Leadership in Impact Assessment – An international symposium

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
ENHANCING ATTRACTIVENESS OF ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND MANAGEMENT HIGHER EDUCATION Seminar on Experiences in S Korea, Japan and the EU Yonsei University,
Advertisements

Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development EAM Master programmes in the Netherlands Preparing students for working with environmental assessment in.
HELPING THE NATION SPEND WISELY Performance audit and evaluation: common ground with Internal Audit ? The UK National Audit Office experience Jeremy Lonsdale.
The Voice of Carers Developing carer organisations across Europe Sebastian Fischer VOCAL - Voice of Carers Across Lothian Coalition of Carers in Scotland.
End of Waste – Experiences from the UK Roger Hoare, Environment Agency 3rd October 2013 Malta 2013 IMPEL Conference on Implementation and Enforcement of.
ESTABLISHING A CO-OPERATIVE FRAMEWORK BETWEEN THE ACCREDITATION COUNCIL OF TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO (ACTT) AND PROFESSIONAL STATUTORY AND REGULATORY BODIES.
CURRENT PROPOSALS FOR FURTHER INTRODUCTION OF DISPUTE BOARDS WITHIN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY IN ROMANIA.
Understanding user needs challenges and solutions Dr James Tucker, National Statistician’s Office, United Kingdom.
Claire Draper Director of Membership Services IEMA Annual Conference 12 th June 2007.
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION Innovation and the Structural Funds, Antwerp, 16 January 2007 Veronica Gaffey Innovative Actions Unit.
What is Necessary to Ensure Natural Justice in EIA Decision-making? Angus Morrison-Saunders Senior Lecturer in Environmental Assessment School of Environmental.
HORIZON 2020 European Commission Research and Innovation First stakeholder workshop on Horizon 2020 Implementation Brussels, 16 January 2015.
Results The final report was presented to NICE and published by NICE and WHO. See
Attracting, recruiting, and supporting high performing school leaders School leadership policy needs to ensure that the best available candidates are attracted.
CBE PRESENTATION TO PARLIAMENT 09 June 2009 OVERVIEW 1. Introductions 2. Background to the CBE History 3. The CBE Mandate 4. CBE Vision and Mission 5.
Fitness Check of environmental monitoring and reporting MIG-P meeting 4 Dec 2015 Joachim D'Eugenio Steve White DG Environment European Commission.
UNEP EIA Training Resource ManualTopic 14Slide 1 What is SEA? F systematic, transparent process F instrument for decision-making F addresses environmental.
HIA Capacity Building: comparisons and contrasts Debbie Abrahams, Director, International Health Impact Assessment Consortium, Public Health, 9 th International.
Health in Strategic Environmental Assessment Colleen Williams: Department of Health Paul Fisher: Health Protection Agency
13 August 2012NUAS New forms of communicating research - in a European collaboration Ulla Bredberg, Science Communication Officer.
The council’s future role in education June 2016 [Final] Standards First.
Monitoring Visit to NatRisk Project
Kick Off Meeting Largs, Scotland
Introduction The CIPD Advancing the HR and L &D profession in Ireland
Postgraduate Taught Experience Survey (PTES) 2010 Interim Results
Wales Best Practice Day 20 October 2016
Legal Aspects Related to Brownfield Regeneration
Evaluation Capacity Strengthening and Professional Development Program
Professional Development Lead Support Programme Workshop Version 2
ACTOR Briefing Event -Tendering Process
ECOLNET Training Approach
Implications of BREXIT for Environmental Assessment in the UK
SUPPORT TO PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT REFORM IN GEORGIA
Energy and Technology Partnership Conference
ECOLNET Training Approach
Brexit means Brexit? Divided UK, Divided City
Introductions… Who am I? Why am I here?. Programme Leaders Developing Academic Leadership and Innovative Practice.
Student QEP Workshop Developing Student Engagement in Quality Assurance and Enhancement Student/Staff Strategic Analysis Session Eve Lewis Director.
Ulrich’s model of HR.
25 years of EIA System (UK) Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats Urmila Jha Thakur.
European social dialogue A new start for social dialogue
What is Necessary to Ensure Natural Justice in EIA Decision-making?
IA and the development of green spaces for health
How Health Impact Assessment (HIA) equips the public health workforce to collaborate in addressing health inequalities. Presenter– Lee Parry-Williams –
EIA TRAINING RESOURCE MANUAL FOR SOUTH EASTERN EUROPE
European TRAINING FOUNDATION
Internal Quality Assurance in Higher Education in Europe
So you want to be an Ecologist or Environmental Manager?
The Potential Implications of Brexit for Cross-Border Bodies
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
EUPAN DG-Troika 3rd May 2007, Berlin Medium-Term Programme (MTP)
Overview Issues in the UK aquaculture sector – salmon and trout industries, regulators and government – are not dissimilar to those which concern European.
Role & Relevance of Cochrane UK to trainees
The Well-being of Future Generations Act
EC approach towards financing infrastructure projects Dagmar KALJARIKOVÁ Policy Officer for Turkey, Montenegro, REC CEE and NGOs Unit for Enlargement.
Leadership in HIA and health in EA (?)
HIA Leadership Provided by PHW
Governor Visits to School
IA Leadership provided by the Netherlands’ EA Commission
Plan your journey.
REFIT Platform 20/02/2019 Diversity Europe Group.
Fitness Check EU Water Policy
Evaluation of Second Interregional Meeting on South-South Cooperation
ECOLNET Training Approach
Transformation of the National Statistical System: Experience
Finalisation of study report
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Finalisation of study report
Presentation transcript:

Leadership in Impact Assessment – An international symposium FOTHERGILL Training & Consulting The Higher Education Innovation Fund (HEIF)

WELCOME AND HOUSE-KEEPING Thomas Fischer - Josh Fothergill 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

OPENING THOUGHTS Umrah Mahadik 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

OPENING THOUGHTS Topical – in a country in which leadership is more urgently needed now than probably over more than the last half century United Kingdom Over 450 people viewing the announcement to this event on my personal blog – by far the largest number of views I have received for an announcement like this on my blog… 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Original Idea There is uncertainty with regards to the future of IA IA is under pressure in the current post-factual era, where wishful thinking is frequently stronger than evidence and facts (1+1=3) 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Original Idea ‘Leadership’ is of crucial importance for an instrument that aims at transparency and balance Internationally, leadership is provided through different means and bodies – a few of those representing them are here today... In the UK, leadership has been provided in different ways: EU, UK and governments of devolved administrations (e.g. SEA in Scotland, HIA in Wales, England and NI?) Professional bodies; IEMA (formerly IEA) Consultancies and universities IAIA Ireland-UK branch? 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Original Idea Whilst over 50 HE institutions in the UK offer e.g. EA related degree programmes, less than a handful are active in associated research and outreach, including e.g. organising events like this Recent Liverpool EAM Research Centre events Leadership in IA Implications of Brexit for environmental assessment in the UK Reuniting planning and health – the role of impact assessment Guidance for more effective SEA 25 years of the EIA Directive 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Objectives To look at and understand different ways to providing IA (and instrument under threat) leadership internationally To discuss whether we currently have sufficient and / or the right type of leadership and what type of leadership may be needed in particular 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Participants… Private sector / consultancies Public sector / authorities Universities Others 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Participants… UK Other European Non-European 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Participants… HIA SEA, SA and EIA SIA TIA Other 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Acknowledgements Industrial Strategy Higher Education Innovation Fund Raymond Hung Shiu Fung Speakers Colleagues from the EAMRC You… 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 1 ‘Autocratic’ leadership: resulting in detailed instructions on what to do and how to do it (e.g. through detailed legislation and guidance) with little space provided to go above set requirements 2 ‘Transformational’ leadership: continuously pushing thinking and practice outside the comfort zone in order to go beyond established (through e.g. guidelines) practices 3 ‘Democratic’ leadership: considering opinions of different experts / leaders in their fields and on that basis to continuously developing IA further to achieve best practice 4 ‘Laissez faire’ leadership: leaving the decisions on ‘how to do it’ to the ‘community’ and providing minimum guidance; the focus may be on e.g. providing a platform for the community to discuss relevant issues) 5 ‘Transactional’ leadership: setting clear roles and tasks and rewards those that fulfill them best; e.g. through accreditation 6 ‘Bureaucratic’ leadership, going by ‘the books’; listening and considering the input of experts; but rejecting an input if it conflicts with policy or past practices. 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 54 respondents (16 from UK) 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 54 respondents (16 from UK) 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 54 respondents (16 from UK) 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 54 respondents 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 56 respondents UK Elsewhere 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

Questionnaire 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

15 January 2019 Leadership in IA

The day 10:30 REGISTRATION, TEA AND COFFEE 11:00 Welcome, introduction to the day and aims of the symposium; presentation of results of ‘leadership in IA’ survey; Thomas Fischer and Josh Fothergill 11:25 Rob Verheem: EA Leadership provided by the Netherlands’ EA Commission; Q&A 11:45 Liz Green: HIA Leadership provided by Public Health Wales; Q&A 12:05 Charlotta Faith-Ell: IA Leadership provided by a consultancy – the case of Sweden; Q&A 12:25 Francois Retief: IA Leadership provided by an affiliate of an international association – the case of IAIA South Africa; Q&A 12:45 Ellen Schwaller: The Society of Practitioners of HIA – a brief introduction 12:50 comments from the audience 13:00 LUNCH 14:00 Joachim Hartlik: EA Leadership provided by a membership-based organization – the case of Germany; Q&A 14:20 Elaine McCall: EA Leadership by a devolved government – the case of Scotland; Q&A 14:40 Julia Nowacki: IA leadership by a UN organisation – the case of the WHO European region; Q&A 15:00 Mark King: IA leadership by development banks – reflecting on experiences with the World Bank and the EBRD, Q&A 15:20 comments from the audience 15:40 TEA/COFFEE and Group work: what leadership do we have and what is currently missing (UK and different IA instruments or sectors overall) 16:50 Groups feeding back on main points 17:20 Conclusions of the day (Josh Fothergill and Thomas Fischer) 17:30 CLOSE 15 January 2019 Leadership in IA