Nucleon structure and Gauge field theory

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Parton distribution functions and quark orbital motion Petr Závada Institute of Physics, Prague The 6 th Circum-Pan-Pacific Symposium on High Energy Spin.
Advertisements

The electromagnetic (EM) field serves as a model for particle fields
High Energy Nuclear Physics Fan Wang Dept. of Phys. Nanjing Univ.
Do gluons carry half of the nucleon momentum? X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang NJU and PMO Joint Center for Particle Nuclear.
Standard Model Requires Treatment of Particles as Fields Hamiltonian, H=E, is not Lorentz invariant. QM not a relativistic theory. Lagrangian, T-V, used.
The electromagnetic (EM) field serves as a model for particle fields  = charge density, J = current density.
Unharmony within the Thematic Melodies of Twentieth Century Physics X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang NJU and PMO Joint.
Symmetries By Dong Xue Physics & Astronomy University of South Carolina.
Gauge invariance and Canonical quantization for internal dynamical variables X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang NJU and PMO.
Chiral freedom and the scale of weak interactions.
Spin and addition of angular momentum
Nucleon Spin Structure and Gauge Invariance X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang Dept. of Phys. Nanjing Univ.
An Introduction to Field and Gauge Theories
The World Particle content. Interactions Schrodinger Wave Equation He started with the energy-momentum relation for a particle he made the quantum.
Xiangdong Ji University of Maryland/SJTU Physics of gluon polarization Jlab, May 9, 2013.
Review on Nucleon Spin Structure X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. T.Goldman, TD, LANL X.F.Lu, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. D.Qing, CERN Fan Wang,
Poincare sub-algebra and gauge invariance in nucleon structure Xiang-Song Chen Huazhong University of Science & Technology 陈相松 华中科技大学 武汉 10 July
Xiangdong Ji University of Maryland/SJTU
Problems in nucleon structure study Fan Wang CPNPC (Joint Center for Particle Nuclear Physics and Cosmology, Nanjing Univ. and Purple mountain observatory.
PHY206: Atomic Spectra  Lecturer: Dr Stathes Paganis  Office: D29, Hicks Building  Phone: 
Problems in nucleon structure study Fan Wang CPNPC (Joint Center for Particle Nuclear Physics and Cosmology, Nanjing Univ. and Purple mountain observatory.
Chiral-even and odd faces of transverse Sum Rule Trieste(+Dubna), November Oleg Teryaev JINR, Dubna.
6.852: Distributed Algorithms Spring, 2008 April 1, 2008 Class 14 – Part 2 Applications of Distributed Algorithms to Diverse Fields.
Poincare covariance, Canonical quantization and Gauge invariance in the Nucleon internal structure X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., Huazhong Univ. Sci. Tec. X.F.Lu,
PandaX experiment Direct detection of dark matter using Xenon TPC in Sichuan, China.
Gauge invariance, Canonical quantization and Lorentz covariance in the internal structure X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang.
Poincare covariance, Canonical quantization and Gauge invariance in the Nucleon internal structure X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., Huazhong Univ. Sci. Tec. X.F.Lu,
Gluon Spin and OAM with Different Definitions INT Workshop Feb 6-17, 2012 Orbital Angular Momentum in QCD Xiang-Song Chen Huazhong University of Science.
The Higgs Boson Observation (probably) Not just another fundamental particle… July 27, 2012Purdue QuarkNet Summer Workshop1 Matthew Jones Purdue University.
Quantum Two 1. 2 Angular Momentum and Rotations 3.
Problems in nucleon structure study X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., HUST. W.M.Sun, Dept. of Phys., Nanjing Univ. Fan Wang, Dept. of Phys. Nanjing Univ C.W. Wong,
EIC, Nucleon Spin Structure, Lattice QCD Xiangdong Ji University of Maryland.
Towards a final criteria of separating momentum and angular momentum Outline: I.The matter of convenience II.The matter of reasonableness III.The matter.
Art of Spin Decomposition Xiang-Song Chen 陈相松 Huazhong Univ. of Sci. & Tech. 华中科技大学 Outline:  Spin sum rules and controversies  A most familiar example.
Nucleon Internal Structure: the Quark Gluon Momentum and Angular Momentum X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Fan Wang NJU and PMO.
For s=1 for EM-waves total energy density:  # of photons wave number vector: the Klein-Gordon equation:
Tensor and Flavor-singlet Axial Charges and Their Scale Dependencies Hanxin He China Institute of Atomic Energy.
Prof. M.A. Thomson Michaelmas Particle Physics Michaelmas Term 2011 Prof Mark Thomson Handout 3 : Interaction by Particle Exchange and QED X X.
Nucleon spin structure and Gauge invariance, Canonical quantization X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. X.F.Lu, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun,
Monday, Apr. 11, 2005PHYS 3446, Spring 2005 Jae Yu 1 PHYS 3446 – Lecture #18 Monday, Apr. 11, 2005 Dr. Jae Yu Symmetries Local gauge symmetry Gauge fields.
Nucleon spin decomposition at twist-three Yoshitaka Hatta (Yukawa inst., Kyoto U.) TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint manual before you delete.
Xiangdong Ji U. Maryland/ 上海交通大学 Recent progress in understanding the spin structure of the nucleon RIKEN, July 29, 2013 PHENIX Workshop on Physics Prospects.
Gluon orbital angular momentum in the nucleon
Nucleon spin decomposition
PHYS 3446 – Lecture #23 Symmetries Why do we care about the symmetry?
Sep 21st 2015, INFN Frascati National Laboratories, Frascati, Italy
Introduction to pQCD and TMD physics
Handout 3 : Interaction by Particle Exchange and QED
Nucleon Internal Structure: the Quark Gluon Momentum, Angular Momentum operators and parton distributions X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ.
Qin-Tao Song High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK)
Derivation of Electro-Weak Unification and Final Form of Standard Model with QCD and Gluons  1W1+  2W2 +  3W3.
Construction of a relativistic field theory
Theory : phenomenology support 12 GeV
Handout 9 : The Weak Interaction and V-A
Structure and Dynamics of the Nucleon Spin on the Light-Cone
Quark’s angular momentum densities in position space
August 29, Riken Tokyo Office, Tokyo, Japan
Structure functions and intrinsic quark orbital motion
Quantum numbers.
Central Potential Another important problem in quantum mechanics is the central potential problem This means V = V(r) only This means angular momentum.
Quantum Two.
Unique Description for SSAs in DIS and Hadronic Collisions
PHYS 3446 – Lecture #19 Symmetries Wednesday, Nov. 15, 2006 Dr. Jae Yu
Polarized Structure Function of Nucleon and Orbital Angular Momentum
Structure functions and intrinsic quark orbital motion
Unique Description for Single Transverse Spin Asymmetries
Sichuan Chengdu → Huazhong U of Sci. & Wuhan
Heavy-to-light transitions on the light cone
PHYS 3446 – Lecture #23 Standard Model Wednesday, Apr 25, 2012
Quantum One.
Presentation transcript:

Nucleon structure and Gauge field theory X.S.Chen, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. X.F.Lu, Dept. of Phys., Sichuan Univ. W.M.Sun, Dept. of Phys., Nanjing Univ. Fan Wang, Dept. of Phys. Nanjing Univ. T.Goldman,T-Division,LANL C.W.Wong, Dept.of Phys.,UCLA fgwang@chenwang.nju.edu.cn

Outline Introduction The first proton spin crisis and quark spin confusion The second proton spin crisis and the quark orbital angular momentum confusion A consistent decomposition of the momentum and angular momentum operators of a gauge field system Summary

I. Introduction It is still supposed to be a crisis that the polarized deep inelastic lepton-nucleon scattering (DIS) measured quark spin is only about 1/3 of the nucleon spin. I will show that this crisis can be solved by introducing minimum relativistic modification, the sea quark components in Nucleon, the DIS measured quark spin can be accomodated in CQM. There are different definitions about the quark and gluon orbital angular momentum. This will cause further confusion in the nucleon spin structure study and might have already caused it, such as the second proton spin crisis. The gluon spin is under measurements but what is the gluon spin is controversial.

2008 and 2009 we published two papers in PRL 100, 232002 and 103, 062001, which cause a hot debate on the proper operators for the nucleon internal structure study and the decomposition of gauge potential: X. Ji, E. Leader, K.F. Liu, M. Wakamatsu, Y. Hatta, Y.M. Cho, D.G. Pak and P.M. Zhang, A. Thomas, M. Burkardt, W. Vogelsang, G.R. Goldstein, J.W. Qiu, etc.

II.The first proton spin crisis and quark spin confusion quark spin contribution to nucleon spin in naïve non-relativistic quark model consistent with nucleon magnetic moments.

DIS measured quark spin The DIS measured quark spin contributions are: (E.Leader, A.V.Sidorov and D.B.Stamenov, PRD75,074027(2007); hep-ph/0612360) (D.de Florian, R.Sassot, M.Statmann and W.Vogelsang, PRL101, 072001(2008); 0804.0422[hep-ph]) .

Contradictions!? It seems there are two contradictions between the CQM and measurements: 1.The DIS measured total quark spin contribution to nucleon spin is about 25%, while in naïve quark model it is 1; 2.The DIS measured strange quark contribution is nonzero, while the naïve quark model result is zero.

Quark spin confusion The DIS measured one is the matrix element of the quark axial vector current operator in a polarized nucleon state, Here a0= Δu+Δd+Δs which is not the quark spin contributions calculated in CQM. The CQM calculated one is the matrix element of the Pauli spin part only.

Quark axial vector current operator The quark axial vector current operator can be expanded instantaneously as

Contents of axial vector current operator Only the first term of the axial vector current operator, which is the Pauli spin, has been calculated in the non-relativistic quark models. The second term, the relativistic correction, has not been included in the non-relativistic quark model calculations. The relativistic quark model does include this correction and it reduces the quark spin contribution about 25%. The third term, creation and annihilation, has not been calculated in models with only valence quark configuration.

An Extended CQM with Sea Quark Components (D.Qing, X.S.Chen and F.Wang,PRD58,114032(1998)) To understand the nucleon spin structure quantitatively within CQM and to clarify the quark spin confusion further we developed a CQM with sea quark components,

Model prediction of quark spin contribution to nucleon spin

III.The second proton spin crisis and the quark orbital angular momentum confusion R.L.Jaffe gave a talk at 2008 1th International Symposium on Science at J-PARK, raised the second proton spin crisis, mainly

Quark orbital angular momentum confusion The quark “orbital angular momentum” calculated in LQCD and measured in DVCS is not the real orbital angular momentum used in quantum mechanics. It does not satisfy the Angular Momentum Algebra, and the gluon contribution is ENTANGLED in it.

Where does the nucleon get spin? Real quark orbital angular momentum As a QCD system the nucleon spin consists of the following four terms (in Coulomb gauge),

The Real quark orbital angular momentum operator The real quark orbital angular momentum operator can be expanded instantaneously as

Quark orbital angular momentum will compensate the quark spin reduction The first term is the non-relativistic quark orbital angular momentum operator used in CQM, which does not contribute to nucleon spin in the naïve CQM. The second term is again the relativistic correction, which will compensate the relativistic quark spin reduction. The third term is again the creation and annihilation contribution, which will compensate the quark spin reduction due to creation and annihilation.

Relativistic versus non-relativistic spin-orbit sum It is most interesting to note that the relativistic correction and the creation and annihilation terms of the quark spin and the orbital angular momentum operators are exact the same but with opposite sign. Therefore if we add them together we will have where the , are the non-relativistic quark spin and orbital angular momentum operator used in quantum mechanics.

The above relation tells us that the quark contribution to nucleon spin can be either attributed to the quark Pauli spin, as done in the last thirty years in CQM, and the non-relativistic quark orbital angular momentum which does not contribute to the nucleon spin in naïve CQM; or part of the quark contribution is attributed to the relativistic quark spin as measured in DIS, the other part is attributed to the relativistic quark orbital angular momentum which will provide the exact compensation of the missing part in the relativistic “quark spin”

Prediction Based on the LQCD and the extended quark model calculation of quark spin; and the analysis of quark spin and orbital angular momentum operators; The matrix elements of the real relativistic quark orbital angular momentum should be: under a reasonable assumption that the non-relativistic quark orbital angular momentum contributions are not a too large negative value. This can be first checked by the LQCD calculation of the matrix elements of the real quark orbital angular momentum.

IV.A consistent decomposition of the momentum and angular momentum of a gauge system Jaffe-Manohar decomposition: R.L.Jaffe and A. Manohar,Nucl.Phys.B337,509(1990).

Each term in this decomposition satisfies the canonical commutation relation of angular momentum operator, so they are qualified to be called quark spin, orbital angular momentum, gluon spin and orbital angular momentum operators. However they are not gauge invariant except the quark spin.

Gauge invariant decomposition X.S.Chen and F.Wang, Commun.Theor.Phys. 27,212(1997). X.Ji, Phys.Rev.Lett.,78,610(1997). C.W.Wong, Fan Wang, W.M.Sun & X.F.Lv,arXiv:1010.4336[hep-ph].

However each term no longer satisfies the canonical commutation relation of angular momentum operator except the quark spin, in this sense the second and third terms are not the real quark orbital and gluon angular momentum operators. One can not have gauge invariant gluon spin and orbital angular momentum operator separately, the only gauge invariant one is the total angular momentum of gluon. In QED this means there is no photon spin and orbital angular momentum! This contradicts the well established multipole radiation analysis.

Gauge invariance and canonical quantization satisfied decomposition Gauge invariance is not sufficient to fix the decomposition of the angular momentum of a gauge system. Canonical quantization rule of the angular momentum operator must be respected. It is also an additional condition to fix the decomposition. X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu, W.M.Sun, F.Wang and T.Goldman, Phys.Rev.Lett. 100(2008) 232002. arXiv:0806.3166; 0807.3083; 0812.4366[hep-ph]; 0909.0798[hep-ph]

It provides the theoretical basis of the multipole radiation analysis

QCD

Non Abelian complication

Consistent separation of nucleon momentum and angular momentum

Each term is gauge invariant and so in principle measurable. Each term satisfies angular momentum commutation relation and so can be compared to quark model ones. In Coulomb gauge it reduces to Jaffe-Manohar decomposition. In other gauge, Jaffe-Manohar’s quark, gluon orbital angular momentum and gluon spin are gauge dependent. Ours are gauge invariant.

V. Summary There are different quark and gluon momentum and orbital angular momentum operators. Confusions disturbing or even misleading the nucleon spin structure studies. Quark spin missing can be understood within the CQM. It is quite possible that the real relativistic quark orbital angular momentum will compensate the missing quark spin. A LQCD calculation of the matrix elements of u,d quark real orbital angular momentum might illuminate the nucleon spin structure study.

For a gauge system, the momentum and angular momentum operators of the individual part (quark~gluon, electron~photon), the existing ones are either gauge invariant or satisfy the canonical commutation relation only but not both. We suggest a decomposition which satisfies both the gauge invariance and canonical commutation relations. It might be useful and modify our picture of nucleon internal structure.

It is not a special problem for quark and gluon angular momentum operators; But a fundamental problem for a gauge field system. Operators for the individual parts of a gauge system need this kind of modifications. X.S.Chen, X.F.Lu, W.M.Sun, F.Wang and T.Goldman, Phys.Rev.Lett. 100,232002(2008), arXiv:0806.3166; 0807.3083; 0812.4336[hep-ph]; 0909.0798[hep-ph]

Quantum Mechanics The fundamental operators in QM

For a charged particle moving in em field, the canonical momentum is, It is gauge dependent, so classically it is Not measurable. In QM, we quantize it as no matter what gauge is. It appears to be gauge invariant, but in fact Not!

Under a gauge transformation The matrix elements transform as

New momentum operator Old generalized momentum operator for a charged particle moving in em field, It satisfies the canonical momentum commutation relation, but its matrix elements are not gauge invariant. New momentum operator we proposed, It is both gauge invariant and canonical commutation relation satisfied.

We call physical momentum. It is neither the canonical momentum nor the mechanical momentum

Gauge transformation only affects the longitudinal part of the vector potential and time component it does not affect the transverse part, so is physical and which is completely determined by the em field tensor . is unphysical, it is caused by gauge transformation.

Separation of the gauge potential

Gauge transformation Under a gauge transformation,

Non Abeliean case

Gauge transformation

Hamiltonian of hydrogen atom Coulomb gauge: Hamiltonian of a non-relativistic charged particle Gauge transformed one

Following the same recipe, we introduce a new Hamiltonian, which is gauge invariant, i.e., This means the hydrogen energy calculated in Coulomb gauge is gauge invariant and physical.

A check We derived the Dirac equation and the Hamiltonian of electron in the presence of a massive proton from a em Lagrangian with electron and proton and found that indeed the time translation operator and the Hamiltonian are different, exactly as we obtained phenomenologically before. W.M. Sun, X.S. Chen, X.F. Lu and F. Wang, arXiv:1002.3421[hep-ph]

QED Different approaches will obtain different energy-momentum tensor and four momentum, they are not unique: Noether theorem Gravitational theory (weinberg) It appears to be perfect and its QCD version has been used in parton distribution analysis of nucleon, but does not satisfy the momentum algebra. Usually one supposes these two expressions are equivalent, because the sum of the integral is the same.

We are experienced in quantum mechanics, so we introduce They are gauge invariant and satisfy the momentum algebra. They return to the canonical expressions in Coulomb gauge.

orbital angular momentum The renowned Poynting vector is not the proper momentum of em field It includes photon spin and orbital angular momentum

QCD There are three different momentum operators as in QED,

Angular momentum operators The decomposition of angular momentum operators has been discussed before, and will not be repeated here.

VI. Summary There is no proton spin crisis but quark spin and orbital angular momentum confusion. The DIS measured quark spin can be accomodated in CQM. One can either attribute the quark contribution to nucleon spin to the quark Pauli spin and the non-relativistic quark orbital angular momentum or to the relativistic quark spin and orbital angular momentum. The following relation is an operator relation, The real relativistic quark orbital angular momentum will compensate for the missing quark spin.

The gauge potential can be separated into physical and pure gauge parts. The physical part is gauge invariant and measurable. The renowned Poynting vector is not the right momentum operator of em field. The photon spin and orbital angular momentum can be separated. The quark (electron) and gluon (photon) space-time translation and rotation generators are not observable. The gauge invariant and canonical quantization rule satisfying momentum, spin and orbital angular momentum can be obtained. They are observable. The unphysical pure gauge part has been gauged away in Coulomb gauge. The operators appearing there are physical, including the hydrogen atomic Hamiltonian and multipole radiation.

We suggest to use the physical momentum, angular momentum, etc. in hadron physics as have been used in atomic, nuclear physics for so long a time. Quite possibly, it will modify our picture of nucleon internal structure.

Thanks