
0 Corporate Finance Ross  Westerfield  Jaffe Seventh Edition 6 Chapter Six Some Alternative Investment Rules.
Chapter 10 - Cash Flows and Other Topics in Capital Budgeting.
Construction Accounting & Financial Management, 3/e Steven Peterson © 2013 by Pearson Higher Education, Inc Upper Saddle River, New Jersey All Rights.
BENEFIT-COST ANALYSIS Financial and Economic Appraisal using Spreadsheets Ch. 3: Decision Rules © Harry Campbell & Richard Brown School of Economics The.
Cash Flow Estimation Chapter 10 © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning.
Net Present Value and Other Investment Criteria Chapter 9.
Capital Budgeting Techniques
Investment Decision Criteria
Professor XXXXX Course Name / Number
Key Concepts and Skills
Chapter Outline 6.1 Why Use Net Present Value?
16BA608/FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
CAPITAL BUDGETING PROCESSES AND TECHNIQUES Dr.Rachanaa Datey
Chapter 12 - Capital Budgeting
Net Present Value Decision Rules IRR (Internal Rate of Return)
Investment Decision Rules
Capital Budgeting Analysis
Lecture 7 Capital Budgeting Complications
Chapter 8 Learning Objectives
Net Present Value and Other Investment Rules
L7 - Capital Budgeting Decision Models
Lecture 6 Capital Budgeting Complications
Net Present Value and Other Investment Criteria
CASH FLOWS IN CAPITAL BUDGETING
Advanced Corporate Finance
Net Present Value Bobby Strozak Steve Johnson.
Advanced Corporate Finance Finance 7330 Lecture 2&3 Ronald F. Singer
Chapter 8 - Cash Flows and Other Topics in Capital Budgeting
Capital-Budgeting Techniques.
Net Present Value (NPV) and Other Investment Rules
Presentation transcript:

Advanced Corporate Finance Finance 7330 Lecture 2.2 Ronald F. Singer

Practical Problems in Capital Budgeting We have stated that we want the firm to take all projects that generate positive NPV and reject all projects that have a negative NPV. Capital budgeting complications arise when you cannot, either physically or financial undertake all positive NPV projects. Then we have to devise methods of choosing between alternative positive NPV projects.

Mutually Exclusive Projects IF,AMONG A NUMBER OF PROJECTS, THE FIRM CAN ONLY CHOOSE ONE, THEN THE PROJECTS ARE SAID TO BE MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE. For example: Suppose you have the choice of modifying an existing machine, or replacing it with a brand new one. You could not do both and produce the desired amount of output. Thus, these projects are mutually exclusive. Given the cash flows below, which of these projects do you choose?

Mutually Exclusive Projects Time Modify Replace Difference 0 -100,000 -250,000 -150,000 1 105,000 130,000 25,000 2 49,000 253,500 204,500 IRR .40 .30 .25 NPV(@ 10%) 36,000 77,700 41,700 Notice the conflict that can exist between NPV and IRR.

EXAMPLES OF CAPITAL BUDGETING COMPLICATIONS 1. Optimal Timing 2. Long versus Short Life 3. Replacement Problem 4. Excess Capacity 5. Peak Load Problem (Fluctuating Load) 6. Capital Constraints

EXAMPLES OF CAPITAL BUDGETING COMPLICATIONS These Capital Budgeting Complications will stop the Firm from taking all possible positive NPV PROJECTS. Thus, the firm is faced with the choice of two possibilities. Remember: Goal is still Max NPV of all possibilities

EXAMPLES OF CAPITAL BUDGETING COMPLICATIONS We can divide these problems into three separate classes, each with their own method of solutions. (1) Once and for all deal. Choose the one alternative having the highest NPV. (2) Repetitive Deal. Choose the one alternative having the highest equivalent annual cash flow. (3) Capital Budgeting Constraint Choose the combination of projects having the highest NET PRESENT VALUE.

Once and For all Deals INVESTMENT TIMING: When is the optimal time to take on an investment project? Consider T possible times, where, t = 1, ...T. Then each "starting time" can be considered a different project in a set of T mutually exclusive projects. Then find that t which Max: NPV(t) (1+r)t

Once and For all Deals Example You are in the highly competitive area of producing laundry soap and detergents. You have a new product which you feel does a superior job in washing clothes, but you anticipate that the product will have difficulty being accepted by the consumer. Thus you expect that if you introduce the product now, you will have to suffer a few years of losses until the product is accepted by the consumer. A competitor is about to come out with a similar product. You feel that if you allow your competitor to come out with the product first, you can benefit from the time he spends acclimating your potential customers. However, you will then be giving up your competitive edge.

Once and For all Deals The initial investment in the product has already been spent, is a sunk cost and can be ignored for this problem. The anticipated life of the productive process is ten years from the time the product is first produced. Thereafter, there will be so much competition that any new investment in this product will have a zero NPV. The discount rate is 15%.

Once and For all Deals Expected cash flows are: CASH FLOW ($ MILLIONS ) year (from start of project 1 2 3 4-10 _______________________________________________ immediately -4 -3 -2 20 If introduced after one year -1 1 3.5 19.5 two years 0 2 4 19 WHAT SHOULD YOU DO?

Once and For all Deals NPV(0) (Introduced Immediately) is: 47.649 million NPV(1) (Introduced in one year's time) is: 55.531 million NPV(2) (Introduced in two year's time) is: 56.118 million WHICH ONE OF THESE THREE OPTIONS SHOULD BE TAKEN? 47.649 55.531 56.118 | | | 0 1 2 3 4 5 Calculate NPV from time 0.

Once and For all Deals Shortcut Calculate the annualized rate of change of NPV. If delaying causes the NPV to increase by more than the discount rate, the project should be delayed. If not, the project should not be delayed.

Once and For all Deals Caution This method assumes that the project cannot be reproduced at a positive NPV after the initial life of the project. Otherwise, you have to also account for the fact that the project that is started earlier can also be reproduced earlier. In that case, the alternatives look like: START IMMEDIATELY 0 10 20 30 _______________________________ ONE YEAR DELAY 0 1 11 21 31 _________________________________ THIS LEADS TO THE SECOND CLASS OF PROBLEMS: