PCI & Auditory ERPs for the diagnosis of disorders of consciousness

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Developing Science Skills. Preparing for Tasks Level DLevel ELevel F individually or in small groups will identify two or three questions to investigate.
Advertisements

ERP Characteristics of Early AD
Sensorimotor integration in primary dystonia – its relevance for the sensory trick Dr. Florian Brugger.
1 MMI Man Machine Interface Ohad Stein Sefi Epel Technion - IsraelSummer 2002.
Ensemble Learning: An Introduction
CSE 300: Software Reliability Engineering Topics covered: Software metrics and software reliability Software complexity and software quality.
Stimulus-Specific Adaptation in Auditory Cortex Is an NMDA-Independent Process Distinct from the Sensory Novelty Encoded by the Mismatch Negativity.
Copyright © 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 1 Overview of Nursing Process, Clinical Reasoning, and Nursing Practice.
EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE
CORRELATIO NAL RESEARCH METHOD. The researcher wanted to determine if there is a significant relationship between the nursing personnel characteristics.
New developments in cerebral monitoring Tariq Alzahrani Demonstrator College of Medicine King Saud University.
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) Student Classification Using Genetic Algorithm and Artificial Neural Network S. Yenaeng 1, S. Saelee 2.
The Danielson Framework and Your Evaluation AK Teaching Standard DP_8c: Engages in Instructional Development Activities Danielson Domain 4e: Growing and.
Teacher Page I. Scientific Inquiry, A. Processes of Scientific Inquiry Missouri science standards 1.4, 1.5, 1.6, 1.7, 1.8, 2.1, 2.7 7th grade science MAP.
1 Chapter 3 1.Quality Management, 2.Software Cost Estimation 3.Process Improvement.
Distributed Representative Reading Group. Research Highlights 1Support vector machines can robustly decode semantic information from EEG and MEG 2Multivariate.
Behavioral Variability: Implications for Rehabilitation John Whyte, MD, PhD Moss Rehabilitation Research Institute & Thomas Jefferson University.
The World Around Us and the Media Integrating ICT.
Classification Of Psychiatric Disorders In Children And Adolescent
Fig.1. Flowchart Functional network identification via task-based fMRI To identify the working memory network, each participant performed a modified version.
Clustering Features in High-Throughput Proteomic Data Richard Pelikan (or what’s left of him) BIOINF 2054 April
Introduction to Measurement. According to Lord Kelvin “When you can measure what you are speaking about and express it in numbers, you know something.
An Introduction to Formative Assessment as a useful support for teaching and learning.
Bioethics Lesson 6 Elements of Research. Structures of Research  Types of Research  Systematic Observation  Controlled experiment  Field study  Models.
A comparative study of survival models for breast cancer prognostication based on microarray data: a single gene beat them all? B. Haibe-Kains, C. Desmedt,
EBM --- Journal Reading Presenter :呂宥達 Date : 2005/10/27.
Tuesday’s breakfast Int. 林泰祺. Introduction Maxillofacial injuries in isolation or in combination with other injuries account for a significant percentage.
Consciousness. Seeing activity in the temporal cortex in response to hearing once name would be indication of what conscious state?
Evidence-based Physiotherapy By B.Nelson. Outline of Presentation What is Evidence –Based Healthcare and its importance Labels used across health care.
1 Psychology 304: Brain and Behaviour Lecture 2. 2 Research Methods 1.What techniques do biological psychologists use to assess the structure and function.
Schizophrenia Issues of Reliability and Validity Explain the issues of reliability with classification of schizophrenia.
Canonical Correlation. Canonical correlation analysis (CCA) is a statistical technique that facilitates the study of interrelationships among sets of.
Introduction Background Medical decision support systems based on patient data and expert knowledge A need to analyze the collected data in order to draw.
Methodology in the Biological Level of Analysis Learning Objectives: 1.Discuss how and why particular research methods are used at the biological level.
Techniques to Study the Brain. In the olden days… It was really difficult to study brain anatomy and function unless somebody died or an accident occurred.
COMMUNICATION SKILLS & DOCTOR-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP DR Tabassum Alvi Assistant Professor Psychiatry/Behavioura Sciences Majmaah University 15 TH OCTOBER,
© 2010 Jones and Bartlett Publishers, LLC. Chapter 12 Clinical Epidemiology.
HRM-755 PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT OSMAN BIN SAIF LECTURE: TWENTY THREE 1.
Advance Care Planning in dementia Dr Karen Harrison Dening Head of Research & Evaluation Dementia UK GSF 2016.
Inquiry-Based Instruction
Software Defects Cmpe 550 Fall 2005
Correspondence between Brain Waves and Human Trust using EEG in Autonomous System Seeung Oh.
Parallel Sessions: Pathways & Prediction
Accurate wide field machine assessment of Acne and Rosacea
Neurofeedback of beta frequencies:
Integrated microRNA-mRNA profiling identifies molecular biomarkers in bladder outlet obstruction-induced lower urinary tract dysfunction Fiona C. Burkhard1,
Assessment Activities
Human Resource Management By Dr. Debashish Sengupta
Plymouth Environmental Research Centre
Investigating the Impact of Instructional Strategies to Support the Reading of Scientific Texts Andrew Pola and Don Pata — Science Department, Grosse Pointe.
Part 4 Symbols and Higher-Level Concepts and Activities
Stimulation-based state monitoring – new developments
Left middle frontal cortex, caudate nuclei
Heart Rate Variability as an Indicator of Nociceptive Pain in Disorders of Consciousness?  Francesco Riganello, MSc, Camille Chatelle, PhD, Caroline Schnakers,
Assessing science enquiry
Dynamic Causal Modelling for M/EEG
Florian T. Merkle, Kevin Eggan  Cell Stem Cell 
Northeast Regional Epilepsy Group Christos Lambrakis M.D.
DSS-ESTIMATING COSTS Cost estimation is the process of estimating the relationship between costs and cost driver activities. We estimate costs for three.
Machine Learning for Visual Scene Classification with EEG Data
Brain death and disorders of consciousness
Figure 1. Brain complexity, consciousness and psychedelics
Assessment of Neural Dynamics in Severe Traumatic Brain Injured Patients with Disorders of Consciousness Casey S. Gilmore, Ph.D. Defense and Veterans Brain.
A modest attempt at measuring and communicating about quality
Regression and Clinical prediction models
Behavioral Markers of Recovery of Consciousness After Severe Brain Injury 13th World Congress on Brain Injury, March 2019 Géraldine Martens1,2, Yelena.
higher-order function associated with conscious states
A handbook on validation methodology. Metrics.
Fig. 3 The coordination patterns generalize to other states of preserved and diminished consciousness. The coordination patterns generalize to other states.
10 Steps to a Quality Lesson Plan
Presentation transcript:

PCI & Auditory ERPs for the diagnosis of disorders of consciousness Hello everyone, My name is Leandro Sanz I will introduce you to our research which compares two EEG-based methods for the diagnosis of patients with disorders of consciousness Leandro Sanz, MD Coma Science Group GIGA Consciousness University & Hospital of Liège, Belgium 4th Congress of the EAN Lisbon June 17th 2018 www.comascience.org 1

Disorders of consciousness Differential diagnosis Introduction Disorders of consciousness Wakefulness Variable awareness & communication Unresponsive Wakefulness Syndrome Only reflexive behavior Minimally Conscious State Reproducible non-reflexive behaviors Emergence from the Minimally Conscious State Functional communication or use of object After coma, patients can develop DOC where they are awake but show variable awareness & communication skills. While unresponsive patients only show reflexive behaviours, MCS patients exhibit reproducible behaviours such as command following. They emerge from the MCS when they are able to functionally communicate or use an object. The clinical assessment of these patients yields up to 40% of misdiagnosis, even though an accurate diagnosis is crucial to predict prognosis, to offer adequate treatment and guide end-of-life decisions. Therefore, other non-invasive tools such as EEG-based methods are needed to complement the behavioral evaluation. Differential diagnosis Clinical misdiagnosis up to 40% Crucial for prognosis, treatment, end-of-life decisions EEG-based methods as non-invasive tools to detect consciousness

Methods 2 EEG-based methods 1. Transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with EEG The Perturbational Complexity Index (PCI) The first approach we used is transcranial magnetic stimulation, a technique where we measure the EEG response of the cortex to a magnetic focal perturbation through the scalp. By integrating the complexity of the response into a single metric, the PCI, we can predict the patient’s level of consciousness. PCI=0.31

Methods 2 EEG-based methods 1. Transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with EEG The Perturbational Complexity Index (PCI) We see here an unresponsive patient with local, short, simple response, which yields a PCI under the threshold of consciousness. PCI=0.20 Unresponsive

Methods 2 EEG-based methods Minimally conscious 1. Transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with EEG The Perturbational Complexity Index (PCI) Whereas this minimally conscious patient exhibits a far more complex, widespread and long-lasting response which classifies him above the threshold of consciousness. PCI=0.41 Minimally conscious

2. Auditory evoked potentials Methods 2 EEG-based methods 2. Auditory evoked potentials Local-Global oddball paradigm  Machine-Learning approach 120 EEG markers Evoked potentials Spectral measures Information Connectivity  Multivariate classifier calibrated on a dataset of 130 patients (68 unresponsive; 62 minimally conscious) Regularity 1) ..... Local Standard Global Standard Local Deviant Global Deviant Regularity For the second method, EEG was recorded while during a standardized auditory oddball paradigm, and 120 EEG markers were computed using a machine-learning approach. These markers reflected either evoked potentials, spectral measures, information or connectivity. From these markers, a multivariate classifier was used to evaluate the level the consciousness, which was calibrated on a dataset of 130 previous patients. 2) ..... Local Deviant Global Standard Local Standard Global Deviant

Results 25 patients (4 unresponsive; 16 minimally conscious; 5 emergent) PCI correlates with some individual EEG markers 25 patients with a clinical diagnosis of disorders of consciousness underwent both assessments. On the x axis, you can see individual markers from the machine learning approach, while the y axis shows the PCI value from transcranial magnetic stimulation. The color code indicates the clinical diagnosis. We see that some markers correlate better than others with the PCI value, but there is still some overlap between the different colors. Kolmogorov complexity Permutational entropy (θ) Weighted symbolic mutual information (θ)

Results & Discussion The probability from the multivariate classifier correlates best with the PCI Congruent results for 19 patients (76%) Positive correlation between 2 methods Correct diagnosis for all unresponsive and emergent patients EEG signatures of consciousness  reliable predictive models for diagnosis Using the multivariate classifier with the 120 markers, we observe a better correlation with the PCI, as well as a clear distinction between unresponsive and emergent patients. However, minimally conscious ones are still spread across the graph which might indicate greater variability in their capacity for consciousness. The correlation between these two independent measures provides evidence that EEG-based methods can be reliably used to detect signatures of consciousness and that further tools should be developed to increase the diagnosis of disorders of consciousness. Thank you for your attention. leandro.sanz@uliege.be