Consultation on draft panel criteria and working methods

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
RAE 2008: Goldsmiths Outcomes. Sample Quality Profile.
Advertisements

Research Excellence Framework Jane Boggan Planning Division Research Staff Forum - January 2010.
Main Panel A: Subpanels and Chairs A1: Clinical Medicine - Christopher Day, Newcastle University A2: Public Health, Health services and Primary Care -
Tüzin BAYCAN-LEVENT ERC Advanced Grant Evaluation.
REF2014 HODOMS Birmingham 8 th April Ann Dowling: Chairman of REF Main Panel B John Toland: Chairman of REF Sub-Panel B10: Mathematical Sciences.
RAE 2008 Engineering Ann Dowling, Chairman Main Panel G - Engineering EPC Congress March 2005.
Supporting & promoting Equality & Diversity through REF Dianne Berry, Chair REF E&D Advisory Panel Ellen Pugh, Senior Policy Officer ECU.
Guidance on submissions Chris Taylor, Deputy REF Manager Graeme Rosenberg, REF Manager.
Communicating the outcomes of the 2008 Research Assessment Exercise A presentation to press officers in universities and colleges. Philip Walker, HEFCE.
Research at York Presentation to Council Alastair Fitter Pro-Vice-Chancellor, Research.
The Research Excellence Framework Panel criteria [Main Panel Chair] Graeme Rosenberg.
REF2014 – results and the way forward SSHP Meeting 12 March 2015.
Demonstrating research impact in the REF Graeme Rosenberg REF Manager
The Research Excellence Framework. Purpose of REF The REF replaces the RAE as the UK-wide framework for assessing research in all disciplines. Its purpose.
Consultation on panel criteria and working methods.
REF Information Session August Research Excellence Framework (REF)
The REF assessment framework and guidance on submissions Linda Tiller, HEFCW 16 September 2011.
The Research Excellence Framework Briefing event for REF institutional contacts Graeme Rosenberg REF Manager.
The Research Excellence Framework Briefing events for HEI contacts 21 May: Glasgow 23 May: Manchester 24 May: London 28 May: Cardiff 31 May: London.
Page 1 RESEARCH EXCELLENCE FRAMEWORK : RESEARCH IMPACT ASESSMENT LESSONS FROM THE PILOT EXERCISE Professor John Marshall Director Academic Research Development.
The Impact Initiative ESRC Festival of Social Science Seminar Department for Business, Innovation and Skills 12 th March 2010 Ursula Kelly University of.
Chair: Professor Dame Ann Dowling Sub-panel Chairs: Panel Advisers: SP07: Professor David Price Dr Karen Ness SP08: Professor Richard Catlow Ms Lesley.
Main Panel D Criteria and Working Methods Main Panel D covers: Area Studies Modern Languages and Linguistics English Language and Literature History Classics.
The Research Excellence Framework Impact: the need for evidence Professor Caroline Strange 22 June 2011.
12/9/10 Pilot assessment impact- paperwork Findings of the expert panels- report + appendix Lessons learned- feedback from pilot institutions Examples.
The REF assessment framework (updated 23 May 2011)
Delivering Strength Across the Piece David Sweeney Director, Research, Education and Knowledge Exchange HEPI, Royal Society 31 March 2015.
Research Excellence Framework 2014 and Open Access 23 rd October 2012.
Main Panel A Criteria and Working Methods Cardiff School of Biosciences Ole H Petersen Chair.
Research Excellence Framework 2014 Michelle Double Hyacinth Gale Sita Popat Edward Spiers Research and Innovation Support Conference.
UCAS Preparation Evening 2016
The Research Excellence Framework Assessment framework and guidance on submissions Graeme Rosenberg, REF Manager.
Welcome to the Faculty of Humanities
Current R& KE Issues David Sweeney
Higher Education and Training Awards Council
The Impact Initiative Ursula Kelly University of Strathclyde
Towards REF 2020 What we know and think we know about the next Research Excellence Framework Dr. Tim Brooks, Research Policy & REF Manager, RDCS Anglia.
Research Outcomes Collection
Presentation to the BSC Panel
Phil Quirke RAE 2008 & REF 2014 panels
Presentation to the BSC Panel
Standing Committee on Training
Autumn Term Education Learning Events ( )
Impact and the REF Tweet #rfringe17
Consultation on draft panel criteria and working methods
RESEARCH EXCELLENCE FRAMEWORK 2021
REF 2021 Briefing 25 January 2018.
REF 2021 What we know and thought we knew, in preparation for the next Research Excellence Framework Dr. Tim Brooks, Research Policy & REF Manager, RDCS.
Innovation Project Competition 2017 Briefing Session
REF 2021 Briefing Consultation on the draft guidance
One year on: developments since Duxford 2016
Consultation on draft panel criteria and working methods
REF 2021 & ECRs: policy & planning in an uncertain landscape
Research Update GERI May 2010.
Consultation on the REF 2021 guidance and criteria
Towards Excellence in Research: Achievements and Visions of
Welcome to the Faculty of Humanities
Consultation on draft panel criteria and working methods
Webinar on Equality Impact Assessments in REF 2021
Webinar on Codes of Practice in REF 2021 Follow us on Twitter
us: REF 2021 – an update Follow us on us:
Academic promotions briefing – educational research pathway
Subject Pilot Teaching Excellence and Student Outcomes Framework (TEF)
REF and research funding update
Water Directors meeting Warsaw, 8-9 December 2011
UCML, London 18 January 2019 REF 2021 Susan Hodgett (D25)
Institutional-Level Environment Pilot – HEI workshops: May 2019
REF 2021 Panel criteria and working methods David James
REF 2021 Update Follow us on us:
Introduction to the Islamic Studies Network
Presentation transcript:

Email us: info@ref.ac.uk Consultation on draft panel criteria and working methods Follow us on Twitter @REF_2021 Email us: info@ref.ac.uk Susan Hodgett, UoA25 Area Studies,

REF 2014- to 2021 Outputs 60% Impact 25% Environment 15% All staff with significant responsibility for research are returned to the REF/census date for staff will be 31 July 2020.No longer 4 outputs per person over period of REF but average of 2.5 per FTE. No. of outputs could range from 1-5. Portability of outputs in REF 2021, outputs may be submitted by both the institution employing the staff member on the census date and the originating institution where the staff member was previously employed (when the output was demonstrably generated). Impact case studies (now worth 25% not 20%). The initial threshold for impact case studies will be increased to 20 FTE (from 15 FTE). Submissions will include one case study, plus one further case study up to 20 FTE, after which one further case study will be required per 15 FTE. (Up to 19.99 is 2, 20 to 34.99 is 3, for 35 to 49.99 is 4 etc.) Open Access-relevant outputs to be deposited as soon after the point of acceptance as possible, and no later than three months after this date from 1 April 2018. Consultation closed noon, Monday 15 October. This will be accessed alongside this document at www.ref.ac.uk , under Publications.

UOA 25 Area Studies 132. Taking an inclusive view of Area Studies as a dynamic field, the sub-panel understands Area Studies broadly to include the study of all regions of the world, across any period of time, however defined, and the communities associated with them. As well as in terms of national territories, regions may be delineated in various ways, including by traditional geographical designations (e.g. African Studies, Latin American Studies); by ecological (e.g. Circumpolar Studies), geopolitical (e.g. Post-Soviet Studies) or institutional (e.g. European Union Studies) criteria; or in terms of themes, processes or networks (e.g. Diaspora Studies, Post-Colonial Studies, Gender Studies, Intercultural Studies). 133. The sub-panel has expertise across the humanities and social sciences, and welcomes work in any language from any single-disciplinary, interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, empirical or theoretical perspective. It will assess submissions covering all, but not limited to, aspects of anthropology, history, heritages, languages and linguistics, cultures, literatures, religions, philosophy, media, society, economics, human geography, politics and international relations, and translation, as well as inter-regional and globalisation studies.

U0A 25 Area Studies It welcomes ground-breaking or novel approaches and seeks to reward innovation and excellence in both traditional and non-traditional formats, including applied, practice-based, and pedagogical research. The sub-panel has expertise to assess a wide range of work and given the broad scope of Area Studies, it recognises that submissions may be made in this UOA that include work in languages or on regions falling wholly or partially outside its members’ expertise. Therefore, it is also mindful of the likely need to appoint further panel members for the assessment stage of the REF. The sub-panel recognises the overlapping boundaries in the sub-panel descriptors, and that aspects of research are naturally interdisciplinary or multi-disciplinary or span the boundaries between individual UOAs. The sub-panel welcomes the submission of research that may equally be submitted to other sub-panels. Where judged necessary by the panels, expertise will be augmented by additional assessors, or work will be cross- referred to relevant panels, according to the process detailed in Part 5, paragraphs 387 to 392.

Area Studies UoA 25 2021 Criteria Phase Chair, Susan Hodgett, University of East Anglia Deputy Chair, Tony Chafer, University of Portsmouth Marilyn Booth, University of Oxford Simon Dixon, University College London Rajinder Dudrah, Birmingham City University Natascha Gentz, University of Edinburgh Máiréad Nic Craith,* Heriot-Watt University * denotes interdisciplinary member on a main panel, and interdisciplinary adviser on a sub- panel Matthew Shaw, Institute of Historical Research Brian Ward, Northumbria University Assessment Phase Hugo Dobson, Sheffield University Kevin Featherstone, London School of Economics Robert Gleave, University of Exeter Simon Green, Aston University Roberta Guerrina, University of Surrey Faye Hammill, University of Glasgow Ambreena Manji, Cardiff University Lutz Marten, SOAS Emma Murphy, Durham University Zahia Smail Salhi, University of Manchester Plus 2020 appointments result of HEI submission intentions

AREA Studies Average Profile 2014 3 2 1 U Overall 28 42 25 5 Outputs 23.6 39.7 30.7 5.5 0.5 Impact 34.7 46.2 16.3 2.5 0.3 Environment 37.7 43.6 17.1 1.4 0.2 Area Studies

Timetable Spring 2018 Panels met to develop criteria Summer to Autumn 2018 Consultation on draft guidance and criteria Draft guidance on codes of practice Consultation deadline: noon, 15 October 2018 Early 2019 Publish final guidance and criteria 2019 Complete preparation of submission systems Submission deadline for codes of practice: noon, 7 June 2019 2020 Submission phase Submission deadline: noon, 27 November 2020 2021 Assessment phase Publication of results: December 2021

Further information Consultation survey: https://www.smartsurvey.co.uk/s/DTZ1O/  Registration for consultation events: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/research- excellence-framework-hei-consultation-events-tickets-47811987943 www.ref.ac.uk (includes all relevant documents and FAQs) Enquiries from staff at HEIs should be directed to their nominated institutional contact (available at www.ref.ac.uk/contact) Other enquiries to info@ref.ac.uk