Bellringer Jan 22: IN your NOTES, decide where you are after reading and analyzing SeaWorld’s rebuttal. Do you agree with the film? Do you agree with SeaWorld? Do you agree with parts of the film and/or parts of the rebuttal? Briefly explain why.
Discussion in small groups In your small groups, address the lesson question. How do we determine the truth when storytellers manipulate the way the story is told? 1st determine what are the “FACTS” that the film presents. Example – Dawn Brancheau died on Feb. 24, 2010. 2nd determine what are the opinions the film relies on as part of its argument. Example – Samantha Berg believes the whales should be set free or placed in an ocean “tank” 3rd determine how Cowperthwaite manipulated our viewing of her story (Blackfish is her story)
Discussion in small groups What rhetorical device swayed you the most? Why? What rhetorical device was the “weak link”? Why? How does SeaWorld’s rebuttal influence your opinion (you can’t dismiss them outright because you hate billion dollar corporations in general – that would be a hasty generalization on your part)
Short class due to half day.