Bridging the gap between qualitative and quantitative research: A randomised controlled pilot and feasibility study of the effectiveness of music therapy.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to the unit and mixed methods approaches to research Kerry Hood.
Advertisements

Copyright © Healthcare Quality Quest, Proposed standards for a national clinical audit — How we got involved and what we have learned.
NIHR Research Design Service London Enabling Better Research Forming a research team Victoria Cornelius, PhD Senior Lecturer in Medical Statistics Deputy.
SWRK 292 Thesis/Project Seminar. Expectations for Course Apply research concepts from SWRK 291. Write first three chapters of your project or thesis.
Chapter 3 Preparing and Evaluating a Research Plan Gay and Airasian
Factors that Associated with Stress in Nursing Faculty in Thailand
Creating a service Idea. Creating a service Networking / consultation Identify the need Find funding Create a project plan Business Plan.
Clinical Trials. What is a clinical trial? Clinical trials are research studies involving people Used to find better ways to prevent, detect, and treat.
Copyright © 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 18 Mixed Methods and Other Special Types of Research.
1 October, 2005 Activities and Activity Director Guidance Training (F248) §483.15(f)(l), and (F249) §483.15(f)(2)
Copyright © 2008 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 12 Undertaking Research for Specific Purposes.
The PAN-Care Project Development and testing of a comprehensive care planning service to enable patients with end stage pancreatic cancer die at home Department.
Examination of the effects at one year of referral for brief intervention by an Alcohol Health Worker (AHW) on levels of alcohol consumption, psychiatric.
Evaluating a Research Report
Implementation and process evaluation: developing our approach Ann Lendrum University of Manchester Neil Humphrey University of Manchester Gemma Moss Institute.
PPA 502 – Program Evaluation Lecture 2c – Process Evaluation.
Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches
Results Student Engagement : Students generally found logbooks easy to use and practical in the hospital setting. Purpose : There appeared to be a perceived.
Research Methods Observations Interviews Case Studies Surveys Quasi Experiments.
Evaluation of Psychosocial Support Services for Adolescent and Young Adult Patients at Roswell Park Cancer Institute Allison Polakiewicz, MPA Project Proposal.
Principles of Assessment and Outcome Measurement for Physical Therapists ksu. edu. sa Dr. taher _ yahoo. com Mohammed TA, Omar,
Performing a Successful Supportive Care Clinical Trial Jennifer Temel, MD.
T Relationships do matter: Understanding how nurse-physician relationships can impact patient care outcomes Sandra L. Siedlecki PhD RN CNS.
TES (training, education, support) Presented by: John Chiocchi, Paula Slevin, Mark Sampson,
STEPS IN RESEARCH PROCESS 1. Identification of Research Problems This involves Identifying existing problems in an area of study (e.g. Home Economics),
Title of the Change Project
CLINICAL TRIALS.
Logic Models How to Integrate Data Collection into your Everyday Work.
Evaluation Requirements for MSP and Characteristics of Designs to Estimate Impacts with Confidence Ellen Bobronnikov March 23, 2011.
Mental Health Program; CVH and M Site
Introduction paragraph – what looking to investigate.
Planning my research journey
DATA COLLECTION METHODS IN NURSING RESEARCH
Feasibility of two fatigue management interventions for people with TBI Bhattacharjee R1, Theadom A1, Barker-Collo S2, McPherson, K3, Kayes N3, Mudge S3,
ACT Comprehensive Assessment
Monitoring and Evaluation Systems for NARS Organisations in Papua New Guinea Day 3. Session 9. Periodic data collection methods.
The majority of players were born in January, February, and March
Role of The Physical Therapist in Critical Inquiry
Training Trainers and Educators Unit 8 – How to Evaluate
RUNNING RANDOMISED CLINICAL TRIALS
Research Questions Does integration of behavioral health and primary care services, compared to simple co-location, improve patient-centered outcomes in.
CLINICAL PROTOCOL DEVELOPMENT
The DEPression in Visual Impairment Trial:
“An online programme to enhance the quality of clinical education”.
MUSIC THERAPY INTERVENTION
Implementation Challenges of Wound Interdisciplinary Teams (WIT): A Community‐Based Pragmatic Randomised Controlled Trial.
Chapter 4: Distinguishing Mixed Methods Designs
System and Study of Patient
AN INTRODUCTION TO EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH.
Digital Learning Framework Evaluation Overview
New Beginnings with START: Experiences of piloting a manualised intervention for carers in a secondary care mental health service Dr Rachel Wenman Bedfordshire.
Program Evaluation Essentials-- Part 2
Conducting Research in the Social Sciences
The Practice: a case study evaluation of a Vanguard pilot site
Sia Gravani 10th May th ICTMC & 38th SCT, Liverpool
Reading Research Papers-A Basic Guide to Critical Analysis
Tourism Marketing for small businesses
Professor Stephen Pilling PhD
Training Trainers and Educators Unit 8 – How to Evaluate
Integrated Care European Partnership for Supervisory Organisations
S1316 analysis details Garnet Anderson Katie Arnold
Data and Data Collection
Neuro Oncology Therapy Update
Role of The Physical Therapist in Critical Inquiry
The impact of small-group EBP education programme: barriers and facilitators for EBP allied health champions to share learning with peers.
A Review of Effective Teaching Skills
RESEARCH METHODS Lecture 19
Choosing a research approach
Case studies: interviews
Implementing a carers assessment tool at Woking and Sam Beare Hospices
Presentation transcript:

Bridging the gap between qualitative and quantitative research: A randomised controlled pilot and feasibility study of the effectiveness of music therapy in improving the quality of life of palliative care patients. Professor Joanne Reid

Introductions who you are, where you are from, how comfortable are you using both qualitative and quantitative research methods (very, somewhat, not at all)?

Qualitative and quantitative research – key differences The obvious difference – numerical v. textual data; numbers v. words

Why use both qualitative and quantitative research methods? You have a question that has rarely been asked or has been asked with questionable results You want the strength of multiple methods - triangulation Some, and only some, of your variables are easily quantifiable at this stage of inquiry To “illuminate the black box” of relationships defined only in statistical terms To hear from those who are rarely reached effectively by typical quantitative approaches

How to combine qualitative and quantitative research methods Multi-methods research E.g. more than one qualitative method Mixed – methods research Both qualitative and quantitative methods of data collection and analysis MRC guidance 2008 included a process evaluation

Mixed method type Research processes Examples Explanatory sequential Quantitative data are collected and analysed first, then qualitative data are collected and analysed to help explain quantitative data QUAN →  QUAL AIM: Identify levels of stress among new graduate registered nurses (RNs) working in emergency room (ER) settings QUAN: National survey of new RNs working in ER settings measuring levels of workplace stress QUAL: Personal interviews with 15–20 new RNs working in ER settings to discuss their experiences with stressful workplace situations SYNTHESIS: Sequential QUAL data help explain QUAN data Exploratory sequential Qualitative data are collected and analysed first, then quantitative data are collected and used to test findings empirically QUAL →   QUAN AIM: Identify highest sources of workplace stress for new RNs working in hospital ERs QUAL: Focus group data collected from newly registered RNs working in hospital ERs within a local area health service to discuss workplace stress QUAN: QUAL data used to create a national survey administered to all RNs working in ERs about sources of workplace stress experienced within their first year of practice SYNTHESIS: Sequential QUAL data inform collection of QUAN data, which verify QUAL data Parallel Qualitative and quantitative data collected and analysed concurrently QUAL + QUAN AIM: Identify sources of stress for RNs working in ER settings, personal coping strategies used and types of programmes or support systems provided by hospitals QUAN: National survey of all RNs working in ER departments, based on the literature, to identify common sources of stress and methods of support used by employers to reduce RN stress QUAL: Focus groups and interviews with a random selection of RNs working in ERs to broaden understanding of different sources of stress and personal coping strategies used SYNTHESIS: Data integration during interpretation phase after QUAN and QUAL data analyses Nested Can be either QUAL or QUAN main design with the alternative paradigm embedded within the study to answer a complementary question QUAL + quan or QUAN + qual AIM: Test an online peer support programme designed to reduce workplace stress for new RNs working in ERs QUAN: RCT to test online programme effect on stress levels and intention to remain working in the ER QUAL: Interview nested in the RCT, focused on user experiences of the online programme SYNTHESIS: QUAL analysis embedded within the main QUAN study

Case study: A randomised controlled pilot and feasibility study of the effectiveness of music therapy in improving the quality of life of palliative care patients: J.Reid,1 T.McConnell,1 M.Clarke,4. L.Graham,2 M.McKeown,2 J.Regan,2 K.McGrillen,2 J.Leitch,2 N.Hughes,3 & J.Kirkwood,3 S.Porter 5 1 School of Nursing and Midwifery, Queen’s University Belfast 2 Marie Curie Hospice Belfast 3 Every Day Harmony Music Therapy 4 School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences, Queen’s University Belfast. 5 Social Sciences and Social Work, Bournemouth University 7

What is music therapy? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NF73a9lPJY

Music therapy Use of music and sounds to facilitate the development of a relationship between patients and professionally trained therapists with the aim of supporting relaxation and improving both physical and emotional well-being Used in palliative care for more than a decade In palliative care, the music therapeutic approach used is a creative process of musical interaction where the client engages while singing or playing, listening to music or extemporaneously creating a melody, rhythm, song or instrumental piece. In the sessions, the music therapist uses music in various formats to meet the patients’ specific needs. In doing so, they ‘make use of the therapeutic relationship established with the patient to meet clinical goals and employ a systematic therapeutic process that includes assessment, treatment and evaluation’ [17].

Background Anecdotal evidence strongly supports music therapy as a palliative therapy, with the primary aim of improving people’s quality of life ……..However the evidence base is weak …….Research challenging in this area Anecdotal info suggesting benefits of music therapy BUT we need more scientific evidence to support it. Several challenges to conducting music therapy randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in palliative care have also been identified, including high levels of attrition, the need for flexibility in time commitment and inclusion of family members if desired, and provision of a standardised yet tailored intervention

Study aims Aim – the feasibility of conducting a phase III pragmatic RCT Primary objectives Outcome measures Intervention duration Recruitment and attrition rates Secondary objectives Indicative outcomes related to Quality of life Inter-familial communication (data not available until results unlocked) The main aim of the study is to evaluate the feasibility of administering the McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire (MQOL) [23], reported to have the best clinometric quality rating, content validity, construct validity and internal consistency of reviewed quality of life questionnaires [24]. In terms of ‘dose’ of music therapy, previous studies in palliative care patients have shown that a short course, consisting of two or more sessions, is effective and appropriate for this population [25, 26]. We will also assess the viability of delivering a 3-week music therapy intervention, along with using recruitment and attrition rates to determine the sample size required for a phase III randomised controlled trial. 2 The potential effectiveness of music therapy upon quality of life at week one (one to two music therapy sessions), week three (after completion of the music therapy course) and week five (two weeks after completion of music therapy) The effect of music therapy upon inter-familial Communication. Carer interviews aim to assess whether music therapy improves inter-familial communication within a palliative care population. In the absence of a validated tool to measure this outcome, an interview topic guide will be developed by the research team.

Method UK-based, single-centre, pilot RCT Two parallel arms (randomised 1:1) Participants (n>52) 18-bed specialist palliative care inpatient unit in Northern Ireland Eligibility criteria - ECOG≤ 3, AMT≥ 7 McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire (MQOL), and socio-demographic data. Baseline (before randomisation), one, three and five-week follow-up Qualitative data collection – patients and focus groups HCPs to examine impact and context UK-based, single-centre, pilot RCT Two parallel arms, one receiving individual music therapy in addition to usual care, and the other receiving usual care only. Participants (n>52) recruited from the inpatient unit at an 18-bed specialist palliative care inpatient unit in Northern Ireland. The aim is to recruit 52 patients across both treatment allocations (33% more than the minimum recommended for good practise [33] including a 30% attrition allowance as recommended for a palliative care population. The calculation of the sample size was informed both by good practise for feasibility trials. Participants will be randomly assigned to two groups. Patients assigned to the control group will receive usual care only from the hospice multidisciplinary team. The dose and frequency of usual care will be as deemed appropriate by the hospice practitioner in charge of their treatment. As music therapy is not part of usual care within this hospice, the control group participants will be offered two sessions of music therapy upon completion of their time in the study. In addition to the usual care described above, patients assigned to the experimental group will receive music therapy in an individual setting, delivered by a trained music therapist. Music therapy will be conducted for up to 45 min twice a week. A total of six sessions will be offered, with the aim of completing at least four sessions. Eligibility will be assessed by a hospice clinician during inpatient admission or day hospice attendance using the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) scale and the Abbreviated Mental Test (AMT). The ECOG [28] scale is most frequently used by physicians for assessing palliative care patients’ level of functioning [29]. An ECOG performance status of 0, 1, 2 or 3 (0 indicating the patient is asymptomatic, 1 the patient is symptomatic but fully ambulatory, 2 the patient is symptomatic and confined to bed for less than 50% of the day and 3 the patient is symptomatic and confined to bed for more than 50% of the day) indicating they are able to engage with interactive music therapy The Abbreviated Mental Test AMT [30] has good validity and is widely used to screen for cognitive impairment within a palliative care population [31]. A score of 7 or more on the AMT, indicating they are capable of providing meaningful informed consent and accurate responses to the study’s primary outcome measurement tool.

Analysis MQoL questionnaire - evaluated at each data collection point - feedback on the questionnaire’s appropriateness and level of burden The viability of delivering a 3-week music therapy intervention - assessed by the number of patients completing the intervention and reasons for attrition Recruitment and attrition figures - power calculation for definitive RCT The potential effectiveness of music therapy- change in the outcome variables from baseline Qualitative methods, in particular interviews and focus groups, will be used to assess impact, interfamilial communication and contextual factors The feasibility of using the MQOL questionnaire will be evaluated by the researcher at each data collection point through feedback from patients on the questionnaire’s appropriateness and level of burden. The number of completed questionnaires will also be monitored along with reasons for non-completion. The viability of delivering a 3-week music therapy intervention will be assessed by the number of patients completing the intervention along with reasons for attrition. Recruitment and attrition figures will be used to conduct a power calculation. This will be conducted by the Northern Ireland Clinical Trials Unit to determine the sample size required for a phase III randomised controlled trial. To assess the potential effectiveness of music therapy, data will be analysed using SPSS. The change in the outcome variable from baseline to 1 week, 3 weeks and 5 weeks, will be compared between the experimental and control group using analysis of covariance [35]. To detect differences within groups, repeated measures ANOVAs will be utilised. The principle of intention to treat analysis will be performed blind to treatment allocation. In line with the intention-to-treat principle, patients who attend fewer sessions will not be excluded from data analysis. Qualitative methods, in particular interviews and focus groups, will be used to assess interfamilial communication and contextual factors.

Intervention Format Delivery Content Individual, inpatient unit setting 2 x › 45 minute sessions, for 3 consecutive weeks, in addition to care as usual Family may be present Delivery Delivered by an HCPC certified music therapist Involving live and recorded music ‘Receptive’ and ‘recreative’ Participants will be randomly assigned to two groups. Patients assigned to the control group will receive usual care only from the hospice multidisciplinary team. The dose and frequency of usual care will be as deemed appropriate by the hospice practitioner in charge of their treatment. As music therapy is not part of usual care within this hospice, the control group participants will be offered two sessions of music therapy upon completion of their time in the study. In addition to the usual care described above, patients assigned to the experimental group will receive music therapy in an individual setting, delivered by a trained music therapist. Music therapy will be conducted for up to 45 min twice a week. A total of six sessions will be offered, with the aim of completing at least four sessions. Patient’s needs will be identified by the music therapist during the first session, guided by preliminary discussions with the hospice clinical team and by the patient’s own assessment of what needs are most important to them. The musical equipment used will include accessible instruments provided by the music therapist. As recommended by our PPI (Patient and Public Involvement) collaborators on this protocol, patients can choose to have their carer present during the intervention as time together is precious. Patient’s written informed consent to have their carer present will be obtained by the hospice clinician during recruitment. Carers will only be observing the music therapy sessions and will not be directly involved. In terms of ‘dose’ of music therapy, previous studies in palliative care patients have shown that a short course, consisting of two or more sessions, is effective and appropriate for this population [25, 26]. While the content of the sessions will be influenced by each patient’s needs, interests, preferences and energy level and adapted accordingly in the moment, the music therapist will complete an intervention manual [27] at the end of each session, which will include the details on who chose the music and what strategy was used (i.e. music listening, active music-making, improvising, legacy work), along with strategies to enhance treatment fidelity (how the intervention was monitored for consistency). This will aid transparent reporting, along with guiding the development of a standardised protocol for use across sites in the main trial. As with the control group, the dose and frequency of usual care will be as deemed appropriate by the hospice professional in charge of their treatment. Content A standardised yet tailored intervention May include song composition, life review, active music making, listening to familiar music, creating legacy recordings

Quantitative results Recruited our target sample Determined the viability of the intervention delivery period Ascertained the acceptability of the QoL measure (content and level of burden) Clarified the primary end point for data collection Potential effectiveness - most notably, improvement in psychological and existential well-being sub-measures of MQoL Existential well-being refers to a person’s present state of subjective well-being across existential domains, such as meaning, purpose, and satisfaction in life, and feelings of comfort regarding death and suffering

Practitioner perspective One of our patients, he never would have spoken about feelings and stuff, and he composed a whole song for his wife and literally handed her the CD and was like “Listen to that on the way home”, and she was just like “That’s the nicest thing you’ve ever done for me”, and it was all about her, so it was lovely. (AHP 5) Focus groups with HCPs aim to examine contextual factors and subgroup response to the intervention and acceptability. A semi-structured interview guide will be utilised with the focus groups moderated by an experienced qualitative researcher. The focus group topic guide will be based on realistic evaluation principles to advance theoretical understanding of what components of music therapy work best, for whom and in what circumstances Using a purposeful sampling approach, HCPs with a direct patient role will be recruited from the hospice, approximately 2 months after trial initiation. Data will be analysed by two researchers using a thematic content analysis based on Newell and Burnard’s framework [37] and informed by a realist approach as outlined by Porter [38] to enhance both rigour and the ‘confidence criterion’ (the level of confidence practitioners have that the findings presented accurately portray and explain the issues being addressed and will inform their practise

Family perspective Was a bright spark in a dark environment. A wonderful experience. Great comfort to see XX having fun. (Husband) Helped to see mum happy and having good time. (Daughter and son) Open question at the end of the mcgill QoL tool

Patient perspective Music therapy helped Joy to have lovely girl come in and we bonded through the music Was amazing - the relationship, got on so well Something to look forward to I chose the music – uplifting Overwhelming how this girl was sent to us It was a wonderful experience. Never would’ve dreamt it could be so wonderful

Group work What are the challenges and advantages of combining qualitative and quantitative research methods? Example Challenges Need to have expertise in both qualitative and quantitative research Advantages Can explore aspects of the topic quantitative tool can’t get to Example Challenges Need to have expertise in both qualitative and quantitative research Getting the paper to fit the word count for journals Advantages Can explore aspects of the topic quant tool can’t get to More meaningful research

Email: j.reid@qub.ac.uk Webpage – MusiQual