Counterfactual impact evaluations - experience of EFS Managing Authority in Poland Expert hearing on MS experiences on using control groups in ESF evaluations.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Assessment of administrative and institutional capacity

Advertisements

Local partnership for employment and cohesion. Example of Pomeranian Region. Poland. Janusz Galeziak Director, ESF Department.

PARTNERSHIP IN THE GREEK EQUAL C.I.P. Vassiliki Staikou Managing Authority of C.I.P. EQUAL General Secretariat for the Management of European Funds Ministry.

Putting partnership into context Anna Koziel Forum of Non Governmental Organizations (FIP) Association European Project Brussels 2006.

POLAND Development Management System in Poland Brussels, 2 July 2010.

1 Idea of Territorial Contract (TC) What is it? TC is the most important planning instrument for ensuring the implementation of public policies with territorial.

POLISH PRESIDENCY IN THE EU: COHESION POLICY AND EVALUATION-RELATED ACTIVITIES Presentation of Objectives and Programme Stanisław Bienias, Ministry of.

MINISTRY OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS DG “PROGRAMMING OF THE REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT” OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME “REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT” EVALUATION.

European Social Fund Evaluation in Italy Stefano Volpi Roma, 03 maggio 2011 Isfol Esf Evaluation Unit Human Resources Policies Evaluation Area Rome, Corso.

Improving the added value of EU Cohesion policy Professor John Bachtler European Policies Research Centre University of Strathclyde, Glasgow

Presentation of a real call for proposal from the point of view of the managing authority.

Control procedures in polish public procurement law Public Procurement Office 2007.

Impact of the cohesion policy on the level and quality of employment in Poland Project co-financed from financial means of the European Union within the.

Impact of the cohesion policy on employment in the Czech Republic Budapest, 6th May 2010 Jana Váňová National Training Fund, Prague.

Evaluation plans for programming period in Poland Experience and new arrangements Ministry of Infrastructure and Development, Poland Athens,

GOVERNMENT OF ROMANIA MINISTRY OF PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGING AUTHORITY FOR COMMUNITY SUPPORT FRAMEWORK Evaluation Central Unit Development of the Evaluation.

Information by the Managing Authority on thematic evaluation of EU structural funds in Iruma Kravale Head of Strategic Planning Unit, European.

POLAND Modernisation of development policy Sofia, June 5, 2012.

(Dr. Peter Heil, ALTUS – Hungary)

Plans for the next programming period ESF implementation in Poland

Evaluation Units Open Days Some experience of Implementing Agency in evaluating Pre-Accession Entrepreneurship Development Programmes Polish Agency for.

Experience of the Slovak Republic Budapest April 16, 2015 European Grouping of Territorial Cooperation.

CSF obj.1 Evaluation The ISFOL ESF Evaluation Unit contribution.

1 Cohesion Policy Adam Abdulwahab Evaluation network meeting Brussels, 21 September 2009 Ex post evaluation of cohesion policy programmes

PHARE TWINNING CONTRACT BG/2004/IB/TR/02/UE Strengthening the capacity of the Ministry of Transport to manage the Sectoral Operational Programme on Transport.

Structural Funds Managing Authority – Ministry of Finance 1 Technical Assistance Ilze Aleksandroviča Head of Control and Development Division EU Funds.

29 March 2011 Audit Authority Audit Department Ministry of Finance 1.

Commission’s Anti-Fraud Strategy (CAFS), 2011 COM(2011) 376 final Requirement of the EU Institutional and Horizontal legal framework for the.

1 The Sectoral Operational Programme for Administrative Capacity Development Managing Authority for Sectoral Operational Programme for Administrative Capacity.

EU Cohesion Policy and its implementation in the Czech Republic Zuzana Kasáková Department of W European Studies Charles University in Prague.

Małgorzata Lublińska Ministry of Regional Development in Poland.

MAZOWSZE 2007 – 2013 Operational Program Human Capital Regional Component Ministry of Regional Development.

Developing coherence mechanisms (ERDF/EARDF) in Poland Andrzej Hałasiewicz, PhD Nicolaus Copernicus University in Torun Foundation of Assistance Programmes.

Anna Slupina European Funds Department Silesia Region Marshal Office Regional(Silesian) Preparatory Actions under Structural Funds.

Inese Vilcane Social inclusion department Senior expert

PLANNING OF RAILWAY INFRASTRUCTURE IN THE CZECH REPUBLIC

Evaluation : goals and principles

The role of mutual learning in Migration Integration policies

The EU context for future funding in Scotland John Bachtler The Future of EU Funding in Scotland European Parliament Seminar Grand Central Hotel, Glasgow,

INFORMING THE PUBLIC ABOUT THE ESF Juris Vigulis Department of communication, Ministry of Welfare LATVIA.

Human Capital Study in Poland

Forecast of skills on the labour market

Future of the ESF ESF Committee Amsterdam, 15/06/2016.

Evaluation plans for programming period in Poland

Dorotea Daniele, Facilitator

Operational Programmes Selected Impressions from Negotiations

ESF Evaluation Partnership Meeting

Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resources Development

Jacek Ostrowski Head of Unit

PARTNERSHIP IN THE GREEK EQUAL C.I.P.

How to implement the partnership principle for a better use of ESIF

COLLABORATION with Centre for Research on Impact Evaluation

Panel 1: Synergies between policies and EU funds Creating dynamics and impacts Grzegorz Gajewski DG Migration and Home Affairs EU Funds for integration.

ESF IMPLEMENTATION IN MALTA

Contribution of Employment and Social inclusion Operational programme to the development of Antidiscrimination behaviour at the Labour market and to the.

Monitoring & evaluation in

EU Cohesion Policy : legislative proposals

The Republic of Lithuania

Comment on EU precision requirements

Evaluating the effects of ESF programmes

Cohesion Policy and Biodiversity

Pilot Projects to carry out ESF related Counterfactual Impact Evaluations Alina Ungureanu, Impact Assessment and Evaluation Unit.

Preparation of Member States’ Strategic Reports 2009 European Commission seminar for managing and certifying authorities Brussels, 9 June 2009 John.

ESF ex post evaluation State of play

Embedding Governance & Participation in the European Structural Funds

Counterfactual impact evaluations in Poland

ESF EVALUATION PARTNERSHIP

ESF ex post evaluation State of play

Where do we stand with the Structural Funds?

Programme for Employability, Inclusion and Learning

Presentation transcript:

Counterfactual impact evaluations - experience of EFS Managing Authority in Poland Expert hearing on MS experiences on using control groups in ESF evaluations

Experience: Department for European Social Fund in Polish Ministry of Regional Development has been responsible for coordination of two counterfactual impact evaluations: “The impact of Cohesion Policy on the level and quality of employment in Poland” - on-going evaluation of Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resources Development 2004 – 2006 (SOP HRD); “Study on achieved values of result indicators of the regional component of the Human Capital Operational Programme” Human Capital Operational Programme – on-going evaluation (to be completed in mid 2012). Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019

Reasons for the evaluations; Values of indicators; ESF intervention efficiency (change in time); Improving of the intervention logic (both: national and co-financed by EFS); Success factors; Databases. Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019

Challenges in preparing and managing CIEs: Level of representativeness of the sample; High survey costs; Long-lasting (real on-going) exercise; Hard to predict everything (public procurement and persona data protection law); Data utilization; Data availability. Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019

Possible improvements to undertake CIEs; Legal requirements; Data accessibility; Sources of the „control groups twins” data; Data quality. Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019

Use and dissemination of results: Recommendations for improvement of future CIEs surveys; Recommendations for the policy improvements: 6 recommendation concerning the intervention logic; 1 recommendation for conducting in-depth study. Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019

Thank you for your attention!!! Ministry of Regional Development - May 2, 2019