Writing Literary Analysis A New Approach

Familiar PROMPT Based on your understanding of Homer’s characterization in the epic poem, argue whether or not Odysseus is an effective leader.

A new approach Same concept, new look…

Adding a new layer TO THE PROMPT According to the renowned philosopher, Aristotle, “He who has never learned to obey cannot be a good commander.” Agree or disagree whether Odysseus can be labeled as an effective leader based on Aristotle’s quote.

Let’s Practice Together… Breaking it down STEP ONE: Determine the central argument of the quote. What does the quote MEAN? What is the quote ARGUING? STEP TWO: Assess the literature against the quote. STEP THREE: Make a decision. The prompt gives you very clear directions—agree/disagree, use the quote, focus on Odysseus’ effectiveness as a leader. STEP FOUR: Write. Let’s Practice Together…

DEVELOP A THESIS THAT ANSWERS THIS PROMPT! According to the renowned philosopher, Aristotle, “He who has never learned to obey cannot be a good commander.” Agree or disagree whether Odysseus can be labeled as an effective leader based on Aristotle’s quote.

Sample thesis Although Aristotle describes a leader as one who is disciplined and humble, Odysseus from Homer’s Odyssey is not an effective leader according to Aristotle’s criteria as evidenced by PRONG 1, PRONG 2, and PRONG 3.