Ethical considerations in diagnosing

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Context  How do we define sane? How about insane? Is there a difference? How do we tell?
Advertisements

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS IN DIAGNOSIS RESEARCH SUPPORT ABNORM – NORMS & DIAGNOSIS #3 PART 4.
SELF FULFILLING PROPHECY Negative beliefs predict negative behaviour If a teacher thinks you will fail in an exam you probably will!
Copyright ©2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display. Ethical and Legal Issues.
Devise at least 5 (no more than 10) questions on the Rosenhan study. Try to make them challenging – some ideas: They will mainly be knowledge based, but.
Schemas and Heuristics
Discuss the validity and reliability of diagnosis
Abnormal Psychology: Concepts of Normality. Concepts of normality and abnormality It is not any easy task to define what is normal and what is abnormal.
Discuss validity and reliability of diagnosis
Social - Cognition Personality Reflects Internal Representations.
Psychological Disorders Abnormal Behavior. History of Mental Disorders & Institutions Originally called “lunatics”, it was believed to be related to a.
Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display. Ethical and Legal Issues.
DEFINING “ABNORMALITY” OR CONSTRUCTING PSYCHOPATHOLOGY?: LECTURE OUTLINE Some warnings about “abnormality” Difficulties defining abnormality Thomas Szasz.
Ethical Issues Involved in Assessment & Clinical Diagnosis.
Defining Abnormality and Diagnosing Psychological Disorders.
Schachter’s Two-Factor Theory of Emotion. This theory is similar to Bem’s explanation for the cause of behavior in general. Schachter’s theory looks specifically.
Aims and Outcomes Introduce the issues of reliability and validity in forming a diagnosis Discuss cultural and gender differences in diagnosing disorders.
Ethical considerations in diagnosis Year 13 Abnormal Psychology.
Being sane in insane places
What is going on in this picture? Be as descriptive as possible. We will look at your responses shortly.
Research support for validity and reliability theories
Cultural and ethical considerations in diagnosis By Mr Daniel Hansson.
Schizophrenia Lesson Two. Specification Describe and evaluate two issues in classifying or diagnosing schizophrenia… -Reliability -Validity.
DIAGNOSING PSYCHOPATHOLOGY: DSM-IV MORE HARM THAN GOOD?
Defining Abnormality and Diagnosing Psychological Disorders.
Aims and Outcomes Introduce the issues of reliability and validity in forming a diagnosis Discuss cultural and gender differences in diagnosing disorders.
Preparing for the Assessment Day of the Assessment.
Context  How do we define sane? How about insane? Is there a difference? How do we tell?
DISCUSS CULTURAL AND ETHICAL & GENDER CONSIDERATIONS IN DIAGNOSIS (FOR EXAMPLE, CULTURAL VARIATION, STIGMATIZATION)
Diagnosing Mental Disorders. IB Syllabus Says: Discuss cultural and ethical considerations in diagnosis.
Concepts & Diagnosis Paper 2 Question (Major). Sources of info… Use your textbook……… Use the wiki………. Use the summary sheets….. Use the handouts………..
VALIDITY OF DIAGNOSIS ABNORM – NORMS AND DIAGNOSIS #2 – LESSON #3.
A2 unit 4 Clinical Psychology 4) Content Reliability of the diagnosis of mental disorders Validity of the diagnosis of mental disorders Cultural issues.
Intro to Psychological Disorders CHAPTER 16. Why are we so interested in psychological disorders? Chances are, we have all been affected by a psych disorder.
Dysfunctional Behaviour G543. –Categories: DSM and ICD –Definitions by Rosenhan & Seligman –Diagnostic bias (gender) Ford & Widiger.
Discuss the validity and reliability of diagnosis
-Goals of Psychology- Describe Explain Predict Change.
Lesson Two – Evaluation of the Four Ds of diagnosis
Diversity: from Stereotype to Discrimination
Interviewing Adolescents A Police Perspective
Interviewing Chapters
“I have encountered countless examples of stigma, especially in mental health. Black men are more likely to be sectioned, less talking therapy, more medications.
A2 unit 4 Clinical Psychology
Reliability and Validity
Session Title: Dementia-Breaking The Barriers Speaker Name: Nasseer Masoodi, MD, MBA, FACP Assistant Chair/Senior Consultant; Ambulatory General Internal.
Classification of Schizophrenia Diagnosis of Schizophrenia
IB Psychology Today’s Agenda: Turn in: Abnormal Intro Cont.
MMI Interviews.
MH31 Principles of interviewing and group leadership
Balancing Administrative & Clinical Supervision
Problems & Solutions in Research
Clinical Assessment and Diagnosis
Evaluate one classification systems (e. g
Learning Objectives What are socio-cultural explanations of schizophrenia? What are the key concepts of labelling theory? Socio-cultural = societal or.
Classification and diagnosis of schizophrenia
Consequences of being diagnosed with depression
IB Psychology Today’s Agenda: Turn in: What is Sanity? Nothing
What are the Consequences of Labeling People?
FACTORS INFLUENCING DIAGNOSIS
Yr 7 Drama Lesson 7 Evaluation
Working in Groups.
PSYA3 Essay Planning Pack
Psychological Research Methods and Statistics
Classification & Diagnosis
Discuss cultural & ethical considerations in diagnosis
MH31 Principles of interviewing and group leadership
Alternatives to Aggression
Job Coaching Skills Workshop for Job Coaches
Issues in Diagnosis and Classification
Check-in How are we all doing?.
Presentation transcript:

Ethical considerations in diagnosing What are the negative implications of labelling people? Scheff (1966) argued that one of the adverse effects of labels is the self-fulfilling prophecy. What does this mean? Doherty (1975) found that those who reject the mental illness label often make quicker recoveries than those who accept it. Langer & Abelson (1974) Found that schema processesing is used when making diagnosis: Jenkins-Hall & Sacco European American therapists watched videos of recorded clinical interviews and were asked to evaluate the female patient. The African American patient was seen as less socially competent than the European American woman. Confirmation bias As was shown in the Rosenhan study ‘On being sane in insane places’, clinicians assume that if someone has sought their help, there must be something wrong with them. Kahneman and Tversky (1973) found that there is no positive correlation between the number of assessment techniques and the accuracy of an eventual diagnosis. Turn to the person next to you and tell them what you think this means? Institutionalization can be a confounding variable when trying to establish the validity of a diagnosis. What does this mean? Powerlessness Depersonalization

Ethical considerations in diagnosing What are the negative implications of labelling people? Participants were shown a video of a younger man talking to an older man about his job experience. Those who had been told before watching the video that the young man was applying for a job described him as attractive and conventional-looking. Those who had been told he was a patient described him as defensive, tight, dependent and afraid of his own impulses. What does this say about the effects of schema processing when making diagnoses?