DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report James Priest, PhD, PE Workshop on Fire Protection for Physics Research Facilities FCC Study Collaboration 20 June 2017

Background The Department of Energy (DOE) Annual reporting of Fire Protection Program Summary included monetary loss information. Started in 19721; However, can only retrieve the last 25 years of data. 1 Actual data collection stated in 1950 under the Atomic Energy Commission & Energy Research Development Administration – URL: https://www.energy.gov/ehss/downloads/annual-fire-protection-summary-information-reporting-guide 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Regulatory DOE Order 231.1B, Environment Safety and Health Reporting Requires annual submission of fire protection information Must be submitted by April 30 for the pervious year; Fire loss includes property damage or loss sustained as a consequence of a fire; Fire loss is deemed reportable based upon the fire department incident report; Each fire loss event will include separate entries; Related deaths or injuries resulting from this event. URL:https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2014/10/f18/Annual_Fire_Protection_Summary_Information_Reporting_Guide.pdf 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Regulatory DOE Order 231.1B, Environment Safety and Health Reporting Requires annual submission of fire protection information Must be submitted by April 30 for the pervious year; Fire loss includes property damage or loss sustained as a consequence of a fire; Fire loss is deemed reportable based upon the fire department incident report; Each fire loss event will include separate entries; Related deaths or injuries resulting from this event. Many sites, do not include this information, there is a separate, Computerized Accident/Incident Reporting System (CAIRS) Database for this information 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Exported Files 26 Files were exported. Please note, this is the farthest back that we had access to in the database or the pervious years have been archived. Files were converted to MS Excel latest format Spreadsheet Files – (26) Excel Format 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

What The Data Look Like DOE Site Location, note can have multiply entries for one site based on multiply events Actuation is if some one called in the event of was detected by detection and automatic alarm was received Typically the on-site building or enclosure A brief description of the event, will include if some type of equipment, such as electrical was involved Loss includes property damage or loss sustained as a consequence of a fire – Note in 1994, Site K-25 froze 182 sprinklers, resulting in $688,000.00 loss Type of loss, pull down selection 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

What The Data Look Like Two things to be aware of: There can be a fire or an event without dollar loss amount. For example, 1998, Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory states: “Automatic sprinkler system was actuated when a 4160 volt AC cable, which was disconnected and improperly terminated, was re-energized and causing an electrical explosion.” There is a zero dollar loss amount associated with this event. Have to report Halon discharge events. For example, 1998 Savannah River Site states: “Halon discharge in the FB-Line (1 cylinder) accidentally releasing 250 lbs. of agent.” There s a zero dollar loss amount associated with this event. 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

What The Data Look Like (Continued) 1A Wet Pipe Sprinkler System 1B Dry Pipe Sprinkler System 1C Deluge Sprinkler System 1D Pre-Action Sprinkler System 1E Foam-Water System 1F Water Spray System 1G Halon 1301 Systems 1H Halon 1211 Systems (Fixed) 1I Clean Agent Systems 1J Wet Chemical Systems Etc. Typically left blank Pull down, Yes or No. Typically No This is derived from a separate database (CAIRS) and is typically No No one goes back and modifies the data 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

What the Data Does NOT include WIPP – February 14, 2014, barrel containing radiological waste exploded, as a result of a contractor using organic “cat litter” instead of the clay “cat litter” – January 9, 2017, after three years of cleanup at a cost of $500 million. 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Some Quick Analysis We consolidated the data into one Spreadsheet In the past 25 years, DOE has had a $200 million dollar fire loss Fermilab in the past 25 years, has had $780,000 dollar fire loss 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Comparison of Three Similar Laboratories 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report

Questions? 6/20/2017 J. Priest | DOE Loss Summary (Accident) Report