Preliminary analysis of presentations Arve Meisingset Telenor R&D

Comments Categorisations of ASN.1, TTCN and UML are missing Core/Some Category Rick Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram eODL       Enterprise viewpoint Information viewpoint Computational viewpoint Engineering viewpoint Technology viewpoint 15.04.2019

Open Distributed Processing Category Rick Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram eODL       Enterprise viewpoint SDL MSC URN Information viewpoint Core? SDL Computational viewpoint Core SDL eODL Engineering viewpoint Core ? MSC URN(UCM) Technology viewpoint Some? 15.04.2019

Phases Summary Core/ Some URN Core URN eODL? Core MSC URN? eODL? Core Category Rick Rele- vance Summary Core/ Some   Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram eODL       Surveying Some URN Analysis Core MSC URN eODL? Overall design Core SDL MSC URN? eODL? Detailed design Core SDL MSC eODL Implementation Core SDL MSC Validation and testing Core SDL MSC URN Intro., train. and conv. Some URN Operation and use Some eODL? 15.04.2019

Scale of granularity ? ? Summary Core/Some SDL MSC URN Core MSC eODL Category Summary Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram eODL       Module development Core ? MSC ? eODL System development Core? SDL MSC URN eODL System planning and organization Some? Interoperation plan. betw. organizat. SDL MSC Information society planning 15.04.2019

Media SDL MSC URN SDL? MSC? MSC Core SDL MSC eODL eODL Category Rick Rele- vance Amardeo Clive Daniel Bertram   SDL MSC URN eODL Alpha-gra. screens   Some?           Graphic screens   Some   SDL?         Reports   Some      MSC?       Databases   Some?           Telecom. lines   Some    MSC         Interoperation between processes   Core   SDL    MSC     eODL   15.04.2019

Application areas and Usages Category Rick Rele- vance Amardeo Clive Daniel Bertram   SDL MSC URN eODL Data oriented approach   Core?         eODL   Process oriented approach   Core   SDL    MSC   URN   eODL   End user help   ?           Application software development Core     SDL  MSC     URN   eODL   Application software management   Some?         eODL   Tool development   ?           15.04.2019

Language categories ? Summary Core/Some SDL MSC URN Core SDL MSC URN Category Summary Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Control flow Core SDL MSC URN Data flow Core ? MSC Precedence relations between data Transformations between data Some? ? Nesting of schemata Core? 15.04.2019

Structures and Implementations Category Summary Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Static structures Core? SDL URN eODL Behaviour Core SDL MSC URN(UCM) Abstract Some? SDL MSC URN eODL Detailed Core SDL MSC 15.04.2019

Schema types Summary Core/ Some Core eODL Core? eODL? SDL? eODL SDL Category Rick Rele- vance Summary Core/ Some   Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Layout schema Contents schema Core External terminology schema Concept schema Internal terminology schema Distribution schema Some SDL eODL Physical schema Core? eODL? System schema SDL? eODL 15.04.2019

Levels and constraints Category Summary Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Instantiation language Core SDL eODL Type language Core SDL eODL Selection, projection and union 15.04.2019

Usage granularity Summary Core/Some SDL MSC URN SDL MSC URN eODL? SDL Category Summary Core/Some   Rick Rele- vance Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Individual relative to task SDL MSC URN eODL? Individual to several tasks SDL MSC URN Office with collaborating individuals SDL MSC URN Organizations independ. of tasks URN Market segments with variations SDL MSC URN 15.04.2019

Usages: Closeness, intention, scenario and collaboration Category Rick Rele- vance   Amardeo SDL   Clive MSC   Daniel URN   Bertram       eODL Terminal users Core SDL ? ? Data users Core? Goals Core MSC? URN(GRL) eODL? Requirements Core SDL MSC URN Hands on use ? SDL Scenario language Core MSC URN(UCM) Translations between tiles ? ? Relations between tiles 15.04.2019

Summary Need more responses and validation. Some need for coordination of languages both use and mappings. The languages do not have focus on - technology - end user perspectives and use - management - data and media All the four points are essential to Telecom Operators. These conclusions may not be surprising. The Tile architecture seems to serve the role as an analysis tool, but needs better definitions and requirements, as concluded in the first workshop 15.04.2019