Compensation in Urban Land Readjustment: Experiment with Game Simulation D. Ary A. Samsura Erwin van der Krabben.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Reform the Dimensions of Combating Counterfeits Abbas A. Makki Director International Relations.
Advertisements

UCA Volunteer or Participant? April The fact that someone voluntarily offers to do something, or actually does something voluntarily, does not mean.
Manuel V. Loureiro Supervisors: Paul Fischbeck (CMU) João Claro (FEUP)
American Government and Economic Systems. This is not a course about... dates, facts, and figures that must be memorized and recited, only to be forgotten.
Participation in re-allotment Marije Louwsma. 2 Cadastre, Land Registry and Mapping Agency Cables and pipelines and re-allotment.
American Free Enterprise. Land of Opportunity… American success due to: – Open land – Abundant natural resources – Talented labor supply fueled by immigrants.
Internal and External Motivation of Cooperation Mizuho SHINADA (doctoral student)
Public Outreach Efforts A Bridge to the Future of Brownfields in Delaware.
CREATING THE CONDITIONS FOR INNOVATION IN URBAN LAND ASSEMBLY: THE CASE OF LAND POOLING AND READJUSTMENT IN VIETNAM ROBIN RAJACK, HOA THI MONG PHAM, CHANDAN.
Collaboration in Local Development The Benefits 1www.nrn.ie.
Law and Economics-Charles W. Upton Why Property Rights.
Large-scale land development in Finland and in the Netherlands – comparative case study M. Sc. (Tech.) Eero Valtonen, Aalto University Prof. Erwin van.
EXAMPLE 2 Using the Cross Products Property = 40.8 m Write original proportion. Cross products property Multiply. 6.8m 6.8 = Divide.
1 C H A P T E R What Is Economics?.
Real vs. Ideal Gas Under what types of pressure do gases behave ideally? Under what type of temperatures do gases behave ideally? We originally defined.
Review for Thermal Physics Test. You need to know: How to interpret the heating curve for a substance, especially water Phase changes do not involve temperature.
Today’s Warm Up Answer on your warm up/exit ticket sheet (additional sheets are by the turn-in tray if needed) How do you think the U.S. Constitution compares.
Land in the SDGs discussion Annual World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty 24 March 2015 Washington DC.
An Analysis of Additional Building Bulk as an Incentive for Arranging Urban Renewal Projects Hsiu-yin, Ding National Chengchi University.
Population. Where would you rather live? Population There are more than 7 billion people living on the earth. This number has grown drastically since.
Participatory land consolidation Marco van Beek. 2 Why a new approach? Trends & developments:  Shift in responsibility from government to citizens 
Managing City Operations 2012 Urban Systems Symposium.
Ohio Balanced Growth Program Best Local Land Use Practices Kirby Date, AICP, Cleveland State University.
ROW, AASHTO OKLAHOMA CITY 2009 MELVYN R. COOPER REALTY OFFICER South Carolina Nonconforming Sign Upgrade/Removal (Pilot) Project.
Naam van de presentatie OTB Research Institute for Housing, Urban and Mobility Studies 1 Key players in Dutch urban renewal OTB Research Institute for.
Land Banking Breakout HUD Housing Summit October 7, 2008 Salvatore Sclafani.
Infographics: Thinking about design Infographics sessions Day 4.
Free Enterprise. American way Land of opportunity Protected by Constitutional Rights Property Rights/Taxation only by Constitution PROFIT MOTIVE- increase.
June 4, 2008 Arthur J. Harrington Godfrey & Kahn S.C Pabst/Towne Redevelopment Environmental Legal Strategies.
Tutorial: Discrimination & Disability Act Rowan Brown GPVTS ST3.
This incentive improves productivity, rewards innovation and encourages moderate risk taking Profit Motive.
Ari Meriruoko, Kainuu Finland Metsähallitus, Natural Heritage Services
Mathematics. Session Vectors -2 Session Objectives  Vector (or Cross) Product  Geometrical Representation  Properties of Vector Product  Vector Product.
American Free Enterprise Economics Chapter 3. Basic Principles of Free Enterprise Chapter 3: Section 1.
Eminent Domain: The Kelo Case and its Implications for North Carolina Richard Ducker School of Government UNC – Chapel Hill.
Successful strategies for working with Law Enforcement.
Bag Game Introduction to Economics. Set-up  Property Rights – exclusive authority to determine how a resource is used  Voluntary Exchange – no pressure.
I-394 MnPASS Enhancements: A Vision for the Future Center For Transportation Studies, University of Minnesota 19 th Annual Transportation Research Conference.
PROPERTY PLANT AND EQUIPMENT JOURNAL ENTRIES LAND WAS PURCHASED FOR $10,000 OF CASH.
RCRA 2020 Vision… A View from a Facility Owner Lloyd E. Dunlap Atlantic Richfield Company, BP.
An Introduction to the Voluntary Cleanup Program Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Environmental Trade Fair & Conference May 3, 2016 Gene Muller,
22 February 2008Felix Addor - The Views of Switzerland1 Felix Addor Deputy Director General Swiss Federal Institute of Intellectual Property, Bern Facilitating.
EQUALITY AND SOLIDARITY Section 2 of final document.
Putting It All Together: A Petroleum Brownfields Revitalization Action Plan Carolyn Hoskinson, OUST Paul Connor, NALGEP.
Shared Intellectual Property CHALLENGES OF ACADEMIA COLLABORATING WITH INDUSTRY Per Mercke and Sara Ljung.
Voluntary Exchange.
(Correlated to LCVS Educator Site Content)
Presentation Results & lessons learned of a pilot with innovation teams of professionals, to stimulate bottom-up innovation in the public sector Discuss.
Elmarie van der Schyff One for All and All for Water- Public Trusteeship and Co-operative Governance Elmarie van der Schyff.
Business Use of Home Including the Shared Economy
Chair: Edward Geoffrey Beardsall Moderator: Damir Pahić
Drafting the Code: Who drafts the code?
Ionic and Metallic Bonding
Drag laws for fluid-particle flows with particle size distribution
AM Business Model Wargame Working Team Documentation
AM Business Model Wargame Working Team Documentation
10:00.
Water Directors meeting
قوانين برگزاري مناقصات و آيين نامه مالي و معاملاتي دانشگاه علوم پزشكي و خدمات بهداشتي ،درماني تهران
Voluntary Exchange.
European action programme on
How we help you.
Electric Field The electric force is a field force, it applies force without touching (like the gravitational force) In the region around a charged object,
Wikiwijs The Dutch National OER Strategy
PROPORTIONS.
Three Things for Business Success
ITS Task Force Report Takeshi YAMAMOTO GSC16-PLEN-63 Document No:
Japan Experience on Urban Rejuvenation
VOLUNTARY ACTIONS AND AGREEMENTS
Presentation transcript:

Compensation in Urban Land Readjustment: Experiment with Game Simulation D. Ary A. Samsura Erwin van der Krabben

Urban Land Readjustment Redeveloping land in order to have more optimal reallocation by inviting all the related property/land-owners to collaborate and become stakeholders in the land redevelopment project and instigating property/land exchange.

Urban Land Readjustment Cross-compensation: to let property owners who received more value to compensate other property owners who received less value. It reduces the financial pressure on the government to assemble the land and provide public facilities and facilitates the equal sharing of the benefits and costs of a project

Experiment with Game Simulation Original Land Readjustment A and D should compensate B, C, and E

Experiment with Game Simulation Information Complete Information Incomplete Information vs. Law Voluntarily (without Law) Can be forced (with Law) vs.

Experiment with Game Simulation ULR Game Complete Information Without Law With Law Incomplete Information

Experiment with Game Simulation 70 participants: 2 sessions with 7 groups of 5

Results (Preliminary) Complete Information 2 4 5 10 7 4 14 6 4 Incomplete Information

Results (Preliminary)   COMPLETE INFORMATION Without Law With Law VOLUNTARY FORCED A 0.30 0.34 0.40 B 0.14 0.16 C D 0.29 0.25 E 0.12 0.13 0.00   INCOMPLETE INFORMATION Without Law With Law VOLUNTARY FORCED A 0.44 0.41 0.43 B 0.10 0.15 0.13 C 0.12 0.06 D 0.26 0.20 0.33 E 0.09 0.05