International aspects for the SuperB project

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
November 2004 The Research Infrastructures in FP7 DG RTD – Directorate ‘Structuring ERA’
Advertisements

Neutrinos in CHIPP Allan Clark Neuchâtel Meeting June 2004.
European Strategy for Particle Physics 2013 Preparatory group->Strategy group Individual town meetings Town meeting in Krakow: september 2012 Drafting.
Beyond the ALCPG David B. MacFarlane Associate Laboratory Director for PPA.
This is the last message in this gathering of North American PI’s with an interest in the INFN hosted SuperB project. I will try to deal with issues on.
International collaboration in high energy physics experiments  All large high energy physics experiments today are strongly international.  A necessary.
1 Albrecht Wagner, Snowmass 0805 Albrecht Wagner DESY and Hamburg University Challenges for Realising the ILC.
HEPAP and P5 Report DIET Federation Roundtable JSPS, Washington, DC; April 29, 2015 Andrew J. Lankford HEPAP Chair University of California, Irvine.
ECFA European Committee for Future Accelerators ECFA ACTIVITIES Lenny Rivkin, EPFL & PSI CHIPP Plenary meeting Fribourg, 30 June – 2 July, 2014.
Accelerator activities Brian Foster (Uni Hamburg/DESY) 1 B. Foster - Hamburg/DESY - Orsay 11/13.
SuperB. SuperB has been approved as the first in a list of 14 “flagship” projects within the new national research plan. The national research plan has.
Round-table: Discussion on Future Machines. With the discovery of the Higgs Boson Self-consistent model (SM) accounting for all Particle Physics phenomena.
European Strategy for Particle Physics Proposed Draft to the CERN Council ECFA Linear.
CLIC detector & physics study “news from the ET ” Lucie Linssen L. Linssen, IB meeting, 18 April
Nick Walker, Brian Foster LAL, Orsay WP2: Coordination with the GDE.
The Future of High Energy Physics R. Aleksan CPPM/IN2P3 and DAPNIA/CEA EPS HEP2005 Lisbon, July 23,
E.Elsen European LC Workshop, Cockcroft, UK, Jan 2007 Perspectives for European LC R&D.
CERN Strategy Group WS at Zeuthen Input from Japan Mitsuaki NOZAKI (KEK)
First of all, a very big “thank you” to Misha Danilov for thinking of this idea and bringing us here to share in these two days, and allowing us all to.
P5 and the HEP Program A. Seiden Fermilab June 2, 2003.
Astroparticle Physics for Europe ASPERA – 2 Workpackage 5 1. Workpackage 5 - European-wide common calls and other common actions Deborah Miller, STFC.
27-March-10 LCWS10 - Beijing Global Design Effort 1 Barry Barish LCWS10 - Beijing 27-March-10 “Cost Containment” for the TDR.
Atsuto Suzuki. 1. Toward ILC Construction : Japanese Activities 1. Toward ILC Construction : Japanese Activities.
The time line Autumn 2011CERN Council initiated an update exercise to the European Strategy for Particle Physics which was approved by a special Council.
CLIC Implementation Studies Ph. Lebrun & J. Osborne CERN CLIC Collaboration Meeting addressing the Work Packages CERN, 3-4 November 2011.
Concluding remarks R. Aleksan CERN, November 25, 2005 CARE is almost 2 year old What comes next ?
Guy Wormser, SuperB workshop, 25 July 2006 Super B Factory workshop Round Table Guy Wormser LAL Orsay.
24-Aug-11 ILCSC -Mumbai Global Design Effort 1 ILC: Future after 2012 preserving GDE assets post-TDR pre-construction program.
CARE Steering Committee and Dissemination Board R. Aleksan CARE Steering Committee Paris, April 11, Introduction.
World Wide Study of Physics and Detectors for a future e + e - Linear Collider David J. Miller; towards a WWS response to ILCSC/ICFA How do we propose.
Report from ILCSC Shin-ichi Kurokawa KEK ILCSC Chair GDE meeting at Frascati December 7, 2005.
Status Report on ILC Project in Japan Seiichi SHIMASAKI Director, Office for Particle and Nuclear Research Promotion June 19, 2015.
Activities and news Last meeting: 2015 CERN budget allocations as expected, now distributed on accounts Annual report done, and MTP (Medium Term Plan)
ECFA European Committee for Future Accelerators Report from the chairman M. Krammer HEPHY, Vienna, Austria July 24, 2014RECFA DESY1.
1 GUTs and Branes DESY Theory Workshop 2003 A brief introduction to the future of particle physics at DESY Albrecht Wagner Hamburg, 23 September 2003.
F. Richard LAL/Orsay 1 ELAN in 2006 Annual Meeting.
Atsuto Suzuki (KEK), Chair ICFA Report from ICFA ICFA mission and membershipICFA PanelICFA Activity.
News Y2K June 25, Summary of June 12 Face-to-Face Meeting.
1 Future Circular Collider Study Preparatory Collaboration Board Meeting September 2014 R-D Heuer Global Future Circular Collider (FCC) Study Goals and.
Flavour Physics Speaker: Andreas Hoecker Convener: Ewa Rondio Sc.Secretary: Ulrik Egede Orsay, 31’th January 2006.
Opening CERN to non-European States (aka as ‘geographical enlargement’) Rüdiger Voss CERN International Relations Office FPRIB, SINP Kolkata| April 16-18,
Glion Colloquium / June Accelerating Science and Innovation R.-D. Heuer, CERN HL-LHC, Aix-les-Bains, 1 Oct ECFA HL-LHC Experiments Workshop.
CLIC project 2012 The Conceptual Design Report for CLIC completed – presented in SPC, ECFA and numerous meetings and conferences, also providing basis.
E.Elsen GDE Meeting, Beijing, Feb 2007 Perspectives and Planning for European LC R&D.
ECFA - European Commitee for Future Accelerators Tatsuya Nakada – EPFL, Switzerland– prepared for CERN September Council presented by.
1 Comments concerning DESY and TESLA Albrecht Wagner Comments for the 5th meeting of the ITRP at Caltech 28 June 2004 DESY and the LC What could DESY contribute.
Revealing the Hidden Nature of Space and Time Charting the Course for Elementary Particle Physics (in the U.S.) Committee on Elementary Particle Physics.
WP leaders meeting R. Aleksan October 5 th, 2009 TIARA 1.Objectives 2.General Context 3.Building TIARA 4.Conclusion.
K. Long, R. Roser, 23 July 2014 Report from the Neutrino Summit.
Lucio Rossi for the LARP Internal Project Review Via videlink, June 10, 2013.
The SiD LOI Proposed Milestones and Schedules SiD Collaboration Phone Meeting September 6, 2007 John Jaros.
Opening talk Annecy, March 16 , 2010 Guy Wormser LAL Orsay 15 Feb,2009
LCC L. Evans, Santander, 2nd June 2016
Financing of LHC projects and CMS
The European Strategy for Particle Physics
Input to Strategy currently planned
for the EURISOL Steering Committee
The European Strategy Outline Some reminders
Strategy Ties Behnke
Process of the 2nd update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics FCC week, 29 May 2017, Berlin Sijbrand de Jong, President of the CERN Council (slides.
Asian Cooperation in KEK
FALC report and KEK’s plan for the ILC
Yasuhiro Okada, Executive Director, KEK
Status of SuperKEKB May 11, 2007 SuperB Workshop Masa Yamauchi KEK.
Sustainable Energy Europe
V SuperB Workshop ENS May 9-11, 2007
Marcello A. Giorgi Università di Pisa & Pisa
Experience of the implementation of FP6; preparations towards FP7
Detector Proto-Technical board Sep 30, 2010
LHC Computing, RRB; H F Hoffmann
Presentation transcript:

International aspects for the SuperB project Guy Wormser LAL Orsay SuperB International Review Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati November 12-13, 2007

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions SuperB CDR SuperB CDR represents A very exciting physics case to unravel the structure of the physics beyond the Standard Model (M. Ciuchini, D. Hitlin) A large and very experienced community (320 CDR signatories from 85 institutes) An innovative and very appealing machine design (P. Raimondi et al. ) Exciting test of key machine issues already ongoing in Frascati with international participation A solid detector concept (B. Ratcliff, F. Forti) A cost estimate for machine and detector Machine 191 M€ (and 126 M€ re-used) Site 105 M€ Detector 40 M€ (and 46 M€ re-used) The SuperB is a unique international opportunity HEP needs projects with a very good physics/cost ratio driven by a region or a country, in parallel with the energy frontier machines (LHC, ILC) Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

The right project at the right time! In 2006, Europe launched a strategic planning exercice under the aegis of the CERN Council This process included a symposium open to the community in Orsay (January 2006), a workshop in Zeuthen and was concluded in Lisbon in July 2006: “Flavour physics and precision measurements at the high-luminosity frontier at lower energies complement our understanding of particle physics and allow for a more accurate interpretation of the results at the high-energy frontier; these should be led by national or regional collaborations, and the participation of European laboratories and institutes should be promoted.” The SuperB project is fully in line with the European Strategy!! Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

International process Similar strategic reviews were conducted at the same time in US (EPP2010/P5 roadmap) and in Japan and reached very similar conclusions: the worldwide HEP community is eagerly waiting for an ambitious flavour machine led by a national or regional effort The SuperB project was presented to ECFA in July 2007 in joint ECFA/HEPP EPS session organized during the EPS conference in Manchester Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions The US EPP2010 report 1) Full realization of LHC experimental program 2) The US should launch a major program of R&D, design and industrialization, management, financing studies of ILC accelerators and detectors 3) US should announce its strong intent to become the host country for the ILC and should undertake the necessary work to provide a viable site and mount a compelling bid 4) promote projects at the interface between particle physics,astrophysics and cosmology 5) Determine properties of neutrino through a well coordinated, staged program of experiments developed with international planning and cooperation 6) US participation to large scale high precision experiments should continue but the level of support will be very sensitive to the overall budget picture…Participation in small scale, high precision measurements should be encouraged in any budget scenario. Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

The Japanese strategic document (1) The HEP community of Japan understands that physics at high energy frontier is the most important one. With this understanding the realization of the ILC is the highest priority among all projects. Before the start of the ILC the flavor physics can also be carried out as Physics complementary to the energy frontier.  The wide range of accelerator technologies in Japan which support the ILC and the flavor experiments is leading the world. In order to realize the international project  ILC the accelerator technology will be industrialized. The R&D efforts for energy frontier and for flavor physics will be unified to be used for the development of ILC accelerator technology.   In Japan the long-base line neutrino experiment has been   successfully operated for the first time in the world, and the KEKB became the highest luminosity machine in the world. Based on these successes,  J-PARC will soon be started.   By the upgrade of the B-factory, even higher luminosity will be reached and new physics in b, c, tau will be searched for. Nowadays, most of the particle physics or accelerator projects are done by international collaborations. The Japanese community must be further internationalized and must build up closer connections with Asian countries as well as with countries all over the world Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

The Japanese strategic document (2) Energy frontier physics: We make efforts towards the success of the LHC experiment.  We perform the R&D towards the construction of ILC, establishing the mass production and industrialization, and reinforce the R&D organization. Flavor physics: We will complete the construction of J-PARC and promote T2K and Kaon rare decay experiments.   The B-factory will be upgraded and lead the world with new results. It can be used for the R&D of ILC. Since there are common items in ILC and KEKB accelerators, human resources and material resources can be shared: the R&D should be jointly organized.    'Prospects of elementary particle physics' was prepared by HEP committee and was unanimously approved by the HEP community of Japan in the general assembly on 25th October 2006 Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions Contacts with KEK Since there is a worldwide agreement that only one Super Flavour factory will be built in the world, the SuperB project has always maintained very close contacts with KEK at three complementary levels Machine experts Detector and Physics community Strategic planning Participation of a strong japanese delegation to the recent SuperB workshop organised in Paris in May 2007 Visible impact of SuperB original machine ideas on KEKB machine upgrade Discussion of a common « physics manifest » Implicit agreement of common work on THE future detector Since then, KEK seems to favour now a more adiabatic KEKB upgrade Unique window of opportunity for SuperB project Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions Recent news from KEK Date: Wed, 26 Sep 2007 16:59:28 +0900 From: Masa Yamauchi yamauchi@post.kek.jp To: belle_ml@bpost.kek.jp Subject: [belle_ml:8040] Status of the upgrade proposal Dear colleagues, This mail is to inform you of the recent status of our proposal on the KEKB upgrade. We have been proposing to upgrade KEKB to increaseits luminosity to 8x10^35/cm^2/sec, and the Belledetector accordingly. We have not made much progress with this proposal mainly due to the financial constraintsat KEK. To pursue the KEKB upgrade in a realistic way,both in cost and time, we (=three spokespersons of Belle and Oide) agreed to propose the following compromise upgrade plan after some discussions with the KEKmanagement. "A partial upgrade of KEKB and Belle will be carried outin 2009-2011 within our annual operation budget.Installation of additional RF and so on will continue after resuming operation in 2012. The target luminosity is 2x10^35/cm^2/sec." Detail of the machine upgrade plan will be shown soon by our KEKB colleagues. It will be designed in such a way that allows a further upgrade to 10^36/cm^2/sec in case this is required by new physics results from this upgrade and/or LHC experiments. We have a working group at KEK to discuss KEK'sroadmap in the near future, which submitted a report to the KEK-DG recently. The roadmap that they recommended includes the proposed KEKB upgradeas well as ILC R&D and so on, and was positively receivedby Suzuki. We believe some official statement will beissued by the KEK management soon referring to the KEKB upgrade. In addition, the roadmap recommended by the working group was shown to the Japanese HEP community by Takasaki at the J-HEP general meeting a few days ago. Browder, Iijima and Yamauchi Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions ILC synergy ILC , the next frontier machine, is the worldwide HEP top priority. Quite important for a new project to show that it can benefit to ILC Obvious and strong similarities between ILC damping ring and Final focus and SuperB project The ILC/SuperB synergy was discussed in length during the last SuperB workshop in May Although it was recognized that ILC and SuperB can be approved independantly, ILC can benefit a lot from all the lessons learned for SuperB if it is built and operated early enough Importance of the relative schedule of both projects Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions Towards a TDR in 2010 Spring 2007 : CDR sent to INFN Spring 2008: International committee report Summer 2010: complete Technical Design Report covering machine and detector To favour international participation to the machine project, organization could be somewhat similar to XFEL project Workpackages definition EoI to form a consortium for each WP , accompanied by a MoU Central team mostly based in Italy Conventional organization for the detector part Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

Collaboration forming For the detector, open international process based on a LOI Letter of intent Key question: will this project attract beyond BABAR collaboration? Good sign from the CDR: 65 exp. outside BABAR signed (174 Babarians) Strong potential attractiveness to LHCb community if the schedule is right « Copetition » with potential KEKB upgrade International steering committee will have to be put in place throughout the TDR phase to monitor the situation Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB project governance SuperB is a large international european-based project led a national initiative, for a total cost around 500 M€ and 350 M€ needed as new money: very similar to XFEL project (but half the price!) National initiative with >50% funds proposed by the host country EU provides some funds for preparatory work International committee formed by the interested funding agencies Site selection rather straightforward Formal framework selection (legal status for the project, manpower,etc) consumes a lot of time and efforts: should be started (and finished) as soon as possible International contributions to the machine as in-kind deliverables Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

International Situation (as of today) In Japan KEKB officially approved until 1 ab-1, ie 2009 Recent move towards limited adiabatic upgrade In USA End of PEP-II in Oct 2008 Potential support for mid size initiatives In Europe Several countries interested besides Italy (France, UK, Germany) My own guess : do not expect huge financial contributions What about Russia ( XFEL Russian contribution could be 100 M€, ie x2 France , UK or Italy) and China ? Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions The SuperB project offers a unique scientific opportunity, well in line with the HEP global and European strategy Excellent timing and good window of opportunity given the present international situation Let us move forward fast towards a TDR in 2010: a prompt schedule is essential for the success of this endeavour Consolidating the international basis for the project (legal framework, ressources, ..) will take time as well and should be started by INFN right away Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions

Europe and US strategies in a nutshell 1) LHC (and LHC consolidation) 2) Accelerator R&D 3) ILC 4) Neutrino 5) astrophysics and cosmology 6) Flavour physics US 1)LHC 2) ILC 3) ILC hosting efforts 4) astrophysics and cosmology 5) Neutrinos 6) Flavour Physics Nov 12-13, 2007 SuperB Review - G. Wormser, Conclusions