Jul 2011 Project: IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [Comparison of Responses to Task Group 802.15.4j Call for Proposals] Date Submitted: [11 May 2011] Source: [Ray Krasinski] Company [Philips] Address [345 Scarborough Road, Briarcliff Manor, NY, USA] Voice:[1-914-333-9687], E-Mail:[raymond.krasinski@philips.com] Re: Comparison of TG 4j Call for Proposals responses Abstract: An overview of the areas of agreement between responses to the TG4j CFP and areas in need of further discussion. Purpose: To outline the points of agreement and differences between the TG4j CFP responses to help drive discussion of the proposals and help move towards consensus. Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein. Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15. Ray Krasinski, Philips

Comparison of Responses to 802.15.4j Call for Proposals Jul 2011 Comparison of Responses to 802.15.4j Call for Proposals Ray Krasinski, Philips

doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Content TG4j RFP Response Requirements Term Comparison PHY Areas of Agreement PHY Areas in Need of Further Discussion MAC Areas of Agreement MAC Areas in Need of Further Discussion Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

TG 4j Technical Requirements 15-11-0064 <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 TG 4j Technical Requirements 15-11-0064 Compliance with: FCC MBANS Rules Part 95 Subpart M – Medical Body Areas Network Service (device control) Amendments to technical requirements covering transmit frequencies, emissions, transmit powers etc TG4j PAR and 5 Criteria Physical Layer Compliant to the existing 802.15.4 DSSS PHY employing O-QPSK, operating in the 2450 MHz band MAC Layer Only additional MAC requirements to support the Physical Layer: To be defined Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

Jul 2011 Terms TG4j Term IEEE 802.15.4 FCC MBANS Device Device (RFD or FFD) Node Hub Coordinator (FFD) Master Transmitter PAN Coordinator PAN Coordinator (FFD) <none> Control Point Band Coordinator - A healthcare facility may have multiple PAN Coordinators but is expected to have only one Control Point. - The Band Coordinator is an independent entity, selected by the FCC, to manage the MBANS band. See 15.11-0341-02, slide 6 for a detailed definition of the Band Coordinator Ray Krasinski, Philips

Comparison of Proposals - PHY <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Comparison of Proposals - PHY Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

Areas of Agreement - PHY <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Areas of Agreement - PHY Use of 802.15.4 2450MHZ DSSS PHY 5 Mhz channel spacing 16-ary based OQPSK Modulation 32 I and Q chips for 250kbps Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

Areas in Need of Further Discussion - PHY <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Areas in Need of Further Discussion - PHY Channelization Plan Forward Error Code Block Interleave Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

Philips Channelization Proposal <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Philips Channelization Proposal AMT spectrum Guard bands 15.4j channels Amateur radio spectrum 2360.5 2360 MHz 2400 2399.5 MHz 2390 MHz 2400 MHz 0 (2363) 1 (2368) 2 (2373) 3 (2378) 4 (2383) 5 (2388) 6 (2393) 14 (2395) 7 (2367) 8(2372) 9 (2377) 10 (2382) 11 (2387) 12 (2392) 13 (2397) For in-hospital deployment 15 channels defined to promote coexistence with AMT Non-overlapping channels will be used in entire 2360-2400 MHz band For out-of-hospital deployment Overlapping channels in 2390–2400 MHz band offers flexibility to avoid interference Low deployment density and low duty cycle will assist MBANS coexistence Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

LG Channelization Proposal Jul 2011 LG Channelization Proposal 9 channels 2360 ~ 2390 MHz: Non-overlapped 6 channels 2390 ~ 2400 MHz: Overlapped 3 channels Ray Krasinski, Philips

Samsung Channelization Proposal Jul 2011 Samsung Channelization Proposal 5 MHz channel spacing 2 sets of overlapping bands with an offset of 2 MHz 7 channels in each set (2395 MHz channel used in both sets) One set selected Different preambles for different sets 5 MHz Center Frequencies First set (MHz) Second set (MHz) 2363 2365 2368 2370 2373 2375 2378 2380 2383 2385 2388 2390 2395 Ray Krasinski, Philips

Forward Error Code (FEC) Jul 2011 Forward Error Code (FEC) Description: Add forward error codes to decrease transmission errors Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Systematic hamming codes (15,11) Optional decoder at receiver Ray Krasinski, Philips

Jul 2011 Block Interleave Description: Interleave blocks to decrease burst errors Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Interleaving in 60 bits blocks 4 blocks of 15 bits will be interleaved into 4 different blocks Ray Krasinski, Philips

Comparison of Proposals - MAC Jul 2011 Comparison of Proposals - MAC Ray Krasinski, Philips

Areas of Agreement - MAC <month year> doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#> Jul 2011 Areas of Agreement - MAC Need for addition of PHY Information Base (PIB) attribute Ray Krasinski, Philips <author>, <company>

Areas in Need of Further Discussion -MAC Jul 2011 Areas in Need of Further Discussion -MAC Multi-Periodic GTS Mutual Broadcast Periods Easy Pairing Unslotted & Slotted CSMA-CA at Nonbeacon-enabled PAN Service Based Discovery Coordinator Switching Channel Switch Notification Congestion Avoidance Ray Krasinski, Philips

Jul 2011 Multi-Periodic GTS Description: Increase efficiency of GTS in 15.4 by allowing for periodic GTS. Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Modify GTS information to support periodic GTS Ray Krasinski, Philips

Jul 2011 Easy Pairing Description: Method of pairing a Device to a Hub when the Device and Hub are not in close proximity (out of range). A portable device is used as a carrier for pairing information Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: 3 new commands: Grant Association Proxy Authority Association Proxy Request Association Proxy Response Ray Krasinski, Philips

Mutual Broadcast Periods Jul 2011 Mutual Broadcast Periods Description: Enhanced channel access method to minimize back-offs Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Additional period using CSMA-CA for mutual broadcasting among devices CSMA-CA with shorter back-off slot length 3 different types of CAPs Exclusive CAP Normal CAP Background CAP Ray Krasinski, Philips

Unslotted & Slotted CSMA-CA at Nonbeacon-enabled PAN Jul 2011 Unslotted & Slotted CSMA-CA at Nonbeacon-enabled PAN Description: Synchronized channel access mechanism at Nonbeacon-enabled PAN Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Pulse-Coupled Oscillator synchronization needed at PHY layer Ray Krasinski, Philips

Service Based Discovery Jul 2011 Service Based Discovery Description: If there are multiple PAN Coordinators, a method for a device selecting a PAN Coordinator based on its service type Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Service ID added to Beacon Frame Ray Krasinski, Philips

Coordinator Switching Jul 2011 Coordinator Switching Description: Proactive method to establish a connection to a new Hub if the connection to the Hub is lost. Active method to check quality of connection or PAN ID conflict and request change. Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Active: Change information (channel number, PAN ID, etc) is broadcasted in beacon frame with realignment command when switch needed Proactive: Setting priority of selected replacement Hubs in the device and transmitting the priority to the selected replacement Hub Ray Krasinski, Philips

Channel Switch Notification Jul 2011 Channel Switch Notification Description: A channel switch command with time and channel information. Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Timestamp: The time at which the channel switching will occur Logical Channel: The logical channel which is chosen by the coordinator and the MBAN device shall switch to. Channel Page: The channel page which is chosen by the coordinator and the MBAN device shall switch to. Ray Krasinski, Philips

Jul 2011 Congestion Avoidance Description: A method of avoiding congestion at a relay Hub by broadcasting a response signal comprising congestion-related information from the Hub with respect to data transmitted to the Hub and using this information to better avoid congestion Proposed Changes to 802.15.4: Add congestion related information Ray Krasinski, Philips