Ecological Fallacy Podcast Prepared and Presented by Valarie Troya and Sean Swanepoel.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Question of Causation YMS3e 4.3:Establishing Causation AP Statistics Mr. Molesky.
Advertisements

Sampling Design Corresponds to Chapter 2 in Triola
Random Assignment Experiments
Economic Methodology1 ECONOMIC METHODOLOGY ECO 2023 Principles of Economics Dr. McCaleb.
CONCEPTS UNDERLYING STUDY DESIGN
Research Methods: How We Do Psychology Forming and Testing Hypotheses Theory Integrated set of principles that explain and predict observed events Hypotheses.
Psychology: A Modular Approach to Mind and Behavior, Tenth Edition, Dennis Coon Appendix Appendix: Behavioral Statistics.
Table of Contents Exit Appendix Behavioral Statistics.
Chapter 4: Designing Studies
Aim: How do we establish causation?
Culture and psychological knowledge: A Recap
MA 102 Statistical Controversies Friday, March 22, 2002 Today: Chapter 15 More on Correlation Regression Causation Reading : None new Exercises: 15.1,
Introduction to Statistics
Exam 1 Review GOVT 120.
Chapter 4 Research Design.
Objective: To test claims about inferences for two sample means, under specific conditions.
Prepared by Anas Alyamani St. Mary’s University Graduate student.
Chapter 4 Section 3 Establishing Causation
1 10. Causality and Correlation ECON 251 Research Methods.
 Correlation and regression are closely connected; however correlation does not require you to choose an explanatory variable and regression does. 
RESEARCH METHODS.
Research Strategies SurveysObservationsExperiments And other stuff…
+ Research Methods CYPA AP Psychology Review Session 2.
Elizaveta Mischerina 9 B
Research Methods in Psychology
Chapter 1 Section 3 “Modern Perspectives”
GerstmanEcological and Cross-Sectional1 Epidemiology Kept Simple Sections 11.1–11.3 Ecological & Cross-Sectional Studies.
More about Correlation
Overview of the Day Research Methods Statistical Reasoning.
Warm-Up.
© 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education The Statistical Imagination Chapter 11: Bivariate Relationships: t-test for Comparing the Means of Two Groups.
Chapter 4 Research Design. Chapter Outline Three Purposes of Research The Logic of Nomothetic Explanation Necessary and Sufficient Causes Units of Analysis.
Research Methods. Research methods Naturalistic observation (Observational) Correlational research Experimentation Comparative method Cost-Benefit analysis.
Chapter 4 Day Six Establishing Causation. Beware the post-hoc fallacy “Post hoc, ergo propter hoc.” To avoid falling for the post-hoc fallacy, assuming.
Activity! Get your heart beating! Are standing pulse rates generally higher than sitting pulse rates? We will preform two experiments to try to answer.
Cautions About Correlation and Regression Section 4.2.
Gender & Non-Gender Specific Cancer. Quick Facts On average, 386 Canadian men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer every week. On average, 407 Canadian.
The Question of Causation
Research Design Vocabulary
Psychology Research Methods. Characteristics of Good Psychological Research © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Statistics 100 Lecture Set 4. Lecture Set 4 Chapter 5 and 6 … please read Read Chapter 7 … you are responsible for all of this chapter Some suggested.
Smoking and Lung Cancer
2.7 The Question of Causation
Cautions About Correlation and Regression Section 4.2
Common Health Problem in KSA
Correlation vs. Cause and Effect Relationships
How to Lie with Statistics
Chapter 2: The Pitfalls and Potential of Spatial Data
Sociological Research Methods
Proving Causation Why do you think it was me?!.
Detecting Causal Relations
Chapter One Data Collection
Exam 1 Review GOVT 120.
Designing experiments
سرطان الثدي Breast Cancer
Persuasive Essay Outline
How can we identify a novel carcinogen?
Sociological Research Methods
Solution for Tutorial 6 We have three types of sampling procedure: Simple Random Sampling, Stratified Sampling with column totals fixed, and with row.
Sketch or describe each graph
The Experimental Method in Psychology
Therefore, the Age variable is a categorical variable.
The Question of Causation
Gender and Tobacco.
Research Design Research Methodology and Methods of Social Inquiry
Chapter 5.2 Designing Experiments
AVOID the word “causes” in
Interpreting Graphical Information
Sociological Investigation
Recent Incidences and Trends of the Top Cancers in Northeast Tennessee Appalachian Region Adekunle Oke1, Sylvester Orimaye2, Ndukwe Kalu1, Dr. Faustine.
Presentation transcript:

Ecological Fallacy Podcast Prepared and Presented by Valarie Troya and Sean Swanepoel

What is Ecological Fallacy It is a statistical relationship observed at one level of aggregation that is assumed to hold because the same relationship holds at a more detailed level. Its when a conclusion is made about individuals based only on the analysis group data..

Ecological fallacy cont. Ecological fallacy is a very common in everyday discourse because it makes explanations simple. Stereotypes are one form of ecological fallacy. In statistical terminology the equivalent term used is biased sampling

Everyone is Different.

Some examples Relating high crime rates to places that have lower incomes or composed of higher minority groups. Relating a country with more fat in their diet that have higher cases breast cancer to women in that county more likely to get breast cancer. Relating higher levels of drug use in counties with higher income to the rich are more likely to be drug addicts. Relating areas of high cigarette smoking rates and rates of death by lung cancer to smoking causing lung cancer.

What can you do to eliminate Ecological Fallacy? Say what the data reveals – No assumptions of the causes. – Correlation does not equal causation. Be aware of biases and tendencies to stereotype individuals, therefore do not make conclusions based on the correlation alone. biased sampling is avoided by using methods such as stratified sampling.