Understanding, Explaining, and Evaluating sources

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Internal Assessment The Historical Investigation.
Advertisements

Paper II Skills Question type 1– Evaluating sources.
How valuable is Source A as evidence of How useful is Source A as evidence of Assess the value of Source A as evidence of How useful is Xs account (Source.
Historical Thinking Skills
Historical-Comparative Research
9/15DO NOW What is the past, and why is it important? How do we learn about events in the past? ______________________________________________________________________.
Literature Web - Full Form
APUSH ‘themes’ (B.A.G.P.I.P.E.)
Process Skill identify methods used by archaeologists, anthropologists, historians, and geographers to analyze evidence.[WHS.29A] October 2014WORLD HISTORY.
Read the documents in the accompanying Resource Booklet and answer all the questions. Access to the Internet 1 Study Document 1. (a)Identify two of the.
Historical Thinking Why Historical Thinking Matters.
What do I do with all of the sources I’ve collected?!? Note-Taking & Analyzing Sources.
Internal Assessment IB History.
Exercises in Assessment for World History Classrooms Patrick Manning University of Pittsburgh April 23, 2011.
7 Themes. Chronological Reasoning 1. Historical Causation: relationships among multiple historical causes and effects, distinguishing between those that.
Judging a History Fair Project Original version 2005 by Karma Adamik, Teacher at Haines Elementary, Chicago CMHEC rev. version 2010.
Judging a History Fair Project Original version 2005 by Karma Adamik, Teacher at Haines Elementary, Chicago CMHEC rev. version 2010.
Chapter 15 Applying the Law. 2 o Do all court opinions apply to the facts of your client’s case? o Look for analogies and distinctions o Similar facts,
What is History?. WWWWWH of History? Who? –Who makes it? Who is it about? What? –What is included? What is not included? When? –When does history take.
Internal Assessment The Historical Investigation.
Amy A. Germuth, Ph.D. EvalWorks.com Blog - EvalThoughts.com
The AP World history EXAM
AF1: Thinking Scientifically
History and Geography A Review.
RESE-1031 Thematic Impendent Studies
Chapter 10 Historical Research.
OPCVL With reference to origin, purpose, and content, analyze the value and limitations.
Academic Rubric Slides
Descriptive Organizer/Main Idea
Welcome to IBDP History
The best historians:.
How to write section 1 All materials taken from Teacher Support Material and Specification (IBO website) and workshop materials provided by Ed Bond (IBDP.
Historical Thinking Skills
What you need to do for the Assignment
IA - Section 1 clearly state the question they have chosen to investigate (this must be stated as a question) include a brief explanation of the nature.
Using Secondary Sources [Secondary Sources.pptx]
INTRODUCTION TO HISTORY AND GEOGRAPHY
“A Warm Clear Day in Dallas” “Address to Congress, November 27, 1963” “Students React to President Kennedy”s Death” Page 674.
Developing and evaluating lines of reasoning
Maximum Points 6 35 minutes 15% of score
Constructing Support Position Statement Reasons Facts Argumentation.
Primary and Secondary Sources
The Historical Investigation
5-6 Marks for Criterion A An appropriate question for investigation has been clearly stated. The student has identified and selected appropriate and relevant.
National Music Standards
Understanding and Planning Business Reports and Proposals
A POCKET GUIDE TO PUBLIC SPEAKING 4TH EDITION Chapter 31
Assessment of Unit 1: USA : 1hr 15mins
Source enquiry skills: comparing the value of sources
The Mid Tudors A2 Evaluation and enquiry questions
NEA What makes a good answer?
OPCVL With reference to origin, purpose, and content, analyze the value and limitations.
Year 11 Controlled Assessment
Primary and Secondary Sources
NET History Exam Skills
October
Historical Thinking Skills
INTERPRETATION FLOW CHART
Process of historical inquiry using the History K-10 Syllabus
Analyse (HL) To study a problem in detail, by breaking it down into various parts and to examine possible relationships.
Primary vs. Secondary Sources
Historical Investigation
Immediate activty Give 2 advantages and disadvantages of the following methods: Group interviews Questionnaires Lab experiments Participant observation.
Ch 5 & 6.
Historical Thinking Matters!
Summarizing vs. Analyzing
Briefing on FHS 2019 ‘Igor Stravinsky and the Twentieth Century’
Source Viewer Do you have any wider knowledge that relates to this source? Is this a primary or secondary source? What does the source want the reader.
Unit 1 Exam Question Help-Sheet/PowerPoint
ORIGIN – PURPOSE – VALUE - LIMITATION
Presentation transcript:

Understanding, Explaining, and Evaluating sources

Understanding sources If you can accurately summarize a source, then you understand the source Summaries can be wrong! P and O of POVL also show understanding Not a place for your analysis or interpretation

Explaining importance Comes after you understand the source You must have knowledge of historical context to grasp importance

Explaining cont. Every primary source is important, BUT some are more important than others There are MANY UNimportant secondary sources: Common knowledge sources = generic MOST history Internet sites No analysis/historical argument = NOT important New to you ≠ important (don’t be fooled!)

Evaluating sources Evaluate = weigh strengths and weaknesses (i.e. value and limitation) ALL important sources have both value and limitation Must evaluate value and limitation as directly connected to purpose and origin Important sources may not be valuable to your investigation