Megan Kunze, Buket Erturk, Sloan O’Malley Storie, & Tasia L. Brafford

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
April 4, 2012 Indiana Joint National Public Health Week Conference.
Advertisements

SCHOOL PSYCHOLOGISTS Helping children achieve their best. In school. At home. In life. National Association of School Psychologists.
+ Evidence Based Practice University of Utah Presented by Will Backner December 2009 Training School Psychologists to be Experts in Evidence Based Practices.
Project Aim To provide training for Early Childhood Care Providers (ECCPs) on Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) principles within the EIBI autism classroom,
Bridgeport Safe Start Initiative Update Meeting September 23, 2004 Bridgeport Holiday Inn.
+ Interventions for Ethnically Diverse Populations Chapter 7.
Creating a service Idea. Creating a service Networking / consultation Identify the need Find funding Create a project plan Business Plan.
RESULTS INTRODUCTION Laurentian_University.svgLaurentian_University.svg‎ (SVG file, nominally 500 × 87 pixels, file size: 57 KB) Screening for Developmental.
ED 315 Inclusive Practices for Students with Learning Problems Spring 2013.
The Multiethnic Placement Act of 1994 (MEPA) As Amended by the Interethnic Adoption Provisions of 1996 (IEAP)
Inclusion EI/ECSE SPR&I Training ODE Fall What do we know? Inclusion takes many different forms A single definition does not exist. DEC Position.
Covered California: Promoting Health Equity and Reducing Health Disparities Covered California Board Meeting March 21, 2013.
Special Education Resources Hello, My name is Amy Mathews and I am studying to be a special education teacher. I am presenting some valuable information.
Autism Five -Year Plan Phase II Christie Reinhardt Governor’s Council on Disabilities & Special Education.
What Is Child Find? IDEA requires that all children with disabilities (birth through twenty-one) residing in the state, including children with disabilities.
Make a Move: An Intervention to Reduce Childhood Obesity Kimberly Nerud, PhD, RN International Rural Nursing Conference Rapid City, South Dakota July 19,
EDU 564 MODULE 5(CHAPTERS 10, 11 AND 12). Chapter 10  Self Determination - many definitions and models to teach this skill -essential characteristics.
PYRAMID PLUS APPROACH: THE “WHAT’S NEW REPORT”FOR EARLY INTERVENTION COLORADO Webinar: March 3 rd, :00-1:00 pm.
Market Analysis and Target Market
Shubhangi Arora1; Eden Haverfield2; Gabriele Richard2; Susanne B
Chapter 1 Inclusive Education: An Introduction
SEN, disability and the EYFS
Chapter 5 Learning Disabilities
Building an Evidence-Based Nursing Practice
Access to Epinephrine for Self-Administration (EPI Rph)
Virginia Department of Health Staysi Blunt, Evaluator
For more information contact:
Agenda What is a high probability (high-p) request sequence?
Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University
Funding Your Child’s Education
Making it Work in Your Classroom
Kinship care for the safety, permanency, and well-being of children removed from the home for maltreatment: A Summary of a Systematic Review Erin Geary.
Culturally Adapted Social Skills Interventions:
ASQ : SE 2 Webinar.
CHAPTER 6: WORKING WITH FAMILIES OF CHILDREN WITH DISABILIES
Alessandro Andreucci, Paul Campbell, Kate Dunn
The impact of transition on health
Recommendations for Schools
Distraction Techniques during pediatric medical procedures
Rebecca Frantz, M.A., Sarah Hansen, M.A., and Buket Erturk, M.A.
RAPID RESPONSE program
The National Autism Center’s National Standards Report
OSEP Project Directors Meeting
Evidence-Based Strategies to Increase Adult Vaccination Rates Recommendations of the Task Force on Community Preventive Services Megan C. Lindley, MPH.
Education for Community Agencies
Travis Wright, Ed.D April 26, 2018
MLTSS Kristin Murphy.
Downingtown Area School District Central Office April 4, 2018
The NH Community Transport Project
Empowering Effective Implementation of Evidence-Based Practices
Attachment Dependency
The Social Investment Package (SIP) -20 February 2013
ABAB Design Ethical considerations
Lynne Kahn Kathy Hebbeler The Early Childhood Outcomes (ECO) Center
JAMA Pediatrics Journal Club Slides: Effect of Attendance of the Child in Childhood Obesity Treatment Boutelle KN, Rhee KE, Liang J, et al. Effect of attendance.
Chapter 8 Working with People
Brodhead, Cox, and Quigley (2018)
First 5 Sonoma County Triple P Implementation & Evaluation
IV-E Prevention Family First Implementation & Policy Work Group
Comprehensive Youth Services
Sloan O’Malley Storie, Sondra Stegenga, & Jane Squires
Teaching Students with Other Special Learning Needs
Genevieve Young-Southward1 Christopher Philo2 Sally-Ann Cooper3
Professor Deborah Baker
Systematic review of atopic dermatitis disease definition in studies using routinely-collected health data M.P. Dizon, A.M. Yu, R.K. Singh, J. Wan, M-M.
HOW TO ENGAGE COMMUNITY MEMBERS IN OUTCOME EVALUATION?
The Norwalk Story: How one community is using the Ages and Stages Questionnaires (ASQ®) to build a system for developmental screening for young children.
Misc Internal Validity Scenarios External Validity Construct Validity
ESSA Schoolwide 2017.
M & E Plans and Frameworks
Presentation transcript:

Megan Kunze, Buket Erturk, Sloan O’Malley Storie, & Tasia L. Brafford  Recruitment and Retention of Ethnically Diverse Participants in Early Intervention Research  Megan Kunze, Buket Erturk, Sloan O’Malley Storie, & Tasia L. Brafford Shared Moments: Generalization of Parent-Implemented Joint Attention Intervention for Young Children with Autism Introduction results Table 1. Participant Demographics Across Research Studies. There is a growing need for culturally appropriate EI/ECSE services as society becomes increasingly diverse in terms of ethnicity and socioeconomic status. Despite increasing diversity, there is a lack of research evaluating the use of evidence-based practices (EBP) with diverse populations (Huey & Polo, 2008), slowing the dissemination and validation of EBPs (Dingfelder & Mandell, 2011). In EI/ECSE, caregiver involvement is crucial (Odom & Wolery, 2003), with caregiver coaching as an essential component. Recruiting and retaining diverse participant families requires additional effort (Ratto et. al., 2016). 84% of EI articles reported recruitment strategies (n = 26) 61% of EI articles reported retention strategies (n = 19) Family SES was reported in three ways: as income (45%), descriptively (14%), or as Hollingshead index (14%). Payment offered for transportation costs in two studies. No studies reported provision of transport as a retention strategy. The majority of articles (76%) did not report or were unclear on the participant families’ home language, while 41% of the articles did not report the language in which the study was provided. Of the studies that did report family language, 21% of families spoke a language other than English and 24% of the studies provided the option to implement the study in a language other than English. Less than half (41%) of the articles used strategies to culturally adapt their intervention. However, majority of the articles did not report what strategies were used. The cumulative number of participants screened for all 29 studies included (n = 22,589), 41% met eligibility criteria (n = 9,329). Of the participants eligible, only 28% completed a research study (n = 2644). The most frequently used interventions were Parent-child Interaction Therapy (n = 5) and Behavioral Parent Training (n = 3). IOA of 72.02% across all variables for 34% of articles. Figure 1. Number of reported reasons of drop out in the reviewed studies. Research questions 1. What strategies have researchers reported to recruit and retain ethnically and economically diverse participants in caregiver education and coaching targeting young children with, or at risk for, disabilities and their families?  2. Are there opportunities for cross fertilization from recruitment and retention strategies used in disruptive behavior caregiver intervention research to improve recruitment and retention of families in autism/developmental disability caregiver training research?  Note. Percentage of studies indicates the ratio of studies reporting at least one participant in the specific category in relation to the total number of studies (n = 29). Low- or under-resourced status determined by authors’ description or an income of $20,000 or below. Figure 2. Number of cultural adaptation strategies in the reviewed studies. Discussion Method Table 2. Retention and Recruitment Strategies Reported in Reviewed Studies. It has become common practice to report on the recruitment of participants in research, though similar weight has not been provided on retention of these participants. The discrepancy between number of families screened and number of families meeting criteria is high. The difference in the number of those families who consent and who complete a study is even greater. Is research meeting needs of larger population concerns and issues? Various retention strategies are reported, but not identified as culturally adapted. Could particular retention strategies lead to lower drop out rates? Consistency in reporting the demographic characteristics would allow for interpretation across studies on the utility of an intervention for a specific population. Should a particular reporting measure be recommended? Consideration for length, intensity and response effort of interventions may impact retention. Could intervention length and response effort correlate to drop out and retention? Systematic review of literature was conducted through electronic data bases (i.e., PsycInfo, MedLine). Inclusion criteria were: Published between 2011-2016 Parent training/coaching in behavioral interventions for at least one participant with, or at risk for, disabilities between the ages of zero to 8 Experimental or quasi-experimental design Publication in an English language peer-reviewed journal in the U.S. Behavioral intervention: Demonstration of a functional relation between the manipulated events and a reliable change in some measureable dimension of the target behavior. The behavior of interest must be a behavior in need of improvement, directly observed and clearly defined (Cooper, Heron, & Heward, 2007). Diversity: Gibson (1991) “subordinate position in a multiethnic society, suffering from the disabilities of prejudice and discrimination, and maintaining a separate group identity (p. 358).   Retention Strategies Recruitment Strategies Money or gift cards Free services or childcare Educational materials Flexible scheduling Reminders Not reported School 8 3 2 1 Direct referral Community agencies or setting 5 Physicians or service providers 4 Flyers or mailings 6 Workshops or open house Self-referral Trusted person Word-of-mouth Radio or newspaper University clinic or faculty Online or social media Child Protective Services Note. Cells include the number of studies reporting the corresponding retention and recruitment strategies. Free services included therapy, motivational interviewing, or childcare. This poster developed as part of larger project, with all authors contributing equally: Machalicek, W., Storie, S. O., Brafford, T. L., Erturk, B., Kunze, M., Drew, C., Douglas, A., Crowe, B., Glugatch, L., & Magaña, S. (in preparation). Recruitment of ethnically diverse participants in autism intervention research: A cross over review from public health.