Tackling problem debt Rich Sullivan-Jones and Ivan O’Brien

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
HELPING THE NATION SPEND WISELY Performance audit and evaluation: common ground with Internal Audit ? The UK National Audit Office experience Jeremy Lonsdale.
Advertisements

Governance for REDD+ Crystal Davis Governance of Forests Initiative World Resources Institute REDD Civil Society Coordination Seminar CIFOR campus, Bogor.
Debt Management Strategy: Governance and Transparency
Monitoring and Evaluation in the CSO Sector in Ghana
29e CONFÉRENCE INTERNATIONALE DES COMMISSAIRES À LA PROTECTION DES DONNÉES ET DE LA VIE PRIVÉE 29 th INTERNATIONAL DATA PROTECTION AND PRIVACY COMMISSIONERS.
Overview of NAO work relating to Jobcentre Plus Presentation to NAWRA 2 September 2005 Rebecca Sidell Dawson Auditor - Welfare, Work & Education VFM.
Key National Indicators and Supreme Audit Institutions: U.S. and INTOSAI Perspectives Bernice Steinhardt Director, Strategic Issues U.S. Government Accountability.
Australia’s Experience in Utilising Performance Information in Budget and Management Processes Mathew Fox Assistant Secretary, Budget Coordination Branch.
Session 3 - Plenary on implementing Principle 1 on an Explicit Policy on Regulatory Quality, Principle 3 on Regulatory Oversight, and Principle 6 on Reviewing.
Common recommendations and next steps for improving local delivery of climate finance Bangkok, October 31, 2012.
The role of Audit Scotland in monitoring police performance Miranda Alcock Portfolio Manager – Public Reporting Group.
Planning and submitting a shadow report Charlotte Gage Women’s Resource Centre.
Evaluation Office 1 Evaluating Capacity Development David Todd Senior Evaluation Officer GEF Evaluation Office.
The Future of Adult Social Care John Crook March 2011.
East Asia and the Pacific Region
Why is financial inclusion important? Financial inclusion is about ensuring that everyone has access to appropriate financial services to Manage their.
Improving Regulation in Scotland (IRIS) Unit 'A better deal for business' Working together for Scotland - A programme for Government lays out the Scottish.
Guidance for AONB Partnership Members Welsh Member Training January 26/
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY REGULATION AND POLICY-MAKING FOR AFRICA Module 5 Energy Regulation Module 5: STRUCTURE, COMPOSITION AND ROLE OF AN ENERGY REGULATOR.
Commissioning Self Analysis and Planning Exercise activity sheets.
THE SCOTTISH EXPERIENCE OF PROMOTING GENDER-SENSITIVE BUDGETING Rona Fitzgerald, EOC Scotland and SWBG and Morag Gillespie SLPU/Glasgow Caledonian SWBG.
DRAFT: Budget Transparency and Country Systems December 4, 2013, Seoul Forum on Using Country Systems to Manage Climate Finance.
1 Governance, accountability and performance reporting in the public sector Des Pearson Executive in Residence August 2013.
1 Harmonisation and Alignment: Challenges for US and European donors Alex Wilks, European Network on Debt and Development GMF, 18 th December
Slide 1 The Young Foundation 2010 Making the difference – why measurement matters in work with young people Gemma Rocyn Jones The Young Foundation NYCI.
HELPING THE NATION SPEND WISELY Evaluating the quality and use of Impact Assessments The role and approach of the NAO.
DETERMINE Working document # 4 'Economic arguments for addressing social determinants of health inequalities' December 2009 Owen Metcalfe & Teresa Lavin.
Cutting the cost of keeping warm: A fuel poverty strategy for England 08 September 2015.
Kathy Corbiere Service Delivery and Performance Commission
IRSPM 2014 Intersections: Governance, Democracy, Accountability D1 Special Interest Group Accounting and Accountability A strategic state firework fallen.
Regulation Inside Government: Approach and lessons learned Punita Goodfellow, Better Regulation Executive, Cabinet Office, UK.
Nottingham Trent University Alternative Futures Conference 2014 The OECD concept of the ‘Strategic State’ and its application to 3 inter-related areas.
An overview of OECD Strategies for Improving Regulatory Performance Regulatory Reform and Building Governance Capacities – New Delhi 3 December 2009 Mr.
Supporting People Review Presentation for NIFHA Care and Support Conference – 3 June 2015 Stephen Martin, Deputy Director, Housing Policy Delivery.
ITP 1325 March The Women's Budget Group The Women's Budget Group produces reports and responses providing gender analysis of government policy and.
Page 1 The statutory framework for financial oversight Select Committee on Finance, 13 April 2010 Annexure B.
PROTECTING THE INTERESTS OF CONSUMERS OF FINANCIAL SERVICES Role of Supervisory Authorities Keynote Address to the FinCoNet Open Meeting 22 April 2016.
Overview of Good Regulatory Practice Kent Shigetomi Office of the U.S. Trade Representative.
Torbay Council Partnerships Review August PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP Date Page 2 Torbay Council Partnerships Background The Audit Commission defines.
Raising standards improving lives The revised Learning and Skills Common Inspection Framework: AELP 2011.
Techuk.org | #techUK Is Government Meeting its SME Target? Join the #SMETownHall.
Money Advice Scotland Annual Conference & Exhibition 2016 Crieff Hydro, 2 nd & 3 rd June 2016.
Putting market outcomes on the centre stage The LSBs efforts to evaluate market change Robert Cross PSA 11 March 2016.
CISI – Financial Products, Markets & Services
Background Significant reform across aged care sector aiming to create greater national consistency and more integration across the care system. Changes.
Building evaluation in the Department of Immigration and Citizenship
Transforming the future of public health in Missouri
Joint Seminar Brussels 2017.
Agency Performance: A New Agenda
Parliament and the National Budget Process
Governance and Accountability of Policing in Scotland
Information for New Members of Crown Entity Boards
PEMPAL, Moscow, October 2016 Natalia Pilets Deputy Head,
Data Sharing Consultation Event
GODFREY HODGSON HOLMES TARCA
Professionalisation leads to better governance and Public Financial Management Gillian Fawcett May 2018.
The SWA Collaborative Behaviors
MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF SUPREME AUDIT INSTITUTION
Council of Europe Child Participation Assessment Tool
Aged care research project overview of findings and key themes
Scotland’s Debt Solutions
The role of Supreme Audit Institutions in fragile situations: initial findings Research by David Goldsworthy and Silvia Stefanoni of Development Action.
Social Justice Support for the most disadvantaged families and individuals Second chance society Getting on to the first rung of the ladder (progress.
Preparing for Universal Credit: lessons from the front-line".
Update Scottish Government Support for Advice Services
FINANCING NATURA 2000 Agenda item 2.1 CGBN Co-ordination Group
NAO report Abdool Kara, Executive Leader March 2019
MGT601 SME MANAGEMENT.
Overview of Good Regulatory Practice
Presentation transcript:

Tackling problem debt Rich Sullivan-Jones and Ivan O’Brien National Audit Office 7 February 2019

Structure 1. The NAO Our role Our value for money (VFM) work 2. Report overview Background VFM Conclusions 3. Key findings Identifying the problem and coordinating the approach Preventing over-indebtedness Managing problem debt 4. Questions for group discussions

The NAO

Our role The National Audit Office (NAO) scrutinises public spending for Parliament We help to hold government departments and other public bodies to account for how they use public money or deliver public policy Our work helps public service managers to improve performance and service delivery, nationally and locally

There are five dimensions to our work * International Organisation of Supreme Audit Institutions

Our VFM work Through our Value-for-Money (VfM) work, we report on the economy, efficiency and effectiveness with which public sector bodies use public money National Audit Act 1983 gives statutory access & reporting rights ~ 60 published outputs a year; most heard by the Committee of Public Accounts (PAC) We do not comment on the merits of policy objectives, but aim to conclude on whether value for money has been secured Our public audit perspective helps Parliament hold government to account and improve public services. It leads to savings and other efficiency gains: £741 million of agreed, audited savings in 2017-18

Tackling problem debt: report overview

Background On 6 September 2018 we published our report on Tackling problem debt. The report aims to evaluate and conclude on HMT's overall approach to over-indebtedness, and how well it brings together government's and other stakeholders' various activities and interventions to meet its objectives. In particular, the report examines: Whether HMT has appropriate mechanisms to identify the scale and nature of the problem it is seeking to address and organise government's response Evidence on the effectiveness and coordination of government actions to prevent problem debt through improving people's financial capability and regulating consumer credit lending The extent to which government as a whole adopts best practice in managing its own debtors, and supports over-indebted people more generally through debt advice and other protections

VFM conclusions HMT is taking a thoughtful and well-intentioned approach to excessive indebtedness. It recognises that this has significant damaging effects in terms of public and economic costs, as well as on individuals, although these are not quantified. The effort to provide support across multiple government actors has become more coherent in recent years. However, the problem has not stood still. Utility providers and the public sector have emerged as major components of debt problems. The information available in these areas is, disappointingly, much less coherent or transparent than commercial debt information. There are also crucial areas, such as debt collection, where public oversight lacks impact. While recognising the positives, we conclude that HMT cannot promote improvement in the management of excessive debt as effectively as possible across a wide network without fixing the weak links. This leads us to assess that there is further to go before value for money is secured.

Identifying the problem and coordinating the approach

HMT relies on many organisations to meet its objectives on problem debt, but there are weaknesses in its accountability arrangements for ensuring there is an effective and coherent approach.

People increasingly report problems with debts owed to government or utility providers, but HMT has limited insight into these areas. Government has less detailed insight into debts in other private and public sectors compared with consumer credit and mortgages, and it does not accurately know the overall level of outstanding personal debt. Not all departments, agencies and regulators collect data on personal debts.

Government has no estimate of the extent to which problem debt leads to increased use of public services, or the resulting cost to the taxpayer. Understanding these costs is important for policymakers in considering the impact of policy design on over-indebtedness. We modelled national survey data to produce our own estimates.

Preventing over-indebtedness

MAS has improved coordination of interventions to raise individuals' financial capability, but its strategy does not involve all relevant parts of government and MAS does not yet know the strategy's impact. MAS has improved coordination of interventions to raise individuals' financial capability, but its strategy does not involve all relevant parts of government and MAS does not yet know the strategy's impact. Research from MAS and the OECD suggest financial capability in the UK is low, and below average among OECD countries.

The FCA has taken action to improve responsible lending, but recognises that it has more to do to tackle persistent and unsustainable consumer credit debt. Many people, including the poorest in society, will struggle to afford services regardless of how well they manage their money. Government therefore seeks to prevent people getting over-indebted by ensuring that service providers consider what their customers can afford. Affordability is a particular concern in unsecured consumer credit, where debt levels can escalate quickly due to high interest rates.

Managing problem debt

Evidence shows that good debt collection practice both benefits individuals and boosts collection rates. Common best practice principles include timely assessments of vulnerabilities, affordable repayment plans, and signposting or referring people to debt advice. Research in 2014 estimated that tailored debt advice, support and affordable repayments saved creditors £82 million in a year from 110,000 over-indebted clients, an average saving of £750 per person. Lenders and debt collection agencies we interviewed also reported benefits from following best practice. By comparison, our modelling, based on a survey of debt advice clients, estimates that intimidating actions and additional charges were 15%–29% more likely to make debts harder to manage and increase levels of anxiety or depression.

Barriers to adoption of good practice in government: 1. A lack of data sharing The Committee of Public Accounts' 2014 report on managing debt owed to central government found that departments lacked the information necessary to target collection activities, and recommended developing a single view of what each debtor owes to government as a whole. There are legal barriers to sharing personal data between organisations. Furthermore, not all departments can disaggregate all debts owed by individuals from debts owed by organisations. The Cabinet Office developed data-sharing legislation through the Digital Economy Act 2017, which includes new powers that allow specified public authorities to pilot data-sharing for specific purposes and with appropriate safeguards.

Barriers to adoption of good practice in government: 2. Short-term incentives and funding pressures People report more problems with debts owed to government as the fiscal year progresses. This pattern is not observed with private sector debts. Stakeholders we interviewed considered that this could be affected by short-term incentives (in-year collection targets and league tables) and local funding pressures creating a greater demand to pursue debts more quickly and aggressively.

Strengthening statutory protections and a shortfall in debt advice Following manifesto commitments in the 2017 election, HMT announced the Breathing Space scheme and Statutory Repayment Plan for people who have problem debt. Success will depend on the extent to which the new protections are used and the impact they have on outcomes, which HMT recognises it will need to consider when designing the scheme. MAS commissioned an independent review of debt advice funding which highlighted there is a shortfall in the current level of provision, with an estimated 600,000 over-indebted individuals unable to access advice. To satisfy future demand, the review recommended that the amount of free debt advice available needs to rise by 50% within two years.

Questions for group discussion Three groups, to discuss one question each. We will have around 25 minutes to discuss the question and capture our thoughts, after which we will each feed back to the other groups. What can be done to improve the quality and availability of data on the scale, nature and impact of problem debt? What are the three main barriers to preventing problem debt from occurring in the first place, and how might we overcome them? What can public sector creditors learn from private sector creditors and the debt advice sector about good debt collection practice, and how can we facilitate this?