2018 Conference – December 5-7 THE HIDDEN REEFS Navigating the Organizational Cultures of Healthcare & Community-Based Organizations for Success National Center for Complex Health & Social Needs 2018 Conference – December 5-7 Jane Pirsig, MSW, MBA Advocate Aurora Health Alliance for Strong Families and Communities
The Cultural Web Cultural Paradigm – the set of assumptions about the organization which is held in common and taken for granted in the organization Fundamental of Strategy by G Johnson, R Whittington, and K Scholes 2012
Stories The past events and people talked about inside and outside the company. Who and what the company chooses to immortalize says a great deal about what it values, and perceives as great behavior.
Stories What reputation is communicated? Who are the heroes and villains? Do stories relate to strengths /weaknesses, success, failures, conformity, mavericks? What core beliefs do the stories reflect? What important events and personalities are flagged?
STORIES – Health Care Faith-based Legacy Technology – 1st Gamma Knife in Midwest Clinic Director rides bike through snowstorm “World Class” practitioners / patients
STORIES – Community-based Organization Founding “father/mother” is Executive Director Year closed with $1 in bank Resident sought safety in building Internal promotions
Symbols The representations of the company that can be seen, heard, or touched.
Symbols Are there particular symbols which denote organization? What status symbols are there? What language and jargon are used? What aspect of strategy are publically highlighted?
SYMBOLS – Health Care Organization Logo Scrubs, Stethoscope, RN Name Badges Clinical / medical language i.e., “frequent flyers” Strategy: Best Care Building Based
SYMBOLS – Community-based Organization Third Party Logos – United Way, COA Casual Dress, “running” shoes Private offices Donated Furniture Community / Home-based Service Provision
Power Structures The pockets of real power in the company. This may involve one or two key senior executives, a whole group of executives, or even a department. The key is that these people have the greatest amount of influence on decisions, operations, and strategic direction.
Power Structures How is power distributed in the organization? What are the core beliefs of the leaders? What are the main blockages to change? How is power used/abused? How widely spread is power? On what is power-based?
POWER STRUCTURES – Health Care Hierarchal Compliance / Regulations Board of Directors focus: governance model
POWER STRUCTURES – Community-based Organization Single, linear Practice rather than Business based Single Practitioners Board of Directors focus: Operations
Organizational Structure This includes the roles, responsibilities, and reporting relationships and unwritten lines of power and influence in organizations.
Organizational Structure How formal/informal are the structures? How flat/hierarchical are the structures? Do structures encourage collaboration / competition? How is communication delivered? How does workflow through the structure? Reporting lines?
STRUCTURE – Health Care ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE – Health Care Clinical vs. Operations Linear Workflow Efficient
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE – Community-based Organization Team-based Practice-based Multiple Funder driven Fluid
Control Systems The ways that the organization is controlled. Formal and informal ways of monitoring and supporting people within and around an organization.
Control Systems What is measured/monitored to be reported? What is rewarded / punished? What drives controls –history, strategy, external? Are controls systematic or informal? What process/procedure has strongest/weakest control?
CONTROL SYSTEMS –Health Care Productivity; number of procedures, visits Finance Compliance/Regulation Clinical Outcomes
CONTROL SYSTEMS – Community- based Organization Funder Reporting Requirements Budget “Cap” Community Perception Number of clients, activities Behavioral Outcomes
Rituals and Routines The daily behavior and actions of people that signal acceptable behavior “taken-for-grantedness” about how things should happen and can guide how people respond to issues.
Rituals & Routines Which routines are emphasized? Which would look odd if changed? What are key rituals? Informal / formal? What do training programs emphasize?
RITUALS & ROUTINES – Health Care Clinic Workflow for All EHR Documentation MD/RN Directed Focus on Body
Community-based Organization RITUALS & ROUTINES – Community-based Organization Multiple Workflows Frequent Disruptions Fluid Documentation Delayed Decision-making
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
NAVIGATION Assessment Connection Modeling Transparency & Change