Overview of the Cross-border initiatives 2018

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bruxelles, 13 February 2008 Regional Market and Cross Border Luigi de Francisci TERNA - Rete Elettrica Nazionale S.p.A.
Advertisements

Coordinated Market Coupling for GB. 2 Service Provision specified to create a GB Hub with open access to : All GB connected ICs to coordinate XB Capacity.
European Federation of Energy Traders 1 Electricity Regional Initiative Central-South Europe Region 4th Stakeholder Group meeting The Central South Region.
Deliverable I.4 Balancing (15th IG meeting, Paris, April 7th 2014)
TF EDI ETSO & ETSO TF EDI Main achievements and perspectives in information exchange for the European Electricity Market Maurizio Monti ETSO TF EDI Convener.
1 page 1 NWE Intraday - Joint TSO and PX presentation London.
France-UK-Ireland Region 1 February 2007 Written Consultation – Overview of Responses Shaun Kent – Head of European Electricity Policy, Ofgem.
Guidelines for Good Practice on Information Management and Transparency EuroPEX Comments and Suggestions Brussels, 6 th of July 2006.
CM Guidelines, Implicit Auction as a Congestion Management Method Baltic Electricity Market Mini-Forum 24 April 2009 Jyrki Uusitalo, Fingrid Oyj.
FR-UK-IE Regional Initiative Cross-Border Balancing Procurement State of progress SG July 2008 Jean-Philippe Paul - John Prime.
Progress with coupling FUI and CWE region
1 page 1 C O U P L E D NWE TSO Day Ahead Project NRA – TSO – PX meeting, 15 June 2011 ENTSO-E Regional Group Northwest Europe C O U P L E D.
Feedback on the SWE coupling Public Consultation Imeplementation Group meeting – 7th april 2014.
TSO Comparison Group : An Overview
Deliverable I.4 Cross-border balancing model among TSOs -BALIT project- (7 th SG SWE, Lisbon, December 3 rd 2013)
Lithuanian TSO view on the Baltic electricity market development Robertas Staniulis 14th Baltic Electricity Market Mini-Forum, Riga September 21, 2012.
Smart transmission system Marián Belyuš18. April 2012 R&D Conference ČEZ Měření ČEPS, a.s.
The Market Coupling Experience in Europe Jean-François CONIL-LACOSTE CEO Powernext SA CEO EPEX Spot SE APEX 2008 Conference Session 1 - Part 3: European.
SPOC meeting: Trans European Replacement Reserve Exchange Amine Abada (RTE) 07 th Nov 2013.
FR-UK-IE Regional Initiative Cross-Border Balancing Procurement 26 Nov 2007 John Prime.
SUMMARY OF THE IG DISCUSSION PAPER ON THE BALANCING IN THE BALTICS Aistija Zubaviciute, NCC Baltic Electricity Market Mini-Forum 23rd November 2006, Vilnius.
How do CEE countries benefit from improved regional cooperation? from the Czech TSO perspective The Regional Initiatives - Progress and Prospects Joint.
Nord Pool Spot and Europe
BALANCING IN THE BALTIC REGION WG CONCLUSIONS Ingrid Arus Riga/ Baltic Mini-Fora meeting, 24 th of April 2009.
Cross border redispatching Central West Electricity Regional Energy Market Mini Forum Alain Marien 20 th of June 2006.
Agenda point 2a) Plans for handling of losses on HVDC cables in NWE day-ahead price coupling IG Meeting Copenhagen 19. September 2012.
European Commission views on intra-day and balancing markets
Cross Border TSO Balancing Procurement - a Generator/Trader Perspective Malcolm Taylor Head of Electricity Trading Association of Electricity Producers.
General support to Northern Europe ERI priorities. Urges the Northern Europe RCC to proceed – not only with - Optimizing the use of interconnectors - Transparency.
1 ELECTRICITY REGIONAL INITIATIVE BALTIC REGIONAL ELECTRICITY MARKET Dace Bite Public Utilities Commission Latvia Creating a Single European Energy Market.
BALTIC BALANCING MARKET Ingrid Arus Baltic Balancing Market Harmonisation WG meeting
SEM Regional Integration Decision Paper FUI Stakeholder Group Meeting 16 June 2010.
Nord Pool Spot update 11th Baltic Electricity Market Mini-Forum October 01, 2010 Hando Sutter, Nord Pool Spot AS.
INTEGRATION PLATFORM FOR FUI REGION November 22th, 2010 Miroslav Hašek Unicorn Systems.
Interconnector Physical Notification submissions following XBID (Cross Border Intra Day) market implementation; the cross border gate closure definition.
1 page 1 C O U P L E D NWE Day Ahead Project Update FUI IG Mtg – London 13 th September 2010 ENTSO-E Regional Group Northwest Europe C O U P L E D.
Balancing electricity market and future of the organized market in BiH
Joint Proposal for a Day Ahead Market Coupling Initiative between GB and Mainland by National Grid, RTE, ELIA and TENNET   Results of a joint study on.
Power market structure and market price development in the SEE region
EBGL implementation Organization
NORD POOL SPOT UPDATE Hando Sutter September 21st, 2012
Agenda point 2a) Plans for handling of losses on HVDC cables in NWE day-ahead price coupling IG Meeting Copenhagen 19. September 2012.
Coordinated Market Coupling for GB
Regulators’ update on Congestion Management and Balancing
Leonardo meeus & Samson Yemane Hadush
International Conference
9th FUI Stakeholder Group Meeting Dublin, 16 June 2010
Trans European Replacement Reserve Exchange
NORD POOL SPOT UPDATE Hando Sutter September 21st, 2012
PICASSO Electricity Balancing Stakeholder Group
ENTSO-E CIM implementation
Update on European Network Codes
MARI BSG Meeting Manually Activated Reserves Initiative 5 March 2018
MARI BSG Meeting Manually Activated Reserves Initiative 5 March 2018
GLEB planning 05 March 2018.
TERRE Trans European Replacement Reserves Exchange
ARP contract WG Belgian Grid –
Imbalance Netting Platform
Webinar on imbalance settlement
8th SG meeting ERI South-West Europe
Survey on Ancillary services procurement, Balancing market design 2018
Svetlana Rybina, Lauri Holopainen
Electricity and Natural Gas Markets in Serbia
Cross Border Intraday (XBID) Trading Solution Pre-launch Event
Balancing Implementation Projects
Scheme of the Algorithm for the Acceptance and Settlement of Bids in the TSO-TSO Model of AT-BE-CH-DE-FR-NL.
Scheme of the Algorithm for the Acceptance and Settlement of Bids in the TSO-TSO Model of AT-BE-CH-DE-FR-NL.
XBID – A review of our 1st year and future plans
RR Platform – Implementation Framework
Basic principles of the Trial Period (1/2)
Presentation transcript:

Overview of the Cross-border initiatives 2018 ENTSO-E WGAS March 2019 20.03.2019

Table of Contents Exchange or sharing of balancing capacity (Slides 3 - 20) Exchange of balancing energy (Slides 21 - 39) Exchange of imbalance netting (Slides 40 - 47) Page 2

Exchanges or Sharing of Balancing Capacity Part one Exchanges or Sharing of Balancing Capacity Page 3

FCR Cooperation between AT, BE, CH, DE, FR, and NL TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion, Tennet GER, TenneT TSO, APG, Swissgrid, ELIA & RTE Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? Exchange of balancing capacity (TSO-TSO cooperation) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Containment Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprocity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? N/A (if initially the same) Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information There is a common TSO-TSO Settlement scheme (same for all participants) but no harmonization for TSO-BSP Settlement. Page 4

TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Nordic TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? Exchange of balancing capacity (TSO-TSO cooperation) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Containment Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprocity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? N/A (if initially the same) Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Partially Harmonised Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 5

German Grid Control Cooperation (GCC) TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion & Tennet GER Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? Sharing of balancing capacity (TSO-TSO cooperation) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprocity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Full Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 6

Baltic Coordinated Balancing Area (COBA) TSO's involved: Elering AS, AS Augstsprieguma tīkls & LITGRID AB Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprocity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Partially Harmonised Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information  Common Baltic mFRR balancing energy market Page 7

Emergency reserves activation SO UPS, Russia Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 8

Agreement on the provision on the system service ODU Belenergo, Belarus Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 9

TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & ODU BELENERGO Agreement on provision of system services/Agreement on provision of regulation service TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & ODU BELENERGO Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 10

TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & CDU TEK Agreement on provision of system services/Agreement on provision of regulation and balancing service TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & CDU TEK Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 11

Cross Border Balancing between Ireland & GB TSO's involved: Eirgrid & National Grid Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Containment Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 12

Cross-border market for FCR: Czech Republic - Slovakia TSO's involved: ČEPS & SEPS Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? Exchange of balancing capacity (TSO-TSO cooperation) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Containment Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? No, in Slovakia ISP is 15 min. In Czech Republic ISP is 60 min. Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? N/A Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 13

Finland - Estonia TSO's involved: Elering AS & Fingrid Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? Exchange of balancing capacity (TSO-TSO cooperation) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? N/A (if initially the same) Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Using any other cross-border arrangement? Page 14

Emergency reserve activation agreement TSO's involved: Elering AS & ODU BELENERGO Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? N/A (if initially the same) Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 15

TSO's involved: NOS BIH & ELES & HOPS Agreement on common frequency control reserves in the control block SHB TSO's involved: NOS BIH & ELES & HOPS Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No Harmonisation & creation of dedicated cross-border products Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 16

TSO's involved: NOS BIH & HOPS Agreement on common frequency control reserves in the control block SHB TSO's involved: NOS BIH & HOPS Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation If Yes, Method in Use N/A Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Some Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Yes Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Joint definition of reserves Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information   Page 17

Cross Border Balancing Northern Ireland & GB TSO's involved: SONI & National Grid Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Containment Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? No harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 18

Cross-border Tertiary Regulation TSO's involved: EMS Serbia & CGES Montenegro Question Exchanges of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation If Yes, Method in Use   Level of harmonisation What is the level of Harmonisation of national or local Products? Full Harmonisation Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Yes Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Is the Imbalance Settlement Time Period harmonised? N/A (if imbalance settlement period is already the same for exchanging parties) Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 19

TSO's involved: Elia & TenneT NL Pooling of Power reserves and exchange of Control energy between TenneT and Elia TSO's involved: Elia & TenneT NL Question Sharing of Reserves Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the requesting TSO through the providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information   Page 20

Exchanges of balancing energy Part two Exchanges of balancing energy Page 21

TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Nordic TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Some Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Using any other cross-border arrangement? Page 22

TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Nordic TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Some Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 23

German Grid Control Cooperation (GCC) TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion & Tennet GER Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Full Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 24

TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion & Tennet GER, APG FRR-Cooperation TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion & Tennet GER, APG Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 25

Baltic Coordinated Balancing Area (COBA) TSO's involved: Elering AS, AS Augstsprieguma tīkls & LITGRID AB Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing  No Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? No Additional information  Common Baltic mFRR balancing energy market Page 26

Emergency reserves activation TSO's involved: AS Augstsprieguma tīkls Latvia, SO UPS Russia Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 27

Agreement on the provision on the system service TSO's involved: AS Augstsprieguma tīkls Latvia, ODU Belenergo Belarus Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 28

TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & ODU BELENERGO Agreement on provision of system services/Agreement on provision of regulation service TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & ODU BELENERGO Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged?   Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 29

TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & CDU TEK Agreement on provision of system services/Agreement on provision of regulation and balancing service TSO's involved: LITGRID AB & CDU TEK Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged?   Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 30

Cross Border Balancing between Ireland & GB TSO's involved: Eirgrid & National Grid Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Replacement Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 31

Inter-control area support with emergency reserve capacity TSO's involved: TenneT GER & TenneT Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 32

Finland - Estonia TSO's involved: Elering AS & Fingrid Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Using any other cross-border arrangement? Page 33

BALIT TSO's involved: RTE, REN, REE & National Grid Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Replacement Reserve Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? No Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 34

TSO's involved: NOS BIH & ELES & HOPS Agreement on common frequency control reserves in the control block SHB TSO's involved: NOS BIH & ELES & HOPS Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? N/A Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 35

TSO's involved: NOS BIH & HOPS Agreement on common frequency control reserves in the control block SHB TSO's involved: NOS BIH & HOPS Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? N/A Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 36

Cross Border Balancing Northern Ireland & GB TSO's involved: SONI & National Grid Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? No Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 37

Cross-border Tertiary Regulation TSO's involved: EMS Serbia & CGES Montenegro Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Yes Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 38

Mutual Energy Assistance between Elia & RTE TSO's involved: Elia & RTE Question Exchanges of manual balancing energy Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the requesting TSO through the providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Manual) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing  Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place?  No Additional information Page 39

Exchanges for Imbalance netting Part three Exchanges for Imbalance netting Page 40

Imbalance Netting Cooperation TSO's involved: APG & ELES & HOPS Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information   Page 41

TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Nordic TSO's involved: Fingrid, Energinet.dk IPC, Svenska Kraftnät & Statnett Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism?   Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Full Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 42

International Grid Control Cooperation TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion, Tennet GER, TenneT TSO, ČEPS, Elia, Energinet.dk IPC, RTE, APG & Swissgrid Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? N/A Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Yes Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? No Reserves Responsibility in sizing  Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place?  Yes Additional information There is a common TSO-TSO Settlement scheme (same for all participants) but no harmonization for TSO-BSP or TSO-BRP Settlement. Page 43

German Grid Control Cooperation (GCC) TSO's involved: 50Hertz, TransnetBW, Amprion & Tennet GER Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? Full Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 44

eGCC TSO's involved: ČEPS, SEPS & MAVIR Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Capacity reservation Cross-Border Capacity Reservation No If Yes, Method in Use No Harmonisation Level of harmonisation Reserves Are the Gate Closure Times for TSO-TSO bids harmonised? Defined separately Are the Gate Closure Times for internal markets harmonised? Additional information   Page 45

ENDK-W-Tennet Ger/ENDK-W view TSO's involved: Tennet GER & Energinet.dk IPC Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO-TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? Frequency Restoration Reserve (Automatic) Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? Yes Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? No Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing   Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information Page 46

Imbalance Netting Cooperation – BritNed Frequency Coupling Trial TSO's involved: Tennet & National Grid Question Exchanges for imbalance netting Products & Models Involved Who participates in the cross border transaction? TSO- Interconnector Owner - TSO (power request by the reserve requesting TSO through the reserve providing TSO) What products are used in the exchange mechanism? N/A Is there symmetry/reciprosity in the products exchanged? No Level of harmonisation Are the Settlement Rules harmonised? Are the imbalance pricing methods harmonised? No Harmonisation Are other items harmonised? Reserves Responsibility in sizing Defined separately Are there defined cost-sharing rules in place? Additional information   Page 47