Legal Analysis of the Supreme Court Ruling on Hobby Lobby

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Health Reform and Private Insurance Gary Claxton Vice President Kaiser Family Foundation April
Advertisements

Background – Mr. Duncan began career helping individuals and organizations protect their religious freedoms by teaching con law at U Miss. Law. – Served.
Supreme Court (and More) Health Law Cases 2014 Marshall Kapp, J.D., M.P.H. FSU Center for Innovative Collaboration in Medicine and Law.
Founded Hobby Lobby in 1972 – 514 stores in 41 states with 13,000 employees Also founded Mardel – bookstore and educational supply co. specializing in.
Indiana State Nurses Association –Meeting of the Members – 9/12/14 –Policy 101 – 11/7/14
Religion and Zoning Professor Lora A. Lucero Planning & Environmental Law Fall 2011.
Part 1 Facts about Sebelius vs. Hobby Lobby Part 2 Implications if Hobby Lobby Wins Part 3 Implications if Hobby Lobby Loses.
ISSUES AROUND WYMAN- GORDON BOARD RULE-MAKING AUTHORITY –RULE: An agency statement of (usually) general applicability and future effect for all affected.
Women’s Health under the Affordable Care Act The Covering Health Reform Webinar Series For Journalists Presented by the Kaiser Family Foundation Thursday,
+ The Affordable Care Act. + Outcomes Participants will: Gain knowledge of the history of the Affordable Care Act; Understand the benefits for children.
How Americans Pay for Health Care: A Brief Overview October 12, 2010 Merton D. Finkler, Ph.D. John R. Kimberly Distinguished Professor in the American.
STAY INFORMED! WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT HEALTH CARE REFORM May 2012.
The Health Care Law and What Women Stand to Gain Reproductive Law & Policy 101 June 13 th, 2014 Judy Waxman, Vice President Health & Reproductive Rights.
Legality and Requirements Legal in 5 states: Oregon, Washington, Vermont, New Mexico and technically Montana Oregon, Washington, Vermont, and New Mexico.
RFRA Religious Freedom Restoration Act
The Obama Plan Cedric K. Dark, MD, MPH Disclaimer: I’m not advocating for the plan, I’m just analyzing it...but you gotta admit...it’s a million times.
HEALTH CARE REFORM LEGAL UPDATE – WHERE ARE WE GOING NOW? Vickie J. Williams Associate Professor of Law Gonzaga University School of Law September 15,
IF Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood have religious rights, AND IF the contraceptive coverage rule substantially burdens these rights, Next question for.
1 October 15, 2013 Eric Rasmusen, Can a Corporate Director Try to Help Stakeholders? This paper is not yet written. It would be aimed.
Impact of the Affordable Care Act on the Latino Community National Hispanic Medical Association Meeting Steven Weinberger, MD, FACP Executive Vice President.
2013 QHP Eligible Uninsured Cowlitz Family Health Center.
Healthcare in the Netherlands Kees-Pieter Dekker Athens 24 – 27 May 2009.
BY: EMILY HAWKINSON, SARAH MACEDONIA, HEATHER RICKS, & ANDREW WHITIS Controversy Surrounding the Obama Administration’s Compromise on Contraception Benefits.
The Human Rights Implications of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores Inc. & Conestoga Wood Specialties Store v. Burwell Katrina Anderson, Senior Human Rights.
SCOTUS Case Zubik v. Burwell to Decide Whether ACA Accommodates or Burdens Nonprofits’ Religious Beliefs CONTRACEPTION BATTLEPRESENTATION CENTER March.
Sara Rosenbaum, JD Harold and Jane Hirsh Professor, Health Law and Policy.
Homework: Assignment 3 Consider: What examples of the mixture of “church and state” can you cite?
Percentage of Plans with General Annual Deductible, Marketplace and Employer-Based Plans, 2016 Exhibit 2 * Most recent employer survey data are from 2015.
Legality and Controversy of “Obamacare” Contemporary Political Problem Julie Crouse.
Advancing the health of Ohioans through informed policy decisions Insurance basics: Provisions of the Affordable Care Act and how Ohioans are covered Reem.
1 Views on Paying for Quicker Access Q: Do you think that Canadians should be allowed to pay out of pocket to purchase faster access to health services.
Percentage of Plans with Annual Deductible, by Metal Tier, Cost-Sharing Reduction, and Employer Plans, 2016 Notes: Base silver plans have an actuarial.
Healthcare Law and the Role of the Courts
Health Reform: What It Means to Our Community
ACC Financial Services Committee Panel on Supreme Court
Contraceptive Coverage Under the ACA
Supplementary Data Tables, Trends in Overall Health Care Market
Public opinion on women’s health and preventive care
Public opinion on women’s health and preventive care
Coverage type Percent of population
Change in Benchmark Silver Premiums, 2014 – 2015 Percent change in second-lowest silver plan, by county in 50 states and the District of Columbia Note:
ERISA Litigation Update
Due Process Flowchart1 Due Process violated Due Process not violated
The Hobby Lobby Decision and Beyond
Health Policy: The Role of the Courts
Divisibility Rules Practice 2, 5, or 10?
REPEAL/REPLACE THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT?
ASKED OF THOSE WHO WANT TO EXPAND MEDICAID:
Marriage Rights October 12, 2017.
Trends in the Overall Health Care Market
Daniel Bruner Senior Director of Policy May 1, 2015
Silver and Bronze Premium Changes from 2014 to 2015 Percent change in second-lowest silver and lowest-cost bronze plans, by county in 50 states and the.
Trends in the Overall Health Care Market
How Does Health Care Reform Impact Your Company?
Federalism 10th Amendment.
Public opinion on women’s health and preventive care
Consumer-Driven Health Care: A National Overview
1st Amendment Free Exercise Clause
NHE Total Expenditures: $2,700.7 billion
How does cost affect access to care?
New Coverage for 45 Million Uninsured 12m 19m 13m <1m
Supplementary Data Tables, Trends in Overall Health Care Market
Health Reform: What It Means to Our Community
Credit per employee $9,435—projected family premium 50% employer
* Most recent employer survey data are from 2015.
Barriers to Care Experienced by Women in the United States
Percentage of Plans Where the Beneficiary Must Meet a Deductible Before Primary Care Office Visits or Prescription Drugs Are Covered, Marketplace and.
June 2013 Supreme Court Ruling
Estimated Premiums for New Public Plan Compared with Average Current Premiums, Individual/Small Employer Private Market, 2010 Average annual premium.
Over A Third Report Actively Seeking Out ACA Information
Presentation transcript:

Legal Analysis of the Supreme Court Ruling on Hobby Lobby Is the for-profit employer a “person” capable of religious belief? Does the requirement to provide health insurance for contraceptives substantially burden the employer? Does the government have a compelling interest to provide health insurance coverage for preventive care including contraceptives? Is the government meeting the compelling interest in the least restrictive way? Burden on Employer Burden on Government 2. 3. 4. 1. YES YES NO No Ruling NO NO NO YES Does not violate RFRA Violates RFRA SOURCE: Kaiser Family Foundation.