Options for TGaa Proposal Selection Procedures

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: Title: IEEE Down Selection Process Date Submitted: January 18, 2005.

Advertisements

1 Introduction to IEEE Standardization Hang Liu. 2 IEEE Standard Association [1] Standards Activities Board CSMA/CD Ethernet Token Passing.

Submission doc.: IEEE /0924r0 July 2015 Sean Coffey, RealtekSlide 1 Straw polls on preferred ways forward in 11ah Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0707r0 Submission May 2011 Minyoung Park, Intel Corp.Slide 1 Overview on TGah Specification Framework Development Date:

Doc.: IEEE /0024r0 Submission February 2010 Päivi Ruuska, NokiaSlide 1 Process Considerations Notice: This document has been prepared to assist.

Doc.: IEEE /1253r0 Submission September 2014 Yunsong Yang, HuaweiSlide 1 Extending CAG Number Concept Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /XXXr0 Submission March, 2004 Matthew Sherman, BAE Systems Slide 1 LMSC Policy and Procedures Update Date: March 18 th, 2005 Author:

Doc.: IEEE /0618r1 Submission July 2005 Eleanor Hepworth, Siemens Roke ManorSlide 1 TGu Down Selection Procedure Notice: This document has been.

TGn Chair’s Status Update

A Proposed Timeline for IEEE ba TG

IEEE 802 JTC1 Standing Committee Proposal for SC6 contribution process

IEEE TGa Project Timeline

IEEE TGw March Agenda Date: Authors: May 2008

Suggested TGu Down Selection

Towards an Improved Proposal Development Process for VHT

Towards an Improved Proposal Development Process for VHT

IEEE 802 JTC1 Standing Committee Proposal for SC6 contribution process

TGs Closing Report Date: Authors: January 2006 January 2006

TGs Process Date: Authors: November 2005 November 2005

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 Jan 2010

TGaf Waikoloa Closing Report

Light Communications Task Group BB Progress Document

TGs Process Date: Authors: September 2005 September 2005

TGv redline between Draft 1.0 and 1.01

doc.: IEEE <doc#>

EDCA Enhancement to Improve Link Reliability for Multicast Streams

– Proposed change to Operations Manual – access to members area

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 March 2009

doc.: IEEE <doc#>

TGn Chair’s Status Update

IEEE TGaf Orlando Closing Report

IEEE White Space Radio Draft Development Procedure

TGn Closing Report – November 05

TGw Selection Process Date: 19 July 2005 Authors: July 2005 Month Year

Proposed TGv Selection Process

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 May 2010

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 March 2009

IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN:

TGn LB97 Frame Format Ad Hoc

TGaq Protocol Name Date: Authors: March 2014 March 2014

TGn PSMP Adhoc Group Dallas Opening report

TGaf Waikoloa Closing Report

Proposal for TGac Selection Procedure

TGu Motions Authors: March 2010 Date: March 2010

IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN:

TGn Selection Procedure Straw Polls

IEEE SGa Project Timeline

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 May 2010

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 Mar 2010

802.11ax Spec Development Process Proposal

IEEE 802 JTC1 Standing Committee Proposal for SC6 contribution process

Proposed TGv Selection Process

TGba November 2017 Closing Report

TGba September 2017 Closing Report

Spec Framework Decision Process Alternatives

TGu Motions Authors: January 2010 Date: January 2010

802.11s motion Date: Authors: November 2007 Month Year

WG Editor’s Meeting (Mar ‘10)

TG 1 November Session Opening Report

TGw Selection Process Date: 19 July 2005 Authors: July 2005 Month Year

EHT SG formation Motion

TGu Draft Revision Procedure

EHT SG formation Motion

TG ax DSC derived CCAeff and OBSS_PD

TGu Down Selection Procedure

TGs March Mid-Week Report

E911 Bits Date: Authors: May 2007 Month Year

September 2008 doc.: IEEE /1003r0 Sep 2010

Selection Procedure Recommendation

80 MHz Channelization Date: Authors: July 2010 Month Year

Presentation transcript:

Options for TGaa Proposal Selection Procedures November 2007 4/4/2019May 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2752r1 Options for TGaa Proposal Selection Procedures Date: 2008-11-10 Authors: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al Peter Ecclesine, Cisco Systems

November 2007 4/4/2019May 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2752r1 Abstract This contribution tries to initiate discussions on the procedures that the IEEE 802.11aa Task Group will follow for selecting the proposals. Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al Peter Ecclesine, Cisco Systems

Etiquette It is nice if the consensus can be achieved on a proposal through discussions without a vote However, in reality, this may not always be true. It is important that All members respect all opinions during the discussion of the proposals and are open minded to work with others to enhance proposals via harmonization and merger according to the best technical solutions. The selection procedures Several options Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al

Option 1 Similar to the ones used by TGs, TGn, etc. 1st round proposal presentations and voting Yes Similar to the ones used by TGs, TGn, etc. Out Bottom 25%? No 2st round proposal presentations and voting No Out Support Votes >= 50%? Yes 3st round proposal presentations (normally 2 or 3 merged full proposals left) No Out Most supported proposal? Yes Final two or three most popular proposals come back, compete and merge One winning proposal No Confirmation vote on the final proposal as baseline draft (>=75%)? Yes Baseline specification requires 75% or greater approval Baseline document Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al

Option 2 Similar to the ones used by 802.16 Define a baseline ToC according to PAR scope and requirements documents Present the partial proposal + proposed text No Out Support Votes >= 75%? Yes Incorporate into the baseline Baseline specification requires 75% or greater approval Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al

Straw Poll 1 Would you prefer that TGaa adopts a selection procedure similar to Option 1 that is described in document IEEE 802.11-08/1341r0? Yes: No: Abstain: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al

Straw Poll 2 Would you prefer that TGaa adopts a selection procedure similar to Option 2 that is described in document IEEE 802.11-08/1341r0? Yes: No: Abstain: Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al

Thank You! Questions? Hang Liu (Thomson Inc) et. al