Primer on Dispute System Design

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Communication from the Commission COM(2010) 171 final Action Plan Implementing the Stockholm Programme Delivering an area of freedom, security and justice.
Advertisements

Mediating Corporate Governance Disputes An international Experts Workshop organised by the Global Corporate Governance Forum Mediation and Arbitration.
The hierarchy of courts
The View of European Business Stuart Popham 14 March 2008 Survey Results.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in American Society, the Executive Branch and the DON DON ADR Program Office.
Consumer ADR in the UK Gregory Hunt, Head of Business Relationships The Chartered Institute of Arbitrators.
Law and Institutions of International Trade Class 8 MGT 3860Z Daryl Hanak.
Implementing and Auditing Ethics Programs
Consumer Law: Protection and Compliance UCC 11 December 2014 Consumer Law: the European Agenda.
EXTRAJUDICIAL SETTLEMENT OF CONSUMERS DISPUTES IN DOMAIN OF FINANCIAL SERVICES – EU AND CROATIA Prof. Čulinović-Herc, Edita PhD University of Rijeka, Faculty.
DISPUTE RESOLUTION Collie Edgar Norman Interim Program Director Office of Dispute Resolution.
Practicing the Art of Leadership: A Problem Based Approach to Implementing the ISLLC Standards, 4e © 2013, 2009, 2005, 2001 Pearson Education, Inc. All.
1 Brief Overview of Selective Legal and Regulatory Issues in Electronic Commerce United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Geneva, 14 June 2001.
From Contract to Relationship: The Employment Relations Approach of New Zealand James Wilson, Chief of the Employment Relations Authority Craig Smith Chief.
ADR and ODR in Colorado by Cynthia A. Savage, ODR Director.
Alternative Dispute Resolution. Introduction Alternative dispute resolution is often referred to as ADR. It describes the ways that parties can settle.
European developments in judicial systems Pim Albers Special advisor of the CEPEJ Council of Europe.
HARNESSING INFORMAL CROSS BORDER COMMERCIAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISMS FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN WEST AFRICA Presented by Oluwafemi A. LADAPO (Chartered.
1 ISO WD3 ISO/TMB WG SR – ISO ISO WD3 Contributing to the development of ISO Dubai Practitioners Workshop (10 July 2007)
Building a Global Small Claims System for Cross-Border Transactions Colin Rule (Director of Online Dispute Resolution, PayPal) Zbynek Loebl (ADR.EU / the.
E – Commerce and the Applicable Law Rules Judge Ehab Maher Elsonbaty Judge of South Sinai Court in Egypt and Visiting Scholar in the Institution for computer.
The Institutionalization of Business Ethics
ONLINE DISPUTE RESOLUTION : SOME REFLECTIONS ON LAW AND PSYCHOLOGY Workshop: Arbitration & Psychology Brunel University, London 24 May 2013 Dr Pablo Cortés.
Dispute Resolution and the Internet By John Zillmer.
Building Community Through Justice and Policing Challenging Attitudes Towards Racism and Sectarianism Seminar 21 st September 2011.
Johan Billiet Association for International Arbitration Billiet & Co November 21-22, 2013.
ODR and the Administration of Justice An Asian Perspective Emeritus Professor Mary Hiscock Bond University 10/13/20151 Fresh look at Online Dispute Resolution.
Recent developments on access to justice and mediation Rome Adam Daniel Nagy Compliance promotion, governance and legal issues, Unit A2 – Directorate.
SEMINAR ON OUT-OF-COURT DISPUTES RESOLUTION OF CONSUMER DISPUTES Belgrade, 27 th and 28 th June 2013 Sava Centar.
Seminar Out-of-court resolution of consumer disputes Sava Centar, Belgrade, June 2013 Dr Christine Riefa.
Transborder Mediation Knowledge, ethics and skills Professor Dr Nadja Alexander Australian Centre of Peace and Conflict & European University Viadrina,
11/6/2015 / 1 Electronic Commerce Branch UNCTAD - United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Overview of Selective Legal.
Marquette University Law School
A REPORT ON THE PUBLIC HEARING ON ACCESS TO JUSTICE Conducted by the ABA Standing Committee on the Delivery of Legal Services on August 10, 2002 ~Draft~
Resolution of Conflicts, Options under Mexican and Chinese Laws
EVOLUTION OF THE INTERNATIONAL LEGAL FRAMEWORK (EU & UNCITRAL) Key Incentives for the Success of ODR Schemes ODR Forum 2013 Montreal Cyberjustice Laboratory,
ICT AND ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION Knowledge Society and the Law Alberto Fortún© Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche Rome, 26 April 2004.
Dr. Martin SVATOS World Forum of Mediation Centres.
Evaluating Dispute System Design: Forms of Justice as Measures of Accountability and Impact Lisa Blomgren Amsler (formerly Bingham) Keller-Runden Professor.
Comparative Criminal Justice Systems AN INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE CHAPTER ONE Reichel.
CLOSE PROJECT OR PHASE CLOSING PROCESS GROUP PROJECT INTEGRATION MANAGEMENT.
Participatory Environmental Governance : Role of Communities in Europe and Asia Jona Razzaque Reader in Law Bristol Law School, UWE, Bristol, UK Bristol.
CJA 484 NERD Inspiring Minds CJA 484 Entire Course FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT CJA 484 Week 1 DQ 1 CJA 484 Week 1 DQ 2 CJA 484 Week 2 Individual.
Civil and business law in international trade Dr Joanna Kruczalak – Jankowska I.
AN OVERVIEW OF ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR) MECHANISMS BY MUENI MUTUNGA.
Geert Van Hauwermeiren Workshop, Ljubljana, 13 Sept 2011
American Bar Association Section of Labor & Employment Law
PUTTING IT RIGHT – THE AJTC’S STRATEGIC APPROACH TO DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Contextualizing International Voluntary Guidelines into Country Specific Land Investment Governance Systems: Experience from Tanzania Wilbard Mkama.
The Institutionalization of Business Ethics
First Impressions and an Ethical Foundation
Ethical Issues in Health
Multilateral reform of ISDS: Possible paths forward
Cambodia’s New Environment and Natural Resources Code
Consumer protection in eCommerce
Preparing for Negotiation & Drafting Business Contracts
A comparative study in Saudi Arabia and China
in the Context of National Food Security
INTRODUCTION INTO PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
The integrated Classroom and the role of the educator
Why updating our Memorandum? Context
Alternative Dispute Resolution AGF 420
The European Consumer Centres Network (ECC-Net)
Corporate Governance It is a system by which companies are managed and directed in the best interests of the owners and shareholders. It refers to the.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in American Society, the Executive Branch and the DON DON ADR Program Office.
Online Dispute Resolution The State of the Art.
Developing the power sector in Federal Nepal Main lessons from international experience Kathmandu, November 06, 2018.
Outline Background: development of the Commission’s position
Mediation Law in Austria
DRAFT ISO 10008:2013 Overview Customer satisfaction — Guidelines for business-to-consumer electronic commerce transactions ISO/TC176 TG 01.
Presentation transcript:

Primer on Dispute System Design Janet Martinez 23 June 2018

Dispute System Design One or more processes adopted to prevent, manage or resolve a stream of disputes connected to an organization or institution

Array of Design Contexts Public and Community Justice Court ADR Claims Facilities Community [neighborhoods, restorative justice] Conflict and the Organization Commercial: vendors/suppliers, regulators Consumers Collective Bargaining; Employment Ombuds International/Transnational States as Contracting Parties to Treaties Cross-boundary Commerce Transitional Justice

Analytic Framework GOALS PROCESSES & STRUCTURE STAKEHOLDERS Which types of conflicts does the system seek to address? What does the system designer seek to accomplish? PROCESSES & STRUCTURE Which processes are used to prevent, manage and resolve disputes? If more than one process, are they linked or integrated? What are the incentives and disincentives for using the system? What is the system’s interaction with the formal legal system? STAKEHOLDERS Who are the stakeholders? What is their relative power? How are their interests represented in the system?

Framework - continued RESOURCES SUCCESS & ACCOUNTABILITY What financial resources support the system? What human resources support the system SUCCESS & ACCOUNTABILITY How transparent is the system? Does it include an evaluation component? Is the system successful? CONTEXT & CULTURE How does the context affect its viability and success? What aspects of culture (organizational, social, national) affect the working of the system?

Possible Goals Prevent/manage/resolve Substantive outcome Efficiency/resource saving for institution and user Reputation Relationships Compliance Safety Satisfaction Public recognition Organizational improvement

Conceptions of Justice Outcomes Substantive, Distributive, Utilitarian, & Social Justice Voice and Process Control Procedural Justice Organizations Organizational, Interactional, Informational, & Interpersonal Justice Community Corrective, Retributive, Deterrent, Restorative, Transitional, Communitarian, Communicative Justice

Example: Claims Resolution Facilities Trigger Asbestos, oil spill or other tort Natural disaster Terrorist [September 11] Process Control Court, congress/parliament, special master Process Choice Fact finding Establish liability Allocation of compensation Mediate, arbitrate

Commercial: European Directive Over past 20 years EU emphasized use of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) processes to improve access to justice Commission’s 2002 Green Paper made ADR a political priority Diverse civil litigation experience across Europe 2008 Mediation Directive implemented May 2011, to cover civil, cross-border disputes (but may apply internally as well)

Example: Online dispute resolution (“ODR”) What is ODR? The use of information and communication technology to help parties prevent, manage, and resolve disputes What are current examples? Ecommerce Public disputes Administrative Tribunals Courts Cross-border UNCITRAL WG III: Technical Notes on ODR; EU Directive

Overview of Ethics in DSD What are Ethics? Norms? Guidelines? Best Practice? Ethics for Whom? Individual designer/provider organization Internal/External Individual/Team U.S./international Professional affiliations [lawyers who design?] Ethics When? Prevent, manage, resolve Phase: Assessment, Design, Implementation, Evaluation