Three Procedural Issues for Discussion

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Doc.: IEEE /0024r0 Submission July 2004 Steve Shellhammer, Intel CorporationSlide 1 IEEE Wireless Coexistence TAG Steve Shellhammer

Advertisements

Doc.: VC1_ _r2_EC_Closing_Motions.ppt Submission 1 st Vice Chair Closing Motions Date: November 20 th, 2009 Author: Matthew Sherman 1 st Vice Chair,

IEEE mc Closing Report for March 2015

802.16p Closing Report for Session #76 [IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9.2)] Document Number: IEEE p-11/0037r1 Date Submitted:

Proposed P802.16r Activity Schedule [IEEE Mentor Presentation Template (Rev. 0)] Document Number: IEEE gcon Date Submitted:

Doc.: IEEE 802 EC-12/0004r1 Agenda February 2012 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 IEEE 802 EC Interim Telecon – Feb Date: Authors:

P802.16r Small Cell Backhaul Closing Report – Session #94 [IEEE Mentor Presentation Template (Rev. 0)] Document Number: r Date.

Page 1 Agenda and General Information IEEE > >, >

Title: LE TG Closing Report for Session #64 Document Number: h-09/0029 Date Submitted: Nov. 19, 2009 Source: Chair of LE TG: Mariana GoldhamerVoice:+972.

Doc.: IEEE /0144r01 Submission February 2015 Apurva N. Mody, BAE SystemsSlide 1 IEEE Motion at the February EC Telecon IEEE P Wireless.

Proposed P802.16s Amendment Extension Request to RevCom

Agenda and General Information

Agenda and General Information

IEEE TGmc November 2013 Agenda

NG60 SG March 2015 Agenda Date: Authors: March 2015

Proposed P802.16s Amendment Extension Request to RevCom

IMT-2020 Contribution Content

Proposal for P&P Change - #2009-1

IEEE 802 JTC1 Standing Committee formalization proposal

John D’Ambrosia Recording Secretary, IEEE 802 LMSC

Matthew B. Shoemake Task Group G Chairperson November 15, 2002

Consent Agenda Request Procedure

John D’Ambrosia Recording Secretary, IEEE 802 LMSC

Use of Industry Connections in IEEE 802

Proposed Update to Motion Templates & Other Issues

Roger Marks (Huawei) March 2018

Action Item Start of IEEE 802 Nov Plenary

IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT HANDOVER DCN: sec

Roger Marks (Huawei) May 2018

Roger Marks (Huawei) May 2018

Action Item Start of IEEE 802 Mar 2017 Plenary

IEEE Motions at the November Plenary EC Meeting

Motion IEEE Standards withdrawals to RevCom

– Proposed change to Operations Manual – access to members area

June 2015 Wireless Chairs Standing Committee Proposed Initial OM Approval Process Bob Heile, Wi-SUN Alliance.

Action Item Start of IEEE 802 Mar 2017 Plenary

IEEE Motion at the February EC Telecon

John D’Ambrosia Recording Secretary, IEEE 802 LMSC

OmniRAN EC SG Agenda May 2013, Waikoloa, HI

Agenda and General Information

TGu Agenda Date: Authors: November 2010 November 2010

Title: LE TG Closing Report for Session #63

IEEE Motion at the July EC Closing Meeting

Title: LE TG Closing Report for Session #63.5

Action Item Start of IEEE 802 Mar 2017 Plenary

IEEE Motion at the February EC Telecon

Agenda and General Information

IEEE aj Task Group September 2017 Agenda

IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks

November 2008 doc.: IEEE /1437r1 August 2010

EC Update on LMSC Policy and Procedures

Second Vice Chair Report, addressing Orientation Activity

Roger Marks (Huawei) capable 13 March 2019

TGMb – Report Date: Authors: March 2008 March 2008

<month year> <January 2019>

IEEE TGmc Sept 2012 Agenda Date: Authors:

Opening March 2006 Plenary Session #19

IEEE P Motions at the July Plenary EC Meeting

IEEE MEDIA INDEPENDENT SERVICES DCN:

November 11, 2010 Dallas, Tx Session #70

Agenda and General Information

Agenda and General Information

Motion for EC Approval to forward the draft to Revcom

1st Vice Chair Closing Motions

Agenda and General Information

IEEE P Motions at the July Plenary EC Meeting

Recording Secretary, IEEE 802 LMSC

July 2019 TG22 Spectrum Sharing Closing Report Austria Center, Vienna, Austria Apurva N. Mody Chair, TG22 Apurva Mody, BAE Systems.

July 2019 TG22 TVWS Closing Report Austria Center, Vienna, Austria Apurva Mody Chair, TG22 Apurva Mody, BAE Systems.

EHT SG Agenda Date: Authors: March 2019 January 2019

Presentation transcript:

Three Procedural Issues for Discussion Mentor DCN 802-ec-18-0233-00-00EC Three Procedural Issues for Discussion Roger Marks (EthAirNet Associates; Huawei) roger@ethair.net +1 802 227 2253 16 November 2018

Issue #1: LMSC enforcement of WG procedures Recently the EC had a case in which an LMSC motion was debated on grounds that it had not met all internal WG procedures, when the alleged failure involved a WG policy more restrictive than the LMSC policy. Is this valid grounds for the Sponsor to reject? Is the EC responsible to police WG procedures beyond LMSC requirements? This is parallel to, for example, RevCom checking to see whether a draft had received a proper WG ballot per LMSC procedures. What are the appeal issues if the EC ignored an internal WG restriction?

Issue #2: Call for Patents in non-PAR activity Many pre-PAR or non-PAR activities present the PAR slides and issue a Call for Patents. People may think this is somehow safest. In my view, this wastes time, weakens the meaningful Call for Patents, and puts an undue burden on the participants . See “Understanding Patent Issues During IEEE Standards Development” Should a Call for Patents be issued at a Study Group or other meetings that occur before approval of a Project Authorization Request (PAR)? No. However, it is recommended that the Patent Slides for pre-PAR Meetings be used in these meetings.

Issue #3: Motion Procedures for Ballots Recording Secretary maintains procedures for motions at meetings; for example, Motion template Referenced documentation must be posted at Mentor or elsewhere Not just an attachment to an email I recommend that email ballots follow the same procedures. The procedure for email ballots should be recorded in Chair’s Guidelines, or Operations Manual Procedures for motions at meetings should also be upgraded in status.