Electricity Markets A Consumer perspective Liechtenstein Palace conference, Prag September 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
COPENHAGEN – KEY TO CLIMATE INVESTING
Advertisements

A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies Marten Westrup
The challenge in UK power generation Steve Riley, Executive Director, Europe London, 3 December 2010.
Dokumentname > Folie 1 > Vortrag > Autor Potentials for Renewables in Europe Wolfram Krewitt DLR Institute of Technical Thermodynamics Systems.
Basic Project Meeting – 17-18/02/ Beijing Irreversibility in infrastructures of emerging countries Implication for climate.
Agenda Item 8.4: Trade and the crisis Infrastructure: Recent developments and outlook for traffic flows and capacities.
DG Energy and Transport, European Commission Fabrizio Barbaso 16/04/2008 EU ENERGY SECURITY STRATEGIES ARF Energy Security Seminar EUROPEAN COMMISSION.
Pakistans Power Sector Need for Reforms By Kalim A. Siddiqui President-Petroleum Marketing Byco Petroleum Paksitan Limited 4 th International Power Generation.
Forschungszentrum Jülich in der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft IEF – Systems Analysis and Technology Evaluation (STE) J.-F. Hake Facing the truth: EU energy policy.
European Commission: Environment Directorate General Slide: 1 Linking sustainable energy use to regional economic development Open days 2006 Erik Tang.
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY AGENCE INTERNATIONALE DE LENERGIE Energy Technology Policy Progress and Way Forward Fridtjof Unander Energy Technology Policy.
Leaders in the design, implementation and operation of markets for electricity, gas and water. Portfolio Generation Investment Under Uncertainty Michael.
R&D 1 Demand Response and Pricing in France EDFs experience New regulation Main goals 10/11 th April 2007.
JT 1 Support schemes for renewable energy in the Nordic countries Jouni Tolonen.
Renewable Energy Workshop 2012 Global Market Impacts on Wind and PV Technologies A Presentation to the Bucknell University Renewable Energy Workshop –
31 Mount Pleasant, London WC1X 0AD UK Tel Fax LONDON | BEIJING | PHILADELPHIA | WASHINGTON The Energy.
The Single Electricity Market in Ireland
PERSPECTIVES OF THE COMMON BALTIC ELECTRICITY MARKET Prof. Inna Steinbuka, Chair, Public Utilities Commission, Latvia The Institute of Economic Affairs.
Update on the power situation in Asia Edgar van der Meer Energy Analyst June 21, th World Chlor-Alkali Conference.
Implementing a Realistic Climate Change Strategy Hans Konow Canadian Electricity Association April 03, 2003.
© Vattenfall AB The Swedish Power Market Presented for Invest in Sweden Agency and Sun Microsystems Stockholm 20 March, 2009 Sandra Grauers Nilsson, Vattenfall.
Climate Change Mitigation in Developing Countries: South Africa Prepared for the Pew Center on Global Climate Change by Ogunlade.
Market4RES –the policy framework
28 th of February, Romanian Power System – the right time to act Ph.D.(Eng) Carmencita CONSTANTIN, Director of Energy & Environment Strategies.
Energy. oil and natural gas  supply 62% all energy consumed worldwide  how to transition to new sources?  use until mc of further use exceeds mc of.
Beijing | Brussels | London Global Overview of New Markets Steve Sawyer, Secretary General EWEA Vienna, 6 Feb 2013.
Energy in the Middle East John Ridgway.  Global Energy Outlook  Middle East Outlook Safety of our people – Protection of the environment Agenda.
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY World Energy Outlook 2004: Key Trends and Challenges Marco Baroni Energy Analyst Economic Analysis Division INTERNATIONAL HYDROGEN.
© OECD/IEA POWER SECTOR OUTLOOK IN OECD COUNTRIES 28 May 2010 Roundtable: Russian Federal Tariff Service Ian Cronshaw, Head, Energy Diversification.
© OECD/IEA NATURAL GAS MARKET REVIEW 2006 Towards a Global Gas Market TOWARDS A GLOBAL GAS MARKET APEx CONFERENCE, Seoul 31 October 2006 Session.
Copenhagen 29 June Energy and climate outlook: Renewables in a world and European perspective Peter Russ.
© OECD/IEA 2011 COAL AND CHINA’S CHOICES Jonathan Sinton China Program Manager International Energy Agency Washington, D.C., 12 January 2011.
The outlook for electricity in Western Europe
Charting the Upsurge in Hydropower Development 2015
Uib.no UNIVERSITY OF BERGEN Development of Energy law Legal Challenges Professor Ernst Nordtveit Faculty of Law Insert «Academic unit» on every page: 1.
Energy: Responsibility for the Future Vujica Lazovic, PhD 5 th VIENNA ECONOMIC FORUM Investment Possibilities in The Countries from The Adriatic to The.
Dr. Fatih Birol Chief Economist Head, Economic Analysis Division International Energy Agency / OECD WORLD ENERGY INVESTMENT OUTLOOK.
Wind power suppliers’ challenge to meet utility standards …or conservative utilities ability to understand wind power? May 2007.
WIND ENERGY Is there a Latvian Master Plan? CHRISTIAN KJÆR Chief Executive Officer European Wind Energy Association SSE Riga, 4 December 2008 © EWEA/L.
THE CHALLENGES OF EUROPEAN ENERGY SECURITY Jiří Feist, CEZ Group.
Panel on Water, Food and Energy Overview of the Water & Energy issues and their linkages with food Richard Taylor, Executive Director, International Hydropower.
Electricity Supply in the New Century Dr Malcolm Kennedy Chairman PB Power Ltd including the power businesses of Merz and McLellan and Kennedy & Donkin.
ESPON Project TERRITORIAL TRENDS OF ENERGY SERVICES AND NETWORKS AND TERRITORIAL IMPACT OF EU ENERGY POLICY Álvaro Martins/Luís Centeno CEEETA Research.
Future Energy Insights and Nuclear Power Mark Howells, Professor and head of the division of Energy Systems Analysis (KTH-dESA) Royal Institute of Technology,
© OECD/IEA NATURAL GAS MARKEREVIEW 2008 Gas and the Sustainability Drive: what will it do the fuel mix? Ian Cronshaw, Head of Energy Diversification.
BG Group Managing Risks and Seizing Opportunities for Local Companies in the Oil & Gas Sector pre-UNCTAD XI Perspectives for the Gas Sector in Brazil Luiz.
1 Macroeconomic Impacts of EU Climate Policy in AIECE November 5, 2008 Olavi Rantala - Paavo Suni The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy.
ENTSO-E’s Network Development Plans and Network Codes: How a strong European grid supports security of supply, affordable electricity prices through market.
Technologies of Climate Change Mitigation Climate Parliament Forum, May 26, 2011 Prof. Dr. Thomas Bruckner Institute for Infrastructure and Resources Management.
The need for a European gas index 14 th Nov 2008 Dominique Venet Executive VP Gas.
6, rue du Général Clergerie Paris – France Tel: +33-(0) Fax: ~ Michel COLOMBIER IDDRI Paris Impacts and Adaptation.
World Energy Outlook 2006 Scenarios for the World and the European Union Presentation to European Wind Energy Conference Milan, Italy, 7-10 May 2007.
Washington Coal Club May 14, 2008 Carl O. Bauer, Director Coping with Competing Energy Strategy Directions Office of Fossil Energy National Energy Technology.
Keeping the door open for a two-degree world (Climate, Renewables and Coal) Philippe Benoit Head of Environment and Energy Efficiency Division International.
IFIEC Europe International Federation of Industrial Energy Consumers 1 Promotion of Renewable Energies in the EU Member States Consequences on the Price.
© OECD/IEA 2011 Energy Efficiency in Central Asia: Challenges and Opportunities VII KAZENERGY EURASIAN FORUM World in Transition Shaping Sustainable Energy.
ENERGY SECURITY AND ENERGY UNION PERSPECTIVES FOR COUNTRY October/20/2015 CSF, Brussels BETTER RESEARCH, BETTER POLICY, BETTER REFORM
Energy Transformation for Green Growth Pathways for Sustainable Energy Security to Power India’s Economic Growth 29 August 2015, Kolkata.
Energy Sector of Turkey “General Overview and Policy Objectives” Sinem ÇAYNAK General Directorate for Energy Affairs IEA Turkey IDR Meeting December 8,
1 Energy Security Global Issues Seminar Series November 8 th 2006.
ГММ -1( а ) Li Jianfei. By 2040, the world and, in particular, countries which have large and technologically advanced economies – such as the USA,
© OECD/IEA 2016 The global energy outlook and what it means for Portugal Dr. Fatih Birol Executive Director, International Energy Agency Portugal IDR launch.
World Energy and Environmental Outlook to 2030
NS4960 Spring Term 2017 Korea: Energy Policy
International Renewable Energy Agency
NS4960 Spring Term 2018 Korea: Energy Policy
NS4960 Spring Term, 2018 China: Expanded Renewables
European Power Markets: Performance and Prospects
Context of the Roadmap 2050 and WEO-2010 for Europe
Jim Mcintosh Director, Executive Operations Advisor California ISO
Presentation transcript:

Electricity Markets A Consumer perspective Liechtenstein Palace conference, Prag September 2008

Liechtenstein conference1 Contents 1.Global Electricity outlook 2.Overview of Europe situation 3.ArcelorMittal & electricity 4.Conclusion

Liechtenstein conference2 Clear Shift towards much hardest times of Energy scarcity The age of abundance is over : Competition for energy sources becomes fierce. No more easy sources : Low hanging fruits are gone, we have to deal with huge investments to keep up with ever-growing demand and to cope with years of underinvestment. Diversification of energy sources is becoming pivotal, both to guarantee energy security and to mitigate costs. Need for consolidation to create entities with the necessary resources and clout to cope with the projects and investments needed. Sources: IEA, GBN Economy Supply /Demand Policies ? Environm ent & Energy policies Unsustainable shift towards developing nations. More disruption in supplies. Political conflicts increase and under-investment remains Delayed shifts until weather-related and geo-political events take place. Stringent regulations emerge to control investment and energy choices $ ? Prices fluctuate abnormally. Supply shocks cause price spikes and LT uncertainty Energy prices Cheap & abundant energy times are gone With developing countries emergence and older economies renewal needs Energy complex is heading towards the « long road » scenario Leading to long term uncertainty

Liechtenstein conference3 On worldwide scale, a booming demand… Electricity demand rises in every region, following population and economic growth Demand in developing countries grows twice as fast as in developed ones In the long term, the developed world is no longer the driver of power demand. Emerging economies take the lead and take part in key decisions such as technology choices Sources: Exxon, IEA, Alstom Exxon, 2007

Liechtenstein conference4 … Which means big challenges ahead for supply : new capacity to be installed by 2030 > existing one period will define the shape of the power industry for the decades ahead Especially in developing regions, where the sector is expanding In industrialized regions, enormous replacement needs for retiring plants Enormous investments will be needed More capacities will be constructed in the period than exist today, about GW According to the graphs on the right, about 80% of the capacities reaching 40years are being replaced. The rest accounts for long-life assets (hydro, nuclear) Sources: Alstom, Exxon, IEA ~1500 GW

Liechtenstein conference5 Interest in nuclear power is rising around the world Based on favorable economic and low CO2 impact Fuel resource is abundant when compared to fossil fuels and accounts for a modest part of total cost (<10%) Safety issues are a major concern. Come back of Nuclear Energy in the last years Nuclear: A revival ahead? Sources: IEA, Vattenfall, CitiGroup Outlook: The IEA forecasts between 14% and 42% of nuclear capacity increase by 2030 More than 200 GW of NPPs could be built around the world in the study horizon The number of decommissioned reactors is difficult to quantify, due to the possibility of reconstruction Some countries have a stated policy for nuclear phase-out (Germany, Belgium…). However, worries about security of energy supply lead to re-opening of the discussion on extension of nuclear use (UK) +42% (9% nuclear) (11.5% nuclear) 50% of planned, not realized, 25% of actual, retired NPPs are being built in many countries around the world During the last 20 years, expansion has been concentrated in Southeast Asia (China, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, India) In recent years preparations have been under way for extensive new construction also in the West In many more countries, the discussion on nuclear is initiated: South Africa, North Africa, Middle East, Italy…

Liechtenstein conference6 Contents 1.Global Electricity outlook 2.Overview of Europe situation 3.ArcelorMittal & electricity 4.Conclusion

Liechtenstein conference7 European electricity market opening Resulted in rapidly increasing prices… Upward convergence of overall wholesale electricity prices in Europe Disconnection between prices and economical fundamentals of electricity production Sudden increase in the margins of historical producers +190% Average long term price of the French park including investment needs = Green Tariff Cost of development announced by EDF for its NPP Historical operators argue having lost all their economic freedom. Indeed, to avoid a cost based discussion, only the so-called market price is taken as a reference, bringing them advantages. Evolution of year ahead base load price (/MWh)

Liechtenstein conference8 … due to market design change at the sole benefit of utilities Windfall profit has been further increased with EU-ETS LT cost based system: Electro intensive industries benefit from cost + long term prices Tendency to over-investment ( public service constraints imposed to utilities + balanced tariffs) /MWh TWh Hydraulic Coal Nuclear Gas*Fuel Capacity 2001 indicative figures for EU 15 (*): Gas used as main switching fuel Different tariff levels Ebitda Cash cost /MWh TWh Hydraulic Nuclear Gas*Fuel Additional margin from market liberalization « Market reference » alignment Short term Market based system: Electro intensive industries do no longer get access to segmented cost-based prices Power companies tend to limit their investments, therefore increasing market volatility Increasing remuneration for interruptibility 12

Liechtenstein conference9 Market organizations are more industry friendly out of Europe Australia: Pool is obligatory. Energy price: 20 to 40 /MWh Maintain of regulated tariffs in some states. Lack of investments. New-Zealand: Pool is obligatory Energy price + transport: 45 /MWh Maintain of long term contracts for industrials. CO 2 : no market, ratified the Kyoto Protocol South Africa: Failure of wholesale market > set up of a single-buyer system Energy price: 15 to 20 /MWh Regulated tariffs will be maintained Scandinavia: Pool Energy price: 30 to 50 /MWh Long term contracts + direct investments for industrials. Gradual disconnection between pool prices and fundamentals. USA: Each state chooses its market organization 18 are completely open to competition 33 did not deregulate or interrupted the process (ex: California) CO 2 : local markets, did not ratify the Kyoto protocol Canada: Each province chooses its market organization. Single buyer system in Quebec and British Colombia. CO 2 : No market, ratified the Kyoto protocol United Kingdom: Failure of the pool > set up of pseudo bilateral systems with centralization and adjustment. Energy price: 50 to 80 /MWh Pool system « Power exchange » model « Single buyer » model System depending on the States, no unique system Continental Europe: Energy price: 65 to 75 /MWh CO 2 = EU-ETS

Liechtenstein conference10 Contents 1.Global Electricity outlook 2.Overview of Europe situation 3.ArcelorMittal & electricity 4.Conclusion

Liechtenstein conference11 unit: TWh (*) 2006 figures Total Consumption 64.1 TWh ,5 Electricity: with 64 TWh/yr(*), AM consumption exceeds the production of 5 nuclear reactors With more than 50% of group consumption in Europe Electricity is key to our competitiveness

Liechtenstein conference12 ArcelorMittal specificities… Attractiveness for power plant projects On-site off gases project are big enough (up to 300 MW) Excess land on « brown field » is very attractive Long term industrial visibility Blast Furnaces relining and re-investments, gives a visibility New Major steel projects in many countries New blast furnaces in existing plants will require additional power capacities Associated power plants to be built in real Greenfield projects (India, Africa) Ability & willingness to invest whenever necessary & attractive Securing LT volume & cost

Liechtenstein conference13 Temirtau (Kazakhstan) Kriviy Rih Galati Katowice Bremen EKO Fos Gent (Cernavoda) 100 MW, (Exeltium) Dunkirk LT Contract – LT Nuclear power plant – NPP Sid Gas Plants Thermal power plant – TPP ArcelorMittal main integrated sites with off gases based assets or projects Ostrava Liege On top of Off-gases power plants, AM developped thermal assets or participates to either VPP (exeltium) or real asset (Cernavoda) consortiums Aviles Gijon

Liechtenstein conference14 …Lead to specific opportunities Synergies with on-site off gases power projects Meet both ArcelorMittal needs and new capacities search for Utilities New projects co-invested with new entrants looking for brown field Joint administrative lobbying Greenfield projects brings synergies for AM and Utilities From power plant fuel sourcing (mining…) to power production Long term partnerships developed with utilities All potential opportunities assessed Appropriate means decided on a case by case basis (VPP, JV, real asset offtake contracts…)

Liechtenstein conference15 Contents 1.Global Electricity outlook 2.Overview of Europe situation 3.ArcelorMittal & electricity 4.Conclusion

Liechtenstein conference16 Global electricity market is heading towards higher & volatile prices scenario due to high growth in emerging markets & replacement needs in OECD =>Utilities must face huge investments both in « home » country and in respective new markets AM strategy is to reach long term self sufficiency to back its industrial activity (Cost + based on long term) However, European market opening, is endangering industrial competitiveness On the short term, via price increases de-correlated from economic fundamentals On the long term, by lack of new asset investments & impossibility to sign long term contracts Clear Synergy for long term perspective between AM & utilities AM capability to invest or commit on the long term; Attractiveness of off-gases based projects; Brownfield lands availability. Conclusion