D 4 Food webs Process: two open workshops WGGES consultation

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Marine Strategy Framework Directive Consultation on Good Environmental Status Descriptor 7 – Hydrographical Conditions Dr Alejandro Gallego Marine Scotland.

Advertisements

Conducting the IT Audit

TEMPUS IV- THIRD CALL FOR PROPOSALS Recommendation on how to make a good proposal TEMPUS INFORMATION DAYS Podgorica, MONTENEGRO 18 th December 2009.

Recommendation 2001/331/EC: Review and relation to sectoral inspection requirements Miroslav Angelov European Commission DG Environment, Unit A 1 Enforcement,

Group 1 – Monitoring, reporting and evaluation of adaptation at national level Chair: Stéphane Isoard (EEA) Rapporteur: Sergio Castellari (EEA)

Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation Using the AGREE¹ Instrument CAN-IMPLEMENT Toolkit Version 1.0 April 2010 Modified from:

Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.

Reporting on internal control in the light of the results of the survey of the Subcommittee on Internal Control Standards Maria Sieklucka Senior Public.

Croatia: Result orientation within the process of preparation of programming documents V4+ Croatia and Slovenia Expert Level Conference Budapest,

Specific Literacy Difficulty Service March 2012 Children & Young People’s Services.

An Integrated Approach to the Future Role of the RCARO in Support of the RCA Programme.

Theme 3 – Physical loss and damage to the seafloor

Indicators for a healthy age and size structure distribution:

Marine Environment and Water Industry Unit

Guidance on Natura 2000 and Forests – Scoping Document

Project Coordination Group (PCG) for the implementation of the MSFD

ICES led Reviews of D3, D4, D6 & D11

Guidance report: Methodology for the assessment of ecological coherence of MPA’s Henk Wolters 30 October 2014.

Guidance on Natura 2000 and Forests – Scoping Document

Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)

Draft Article 8 MSFD assessment guidance

D 3 Commercially exploited fish & shellfish

JRC’s Follow-up work to improve GES assessment

Project Coordination Group (PCG) for the implementation of the MSFD

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

D2 NIS REVIEW PROCESS March 2014: Draft Manual endorsed by WG GES

The Marine Strategy Framework Directive

D 11 Energy, including underwater noise

Improving assessment of GES Draft conclusions and Way forward

Progress Works, recommendations and future work programme

Revision of Common Understanding on Art. 8, 9 and 10 MSFD

Technical guidance for assessment under Article 8 MSFD

WG GES Workshop Art. 8 MSFD Assessment

Road map of proposed work

Art. 8 MSFD assessment guidance

Conclusions: Parallel session 2, Group 2

Progress in the implementation of D11

Marine Strategy Framework Directive State of play and follow up

European Commission DG Environment

MSFD Com Dec 2010/ 477/ EU review Recommendations for D2

Good practice in preparing an application

Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)

D1 Species Conclusions.

Conclusions Group 3 Parallel sessions 2 and 3

15th meeting of MSCG, 9 February 2015, Brussels

Information on projects

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

Assessment of Conservation Status for Large Carnivores

WG GES: Decision review progress

D 6 Sea floor integrity Process: two open workshops WGGES consultation

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

Methodological choices linked to the 2nd consultation on the EU reference document on natural capital accounting Expert workshop on Natural Capital Accounting.

Green Paper ‘Adapting to Climate Change in Europe’

European Commission, DG Environment, Marine Unit

Reporting for MSFD Article 13 and 14 –

Draft CIS work programme

Main recommendations & conclusions (1)

Scene setter European Commission DG Environment

Metadata on quality of statistical information

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

WG GES Drafting Group June 2013 Berlin

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

Joint meeting of WG’s DIKE, GES, POMESA 27 April 2017, Brussels

WG A ECOSTAT Draft Mandate

ICES requested to give guidance on integration

Marine Environment and Water Industry

Article 8 Guidance – Integration levels and methods

The Marine Strategy Framework Directive

WGCV CARD4L Peer Review Medhavy Thankappan WGCV-45 July 15-19, 2019.

Presentation transcript:

D 4 Food webs Process: two open workshops WGGES consultation external peer review ICES advice

D 4 Recommendations Revise criteria to structure and function Use the concept of trophic guild Guidance provided on GES assessment and use of surveillance indicators. Consider links to D1, H&BD

D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame Uncertainty D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame 1. Further clarification on surveillance indicators and accounting for uncertainty. Use existing EU projects and ICES working groups to formulate appropriate methods 2016 Suggested request to ICES for advice to provide methods to deal with uncertainty in D4 indicators.

D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame Regional consistency D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame 2. Few clear regional approaches on setting limits Best practice guidelines be developed jointly by RSCs and ICES. 2017 Process developed in 2015-2017, where RSCs and ICES experts jointly meet to address D4 limits and targets. Similar to a TG for D4.

D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame GES assessment D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame 3. No clarity on whether GES assessments are appropriate when using surveillance approaches National and regional consultations on the implementation of the proposed framework for D4. 2017 Consultations be held to address how to use surveillance approaches to assess GES, under the auspices of WGGES/DGENV

D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame Improved indices D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame 4. The suggested revision does not address food web stability, the functional role of lower trophic guilds and relevance of size to foodwebs Further development of D4 indicators associated with management strategy evaluations of the impacts of pressures through national and EU projects. 2018 The job is only half done. Member states and RSC continue development of more iterative indicators for D4.

Summary Uncertainty Regional consistency GES assessment D 4 Outstanding Issues, Resolution, Potential Time Frame Summary Uncertainty Regional consistency GES assessment Improved indices