On the meaning of the likelihood ratio: Is a large number always an indication of strength of evidence?  Hinda Haned, Guro Dørum, Thore Egeland, Peter.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Maria Eugenia D’Amato, Mohaimin Kasu 
Advertisements

A. Verzeletti, V. Cortellini, S. Cisana, S. Pretto, N. Cerri, F
Genotyping microhaplotype markers through massively parallel sequencing  Jing Zhu, Peng Chen, Shengqiu Qu, Hui Wang, Dan Chen, Weibo Liang, Lin Zhang 
S. Alimat, S. Hadi, W. Goodwin 
Carolyn R. Steffen, Margaret C. Kline, David L. Duewer, Peter M
A priori probabilities in Y23 mixture analysis: Non-contributor experiments using simulated powerplex® Y23 Y-STR mixtures  D. Moore, T. Clayton, J. Thomson 
Peter G. Ristow, Maria E. D’Amato 
Systematic study on the analytical parameters relevant to achieve reliable STR profiles, as assessed in a multicentre data set  G. Marrubini, C. Previderè,
Performance of the RapidHIT™200
Evaluation of the IrisPlex system in admixed individuals
NIST validation studies on the 3500 Genetic Analyzer
C. Davies, J. Thomson, F. Kennedy 
The effect of increased cycle numbers using the Quantifiler® Duo DNA Quantification Kit (AB) on the detection of minute amounts of male DNA in mixtures.
DNA typing of trace DNA recovered from different areas of sandals found at a homicide crime scene investigation: A comparative study  Samuel T.G. Ferreira,
Template preparation of AmpliSeq™ libraries using the Ion Chef™
Establishment of Italian national DNA database and the central laboratory: Some aspects  R. Biondo, F. De Stefano  Forensic Science International: Genetics.
A new approach for the separation of spermatozoa from other cell types in forensically relevant samples  F. Grosjean, V. Castella  Forensic Science International:
Yan Liu, Li Li, Chengtao Li, Zhenmin Zhao 
U. Ricci, I. Carboni, S. Iozzi, A. Gozzini, F. Torricelli 
Plant dna barcoding system for forensic application
Development and validation of an allelic frequency database for Qatari population using 13 rapidly mutating Y-STRs multiplex assay  E. Almohammed, R.
Population data for SE33 locus in United Arab Emirates Arab population
A new strategy for body source identification of tumor sample
Maria Eugenia D’Amato, Mohaimin Kasu 
PCR-based tests for forensic detection of feces; use of Bacteroides species as indicator of fecal matter  A. Sinelnikov, E. Kopitke, K. Reich  Forensic.
Using EuroForMix to analyse complex SNP mixtures, up to six contributors  Øyvind Bleka, Mayra Eduardoff, Carla Santos, Chris Phillips, Walther Parson,
A rape case with multiple unknown perpetrators
SNP-STR analysis for non-invasive paternity test for fetus
Combining DNA evidence for greater match information
Oskar Hansson, Peter Gill 
A. Verzeletti, V. Cortellini, S. Cisana, S. Pretto, N. Cerri, F
Body fluid mixtures: Resolution using forensic microRNA analysis
Rapid DNA maturity assessment
Evaluation of GeneMapper®ID-X Mixture Analysis tool
Performing a BLAST search of the STRSeq BioProject
Peter G. Ristow, Maria E. D’Amato 
DIP–STR: A new marker for resolving unbalanced DNA mixtures
Distribution of Y chromosome haplogroup Q in Greenlanders
Introducing a latent variable approach for finding populations in a forensic DNA database  Maarten Kruijver  Forensic Science International: Genetics.
Determination of siblings: A special case report from Halle
Forensic analysis of soils using single arbitrarily primed amplification and high throughput sequencing  Anastasia S. Khodakova, Leigh Burgoyne, Damien.
On the exact distribution of the numbers of alleles in DNA mixtures
Direct STR typing from bullet casings
Analysis of complex DNA mixtures using the Forensim package
Developmental validation of a fully automated genotyping assay capable of detecting length and sequence variation in the CODIS STR loci  David D. Duncan,
Zheng Wang, Xueying Zhao, Yiping Hou 
Genotyping microhaplotype markers through massively parallel sequencing  Jing Zhu, Peng Chen, Shengqiu Qu, Hui Wang, Dan Chen, Weibo Liang, Lin Zhang 
Semen detection: A retrospective overview from 2010
Sex determination problems in forensic genetic analysis
Linda Albinsson, Johannes Hedman, Ricky Ansell 
Eye colour and SNPs in Danes
Carolyn R. Hill, Margaret C. Kline, Michael D. Coble, Peter M. Vallone 
Kpop: A Python package for population genetics analysis
Simulated approach to estimate the number and combination of known/unknown contributors in mixed DNA samples using 15 short tandem repeat loci  Sho Manabe,
Effect of linkage on sibship determination based on likelihood ratio
When the alleged father is a close relative of the real father: The utility of insertion/deletion polymorphisms  M. Magalhaes, N. Pinto, C. Gomes, R.
mixsep: An R-package for DNA mixture separation
Monique Wesselink, Irene Kuiper 
Effects of the most common methods for the enhancement of latent fingerprints on DNA extraction from forensic samples  S. Gino, M. Omedei  Forensic Science.
Genetic data for the locus SE33 in a Southern Italy population with AmpFlSTR NGM SElect™ PCR amplification kit  A. Barbaro, P. Cormaci, A. La Marca  Forensic.
Development of a 24-plex Y chromosomal STR loci typing system
Statistical aspects of familial searching
DNA/RNA co-analysis of seminal fluid-stained fabrics after water immersion for up to seven days  G. Kulstein, P. Wiegand  Forensic Science International:
N. C. L. Oliveira, M. H. F. Ekert, C. A. Souza, K. C. N. Rabêlo, S. M
Forensic nomenclature for short tandem repeats updated for sequencing
Trace DNA success rates relating to volume crime offences
Discrepancies between forensic DNA databases
Peter M. Vallone, Carolyn R. Hill, Erica L.R. Butts 
The study of ABO genotyping for forensic application
A simple unconstrained semi-continuous model for calculating likelihood ratios for complex DNA mixtures  Daniel Russell, William Christensen, Todd Lindsey 
Presentation transcript:

On the meaning of the likelihood ratio: Is a large number always an indication of strength of evidence?  Hinda Haned, Guro Dørum, Thore Egeland, Peter Gill  Forensic Science International: Genetics Supplement Series  Volume 4, Issue 1, Pages e176-e177 (January 2013) DOI: 10.1016/j.fsigss.2013.10.091 Copyright © 2013 Terms and Conditions

Fig. 1 A case example: Crime-stain epg with allele designations. There are two suspects S1 and S2. Shaded alleles are shared with victim and red alleles are found in the victim. Bracketed alleles are below detection threshold but appear distinct. Forensic Science International: Genetics Supplement Series 2013 4, e176-e177DOI: (10.1016/j.fsigss.2013.10.091) Copyright © 2013 Terms and Conditions

Fig. 2 Results of non-contributor tests where S1 and S2 are respectively replaced by 1000 random (R) genotypes, showing the observed rLR (random likelihood ratio); the one percentile (1%rLR); median (50%rLR) and 99 (99%rLR) percentile random man rLRs. In (A) the tests are all negative log10; in (B) the distribution of rLRs is either neutral or positive log10. Forensic Science International: Genetics Supplement Series 2013 4, e176-e177DOI: (10.1016/j.fsigss.2013.10.091) Copyright © 2013 Terms and Conditions