21 november 2011 Coherent geographic scales and aggregation rules in assessment and monitoring of Good Environmental Status - analysis and conceptual phase.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

26 February 2014 EU Service contract: Development of a shared data and information system between the EU and the Regional Sea Conventions (phase 1) WG.

Advertisements

Trine Christiansen European Environment Agency (EEA) Regional and EU level data streams for D5 Copenhagen, 28 April

Project Coordination Group (PCG) for the implementation of the MSFD

Guidance report: Methodology for the assessment of ecological coherence of MPA’s Henk Wolters 30 October 2014.

Coherent geographic scales and aggregation rules in assessment and monitoring of Good Environmental Status Theo Prins, Myra van der Meulen, Arjen Boon.

Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)

Marine Strategy Framework Directive:

D5 EUTROPHICATION REVIEW PROCESS

Draft Article 8 MSFD assessment guidance

Revision of Commission Decision 2010/477/EU

JRC’s Follow-up work to improve GES assessment

Project Coordination Group (PCG) for the implementation of the MSFD

D8 and D9 REVIEW PROCESS April-June 2014: February 2015:

Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)

The Marine Strategy Framework Directive

EU Service contract: Development of a shared data and information system between the EU and the Regional Sea Conventions (phase 1) WG DIKE , Brussels Deltares.

Taking forward the common understanding of Art. 8, 9 and 10 MSFD

In-Depth Assessment (IDA) of MS submissions for MSFD article 8, 9 & 10 compiled and presented by Nikolaos Zampoukas based on material provided by V.

Task 1 - Intercalibration WG 2A ECOSTAT - Intercalibration

CIS-Workshop on River Basin Management Plans

Results of breakout group

Review of Decision 2010/477/EU and MSFD Annex III

D1 BIODIVERSITY REVIEW PROCESS

Technical review of Commission Decision 2010/477/EU concerning MSFD criteria for assessing GES Work flow and progress 20/21 October th WG GES.

16 april 2009 Draft OSPAR’s MSFD Advice Manual on Biodiversity approaches to determining GES, setting of environmental targets and selecting indicators.

Technical guidance for assessment under Article 8 MSFD

Initial Assessment: reflections on structure and contents

Taking forward the common understanding of Art. 8, 9 and 10 MSFD

WG GES Workshop Art. 8 MSFD Assessment

Art. 8 MSFD assessment guidance

19th meeting of the WG GES 22/03/2018

Proposal for MSFD risk-based approach project in OSPAR region

Q1: How are the overlaps between MSFD and other EU and RSCs requirements going to be considered and coordinated? How far is the current effort contributing.

Conclusions: Parallel session 2, Group 2

Marine Strategy Framework Directive State of play and follow up

European Commission DG Environment

Draft examples of possible GES Decision criteria Descriptor 9

Methodology for Art. 12 assessment of 2018 Art updates

MSFD list of criteria elements

Action Points 16th meeting of the Working Group on

MSFD Com Dec 2010/ 477/ EU review Recommendations for D2

Meeting of the WFD CIS Working Group on Ecological Status (ECOSTAT)

Francesca M. SOMMA - EC - DG JRC MSCG Meeting – Brussels,

15th meeting of MSCG, 9 February 2015, Brussels

MSFD list of criteria elements

Information on projects

Coherent geographic scales and aggregation rules in assessment and monitoring of Good Environmental Status Theo Prins, Myra van der Meulen, Arjen Boon.

INSPIRE Development of Implementing Rules

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

Marine Strategy Framework Directive: implementation process at EU level Gert Verreet – WFD WG Reporting - 31 March 2009.

WG GES: Decision review progress

Common Understanding Way forward

Reporting units for MSFD assessments

Water Framework Directive 2000/60/EC

Common Implementation Strategy for the Water Framework Directive

Workshop Coherent geographic scales and aggregation rules in assessment and monitoring of GES GES SCALES workshop 23 October 2013.

Eutrophication activity

Scene setter European Commission DG Environment

WG GES Drafting Group June 2013 Berlin

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry

WG A ECOSTAT Draft Mandate

Review of Decision 2010/477/EU and MSFD Annex III

ICES requested to give guidance on integration

Assessment scales and aggregation

Marine Environment and Water Industry

The Marine Strategy Framework Directive

Preparatory meeting for the establishment of the Project Coordination Group (PCG) for the implementation of the MSFD 13 November :00-13:30 European.

Marine Strategy Framework Directive Strategic discussion on the future role of WG GES WG GES, 5-6 March 2013 European Commission, DG Environment, Marine.

Item 4 b) Marine Strategy Framework Directive and CIS WFD

Presentation transcript:

21 november 2011 Coherent geographic scales and aggregation rules in assessment and monitoring of Good Environmental Status - analysis and conceptual phase T.C. Prins, A. Boon, M. van der Meulen (Deltares) E. Papathanassiou, M. Simboura, C. Tsangaris (HCMR) A. Borja, O. Solaun, A. Uriarte (AZTI) A. Gilbert (IVM)

Analyse and compare national approaches per descriptor regarding geographic scales Analyse which aggregation rules have been applied Develop broad EU guidance for coherent geographic scales in assessment and monitoring of GES and for sets of aggregation rules and organize a debate with MS on this. 21 november 2011 Objectives Download the Deltares in 2 minutes film via intranet r http://orasvr02.wldelft.nl:7778/txmpub/files/?p_file_id=6695 or Deltares-website http://www.deltares.nl/xmlpages/TXP/files?p_file_id=22674

Current state of play lAnalysis of MS approaches 21 november 2011 Current state of play lAnalysis of MS approaches Electronic reporting from a limited number of MS (by mid-April) Now completed with all submissions by 30 April Aditionally, analysis of a selection of MS reports Impression so far: In general, limited specific and detailed information on geographic scaling and application of aggregation rules National expert reviews (Art. 12) may provide additional information (expected in July) Download the Deltares in 2 minutes film via intranet r http://orasvr02.wldelft.nl:7778/txmpub/files/?p_file_id=6695 or Deltares-website http://www.deltares.nl/xmlpages/TXP/files?p_file_id=22674

Current state of play lAnalysis of RSC and other approaches 21 november 2011 Current state of play lAnalysis of RSC and other approaches Inventory of current practices for geographic scaling, e.g.: HELCOM, OSPAR, ICES, WFD Methods for defining assessment units Methods for upscaling Inventory of approaches for aggregation Distinction between levels: metrics -> indicators -> criteria -> descriptors -> overall GES Inventory of existing practices within RSC’s, WFD, etc. E.g. one-out all-out, weighted averaging, decision trees, etc. Identification of requirements Pros and cons of current methods Download the Deltares in 2 minutes film via intranet r http://orasvr02.wldelft.nl:7778/txmpub/files/?p_file_id=6695 or Deltares-website http://www.deltares.nl/xmlpages/TXP/files?p_file_id=22674

Planning lAnalysis of MS approaches 21 november 2011 Planning lAnalysis of MS approaches Electronic reports (all MS that have reported by 30 April) Selection of national reports National expert reviews Comparison and identification of common grounds and best practices; definition of requirements for scaling and aggregation Draft analytical report Discussion with Drafting group GES, workshop preparation Workshop 23 October suggested issues for workshop: MS opinions on results of analysis requirements and commonalities in approaches priority issues for guidance …. Download the Deltares in 2 minutes film via intranet r http://orasvr02.wldelft.nl:7778/txmpub/files/?p_file_id=6695 or Deltares-website http://www.deltares.nl/xmlpages/TXP/files?p_file_id=22674