Valuation Quality – A Pillar of financial stability in Europe and beyond. Quality Valuations – A must today Roger Messenger BSc. (Est.Man) FRICS FIRRV.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Valuations for bank lending purposes
Advertisements

Prof. Dominique Fischer, Curtin University GST in Australia This presentation is illustrated and completed with the attached Excel workbook GST excel presentation.
1 Global Real Estate Valuation Policy Update: the European Perspective The principle: the EU Treaty does not provide the European institutions with direct.
Voluntary Action Camden Open Book Presentation. The Proposal – Open Book Policy To sell land owned by Camden Local Authority to generate funds to reinvest.
29/10/04 The Development of European Valuation Standards & EVS 2003 EVS 2003 – The New Standards.
Improving the versatility of D.C.F. models by simple computer applications.
China’s Residential Market – Potential Profit or Pure Hype? Nicholas Brooke, FRICS FHKIS Chairman, Professional Property Services Ltd 25 May 2007.
Silvia Cappelli Vice President ASSOVIB Board Member TEGoVA Milan 26 th June 2014 TEGoVA European Valuation Standards (EVS) and the ISO/REV valuer certification.
Development Appraisal Chia Fah Choy MSc, BAppSc (Hons) Assistant Professor, BE, FES, UTAR.
Chapter 3 Development Appraisal and Risk Property Development (6 th Edition) Publisher: Routledge Authors: Professor.
Defvas Project In Partnership with TEGoVA and the IRRV EUROPEAN VALUATION STANDARD – 4 THE VALUATION PROCESS.
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL Positioning for Growth Tasmanian Strata Industry Tim MacKenzie Associate Director Friday 9 th August.
Structures for Investors Presented by: Kerrie-Anne Bailey KAS Tax & Business Solutions Phone: (07) April.
One Step Further Practical Implementation of Guide Note 12.
Defvas Project In Partnership with TEGoVA and the IRRV EUROPEAN VALUATION STANDARD – 5 REPORTING THE VALUATION.
Housing Affordability Fund. Branch Name - Presentation Heading name What is the Housing Affordability Fund? A fund of $512 million over five years to.
Affordable Housing: Policies into Practice Louise Dwelly Housing Strategy & Enabling Manager October 2004.
Risk, Return, and the Time Value of Money Chapter 14.
Thriving communities, affordable homes Custom Build Briefing Newcastle City Council Self Build/Custom Build Event 17 November 2012 Victoria Keen Area Manager.
Presented By Dan Coleman The Short Sale Process The short version.
Land Reform – Housing and Regeneration. Land Reform Review Land Reform Review Group established by Ministers 2012 LRRG Report ‘Land of Scotland and the.
Land Value Taxation Recapturing Community Created Land Values.
Essex Planning Skills 5 Chris Marsh FRICS MRTPI Daniel Kaye BSc (Hons) MRICS 02/12/2015.
Hawthorne Village/ New Horizons South Apopka. Presentation Outline Background Re-Development Plan Action Requested.
Defvas Project In Partnership with TEGoVA and the IRRV EUROPEAN VALUATION STANDARD - 3 THE QUALIFIED VALUER.
EVS 2016 John Hockey and Jeremy Moody 1. Framework and Content Determined by: recognition; extensive consultation; feedback. 2.
Perth Property Valuers.
A presentation to… Trust Professionals Phil Lane BSc(Hons) FRICS MBEng Valuation Services Manager 3 rd December 2010.
Property Management Course Real Estate Management Course Real Estate Management Course - IMPERIA institute providing a lot of information Chartered Surveying.
INTRODUCING CIL AND DEALING WITH SCHEME SPECIFIC VIABILITY ISSUES – BRISTOL’S APPROACH Jim Cliffe Planning Obligations Manager Bristol City Council.
Session 2: The role of viability in plan-making and development management.
Development Appraisal Day 1 Exercises – Part I
ADDED VALUE The innovation of aggricultural valuation methods Sebastiaan Roggeveen MSc BBE Real Estate Valuation Expert Dutch association for Real Estate.
Valuation Co-operation beyond Europe AIC/TEGoVA Mutual Recognition of Canadian and European Standards and Qualifications Roger Messenger B.S.c (Est.Man)
Thriving communities, affordable homes. HCA Area Wide Viability Model PAS Viability Skills for Planners – Workshop B January 2011 Graeme Geddes – Planning.
Session 2: The role of viability in plan-making and development management.
Session 2: The role of viability in plan-making and development management.
Viability and development economics 5 th and 6 th June
FIRST TIME HOMEBUYERS EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW TO MAKE BUYING YOUR FIRST HOME EASY AND AFFORDABLE. Your Logo Here Presented By:
Areas covered Role of valuations and valuer Definitions of market value, price and worth Five methods of commercial property valuation – Applications –
Valuation of Lease Purpose
Presented by Ahmed Khadar Abdi Jama at 2nd Conference of Enreprenuership and Business, SIMAD University Main campus, December 2016 in Mogadishu,
Diversify Your Practice
The Residual Method Introduction:
Alternative Use of Decommissioned Buildings
AGENDA The current focus on housing Do we need older people’s housing? The role of planning? National Level Local Level Opportunities to influence Planning.
Sydney Cooperative Housing Society of NRB (Non Resident Bangladeshi)
A powerful voice for the people of rural Scotland Empty Homes Scheme
The Rural Housing Fund Community empowerment at forefront
Affordable/Workforce Housing Issues and Programs
HOME Underwriting and Subsidy Layering Training
Using LIHTCs to Preserve Rural Affordable Housing
NPLs in Italy Silvia Cappelli Member of the Board of TEGoVA
MANAGING PERSONAL DEBT AND INVESTMENT
19 Savings and Investment Strategies
MODULE 3 THE NEXT BIG THING Lesson 3.2 Stocks, Bonds & Mutual Funds.
Handbook on Residential Property Price Indices
MODULE 3 THE NEXT BIG THING Lesson 3.2 Stocks, Bonds & Mutual Funds.
Acting as a Consultant to the Client and taking back Control over Fees Two Sides of the Same Ticket to Successful Valuation Practice Roger G. Messenger.
Appraisal Institute President
VALUERS’ FEES Competition/Fees/Quality
Planning risk and development: How greater planning certainty would affect residential development a Bartlett/LSE London project for the RTPI Highbury.
Stocks, Bonds & Mutual Funds
Sustainable buildings
REV AND TRV The Key to Valuers in Europe –
Viability and Capturing Development Value
MODULE 3 THE NEXT BIG THING Lesson 3.2 Stocks, Bonds & Mutual Funds.
Business plans.
VALUERS’ FEES “The Fallacy of the tick-box Valuation Report”
EUROPEAN VALUATION CONFERENCE. Dubrovnik 17th May 2019
Presentation transcript:

Valuation Quality – A Pillar of financial stability in Europe and beyond. Quality Valuations – A must today Roger Messenger BSc. (Est.Man) FRICS FIRRV MCIArb REV Hon CAAV Vice-Chairman TEGoVA Chairman European Valuation Qualifications Board Wilks Head & Eve Email: rmessenger@wilks-head.co.uk

Importance of Education & Training REV TRV

What is quality Valuation Two elements that set the good ones apart Risk Measurement Certainty/Uncertainty

Real life example of how complex a valuer's life can get Real life example of how complex a valuer's life can get. Regular client came to us with a redundant village garage with flat above that he has just bought for £595,000 GBP.

Instructions Valuation for bank lending purpose to support 80% of purchase price, £476,000 loan requirement. Planning consent for demolition and construction of 6 terraced houses had been refused.

Instructions from the bank: 1. Valuation in existing use. 2 Instructions from the bank: 1. Valuation in existing use. 2. Cost of reinstatement. 3. Rental valuation as garage & flat. 4. Value as a development site.

Problems 1. Existing use redundant – Value? - Why redundant-No demand? - Lack of suitable tenants? 2. Condition to reinstate - Substantial repair - Financially feasible? 3. Rental valuation for garage and flat, as is and as repaired? Value for what? - Planning refused

1. Comparables Most have sold for redevelopment Purchase price – is that a relevant figure? - Not without other evidence. - Considered and based on capitalised rental value based on other properties valuation in existing use £375,000. 2/3. To achieve £375,000 world need to spend minimum of £75,000 so net value £300,000.

4. Planning has been refused 4. Planning has been refused. Detailed consideration of the reasons for refusal. 6 properties would be over development. Consider the case for 4 or 5 discussion with the planning authority.

Valuations for bank Existing use £300,000 Repaired £375,000 Development appraisal /Site for 5 house £620,000 (Purchase price £595,000 – Loan required £476,000)

Bank prepared to lend £350,000 now Revision on grant of planning consent.

Planning Valuations In order to achieve a change of use from employment land to residential in a rural location need to prove. Commercial use is unsustainable with no realistic demand supported by viability valuations.

In order to support the application we needed to agree planning gain to LPA. A. S106 – Off site contributions B. Affordable housing C. Community Infastructure Levy (CIL) LPA wanted A. £30,000 B. £60,000 in Lieu of affordable times 5 x 12k. C. £50,000 £140,000

Proposed additional valuations –Risk weighted Existing use £350,000 with £150,000 repairs net value £200,000 – No demand – Risk of dereliction Proposed use for 5 houses taking known purchase price and 15% profit margin with cautious GDV gives max LPA contribution of £30,000 – Negotiated settlement.

Valuation issues Lack of evidence for existing use. - Relatively Uncertain - Risk - Moderate confidence Repair cost and effect of impairment - Costed repairs - High confidence

3. Residential - No planning consent and a refusal - Uncertain outcome Valuation inputs – Relatively Certain Good confidence in development value Uncertainty and risk on outcome. Planning Need to dissect LPA AVM for development sites and re align with actual site.

Generic Risks - Property – Potential contamination - Uncertain planning - Lack of demand for existing use - Macro – Housing market - Development funding - Development process delays

Information & Evidence Gives lower risk, greater certainty and greater confidence. From the banks perspective the most reliable and certain valuation was for residential redevelopment assuming a consent.

But They were lending on existing use to avoid hope value but based on uncertain figures with poor evidence.

Valuer – No shortcuts and need for lots of advice in the process. - Not a £100 fee job!!

New uncertainty – Brexit - Nothing to report………? No substitute for quality – Everything known is considered Really is no other choice for the professional valuer able to justify the thought process. Report content, file content, client discussion.

Vice Chairman of TEGoVA Chairman of REV Recognition Committee Might get it wrong – but if based on all this info much harder to prove negligence – Just opinion - And we are all entitled to those! Thank You Roger Messenger BSc FRICS FIRRV MCIArb REV Hon. CAAV RICS Registered Valuer Vice Chairman of TEGoVA Chairman of REV Recognition Committee WILKS HEAD & EVE rmessenger@wilks-head.co.uk