Inequality in America The big question: Should equality—economic or political—matter very much? Why are economic and political resources in America so.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
To Accompany Comprehensive, Alternate, and Texas Editions American Government: Roots and Reform, 10th edition Karen OConnor and Larry J. Sabato Pearson.
Advertisements

Government Chapter 17 Elections and voting. Electing the President  Presidential candidates begin the campaign a year before.  Intensity builds after.
Inequality and the UK General Election Background facts May 7th 2015 Election Date:
Jefferson Hamilton I want to become president to assure that the state governments have power. I completely disagree with that. National Government should.
Cluster 2 Unit 6.  Democracy is: 1) A process 2) People listen to one another 3) People say what they think 4) People make decisions together by accepting.
BY TERESA CHATEL ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS 3.1 AND 3.2.
Why People vote Suffering through Suffrage. Clearly Communicated Learning Objectives Analyze the theories of why people vote and apply them to the 2008.
THE BIG PICTURE. WHAT CAN GOVERNMENT DO TO PROMOTE ECONOMIC GROWTH? Is economic growth really the government’s job? What should the government.
Do Now: 1. ) What is the function of Political Parties. 2
Suffrage and Turnout POLS 4349 Dr. Brian William Smith.
Writing Prompt Questions
Republicans vs. Democrats… What’s the difference anyway? Unit 5: Ante Up.
AMERICA = YOU PARLIAMENTARY = PARTY PAGE 231 Presidential –More people vote –Candidate must work harder and spend more –More competitive –Winner gets.
TOPIC 2 POLITICAL BEHAVIOR. PARTY SYSTEMS One-party systems are usually found in nations with authoritarian governments. Minor parties exist in two-party.
Voter registration numbers say a lot about what citizens think of their vote –Less than half of eligible citizens in America are registered to vote –40%
POLITICAL PARTICIPATION IN THE US What do we mean by political participation? Why do we privilege voting as a measure of political participation? Is political.
The Changing Role of Political Parties Answer Review.
Larry Bartels, “Is the Water Rising?” PS: Political Science and Politics, 26 Jan. 39, 1.
 Electing the President  Election days are held the Tuesday after the first Monday in November  Elections  Every 4 years a president is elected  1/3.
Definition: A body of ideas or views of the world that reflect the social needs, values, and ideas of an individual or group Political Spectrum Broad.
CHARACTERISTICS OF DEMOCRACY. SOME COUNTRIES CALL THEMSELVES DEMOCRATIC BUT THEY REALLY ARE NOT EX. DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF KOREA (OLIGARCHY-COMMUNIST)
Sociology 125 Lectures 19 & 20 DEMOCRACY: HOW IT WORKS November 11 & 16, 2010.
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Citizen and Government.
CHAPTER 6 ELENA HOWER Political Participation. A Closer Look at Nonvoting Some people believe that Americans do not vote because they are apathetic, but.
WHAT IS PARTICIPATION? What is a “political” activity? What do political scientists measure when looking at participation – Your readings: Votes, time,
WHAT IS PARTICIPATION? What is a “political” activity? What do political scientists measure when looking at participation – Your readings: Votes, time,
Political Experience.
How do voters make up their minds?
1.We can identify the purpose of political parties.
Ideology or Party Ideology Party Liberal Conservative
POLITICAL KNOWLEDGE AND DEMOCRACY
WHAT MAKES THE ADVANCED DEMOCRACIES DIFFERENT FROM OTHER COUNTRIES?
Political Parties.
Purpose and functions of political parties in the U.S.
Political Socialization
Workshop framework KATRIN WAY WITH CUSTOMER MEETINGS Before, During & After.
Civic Participation in a Democracy
Political parties Chapter four.
Public Opinion and Political Action
Development of American Political Parties
Chapter 9 Section 2&3 Mr. Gordon.
Duties and Responsibilities of Citizens
Political Ideologies Democracies.
Chapter 10 Section 1.
Public Opinion and Political Action
Inequality in America The big question: Should equality—economic or political—matter very much? Why are economic and political resources in America so.
Development of American Political Parties
Chapter 12 Voting and Elections
Voting, Elections, Campaigns and Media
Warm Up List 2 or 3 different reasons people would give as to why they don’t vote.
Public Opinion and Political Action
Voting and Elections.
Assessing Electoral Systems
American Government and Politics Today
WHAT MAKES THE ADVANCED DEMOCRACIES DIFFERENT FROM OTHER COUNTRIES?
Political Parties and the United States
Constitutional Underpinnings
WHAT MAKES THE ADVANCED DEMOCRACIES DIFFERENT FROM OTHER COUNTRIES?
WHY DO SOME DEVELOPING COUNTRIES BECOME AND STAY DEMOCRATIC
Elections and Voting Behavior
CHAPTER 10: ELECTIONS & CAMPAIGNS.
Case issue, p. 467, Private Property (usual format)
Warm Up 5/7 Would you vote for a third party if you agreed with their views? Why or why not?
Civic Participation in a Democracy
Why is voter turnout so low in the United States?
Political Parties Chapter 9 Section 3
Why is voter turnout so low in the United States?
Final Exam Section 3 Part 1: Political Parties and Running for Office
DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPLES
Unit 1: Part 1: Constitutional Underpinnings
Presentation transcript:

Inequality in America The big question: Should equality—economic or political—matter very much? Why are economic and political resources in America so unevenly divided? What happens if there is less inequality? Many conservatives: We would be all be worse off less inequality, and addressing it is wrong (either too much government or redistribution) Many progressives: Inequality undermines growth because it takes money from the poor and middle-class who would otherwise spend it, creating a virtuous circle, and not addressing is wrong because inequality replicates itself. A third possibility: Economic and political inequality don’t matter because what the powerful do with their resources has little impact on everyone else.

Inequality in America: it’s a choice

Inequality in America http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/07/5-facts-about-economic-inequality/: Despite what Robert Reich says, we’ve always had quite a lot of economic income inequality in the US (Next slide) US is unusually unequal relative to other well off countries. Looking at income by race, there is considerable evidence that political and social inequality replicates itself over time. When you look at the data on race, ask yourself what would happen if a business displayed this pattern? Wealth inequality is more unevenly distributed than income inequality? When is severe inequality in wealth ok? When should we ask hard questions? Conservative and libertarian arguments on liberty; these folks vs. Robert Reich on the relationship between redistribution and growth John Rawls and thinking about the Indian model: What’s better if you have to choose---low growth + low inequality or high growth + high inequality Class mobility, race/gender issues, and the relationship between wealth and political power

SHOULD WE CARE THAT SOME PEOPLE PARTICIPATE IN POLITICS WHILE MANY DO NOT? Should lots of every day people be involved in politics? Why didn’t our Founders… or Plato… or Aristotle think so? Do people know enough to participate? Are people capable of looking at the long-term, common good? Do the well off have more “skin in the game”? What about taxes and tipping points? Leftist cynics: Losing your money at the slot machine vs. losing it in the parking lot. Is “republicanism” (indirect democracy) the equivalent of a slot machine? Legitimacy and signaling: If one party wins 60 percent of the vote and 75 percent turned out, what is the mandate? Look at the overall track-record of democratic societies on liberties and human rights: the more democratic and participatory the system is, the better off we all are.

What is political participation? What is a “political” activity? What do political scientists measure when looking at participation Your readings: Votes, time, dollars, knowledge & civic skills Think about the First Amendment’s priorities vs. what it says about voting Participation in democratic vs. totalitarian vs. authoritarian systems? Is there that big of a difference? What is the purpose of political activity? How much is necessary? What types matter most? Do you really have to get involved in formal politics or can you virtually be engaged? Is “violence” a form of “political” participation? What about law breaking that can be characterized as civil disobedience? Does non-participation in politics count as participation… If it’s done on purpose Most Americans don’t participate regularly, even in voting, but is that a really problem? Big question 1: Do voters and non voters mostly look alike? Big question 2: Do non-voters want different things? (more on both in a minute) Big question 3: How much choice are the most powerful and wealthy in our society exercising before any of us have a chance to vote or participate in the selection of candidates

Findings from 2013 research by Page and Bartels Study of Millionaires (N=83)

Findings from 2013 research by Page and Bartels Study of Millionaires (N=83)

Findings from research by Ben Page and Martin Gilens (Logistic Regression) on policy adoption

WHY DO SOME PEOPLE PARTICIPATE IN POLITICS WHILE MANY DO NOT? Forget about what people want for a second and think about the big picture… What does it do to governability if most Americans don’t vote, give time, or give money? How are changes in technology and micro-targeting impacting social voice? How about changes in campaign finance laws?

Are elections the best kind of participation? What limitations do even democratic elections have on who votes and how? Should ID be required? What registration requirements should there be? Should certain groups be disqualified (e.g., military, homeless, youth, imprisoned, formally imprisoned)? Should voting be mandatory? Should it be made easier? Should there be more direct vs. representative democracy? Are referenda, initiatives, & recalls a good idea now that we have the technology? What positions should be elected? Which shouldn’t? (insulation) What is “deliberative” democratic participation? Should we publicly fund elections? What limitations if any should be have on private expenditures? How—if at all—should we use elections to ensure the political voice of “minorities”?