Wason and Johnson-Laird (1972)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Calculating Probabilities If a set of events have an equal chance of occurring, it is possible to calculate probabilities. For example, you can calculate.
Advertisements

Identify if the statement that follow is True or False. Click your choice and see if you got the correct answer. Enjoy!
Copyright © Cengage Learning. All rights reserved. 6 Equations and Formulas.
1 7.6 Quadratic and other Nonlinear Inequalities BobsMathClass.Com Copyright © 2010 All Rights Reserved. Procedure for Graphing Quadratic Inequalities.
Wason’s selection task
Logical Reasoning: Deduction. Logic A domain-general system of reasoning Deductive reasoning System for constructing proofs –What must be true given certain.
Solved the Maze? Start at phil’s house. At first, you can only make right turns through the maze. Each time you cross the red zigzag sign (under Carl’s.
Click Here to Begin the Game CHOICE 1CHOICE 2CHOICE 3 CHOICE CHOICE
 Linear Equations in Two Variables  To Graph a Linear Inequality 1)Graph the related linear equality (forms the boundary line).  and  are graphed.
Theoretical Probability of Simple Events
Today you will be working with algebraic equivalent fractions Next lesson you will be combining algebraic fractions using all four basic operations.
UMBC  CSEE   1 Inference in First-Order Logic Chapter 9 Some material adopted from notes by.
Research Paper Due Monday, November 21 3pm Presentations November 21- December 1.
Reasoning Top-down biases symbolic distance effects semantic congruity effects Formal logic syllogisms conditional reasoning.
1.4 Solving Equations ●A variable is a letter which represents an unknown number. Any letter can be used as a variable. ●An algebraic expression contains.
CH 8 : Enhancing Classes - Review QUICK REVIEW : A Class defines an entity’s (Object’s) data and the actions or behaviors (Methods) associated with that.
Notes Over 12.3 Finding Probabilities of Events
Question of the Day!  We shared a lot of examples of illogical arguments!  But how do you make a LOGICAL argument? What does your argument need? What.
Reasoning.
10.6 Using the Quadratic Formula – Quadratic Formula Goals / “I can…”  Use the quadratic formula when solving quadratic equations  Choose an appropriate.
REASONING AS PROBLEM SOLVING DEDUCTIVE REASONING: –what, if any, conclusions necessarily follow? INDUCTIVE REASONING: –what is the probability that those.
Logical Reasoning:Proof Prove the theorem using the basic axioms of algebra.
Test Better Robert Shaffer, David Colter. Hello Wolrd World Who are we? What do we do? What is this workshop about?
© 2011 MARS University of NottinghamBeta Version Projector resources: Evaluating Statements About Probability Projector Resources.
The Cognitive Perspective Computers vs. Humans. Starter (10 mins) Name the 5 perspectives in Psychology. Name the 5 perspectives in Psychology. Name 3.
Activity 2-5: What are you implying?
[Option 2 instructions] [Option 2 instructions]
Prior Knowledge. Each card has a letter on one side and a number on the other. Rule: If a card has a vowel on one side, it should have an even number.
Fact and Opinion To be a good reader, you should be able to tell the difference between a fact and an opinion. Figuring out facts from opinions is something.
Ch 1.6 Commutative & Associative Properties
Activity 1-12 : Multiple-free sets
EXAMPLE 3 Write an indirect proof Write an indirect proof that an odd number is not divisible by 4. GIVEN : x is an odd number. PROVE : x is not divisible.
Rational analysis of the selection task Oaksford and Chater (1994) Presented by Bryan C. Russell.
Instructions (delete this page when finished)  Choose one of the countries we have studied in the “Russia and the Republics” unit. You may not choose.
Introduction to probability (2) Combinations التوافيق Definition of combination: It is a way of selecting items from a collection, such that the order.
How do we reason and solve problems? Psychological factors in solving problems Varieties of problems Algorithms and heuristics Barriers and strategies.
Adapted by Mrs. Garay. Warm Up Solve. 1. 2x + 9x – 3x + 8 = – 4 = 6x + 22 – 4x 3. + = 5 4. – = 3 x = 1 x = –13 x = x x9x 16 2x2x 4.
The Fundamental Counting Principle and Permutations 18.0 Students use fundamental counting principles to compute combinations and permutations Students.
Confirmation Bias: A Methodology of Social Science
1 מקורות החשיבה המדעית/מתימטית ( ) אורי לירון שיעור ראשון – חידות, מֶטָה-חידות, תהיות, וסתם שאלות מעצבנות.
LEARNING OUTCOMES : a. understand combinations of a set of objects. b. determine the number of ways to form combinations of r objects from n objects Click.
Two Bags of Jellybeans I have two bags A and B. Both contain red and yellow jellybeans.   There are more red jellybeans in bag A than in bag B. If I choose.
5.6 Indirect Proof and Inequalities in Two Triangles
Algebra Bell-work 9/13/17 Turn in your HW! 1.) 7x – 6 = 2x + 9
The Impact of Political literacy on Political Attitudes
Public Key Cryptosystems - RSA
Mutually Exclusive and Inclusive Events
Calculating Probabilities
the first card insert text here.
Proof at Key Stage 4 Jo Sibley. Proof at Key Stage 4 Jo Sibley.
Mutually Exclusive and Inclusive Events
Calculating Probabilities
If Statement Functions in Excel
Mutually Exclusive and Inclusive Events
Objective Solve equations in one variable that contain variable terms on both sides.
Task: Copy Pre-work and Additional Pay Requests
Midterm Discussion.
Rational analysis of the selection task
Objective Solve equations in one variable that contain variable terms on both sides.
Wason and Johnson-Laird (1972)
Confirmation Bias We prefer, look for, remember, and understand information that agrees with what we already believe.1 2.
Mutually Exclusive and Inclusive Events
Calculating Probabilities
Welcome to English 110.
The Cognitive Perspective
Independent and Dependent Events
ID1050– Quantitative & Qualitative Reasoning
Mutually Exclusive and Inclusive Events
I have… I have… Who has 3:40? Who has 12:20? I have… I have…
Independent Writing Time: 15 minutes
Presentation transcript:

Wason and Johnson-Laird (1972) Confirmation Bias The Wason Card Problem Wason and Johnson-Laird (1972)

Confirmation Bias Each card has a number on one side and a letter on the other. You can turn over 1 or 2 cards. Which card / cards would you turn over to prove the following statement false? “If a card has a vowel on one side, it has an even number on the other”.

Confirmation Bias “If a card has a vowel on one side, it has an even number on the other”. 1 card? 2 cards?

Confirmation Bias “If a card has a vowel on one side, it has an even number on the other”. Choose a Combination A and D? D and 4? D and 7? 4 and 7? A and 4? A and 7?

Confirmation Bias By selecting only one card you can only confirm the statement. As you will recall, the objective was to falsify it… Return

Confirmation Bias Selecting this combination means you have confirmed the statement. Which is good. The downside here is that your task was to select cards to falsify the statement… Return

Confirmation Bias You have not chosen a vowel. These cards, therefore, cannot falsify the original statement. Return

Confirmation Bias This selection cannot falsify the original statement because you have not chosen a vowel. Return

Confirmation Bias This selection cannot falsify the original statement because you have not chosen a vowel. Return

Confirmation Bias By selecting these cards you have confirmed the statement. You can take some comfort in the fact this was likely to be the most popular choice among your peers. You are not, in all probability, alone. Return

Confirmation Bias “If a card has a vowel on one side, it has an even number on the other”. The only card combination that can be used to prove this statement false is: A + 7

Confirmation Bias ShortCutstv The Wason Card Problem Wason and www.shortcutstv.com Wason and Johnson-Laird (1972) © 2018