Title Paper Authors Author Organization Presenting team credits

Limitations One sentence summary of the limitation [A result video/figure that best illustrates the limitation] Long statement of the 3 major limitations Don’t be afraid to challenge any claim

Connect contributions to the blackboxes A blackbox overview of the paper [A pipeline figure that clearly shows inputs and outputs of each blackbox] Connect contributions to the blackboxes

Why is this an important problem to solve? Motivation Why is this an important problem to solve? Does the problem definition make sense? Why is this an important problem in the area? Did this method innovate significantly over previous methods?

Statement of Limitation 1 What is the problem? What are the inputs and outputs? What’s the insight of the idea? How does it work (kernel of the idea)? How does it relate to the overall picture?

Statement of Limitation 2 What is the problem? What are the inputs and outputs? What’s the insight of the idea? How does it work (kernel of the idea)? How does it relate to the overall picture?

Statement of Limitation 3 What is the problem? What are the inputs and outputs? What’s the insight of the idea? How does it work (kernel of the idea)? How does it relate to the overall picture?

Run a simulation in your head of each idea Be Critical Run a simulation in your head of each idea Is it original? Is it reproducible? Did the authors omit any results? Any figures? Were all the claims justified? Is it likely to inspire future work? Are there simpler solutions to the same problem? Did they evaluate the approach thoroughly?

Pros and Cons Pros and Cons Pros (Bold claims of contributions) Cons (Honest list of limitations) Not repeat we’ve seen. Prediction cost is about 1ms in an unoptimized python implementation

Answer these Questions SIGGRAPH Review Form Answer these Questions Clarity of Exposition: Quality of References: Reproducibility: Rating: Explanation of Rating: Not repeat we’ve seen. Prediction cost is about 1ms in an unoptimized python implementation

Review the long statement of limitation Summary of Limitations Reiterate the core limitation List all the limitation Review the long statement of limitation