Local Group Proper Motions

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Measuring Our Rotation Measuring rotation in our galaxy is hard because we are inside it. One method for measuring circular rate of rotation at our radius:
Advertisements

Week 10 Dark Matter Reading: Dark Matter: 16.1, 16.5d (4 pages)
Dark Matter in Dwarf Galaxies
Lecture 21 updates. Hubble’s STIS Spectrograph Please include this image at the start of the images of STIS.
Counting Dark Matter Sub-halos: Gaps in Star Streams Ray Carlberg University of Toronto.
Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College1. Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College2.
Distances to PNe using angular expansion parallax Lizette Guzman-Ramirez (JBCA, University of Manchester) Yolanda Gomez and Laurent Loinard (CRyA, UNAM,
DM in the Galaxy James Binney Oxford University TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual before you delete this box.: AA A.
90% of Matter in Milky Way is Dark Matter Gives off no detectable radiation. Evidence is from rotation curve: Rotation Velocity (AU/yr) Solar System Rotation.
Stellar Kinematics Astronomy 315 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 18.
Astrometry William F. van Altena ARAA (1983) 7. Conclusion The field of astrometry is in the midst of a major revolution in terms of the accuracy obtained.
Chapter 15: Chapter 15: The Milky Way Galaxy. Lesson Plan Idea of Gallaxies Idea of Gallaxies Parson’s observations Parson’s observations Hubble’s observations.
© 2005 Pearson Education Inc., publishing as Addison-Wesley 1.3 Spaceship Earth How is Earth moving in our solar system? How is our solar system moving.
Our goals for learning How did Hubble prove galaxies lie beyond our galaxy? How do we observe the life histories of galaxies? How did galaxies form? Why.
Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College1. Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College2 Chapter 14 Variable Stars The Milky Way.
Dark Matter in Galaxies and Clusters AST 112. Matter Galaxies appear to be made up of stars, gas and dust Reasonable to think that’s the end of the story…
The Nature of Galaxies Chapter 17. Other Galaxies External to Milky Way –established by Edwin Hubble –used Cepheid variables to measure distance M31 (Andromeda.
2004 Mar 25 Sgr A* at 30 Must Sgr A* be a Super-Massive Black Hole? Mark J. Reid Harvard-Smithsonian CfA Andreas Brunthaler MPIfR/JIVE.
The Milky Way Galaxy By: Rachel Williams & Deidre Vaughters.
Cosmology and extragalactic astronomy Mat Page Mullard Space Science Lab, UCL 5. The cosmic distance ladder.
Astronomy 404/CSI 769 Extragalactic Astronomy
Test #3 Same types of questions Bring a calculator Study the other exam reviews.
Masers as Probes of Galactic Structure
VERAによる 近傍星形成領域の位置天文観測
Problem. What is the distance to the star Spica (α Virginis), which has a measured parallax according to Hipparcos of π abs = ±0.86 mas? Solution.
Expansion of the Universe Lab 10. Some Facts of Our Milky Way Galaxy Distance from Sun to galactic center = 8 kpc ± 1 kpc Disk of our galaxy = 50 kpc.
Measuring Masses. The Earth is attracted to the Sun by the force of gravity. If the Earth were stationary, the force of gravity would draw the Earth.
Milky Way: Galactic Structure and Dynamics Milky Way has spiral structure Galactic Bulge surrounds the Center Powerful radio source Sagittarius A at Center.
Dark Matter in the Milky Way - how to find it using Gaia and other surveys Paul McMillan Surveys For All, 1st February 2016.
DM in the Galaxy James Binney Oxford University TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual before you delete this box.: AAA.
Nov 19, 2003Astronomy 100 Fall 2003 Next week is Thanksgiving Break. No homework until you get back. On Friday… Exam 2 Grades are posted. Nighttime observing.
Milky Way Galaxy. Galaxy A group of stars, dust and gases held together by gravity. 170 billion galaxies in the universe 200 billion stars in a galaxy.
Cosmic Masers Chris Phillips CSIRO / ATNF. What is a Maser? Microwave Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation Microwave version of a LASER Occur.
EVN 2015: Astrometry Parallaxes of Galactic sources.
A single galaxy with its millions or billions of stars is only a very small spot in the observable universe. Galaxies & AGN’s (Chapter 13) Hercules Cluster.
Astronomy 2 Overview of the Universe Spring Lectures on External Galaxies. Joe Miller.
(Collaborators: James Binney, Tilmann Piffl, Jason Sanders)
Masses of Galaxies Measure mass by: motion within a galaxy
How fast would a galaxy 2,000 megaparsecs away be moving with respect to us, according to Hubble’s Law? Hint: H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc 1,400 km/s 14,000 km/s 140,000.
© 2017 Pearson Education, Inc.
V. Bobylev and A. Bajkova Pulkovo Observatory, St. Petersburg, Russia
Last Ewen Telescope Open House
The Milky Way Galaxy 1/30/03.
The Milky Way Our Galactic Home.
Milky Way (-like) Galaxy
The Megamaser Cosmology Project
Peculiarity of High-Mass (> 6-8 M⊙) Star Formation
Long distance modifications of gravity in four dimensions.
Towards a kinematic model of the Local Group as-Astrometry with VLBI
Klein Bottles.
III. Cycle of Birth and Death of Stars: Interstellar Medium
Star Formation & The Galactic Center
WHAT IS….. DARK MATTER??.
The “Milky Way”.
Milky Way Orbits of stars in the Milky Way Rotation curves
Disk, Bulge, Halo Rotation Curve Galactic Center
GALAXIES!.
The Milky Way Our Galactic Home.
Galaxies.
Chapter 14 Our Galaxy.
(National Astronomical Observatory of Japan)
The Milky Way Galaxy.
Lecture 33- What’s the Milky Way made of?
Chapter 26: Stars and Galaxies
Chapter 20 Galaxies Determining Distance
Maser Astrometry with VLBI and Galactic Structure
The Milky Way Galaxy.
Modeling the Extended Structure of Dwarf Spheroidals (Carina, Leo I)
Regulus (about 75 light years distant) is part of a 4-star system, with a close companion double star visible to its lower left. Leo I (about 800,000 light.
(spectroscopically confirmed)
Presentation transcript:

Local Group Proper Motions 1920s van Maanen claimed to see M33 spin! mas/yr motions  Spiral nebulae nearby (Galactic) Hubble argued more distant (extra-galactic) van Maanen’s error not found

Extragalactic Proper Motions Parallax accuracy: sD ~ 10% at 10 kpc can’t do galaxies yet Proper motion: sm ~ T-3/2 M33 1) see spin (van Maanen) 2) see galaxy’s motion M33 Read slide Andreas Brunthaler’s PhD Thesis

Extragalactic Proper Motions M33/IC133 – M33/19 masers VLBA: Dmx = 30 +/- 2, Dmy = 10 +/- 5 mas/yr HI: Dvx = 106 +/-20, Dvy = 35 +/- 20 km/s D = 750 +/- 50 +/- 140 kpc Improvements in Rotation Model & 3rd maser source: sD < 10% possible sm sv Read slide…skip this and next 2 slides if needed. Brunthaler, Reid & Falcke

Extragalactic Proper Motions M31’s motion unknown Critical for L.G. dynamics Need M31’s P.M. to complete picture…calculate history and fate of these galaxies

Local Group Orbits Assumptions: M31 proper motion (eg, zero) M31 DM halo = 3.4 x 1012 Msun MW DM halo = 2.3 x 1012 Msun Calculate orbital histories: M33 encounters M31 repeatedly MW hits M31 ~8 Gy ago Loeb, Reid, Brunthaler & Falcke (2005)

Tidal Heating of M33 Try non-zero M31 proper motions; then calculate orbits Tidal heating of M33: mM31 = (100,-100) km/s ( -50, -50) km/s ( 0, 0) km/s mM31 ~ 0 km/s  M33 destroyed mM31 ~100 km/s  M33 OK Trial PMs of M31 …some lead to destruction of M33 (eg, 0 PM) If one adopts timing argument (essentially M31/MW bound), M31’s pm can’t be >>100 km/s Most likely PM of M31 ~ 100 km/s. Also, have PM of IC10…if M33 and IC10 bound, 3-D motions => M(dark)M31 >~ 10^12 Loeb, Reid, Brunthaler & Falcke (2005) NB: sensitive to dark matter mass…

Dark Mass in Local Group Galaxies Uncertainty of D.M. halo masses Using 75% of previous values, ie, M31 DM halo = 2.6 x 1012 Msun MW DM halo = 1.7 x 1012 Msun M31 & M.W. never close, but M33 still encounters M31 (NB: for o~ 250 km/s, MW ~ M31 !)

M 31* VLBA/HSA detection 42 mJy peak

M33’s Motion M33/19 apparent motion: East , North M33/19 proper motion 36 (3), -12 (6) mas/yr 122 , -43 km/s @ 730 kpc Correct to galaxy center Remove Sun’s motion around center of Milky Way Combine results both sources M33’s motion: -101, +156 km/s @ 730 kpc M33/19 proper motion