Cannery Park Project Public Hearing Morada Area Association Presentation

Eastern San Joaquin Groundwater Management Plan “Current and historical groundwater pumping rates exceed the sustainable yield of the underlying groundwater basin on an average annual basis” “The net groundwater overdraft is estimated to be approximately 160,000 acre feet per year”

Stockton’s “Firm” Water Supplies Second Amended Agreement 20,000 AFA (From SEWD) Groundwater Basin (Per DWSP Feasibility Report) 40,000 AFA (assumes groundwater basin in balance)

Stockton’s Current Municipal Use (2002) Surface Water 40,078 acre feet Ground Water 26,975 acre feet Total Use: 67,053 acre feet

Current Excess Use Over “Firm” Supply Stockton Urban Area is now using 7,053 acre feet per year more than its “Firm” Supply, assuming Groundwater Basin is in balance (it is not)

Current Municipal Contribution to Groundwater Overdraft Total Groundwater Basin Overdraft 160,000 acre feet per year Based upon Surface Water Availability 17% Based Upon “Firm” Surface Supply 29%

Known Commitments from Groundwater Cannery Park 986 acre feet per year (per WSA) Approved and under Construction (4,342 acres) 6,950 acre feet per year Remainder of Urban Services Area (2,700 acres) 4,320 acre feet per year New Sphere of Influence (5,600 acres) 8,960 acre feet per year

Total New Commitments: 21,226 acre feet per year which must be met from Groundwater, assuming average Surface Water Availability This represents 28,279 acre feet per year in excess of “Firm Yield” of all Urban water sources This will increase Basin Groundwater Overdraft by 13% to 181,226 acre feet per year And result in Urban Area comprising 27% of basin overdraft and 8,201 acre feet per year Above stated “Firm Yield” of Urban Area groundwater

Declining Groundwater Elevations Morada Well Elevations are Currently Declining by approximately 1.4 ft per year Stockton’s Existing Water Service Commitments would cause Morada wells to decline by 1.6 feet per year This represents a total overdraft of 181,226 acre feet per year out of a total storage of 1.5 M acre feet or 8 years of storage

Eastern San Joaquin Groundwater Basin Groundwater Management Plan Objectives Maintain or enhance groundwater elevations to meet the long-term needs of groundwater users within the Groundwater Management Area Maintain or enhance groundwater quality underlying the Basin to meet the long-term needs of groundwater users within the Groundwater Management Area Approval of Cannery Park Subdivision violates the above County groundwater management policies

No New Water Supply Commitments can be Made until: Conclusions: No New Water Supply Commitments can be Made until: Groundwater Basin in Balance (Recharge = Existing Overdraft + New Withdrawals) New Supplemental Surface Water is Secured Water Supply Assessment does not comply with Requirements of SBs 610 and 221

Major Deficiencies in the WSA Analysis Relies on “paper water” (USBR New Melones Contracts) Relies on average surface water availability instead of firm or contracted supply Relies on overstated firm groundwater yield Fails to disclose basin-wide groundwater overdraft and declining water levels Fails to include in analysis impacts of all uses within service area Misstates source of water to service project

Suggested Council Action Defer Action on Cannery Park Project (items a – f) Request a complete evaluation by the Department of Water Resources, affected Water Agencies, Districts and Users to determine Adequacy of Groundwater Basin to Support Existing Uses and Proposed New Uses during normal and dry years