Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick, Ireland

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Indiana State University Assessment of General Education Objectives Using Indicators From National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE)
Advertisements

A Research Active Hospice
The spatial dimensions of Skills for Life workplace provision Dr. Natasha Kersh Institute of Education,, University of London Paper prepared for the Seminar.
Home Economics Teachers’ Readiness for Teaching STEM
A Case Study of Progression on a Foundation Degree Amanda Davis Stockport College Eamon O’Doherty University of Salford.
The Graduate Attributes Project: a perspective on early stakeholder engagement Dr Caroline Walker Queen Mary, University of London.
QUALITY ASSURANCE IN IRISH HIGHER EDUCATION Tuesday, September 19 Fergal Costello Higher Education Authority.
Introducing small-group workshops as formative assessment in large first year psychology modules Suzanne Guerin School of Psychology, University College.
Stuart Hollis Where are we now? An exploration of the provision of teacher training programmes for the Learning and Skills Sector following the 2007 Workforce.
Preparing masters students for teaching in higher education: a new route to enhanced employability? Lorraine Allibone ) Steve.
Evaluating the Vermont Mathematics Initiative (VMI) in a Value Added Context H. ‘Bud’ Meyers, Ph.D. College of Education and Social Services University.
Postgraduate Taught Experience Survey (PTES) 2010 Interim Results Dr Pam Wells Adviser, Evidence-Informed Practice.
Enquiring into Entrepreneurial School Leadership Sue Robson.
Developing Multiple Identities: Collaborative research as a method of professional learning, in a team of teacher educators. Lin Savage Early Years Programmes.
International Conference on Enhancement and Innovation in Higher Education Crowne Plaza Hotel, Glasgow 9-11 June 2015 Welcome.
SUSTAINABLE EDUCATION By CHARBAJI Consultants. What is Sustainability?  In the current literature, sustainability has been defined rather narrowly by.
Integrate English as a Second Language (ESL) strategies into the teacher preparation program for all students the semester prior to student teaching. Require.
By: HANIM MOHAMED (MP ) SITI FATIMAH ZAINI (MP091421)
N ational Q ualifications F ramework N Q F Quality Center National Accreditation Committee.
Assessing the Impact of the Interactive Learning Space Initiative on Faculty Morale and Student Achievement Ball State University 2015 Spring Assessment.
CENTRE FOR EXCELLENCE IN TEACHING & LEARNING ASSESSMENT FOR LEARNING CETL Associates Project Angelina Wilson and Nicola Reimann CENTRE FOR EXCELLENCE IN.
KEVIN SMITH & KIM HORTON JULY 2015 Educational research and teaching Wales.
Graduate School of Medicine University of Wollongong Educators learning together and modeling interprofessional collaboration Sue Vella, Sal Sanzone, Helen.
Myanna Duncan Doctoral Researcher Work & Health Research Centre Loughborough University.
Older people in Higher Education: Why study for a qualification? Anne Jamieson Birkbeck, University of London BSG Annual Conference Bangor September 2006.
Action Research for School Leaders by Dr. Paul A. Rodríguez.
Postgraduate Taught Experience Survey (PTES) 2010 Interim Results
Visible Learning Plus: an introduction
Australian Professional Standards for Teachers Unpacking the Standards
Real Time In-Ear Coaching
Dr Susan Smith, Leeds Beckett University
Factors facilitating academic success: a student perspective
Are Your Educational Programs Learning-Centered? Can You Measure This?
Collaboration for Effective Educator Development, Accountability and Reform H325A
Exploring the Role of Cultural and Policy Context in Distributed Leadership Practices in the US and Denmark The Comprehensive Assessment of Leadership.
Tensions and opportunities in the relationship between assessment design at Masters level and the ‘school improvement’ agenda Professor Hazel Bryan Lynda.
Chartered College of Teaching
Update for ICP Council Meeting
Reforming Teacher Educators’ Professionalism and Pedagogy: Looking for Landmarks in a Changing Europe Jean Murray (England) Marit Ulvik (Norway) Mieke.
Research amongst Physical Therapists in the State of Kuwait: Participation, Perception, Attitude and Barriers Presented by Sameera Aljadi, PT, PhD Assistant.
The impact of being research-engaged; how do teachers involved in research believe it has impacted upon their professional development, practice and sense.
Chapter 2: Mapping and Assessing Career Readiness Policies, Programs, and Industries May 2017 Copyright © 2017 American Institutes for Research. All rights.
Digital Learning Framework Evaluation Overview
Teacher Education for Inclusion TE4I project
The TEAP Portfolio Award and the EAP Teacher Competencies
Mapping it Out! Practical Tools to Use Assessment Well
Conditions for effective teacher educator professional learning
This presentation will include:
Online Instructional Self-Efficacy and Acceptance
Ann MacPhail, Mary O’Sullivan and Paul Conway,
An Evaluation of Practitioner Based Enquiry as a Method of Building Senior Management Team Capacity and Self-Efficacy Elizabeth Bolton, Richard Lockhart,
The Professional Development of Higher Education Based Teacher Educators in Three Countries: Ireland, Israel and Norway Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick,
Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick, Ireland
Building Academic Language
Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick, Ireland
The impact of small-group EBP education programme: barriers and facilitators for EBP allied health champions to share learning with peers.
Essentials of Oral Defense
Making Tomorrow’s Doctors Today’s Teachers
Chartered Society of Physiotherapy
Standard for Teachers’ Professional Development July 2016
Research Problem: The research problem starts with clearly identifying the problem you want to study and considering what possible methods will affect.
External Examiner Briefing: Report Writing 22 January
Building Academic Language
What does assessment literacy mean to language teachers?
The impact of being research-engaged; how do teachers involved in research believe it has impacted upon their professional development, practice and sense.
What aspects of a team make it a Community of Practice?
Insider research The Ethical Issues of being a researcher close to your own practice Sinéad Whiting PhD Candidate Trinity College Dublin, School of Social.
The Impact of Peer Learning on Assessment Literacy and Feedback Orientation
Faye Nicholson, P7 Class Teacher, Kingsland Primary School
A data-driven, multi-disciplinary approach to understanding student non-engagement with employability initiatives Presenters: Dr Stephanie McBurney, Faculty.
Presentation transcript:

Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick, Ireland The use, conduct and role of research: Higher-education based teacher educator-researchers in Ireland Ann MacPhail, University of Limerick, Ireland INTRODUCTION METHODS (continued) RESULTS CONCLUSIONS Teacher education and research: If teaching and teacher education are to be taken seriously, need to be research-based / informed / ‘public intellectuals’ (Coachran-Smith, 2005) Re-positioning of teacher education and associated programmes to be ‘research driven’ / develop a research disposition / consumers and producers of research (Tack and Vanderlinde, 2014 ) Pressure from universities for teacher educators to focus on securing research funding and increase publication output (Stern, 2016) ‘dual economy’ – research and teaching (Christie & Menter, 2009) Irish teacher education and research: The recent policy context in Ireland has re-framed the role of teacher education and research (Gleeson et al., 2017). The joint influence of the more complete universitisation of teacher education recommended in the Sahlberg et al., report (2012), along with increased rankings pressure on universities, has meant that there is more pressure on Irish teacher education academics as they work in higher educational institutions to acquire a PhD and publish in peer-reviewed research outlets. Main recommendations from the International Review Panel (Sahlberg et al., 2012) were (i) to enhance teacher professionalism and practice by increasing the research capacity of providers of ITE, and (2) the development of critical mass of (research) teacher educators through reduction in number of institutions to form ‘centres of excellence of education’. Three trends can be identified. First, the recent growth of research outputs on teacher education in Ireland over the last decade. Second, a small number of larger scale studies as well as a number of commissioned reports on teacher education which have provided more system level insights on teacher education. Third, there is more of a focus on initial teacher education than other elements of the teacher education continuum. A total of 54 teacher educators, two-thirds of whom were female, responded to the survey with a spread of ages represented across the age ranges with the largest percentage (35%) residing in the 45-54 years old bracket. Fifty-one respondents noted working full-time as a teacher educator with nine holding, as their highest academic qualification, a Masters and 45 a PhD or Professional Doctorate. Over 80% were in permanent contracts, with over 70% and 26% working in a university and college context respectively. The mean length of time that teacher educators had worked as a teacher educator was fourteen years. Semi-structured interviews: The interview questions closely mapped the sections of the survey and constituted questions on (i) background and demographics, (ii) professional learning opportunities, and (iii) teacher education and research. Interviews were conducted in each participant’s native language. Ten teacher educators who had completed the survey and noted their interest in being involved further with the study were interviewed. The interviews took place at each teacher educator’ place of work, either face-to-face or by Skype. Each interview lasted between 40 minutes and 70 minutes. A significant proportion of the interviewees held senior posts within their institutions and included being heads of departments and dean of a school of education. Data analysis: Once all the Irish survey data was collected, basic statistical analysis focusing on mean scores / percentages were calculated for each question. An earlier paper related to the larger study from which the Irish cohort reside, explains how principal component analysis yielded two main factors across the complement of countries involved in the larger study (Czerniawski, Guberman & MacPhail, 2016). Thematic analysis was used to analyze and triangulate the interview data. Initially, the lead researcher identified themes arising from the interviews. A coding process, used in identifying similar text units, followed by linking and retrieval of similarly coded segments (Mason, 1996), was compiled. These were arranged under particular themes that complemented the questions posed in the survey. Additional themes that emerged necessitated further consideration and analysis of previously coded data. Questionnaire: Extent to which you use research The highest means were recorded for the comments related to their teaching being informed by research and knowing how to use research as a teacher educator. Extent to which you actively conduct research The capability of presenting and sharing their own research with other teacher educators as well as identifying as someone who is capable of conducting research achieved the highest means. Extent to which you value role as a teacher educator-researcher Research being essential for the TE profession and teacher educators having a responsibility towards their students to study their own practice scored the highest means. Over 90% of the respondents noted actively being involved in research and writing about the findings and being involved in scholarly research. Interviews: “I am an active user of research, but I wouldn't be an active producer of research”. (Interviewee E) “ (…) if I was to become competent as a teacher educator researcher, it requires a huge amount of effort. I know the amount of dedication it takes to develop a specialism in a topic and, to be honest, I want to continue growing my own expertise and scholarship in the work I do currently. It would take me a huge effort, I'd have to sacrifice some of that perhaps to become on my own as a teacher educator.” (Interviewee B) “I love research. I think it's a key element of your role as a teacher educator at any level. (…) Research is really important, first of all, because I'm a teacher and it's really important that I keep abreast of current trends, developments, what are the key players saying, the type of content that I'm delivering (…) I suppose I use evidence and research hugely to inform my practice. I also obviously use research to actually assess my own practice in terms of how I as a teacher perform so research is very much built into my teaching.” (Interviewee D) “They [university] actually don't see it [teacher education] as a clinical situation that requires research, requires competencies, requires professionalism (…) we have an awful lot of work to do there, and part of the development there, has to be the development of the Teacher Educator.” (Interviewee F) “I feel under pressure to do research (…) I suppose I've been at it [teacher education] a long time. I also say there's only so much I can do. We work for very long hours, and I do feel under pressure, I do (…) People say things to you like, "We need to raise our profile." That kind of thing. Like, to be told, when you've been working in an area for 18 years, where everybody knows you, where something like that you've done has been so positively received, to be told to raise your profile I find quite insulting, to be honest.” (Interviewee J) The data suggest these Irish teacher educators value research as essential for the teaching profession. It should be noted the question asked them about the value of research about the teaching profession not the teacher educator profession. Most of these Irish teacher educators believed they should be doing research in their current role in higher education. While these teacher educators perceive themselves capable of both doing and presenting their research with and to others, they seem much less engaged with or familiar with research on the preparation of future teachers (as in specifically teacher education research). This could well explain what on first analysis might seem like a contradictory finding. The respondents noted they read research and are informed by it yet are less likely to use research to solve problems in their teacher education practice. If the research they are reading or doing is not teacher education research, then such research might not be able to inform their work as teacher educators. This interpretation would be supported by Lunenberg et al.’s (2014) extensive review of the research on teacher educators where they noted that often teacher educators are “insufficiently informed about the [teacher education] literature and…not focused on strengthening their theoretical knowledge base” (p. 74). CONSIDERATIONS Teacher educators in this study; … are a highly selective sample. … believe they should be doing research in their current role in higher education. … are capable of both doing and presenting their research with and to others. To note: … value research as essential for the teaching profession (and not necessarily the teacher education profession). … are less engaged with or familiar with research on the preparation of future teachers (as in specifically teacher education research). REFERENCES Cochran-Smith, M. (2005). Teacher educators as researchers: multiple perspectives. Teaching and Teacher Education, 21, 219–225 Christie, D. & Menter, I. (2009). Research capacity building in teacher education: Scottish collaborative approaches. Journal of Education for Teaching, 35(4), 337-354. Czerniawski, G., Guberman, A. & MacPhail, A. (2017). The professional developmental needs of higher education-based teacher educators: an international comparative needs analysis. European Journal of Teacher Education, 40(1), 127-140. Gleeson, J., Sugrue, C., & O'Flaherty, J. (2017). Research capacity and initial teacher education reform: Irish experiences, international perspectives. Teaching and Teacher Education, 62, 19-29. Lunenberg, M. Dengerink, J. & Korthagen, F. (2014). The Professional Teacher Educator: Roles, Behaviors, and Professional Development of Teacher Educators. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers. Mason, J. (1996) Qualitative Researching. London: Sage. Sahlberg, P., Furlong, J., & Munn, P. (2012). Report of the international review panel on the structure of initial teacher education provision in Ireland: Review conducted on behalf of the department of education and skills. Dublin: Higher Education Authority of Ireland. Stern, A. (2016). Building on Success and Learning from Experience - An Independent Review of the Research Excellence Framework. Crown copyright: ref: IND/16/9. Tack, H., & Vanderlinde, R. (2014). Teacher educators’ professional development: towards a typology of teacher educators’ researcherly disposition. British Journal of Educational Studies, 62(3), 297–315. OBJECTIVE The objective of this poster is to report the extent to which Irish higher-education based teacher educators use research, actively conduct research and value their role as a teacher educator-researcher. METHODS Questionnaire: A questionnaire was constructed and distributed through all teacher education institutions and teacher education networks in Ireland. Specific to the data reported here, participants rated on a Likert response scale, ranging from 1 (= not at all) to 6 (= very much), the extent to which they (i) use research, (ii) actively conduct research, and (iii) value their role as a teacher educator-researcher. Through completion of surveys using Survey Monkey all data was automatically accumulated in a central data base. These Irish teacher educators appear to be a highly selective sample, given that 83% of them have PhDs