HMA for Science Task 1 – Project Management Y. Coene, Spacebel s.a. C. Gizzi, ASTRIUM-UK HMA-S Final Presentation, Geneva, 11 June 2014 HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Agenda HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Agenda (cont’d) HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Overview Introduction Activities Results Conclusions HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Overview Introduction Activities Results Conclusions Project Consortium Objectives Activities Results Conclusions HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Introduction - HMA Build-up ESA EUM DLR ASI CNES CSA BNSC HMA Contributing Agencies Heterogeneous Mission Accessibility EOP-G presentation to DOSTAG 43. April 2005. Interoperability standards project HMA Standards Interfaces Initial Specifications HMA Implementation DAIL Implementation (ESA) HMA Architecture Working Group HMA I/F Implementation @ ESA HMA Test Bed (HMA-T, HMA-FO, HMA-S, ..) Standard specifications Standard specifications HMA WG Terms of Reference Ref. GMES-DFPR-EOPG-PR-06-0006 HMA I/F Implementation @ HMA Contributing Agencies Feedbacks Feedbacks Prototyping and Testing Standards Evolution HMA I/F Implementation @ CCMs Operational Implementation Projects Two track approach: operational implementations and parallel "standardisation and support activities (e.g. SW development and conformance testing)" HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Introduction Project: Consortium: HMA for Science (HMA-S) LTDP budget, 600 KEUR (incl. CCN) Kick-Off held 22 January 2013 Consortium: Prime Contractor: Airbus Defence and Space (formerly ASTRIUM-UK) Project Mgt: Airbus DS / Spacebel (after MTR) HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Introduction - Objectives The HMA-S project aims to further advance the HMA standardisation activities and address in particular the following interfaces: Dataset metadata (Task 3) Catalogue access (datasets, dataset series and services) (Task 4 and Task 5) Feasibility analysis (Task 7) Ordering and product download (Task 4) Processing (Task 6) Identity Management (Task 2) Provide conformance tests (CITE / ATS / ETS) for each specification. Provide open-source Demonstrators and Testbed. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Overview Introduction Activities Results Conclusion HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Activities (*) Since MTR HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Overview Introduction Activities Results Conclusion HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 2: Identity Mgt Note: ETS supporting SOAP 1.2 and SOAP 1.1. Demonstrator includes PEP and STS implementations. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 3: Metadata Issues: Task 3 produced 8+ Change Requests. OGC published them very late causing adoption delays. Late ESA clarification request «dateline conventions». HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 4: Dataset Series and Dataset Discovery Issues: TEAM Engine issues were investigated by Terradue and OGC. Initial ETS delivered 6 June by Terradue Inconsistent TEAM engine version required for these ETS ? To be checked if CTL scripts provide Web interface ? HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 4 (cont’d): Ordering, Online Data Access Note: CCN#2 deliverables (ETS for OGC 13-043) not yet available. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 4 (cont’d): Ordering, Online Data Access Note: Demonstrator D4000 not yet delivered to ESA. VM being extended with Task 7 Demonstrator. CCN#2 deliverables D4700 not yet available. HMA-S.TPZ.D4000.4 no longer required as per AI#84. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 5: Dataset Series and Services Discovery Notes: I15 EP Server (Demonstrator) being used in current FedEO Gateway implementation to host ISO19139 dataset series metadata. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 6: Processing Issues: OGC 13-071r1 still subject to SWG vote (Discussion Paper) OGC 13-070r1 depends on WPS 2.0 being approved. OGC WPS 2.0 SWG much slower than expected. Tasks D6000.2 to D6000.4 suspended since october 2013. Agreement in May 2014 to not resume these tasks. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 7: Feasibility Analysis Issues: OGC 13-039 document being voted (30 yes votes already) CCN#2 Demonstrator currently being added. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 8: TestBed Testbed and TEAM Engine being incrementally delivered to ESA: HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 9: Technical Coordination Notes: HMA-S.SPB.D9000.1 Coherence RIDs and feedback on draft documents produced throughout the project. HMA-S.ASU.D9000.1: SOW requirements I60 (GMLJPEG2000), I61 (INSPIRE Orthoimagery) and I62 (OpenDAP) - missing. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results Task 9: Technical Coordination Updates to TM-21 underway. Draft of updates provided to ESA. Collaborative approach for remaining updates. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Overview Introduction Activities Results Conclusion HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Conclusion With respect to the original objectives: Objective 1:The HMA-S project aims to further advance the HMA standardisation activities and address in particular the following interfaces … Objective 2: Provide conformance tests (CITE / ATS / ETS) for each specification. Objective 3: Provide open-source Demonstrators and Testbed. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #1: Standardisation OGC Implementation Standards (voted): OGC 10-032r8 - OpenSearch Geo and Time Extensions OGC 13-084r2 – I15 Extension Package of CS-W ebRIM Profile OGC Implementation Standards (not yet voted): OGC 10-157r4 - EO Metadata Profile of O&M OGC 13-026r4 – OpenSearch Extension for Earth Observation OGC Best Practices (voted): OGC 07-118r9 - User Mgt Interfaces for EO Services OGC 13-042 – RESTful Encoding of Ordering .. for EO Products OGC 13-043 – Download Service for EO Products OGC 14-012 – RESTful Encoding of Sensor Planning Service for Earth Observation Satellite Tasking HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #1: Standardisation OGC Best Practices (voting underway): OGC 13-039 – OpenSearch Extension for EO Satellite Tasking OGC Discussion Paper (voted): OGC 10-068 – OpenSearch Extension for Correlated Search OGC Discussion Paper (not voted): OGC 13-071r1 – WPS 2.0 Transactional Extension OGC Pending Documents: OGC 08-197r3 – INSPIRE Conformance Class of OGC I15 Extension Package of CS-W ebRIM Profile. OGC 13-070r1 – WPS 2.0 Asynchronous Mgt Extension HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #1: Standardisation Achieved simplified versions of many HMA Protocols. Initial step set to Resource Oriented Architecture: Two RESTful bindings accepted as OGC Best Practice Further work required HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #1: Standardisation HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #1: Standardisation HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #2: Compliance Tests Most ETS available and deployed on TEAM Engine 4.0.1. x HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #2: Compliance Tests To be completed: Baseline: OGC 10-032r8, OGC 13-026r4 ETS delivery to be checked. CCN#2: OGC 13-043 HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #3: Open-source and Testbed Open-Source Components: https://code.google.com/hosting/search?q=label=HMA Task 3 Task 7 Task 5 HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #3 – Open Source Task 4 Task 5 Task 7 Task 2 Task 2/3/5 HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Results #3: Open-source and Testbed Note yet completed: Demonstrator OGC 13-043 « Download Service» (CCN#2)  Testbed deployment at ESA (.OVF files) HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014

Conclusion Most of the expected results achieved according to original timeline. Despite challenging OGC environment: Dependency on external votes to reach quorum. E.g. 26 out of 30 votes on OGC 13-039 are external votes. Cumbersome and slow process to approve 8 change requests on OGC 10-157r3 Many specifications supported by NASA, NGA, USGS, NOAA … Comments from CEOS addressed in Task 4 (OpenSearch) Main exception: Processing (WPS 2.0) Further work required, mainly on CCN#2 related activities. Remaining work to be addressed at forthcoming Acceptance Review. HMA-S Final Presentation - 11/06/2014