Northglenn High School Softball Old Chicago Pizza Fund Raiser Get a $25 Old Chicago Pizza for ONLY $11, While supporting Norse Softball With the pizza card, there is no addition purchase required. Cards may be used at Any Old Chicago in the U.S. Cards may be redeemed Sun – Thurs, however most stores historically have also accepted them any day of the week. OC pizzas now typically cost just over $25, so they charge the excess $0.50-$0.75 when you pay for your meal. Pre-Sell your Old Chicago Pizza Cards Now!! You will receive your cards at the time you submit your money to Coach Molly, while supplies last.